Paper
The differences between the hard and the soft energy paths ARE the future and have been the focus of the evolution in the United States and the World in relation to environmental policy. I have combined these two mid-term questions to express how the answers and the answers vacillate and juxtapose each other.
A hard energy path is one with a complex route, expensive means for producing more power, and dangerous capabilities. Some examples of these NON-RENEWABLE sources are fossil fuels, oil and its petroleum products and the natural gas that accompanies some oil wells as well as the recently found pockets of just natural gas, and nuclear energy. These sources not only harden increasingly over time, but they also become scarce. With hard energy paths, it is often a matter of choosing power and convenience over the well being of future generations.
In addition, choices in favor of hard paths are usually more difficult to reverse, if for no other reasons than economic ones. Lovins is a passionate critic of such sources, condemning them for the price they exact from the environment and from posterity.
Lovins instead supports soft energy sources. These include the windmill and more and more as societies move into the future — solar energy. These sources are usually cheaper in the long run and much simpler. Most importantly, they have few destructive elements and are renewable. Methane and manure are also examples of the soft energy path. Lovins has devoted his work to studying the two paths and their social and environmental consequences, good and bad.
Some scientist say that the ‘Soft’ and the ‘Hard’ energy paths are mutually exclusive, and that if ‘we’ choose the soft path of a decentralist political system will follow almost automatically. If we are not careful, we might end up with a mixture of ’soft’ and ‘hard’ energy systems, both of them controlled by the ‘hard’ political system we all know and love.
Soft Energy Paths [1], is a valuable contribution to the environmentalists’ cause. One argument is in favor of a soft energy future–one in which renewable energy sources and diverse and accessible technologies, appropriately matched to their end-uses, form the basis for a pluralistic, non-repressive and participatory social and political framework. The alternative, is a hard energy future–in which expanding energy consumption from coal, oil and nuclear power, utilizing complex and capital-intensive technologies, form the basis for an increasingly centralized, environmentally destructive, and non-democratic social and political formation.
It is becoming increasingly accepted that the reasons for the development, choice, and promotion of particular forms of technology are as much political and social as they are technological and economic [2]. Particular technologies tend to lead to particular types of social and political change, such as fostering equality or inequality. Therefore, technologies are selected in large part because they serve the social, political, and economic goals of those who promote them. Powerful groups in society have the greatest control over technological innovation, the goals which have guided their choice of technologies include fragmentation and powerlessness of the labor force, maximization of profits and bureaucratic growth, and ideological justification for inequalities in wealth and in decision-making power.
For example, nuclear power is an appropriate way to produce energy if it is also important to maintain centralized control over investment and production, keep decisions in the hands of experts and their employers, and maintain a habit of passive consumerism in the populace. On the other hand, research and implementation of technologies for local collection and use of solar energy has been neglected for years mainly because these technologies cannot easily be placed under monopoly control, and hence are unattractive to energy utilities.
Once a preference for one type of technology becomes institutionalized, it becomes even harder for alternatives to compete. Nuclear electricity has not only benefited from immense research and other subsidies, but also has the advantage of a large, already existing electrical grid system and a built-in consumer dependence on electricity through appliance design and resistance heating. All these factors tend to make centralized energy relatively cheap. In terms of political and economic power, this economic advantage is reflected in the enormous industrial and bureaucratic organizations associated with electrical goods and services, which have a vested interest in opposing decentralized solar technologies.
A soft energy path, which included widespread adoption of locally controlled technologies, would pose real dangers to existing political and economic structures. People might be encouraged to take control over their lives in many ways: working conditions, education, health, and perhaps eventually choice of goods produced and control of production itself.
From the point of view of existing political and economic structures, there seems then to be a difficult choice: either a hard energy path beset by technological and economic difficulties and rising public discontent and opposition; or a soft energy path creating the conditions for a major challenge to the current political and economic structures.
For example, local production of solar heaters is easier than local production of nuclear reactors; but adoption of solar heaters does not necessarily lead to local production. The cost for conversion from hard to soft energy sources for homes, businesses, factories, farms, public and private transportation appears to be political suicide.
A possible alternative to hard and soft energy paths, would be a gradual transition to a combined system of hard and soft technologies, the transition to soft technologies occurring as soon as they can be introduced in a form that maintains the essentials of present social, political, and economic structures [3].
Already we can see plans for expansion of nuclear power generation and serious research into massive orbiting solar collectors, and a rapid increase in energy conservation measures (recycling, insulation) and the beginning of a boom in application of solar energy. Evolving from present trends, it seems quite conceivable that a transportation system may develop which is based partly on bicycles and alcohol-powered buses, and partially on cars powered by petrol synthesized from major improvements to solar powered private and public transportation.
To conclude that soft technologies will be introduced only when they are politically ’safe’ may seem like an extremely pessimistic evaluation, yet I fear a realistic one.
BIBLIOGRAPHY and RESEARCH SOURCES
Samuel Bowles and Herbert Gintis, Schooling in capitalist America (New York: Basic Books, 1976), Part III; G. William Domhoff, The agony of the American Left (London: Andre Deutsch, 1970), ch. 1; Alan Wolfe, The seamy side of democracy: repression in America (New York: David McKay, 1973), ch. 8.
5. Ivan lllich, Energy and equity (London: Calder and Boyars, 1974).
6. For example, Lovins says that “centralized energy systems have been built by institutions in no position to ask whether those systems are the best way to perform particular end use functions – an omission reinforced by our consistent under pricing of all forms of energy . . . and by utility regulation which automatically increased profits in proportion to capital invested.” (Pp. 140-1). But he does not explain why institutions were structured this way or why regulations were drawn up this way. On the creation of regulatory commissions by the businesses they are supposed to regulate, see Domhoff op. cit. (note 4) and Gabriel Kolko, The triumph of conservatism: a reinterpretation of American history 1900-1916 (New York: The Free Press of Glencoe, 1963).
7. Paul A. Baran and Paul M. Sweezy, Monopoly capital: an essay on the American economic and social order (New York: Monthly Review Press, 1967).
8. Herbert Marcuse, One dimensional man (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1964)
9. Saul D. Alinsky, Rules for radicals: a practical primer for realistic radicals (New York: Random House, 1971).
10. Andr Gorz, Strategy for labor: a radical proposal (Boston: Beacon Press, 1967)
11. John M. Swomley, Jr., Liberation ethics (New York: Macmillan 1972); George Lakey, Strategy for a living revolution (New York: Grossman, 1973).
Другие работы по теме:
Energy Consumption Essay Research Paper ENERGY CONSUMPTION
Energy Consumption Essay, Research Paper ENERGY CONSUMPTION The United States of America uses more than one fifth of the world’s resources. Energy consumption doubled between 1952 and 1972 and although consumption has slowed it continues to rise at an alarming rate. In the 1940’s the U.S.A exported fuel but by 1952 it was importing large amounts of oil and coal.
Nuclear Energy Essay Research Paper The Present
Nuclear Energy Essay, Research Paper The Present Energy: What’s the Deal?? When dealing with the world’s present sources of energy, the two most popular forms are nuclear and energy by fossil fuels. How long will these supplies last? Are they the most effective? Is it harmful to the environment? All of these questions must be addressed.
Vicky Essay Research Paper Maniac Soft Animated
Vicky Essay, Research Paper Maniac Soft Animated GIF Viewer AGV 1.0 ======================================= Hi there, thank you for using AGV 1.0. My name’s Christian “Maniac” Stauffer from Maniac Soft.
2Nd Law Of Thermodynamics Vs E Essay
, Research Paper Second Law of Thermodynamics vs. Evolution According to the second law of thermodynamics, when energy is converted from one form to another, the amount of useful energy decreases. In relation to the theory of evolution, this law is not contradictory. The second law of thermodynamics is not relating to energy within living things because living things retain energy from the sun.
Lost Essay Research Paper reaching back for
Lost Essay, Research Paper reaching back for something that isn’t there you suddenly feel you no longer care your once soft feelings are hard as stone and in your decisions you are now alone
Covalent Bonds Essay Research Paper The first
Covalent Bonds Essay, Research Paper The first ionization energy IE1 is the energy required to remove the one electron from a gaseous atom. With this the effective nuclear charge increases and thus it takes more energy to remove the next electron. IE2 is always greater than IE1. Each subsequent electron becomes harder to remove.
Anwr Essay Research Paper This web article
Anwr Essay, Research Paper This web article written by Ian Christopher, from CNN is a great reason why Bush is out to diminish our natural areas. This article is titled; In Debate Preview, Candidates outline Competing Energy Policies. This is about the energy portion of the debate. Gore is for environmental preservation; therefore, I am on Gore s side of the argument.
Cheese Essay Research Paper No matter how
Cheese Essay, Research Paper No matter how far archaeological finds go, there is evidence that cheese came into being in prehistoric times. Cheese can not really be said to have been “invented”. This delicious food must have resulted from the simple observation that milk left in a container ends up by coagulating, even more if it is hot.
Yoga And Emotions Essay Research Paper Yoga
Yoga And Emotions Essay, Research Paper Yoga and Emotions Hinduism believes that yoga has many different paths to enlightenment. Jnanic, Bhaktic, Karma, and Raja yoga’s are the different paths. They are different paths, but the Hindus believes that they all lead to the same destination, which is spiritual freedom.
Bohr At The Rutherford Lab Essay Research
Paper Bohr at the Rutherford Lab Everyone at the time imagined the atom as a “plum pudding.” That is, it was roughly the same thing throughout, with negatively charged electrons scattered about in it like raisins in a pudding. As part of an experiment with x-rays in 1909, Rutherford was shooting a beam of alpha particles at a sheet of gold foil only 1/3000 of an inch thick, and tracing the particles’ paths.
Element Essay Research Paper What is an
Element Essay, Research Paper What is an element: Simple substances that can not be broken down into simpler substances. What is an atom: smallest part of an element that can be identified as an element.
Finace Reform Essay Research Paper After what
Finace Reform Essay, Research Paper After what would be considered the closet race in presidential history, the US Supreme Court needs to find a way to get the public more involved. Senator John McCain and Russ Feingold are pushing towards a campaign finance reform. Republic John McCain is saying that we must put a stop on “soft” money, and increase “hard” money.
Gibb
’s Free Energy Cycle Essay, Research Paper The second law of thermodynamics states that energy transitions are imperfect. No matter what, energy is lost. In machines an 75% loss of energy is considered average. In biological reactions there is usually a 60% loss. Since all reactions are constantly losing a percentage of the energy they give, it is necessary to have a constant intake of energy to make up for what is lost.
Should The United States Invest More Money
In Renewable Energy Research And Development As Opposed To Fossil And Nuclear Fuels? Essay, Research Paper The United States should invest more money into the research and development of renewable energy. These renewable resources would take the place of fossil fuels, which are non-renewable resources.
Electrical Energy Essay Research Paper Electrical EnergyA
Electrical Energy Essay, Research Paper Electrical Energy A capacitor can store electrical energy. Connecting it across a resistor or other device discharges it. Across the resistor there is a potential difference that creates the electric current. When the charge in the capacitor decreases, at the same time the voltage decreases.
Energy Essay Research Paper The first question
Energy Essay, Research Paper The first question, which I must ask in order to write this essay, is, what is energy? Energy gives us the ability to do thing. Everything in the world needs a supply of energy, and so energy is used to make things work. The word energy is taken from the Greeks and means the work within and nearly all energy originally came from the sun.
Solar Essay Research Paper SOLAR ENERGY
Solar Essay, Research Paper SOLAR ENERGY — THE ENERGY OF THE FUTURE? About 47 per cent of the energy that the sun releases to the earth actually reaches the ground. About a third is reflected directly back into space by the atmosphere. The time in which solar energy is available, is also the time we least need it least – daytime.
Hydrogen Essay Research Paper Wild Bill
Hydrogen Essay, Research Paper Wild Bill’s Wild Bohr Quiz Niels Bohr’s model of the hydrogen atom, was the primary reason for the understanding of energy levels.
Big Green Trees Essay Research Paper Big
Big Green Trees Essay, Research Paper Big green trees Is what I see, Looking at me happily Bright green grass As thick as can be, Feels so very soft to me Birds and squirrels are playing around
Crossroads Essay Research Paper Steven SimonsCrossroadsThe paths
Crossroads Essay, Research Paper Steven Simons Crossroads The paths people choose to follow throughout life come with happiness and some regrets. Greasy Lake by T. Coraghessan Boyle is a story of how three boys chose the wrong path for themselves and had to learn the hard way. They chose the path that everyone else had chosen.
Pushing An Object Essay Research Paper Pushing
Pushing An Object Essay, Research Paper Pushing an object When an object with mass is moving, that it has kinetic energy is well known. Energy quantity can be expressed in two parameters of the mass and the speed. Generally definition of energy is difficult, though the quantity can be measured easily.
Driving Through Sawmill Towns By Les Murray
Essay, Research Paper A poem Driving Through Sawmill Towns written by Les Murray, describes what a Sawmill Towns is about and what its like. The scenery is basically a man driving his car through small towns surrounded by the forests. In sentences one through five has a small description of the paths taken to get to the Sawmill Towns.
Dream
– At Peace Essay, Research Paper At Peace Everything feels like a dream. I don?t know where I am. I can hear sobbing, and soft music as I lie there. I must be asleep in my bed, waiting for my mom?s soft voice to come tell me that breakfast is ready. I smell flowers. Mom must have cut some fresh roses from the garden today.
Nuclear Energy Essay Research Paper Nuclear Energy
Nuclear Energy Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Energy should be produced because it is an alternative to fossil fuel. Nuclear energy helps to conserve our national resources that we use as fuel such as coil, oil, and natural gas. Another pro of nuclear energy is that radiation that is given off by nuclear energy is mostly thought of a very dangerous thing but it can be used in positive ways too.
Solar Energy An Alternative Energy Essay Research
Paper Solar Energy: An Alternative Energy Imagine a perfect source of energy. One with which no pollution what-so-ever is associated with. No poisonous gasses or destruction of rain forests. This
Campaign Finance Reform Essay Research Paper Campaign
Campaign Finance Reform Essay, Research Paper Campaign Finance Reform: Soft Money One of the key issues facing this year?s Presidential Campaign is campaign finance reform. More specifically, whether or not to ban soft
Windmills Essay Research Paper Wind energy can
Windmills Essay, Research Paper Wind energy can be used to do work. When a boat lifts a sail, it is using wind energy to push it through the water. Farmers have been using wind energy for many years to pump water from wells using windmills. In Holland, windmills have been used for centuries to pump water from low-lying areas.
Alternate Energy Sources Essay Research Paper WINDMILLSThe
Alternate Energy Sources Essay, Research Paper WINDMILLS The reason why I chose to do a project on windmills is because I would always drive out to Palm Springs and I would see these huge thing’s that looked like something out of a
Robert Frost Critique Essay Research Paper Choices
Robert Frost Critique Essay, Research Paper Choices are never easy- men face multitudes of them in their lifetime. Some decisions to these choices are clear while others are sometimes more difficult to effectuate. The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is a first person narrative tale of a monumental moment in the speaker s life- Frost can be considered the speaker.
Failure And Soft Courses Essay Research Paper
Failure and Soft Courses High failure rate in college has been traced back to the taking of soft courses in place of real hard working courses. Some say these soft courses affect minorities more than others do and should be abolished for good. But I say these classes are destructive for anyone, minority or not, and should be strictly limited.