Dual Executive Essay, Research Paper
10/10/96
Dual Executive
The idea of an elective head of state for the American chief executive, in its conception, was virtually without precedent. The idea of an American dual presidency, split between domestic and foreign arenas is itself without precedent. A dual presidency would suit America well due to the pressures of the office of President of the United States. As Commander-in-Chief, the President bears incredible pressures and responsibilities. The President not only has power in the United States, but also tremendous influence throughout the world. It is not arrogant to change the presidency in order to manage America s vast interests all over the globe. The US is certainly not isolationistic anymore, so creating an office for a foreign affairs executive is simply realistic. Thus, the President is not only torn between domestic and foreign responsibilities, but s/he must find time to campaign. A dual presidency with a domestic and foreign leader could divide these campaigning duties. In addition, a dual presidency is better adapted to handle simultaneous crises. A dual presidency is a modern day answer to the realities of the American presidency.
Essentially, the idea of a dual executive is rooted in the concept of a plural
executive. Back in the time of the writing of the Constitution, some anti-federalists wanted a weak executive. This weak executive was called a plural executive or an executive council. (Storing 49) The purpose of such a plural executive was not only to weaken the executive, but also to prevent a monarchy from ruling. In fact, an anti-federalist named Randolph opposed an executive-of-one so much that he believed it to be the foetus (fetus) of the monarchy. (Storing 93) Yet today the threat of monarchy is laughable.
The proposed dual executive has no intentions of weakening that branch. Rather, a dual executive makes the branch more efficient, focused, and in touch.
Plural is not a fitting term for the dual executive. This is because a plural executive implies several office holders, or a committee. The more people, the more chaos and disunity occurs.
In the 70th chapter of The Federalist Papers, Alexander Hamilton made a case for an executive with a great deal of unity. If power was concentrated in a single chief magistrate, then the branch would be more cohesive. Hamilton relied on the failures of plural executive in the history of Rome and Greece to make a case against executive councils.
Some may argue that by dividing the executive office, it saps the energy and vigor required of the job. Inversely, it can be argued that the President has so much to do that his energy is weakened by simply being spread too thin. The latter is true since America is such an
incredible world power. When Hamilton was writing against a plural executive, he never could have predicted America s role in the world.
An example of what this dual executive is not, is Uruguay s multi-member presidency. From 1918 to 1933 the directly elected nine-member National Council of
Administration shared executive power with the President. The Council took care of domestic affairs. Note that there is a divide between domestic and foreign duties.
Such a presidency was intended to be more representative, but simply made the government more fragmented. Within time, Uruguay s multi-member presidency fell to a dictator because it was an ineffectual entity. There were simply too many members. That is why this dual presidency is composed of only two members of the same party who would run together, and rule together.
The proposed dual presidency is quite united. The job of the President has expanded, and so should the office. A dual presidency should be thought of as an extension of the single presidency.
These two leaders would run together in elections under the same party. Both would have the same four year terms, with two term limits. The idea is that the presidency is still one entity. It is the same job as a single executive, but the responsibility is thinned out. Each bill, treaty, or appointment would be approved by both Presidents. Some bills, treaties, and
appointments could affect both Presidents, which is why dual approval is necessary. Such
precautions must be taken to maintain unity in the executive branch.
Both the domestic and the executive President would choose a vice-president. Essentially four people would end up running under one party. Other than that, the presidential election process would remain the same.
Meanwhile, the impeachment process should apply only to the individual offender. One President cannot help it if the other committed an impeachable offense.
The other should not be punished for it. The vice-president for the person who was impeached would fill the office in that situation. After the vice-president, the succession process would remain the same.
The foreign affairs President would be the Commander-in-Chief of the armed forces in actions abroad. Yet, the domestic President could use the armed forces on American soil for natural disaster relief, or whatever else it is used for today. In addition, the Presidents would also have the power to grant reprieves and pardons. Both actions are subject to dual approval.
When disputes arise between the two Presidents, the issue would be formally put in writing. The issue could then be put before a two-thirds house vote for approval. The house would be the Presidential mediator. In the oath of office, the Presidents should be reminded that they are not supposed to be working against each other, but working together.
Both Presidents would give a State of the Union address. The domestic address would be more of a summary of the state of the Union. Meanwhile the foreign address would be about the state of the Union in relation to the rest of the world.
The foreign President would receive ambassadors and other public ministers. Meanwhile the domestic President would be to meet with state Governors, members
of Congress, and so forth. Any situations that fall in between those two categories should be addressed by both Presidents.
One special power the domestic President would have would be that of nominating judges to the Supreme Court. The foreign President s approval would not be necessary. Thus, the final approval for the judges would be carried out the traditional way.
The cabinet would be divided along presidential lines, and would be appointed by the corresponding President. The domestic President would need the Attorney-General , Postmaster-General, Secretary of the Interior, Secretary of Agriculture, and the Secretary of Labor. The foreign President would need the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Commerce. Both would share the Secretary of State, Secretary of the Treasury, and other Secretaries as needed.
One beneficial aspect of having a dual presidency is that it may take some of the media s scrutiny off the office. In other words, it may displace the blame. Yet, by breaking up the focus, the personality and charisma of a President would become less of an issue. It must be kept in mind that this is just speculation.
In conclusion, turning the presidency into two halves of a whole would alleviate some of the vast responsibilities of being leader of the world s largest superpower. Hamilton was right that the executive needs unity. Yet unlike Hamilton s views, the presidency can be divided, and kept a harmonious body.
Другие работы по теме:
A Successful Administration Essay Research Paper A
A Successful Administration Essay, Research Paper A Successful Administration Each president elected desires a smoothly operating administration run by competent officials in order to accomplish his goals and prerogatives and shared political ideologies between head administration members are vital to a successful government.
Dual Labor Market Essay Research Paper Even
Dual Labor Market Essay, Research Paper Even with all the gains women have made on the job market, they will always be a step behind there fellow male coworkers. Women have made significant gains with their numbers in the workforce, but they still fall behind in the their average wages made. There a many major factors for this, but they are all brought about by the dual labor market.
The Cabinet Essay Research Paper Although there
The Cabinet Essay, Research Paper Although there is nothing in the constitution describing a cabinet system, the framers believed that having a cabinet system was necessary. Shortly before being sworn into office Washington consulted with Madison and Hamilton concerning his role and duties as president.
Yahoo Essay Research Paper Yahoo rode the
Yahoo! Essay, Research Paper Yahoo! rode the bull market Thursday, primarily on the strength of a report by Lehman Brothers, which raised its recommendation on the stock to a “Buy.”
Grades Do We Really Need Them Essay
, Research Paper This essay is about the article called “We Should Cherish Our Children?s Freedom to Think.” It was written by Kie Ho, a business executive who was born and raised in Indonesia. Ho writes this article about why he thinks that American education is, in many ways better than any other in the world.
Tuskegee Airmen Essay Research Paper The Tuskegee
Tuskegee Airmen Essay, Research Paper The Tuskegee Airmen In 1948, President Truman issued Executive Order 9981, which called for “equality of treatment and opportunity” in the armed forces. On March 7, 1942, young black pilots stood at Tuskegee Army Air Field in Alabama. It was at this historic graduation exercise that these men were inducted the into the United States Army Air Corps.
Great Expectations Pip Essay Research Paper Great
Great Expectations: Pip Essay, Research Paper Great Expectations: Pip Charles Dickens’s Great expectations is a story about a boy, Philip Pirrip, who comes to a point in his life where his life changes drastically from the way
Internment Essay Research Paper During World War
Internment Essay, Research Paper During World War II, approximately 110,000 Japanese Americans were evacuated from theirhomes and businesses to internment camps scattered throughout the interior of the United States.Executive Order 9066, signed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt in February of 1942, ordered thatall Japanese Americans be evacuated from the West Coast.
Fantasy Story Essay Research Paper Thinking that
Fantasy Story Essay, Research Paper Thinking that it maybe was about time for something not so spectacular, I grabbed this book by Iain Not-M Banks while I was at the bookstore (getting The Naked God). Good thing.
French And German Constitution Essay Research Paper
The executive in the French Vth Republic and the executive in the Federal republic in Germany have a few similarities and many differences. Since the French Vth constitution was tailor made by DeGaulles himself, the executive in this republic is very strong and authoritative. However, the executive in the Federal Republic of Germany, (the Bundesrepublik- Germany after 1945) was made up to prevent another Hitler from raising up, so it is very weak and is more of an executive figurehead.
Comparing And Contrasting Federalists And Antifederalists Essay
, Research Paper 1. The federalist and anti-federalists were very different in the opinions they shared on how the government should be run. The Federalists had very high class and social men while the Anti-federalists had farmers. The Federalists wanted a republican government with a strong executive branch, while the Anti-Federalists wanted a participatory democracy with a minimum executive branch.
Mexican Government Essay Research Paper Type of
Mexican Government Essay, Research Paper Type of Government The Mexican type of government is a presidential federal republic. The government has a president and a cabinet. It also has a bicameral legislature, and a judiciary. The government has the three traditional branches that the United States has- the executive, legislative, and judiciary branches.
Social Democracy Essay Research Paper Austria is
Social Democracy Essay, Research Paper Austria is a democratic, federal republic. The constitution of Austria provides for a distinct division of power among the executive, legislative and judicial branches of government. Basic human rights and liberties are granted by the constitution and so are the rights of minorities granted as well.
Federalism Essay Research Paper Due to the
Federalism Essay, Research Paper Due to the immense power of our federal government, people often argue that it is too powerful and should be lessened. Since the 1990?s there has been an effort to shift power
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallIn
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall In early American history, the powers of the executive and legislative branches of the government were already well defined. However, the judicial branch needed to establish its position as an equal of the other two branches. John Marshall was crucial in making this happen.
French Government Essay Research Paper The modern
French Government Essay, Research Paper The modern French government is run very much like the government of the United States. France is a democratic republic that is divided into three branches,
Presidential Power Essay Research Paper Powers of
Presidential Power Essay, Research Paper Powers of the Presidency The President of the United States is probably the most powerful and influential person in the whole world. Alone, he has full control over the Executive Branch and has a lot of roles that he is the leader of. With this in mind, I think that the power given to the President is still balance along with the Legislative and Judicial Branch.
Seperation Of Powers Essay Research Paper Separation
Seperation Of Powers Essay, Research Paper Separation of Powers Separation of powers is the act of separating of responsibilities of the three branches of the government. The idea of this separation is not a new one either. John Locke originally talked about it. He stated that the legislative power should be divided between the King and Parliament in England.
Japanese Internment Camps Essay Research Paper On
Japanese Internment Camps Essay, Research Paper On February 19, 1942, President Franklin D.Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066, which called for the eviction and internment of all Japanese Americans. After Pearl Harbor, all Japanese were looked upon as being capable of sabotage. The interments began in April 1942.
Goverment Essay Research Paper THE RISE OF
Goverment Essay, Research Paper THE RISE OF THE BUREAUCRATIC STATE The bureaucracy has been constantly growing since its beginning. At the end of the Federalist period, only 3,000 civilian officials were appointed; then in 1925 about half a million were employees in the bureaucracy. However, the size of the bureaucracy is completely insignificant.
Framers Ideals And Legislation Essay Research Paper
Framers Ideals and Legislation Branches on the Tree of Liberty Why, if one were concerned with protecting human liberty, would one want to make the legislative branch of government dominant rather than the executive or judicial? Are these good reasons for someone concerned with liberty to distrust a strong executive or a powerful judicial?
Dual Education Programs Essay Research Paper In
Dual Education Programs Essay, Research Paper In the United States, more and more students are learning and achieving academic excellence in dual language programs. These two-way bilingual programs integrate students who were raised speaking different languages to promote and provide learning and language development in two languages (Christian).
Executive Powers Essay Research Paper Executive Powers
Executive Powers Essay, Research Paper Executive Powers Russia v. Japan Brian Mitchard May 8, 2000 MW 3:30-4:45 Summary of Powers Within the constitution of a nation, powers are delegated to certain institutions of that nation?s government. Although in many cases similar, nations can vary drastically when defining the organizational structure from which they operate.
Japanease Government Essay Research Paper In this
Japanease Government Essay, Research Paper In this report I will compare and contrast Japans Executive Branch to the American Executive Branch, such as the Japanese Prime Minister to the American President, and also some of the other offices of the Cabinet.
Executive Privelage Essay Research Paper exemption of
Executive Privelage Essay, Research Paper exemption of the executive branch of government, or its officers, from having to give evidence, specifically, in U.S. law, the exemption of the president from disclosing information to congressional inquiries or the judiciary. Claims of executive privilege are usually invoked to protect confidential military or diplomatic operations or to protect the private discussions and debates of the president with close aides.
Environment Essay Research Paper Leading the LeaguePaul
Environment Essay, Research Paper Leading the League Paul Beeston is the CEO of the Toronto Blue Jays. His associates think that, like Tom Hanks in the movie Big, he walks a fine line between crazy kid and a top- notch executive. Beesron, who is a legendary for his commitment to the organization, started as the team??s first full-time accountant and rose through the ranks to become president in 1989.
Is Parliament Supreme Over The Judiciary And
The Executive? Give Reasons For Your Answer. Essay, Research Paper Parliament is supreme over the executive and judiciary in the way that it is the sovereign law making body. The parliament however is restricted within the constitution and it can not act outside of it. Although it does hold great power it does not have complete power due to the separation of powers.
Baseball Essay Research Paper Robinson Jackiefirst black
Baseball Essay, Research Paper Robinson, Jackie first black baseball player in the U.S. major leagues during the 20th century, an infielder and outfielder for the Brooklyn Dodgers of the National League from 1947 through 1956.
Executive Compensation Essay Research Paper Executive CompensationExecutive
Executive Compensation Essay, Research Paper Executive Compensation Executive compensation should be pay for performance. The direct link between pay and the company s profitability is an important factor. It can either motivate an executive to work harder for the company or to work against the company.