Paper
A man walks into his workplace thinking that it will be another normal day at work. However, his employer calls him into his office and fires him, on the basis that he had written offensive threats in an email towards one of his bosses. The employee now files a wrongful discharge action alleging that the employer?s actions violated his right of privacy. The employee also states that the company had assured its employees that all email would remain confidential. The employer strike back by saying that he should have the right to have interest in preventing inappropriate and unprofessional comments over the email system. The question is who is right in this case. Does the employee have any privacy rights? This answer is found in the 1986 Electronic Communications Privacy Act (ECPA), the only federal legislation that addresses this issue (Stellin 1996). This act states that ?it a federal crime for an individual to intentionally or willfully intercept, access, disclose or use another’s wire, oral, or electronic communication? (Hernandez 1996). However, the definition of Electronic Communication is defined as ?any transfer of signs, signals, writing, images, sounds, data or intelligence of any nature transmitted in whole or in part by a wire, radio, electromagnetic, photo-electronic or photo-optical system that affects interstate or foreign commerce?(Hernandez 1996). This act does not apply to workers in a private business, because email in a private sector does not affect interstate commerce (Dichter 1996). Therefore, if there is no legislation that gives the right to an employee, then judges in each case has to act on a trial by trial basis, to determine whether the employer has the right to intrude into the employee?s privacy. Although the Electronic Communications Privacy Act of 1986 established limits on employer’s ability to monitor their employees, a new privacy act should be passed that explicitly addresses the employee and employer rights in the realm of Internet and email.
The advancements of technology in such a quick time have outpaced the privacy policies. In 1996, it was estimated that more than 40 million workers were corresponding via e-mail and the number was increasing twenty percent a year (Dichter 1996). But in 1986, when the Electronic Communications Privacy Act was passed, legislators did not consider that technology would get so advanced, and that email and the Internet would influence the workplace. ?The act was mainly to expand preexisting prohibitions on the unauthorized interception of wire and oral communications to encompass other forms of electronic communications? (Dichter 1996). This act was very broad. Therefore, when figuring out if email would be considered as an electronic communication, there were many exceptions including the provider of a service, which the courts interpreted as including employers (Stellin 1996). Therefore by having a more detailed privacy act, it will justify what employers can and can not do.
As more workers begin using email and the Internet in the workplace, employers become more concerned with what the employees are doing. In a survey, 35% of all companies keep an eye on their workers with surveillance (Grimsley 1997). The problem lies in the fact that a lot of companies do not tell their employees that they are monitoring them. There are several types of computer monitoring which an employer can use. ?Employers can use computer software that enables them to see what is on the screen or stored in the employees’ computer terminals and hard disks? (Privacy Rights.Org 1996). Some of this software includes Netnanny, Surfwatch, and Investigator. When these programs are used, Employees? believe that their privacy rights are violated. There have been many cases where the plaintiff (the employee) sued their employers for invasion of privacy. In Bourke v. Nissan Motor Corp., two employees were sending to each other personal emails of a sexual nature (Dichter 1996). Their employers read it, and issued the two workers written warnings for violating company policy (Dichter 1996). The employees thought that because they were given passwords to their emails, they had privacy (Dichter 1996). However, they were wrong in this matter as there is no law or act that states those employees cannot monitor email. The U.S. constitution also, does not guarantee a right of privacy. The Fourth Amendment that protects U.S. citizens against unreasonable search and seizure by the government does not protect private employers (Stellin 1996). In another court case, Shoars v. Epson America Inc., Ms. Shoars, an email administrator, told Epson?s employees that their email was confidential (Garcia 1996).
However she did not know that her supervisor was monitoring all the employees? e-mail (Garcia 1996). ?After finding out that the supervisor was monitoring e-mails, she filed a class-action suit on behalf of her and her fellow employees, claiming invasion of privacy?(Stellin 1996). The court ruled against Shoars stating that the right to privacy guaranteed by the California state constitution covered personal not business information. (Stellin 1996). Even though the company promised the employees that their email would be confidential, they still monitored e-mail. Without a privacy act, employees are usually left helpless from the courts. ?At this moment there is no strong legislation that specifically addresses electronic privacy concerns? ( Stellin 1996).
Employers on the other hand, believe that they should have the right to monitor e-mail and the Internet. Since the employer owns the computer network and the terminals, they believe they have the right to monitor (privacyrights). One reason they monitor is the fear of lawsuits. When someone sends another person adult-oriented jokes, racial jokes, pornography, etc., it can leave the company vulnerable to lawsuits (Bloomberg News 1999). In a survey, seventy percent said they have gotten adult-oriented mail while at work. One case that exemplifies this was when four female employees sued Microsoft for sexual harassment where the alleged sexual harassment included a number of pornographic e-mail messages sent between employees at the company’s information and technology division. The 4 female employees won 2.2 million dollars. This all can be avoided if employers monitor employees email. ?With monitoring email, an employer could hold a employee accountable, and with information will generate sophisticated reports – reports that could hold up in court if an employee tries to slap the company with a wrongful termination suit after they are let go? (Garfinkel 1997). Employers also fear that email and the Internet will affect the overall productivity. In a company, employment is a contract established between the employer and employee whereby the employee benefits the employer through his work and the employer benefits the employee through his salary. When electronics such as email distract employees, performance is usually affected. There is also the security issue, which employers are concerned about. In a survey, 1 out of 10 employees receives email that contains confidential company information (Bloomberg News 1999). If confidential information leave the company, companies could lose valuable ideas and money. These are many reasons why employers would not want another privacy act, because the 1986 Electronic Communication Privacy Act favors their interest more when dealing with email and the Internet.
Even though companies own the computer networks and terminals, workers should at least have the right to be notified when they are being monitored. This can be achieved by developing or extending corporate policies to address employee privacy expectations or by explaining to the employees the extent of their monitoring. In 1996, a survey by the Society for Human Resource Management found that only 36 percent of companies with email have policies addressing proper usage of the technology, while only 34 percent have a written policy on workplace privacy (Stellin 1996). With this information, companies are not doing their part in respecting their employees. States have attempted to pass laws to make sure companies don?t abuse the technology in their workplace. In California, Senator Debra Bowen (D-Redondo Beach) introduced an amendment to the state Labor Code (SB 1016) in the final week of the legislative session that will make it a misdemeanor for employers to look through an employee’s email without warning him or her in advance. (Glave 1999). However, state laws cannot do much, because they are limited to one state. What is needed is a federal law that would make monitoring email illegal in a private sector, unless the employers tell in advance that they are monitoring. One federal bill was nearly passed in 1993. The Privacy for Consumer and Workers Act was a bill to prevent abuses of electronic monitoring in the workplace, and for other purposes(Eff Org, 1993). However, the bill died but it died after being referred to the Committee on Labor and Human Resources. Many state laws and Federal bills have attempted to constrain the power employers have over employees email, but none have become a big impact in the workplace.
Private sectors have presented a potential threat to privacy in the workplace, since there are very few laws and acts to protect employees. The Electronic Communication Privacy Act has so many loopholes that there needs to be a new privacy act that will address the employers and employees right in terms of email and the Internet. The number of workplace conflicts between employers and employees have increased over technological privacy issues. With technology outpacing laws, employers are taking advantage of employees. ?The presence of monitoring can be very stressful to employees, which can lead to lower morale and productivity? (Allen 1996). The federal legislation should pass a new privacy act that would be better suited for the many advancements of technology, which influence the workplace.
Bibliography
Allen, Blair J. 1996. Privacy in the workplace. 18 Oct. 1999 .law.mcgill.ca/academics/coursenotes/complaw/papers/1996_workplace.htm
Bloomberg News.”Study: Most workers get inappropriate email”
CNET News 1.1 (February 1999)
news.cnet/news/0-1005-200-338958.html?tag=st.cn.1fd2.
1996.Employee Monitoring: Is There Privacy in the Workplace? Privacy Rights Clearinghouse. 14 Oct. 1999. privacyrights/fs/fs7-work.htm
Garcia, Erik C.1996. Email and Privacy Act. Dept. of Law, Buffalo U. 17 Oct. 1999,
wings.buffalo.edu/law/Complaw/CompLawPapers/garcia.html
Garfinkel, Simson.” Snooping on Workers Goes PC.” Wired News
1.1 (Feb 1997)
wired/news/topframe/2250.html
Glave,James. “An Email Bill for Employees.” Wired News 1.1
(September 1999)
wired/news/news/politics/story/21792.html
Grimsley,Kirstin D.”35% of Firms found to monitor Workers
Electronically.” Washington Post 1.3 (May 1997)
Hernandez, Ruel. 1996.ECPA and Online Computer Privacy. 17 Oct. 1999
Mark S. Dichter and Michael S. Burkhardt. 1996. Electronic Interaction in the workplace
The American Employment Law Council. 17 Oct. 1999.
mlb/speech1.html
1993 privacy for Consumers and Workers Act. Eff Organization. 17 Oct. 1999.
eff/pub/Privacy/Workplace/s984_consumer_workplace_priv.bill
Stellin, Susan. ?Privacy in the Digital Age.? CNET News 7.7 (May 1996)
cnet/Content/Features/Dlife/Privacy/
Другие работы по теме:
Abortion Essay Research Paper ConceptionI believe that
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Conception: I believe that life begins at the ending of the first trimester through the pregnancy. I consider it a human when there is a beating heart and a brain that is functioning. A beating heart to me represents that there is life, and that there is signs of growth, while still in the mother’s womb.
Do Public Figures Have The Right To
Privacy? Essay, Research Paper This is a very well documented debate, especially after the tragic death of the Princess of Wales. I feel that there is no right and wrong answer. People and the press have to look at individual circumstances and decide whether it is relevant to a high enough degree to pry into other people’s lives
Self Life Essay Research Paper Welcome to
Self Life Essay, Research Paper Welcome to the world of Self Life Where a new way of living awaits you. Self Life estates has been designed with today’s consumer in mind. With poverty at an all-time high, we seek to provide cost efficient housing to the public while maintaining a high standard of building quality.
Internet Privacy Essay Research Paper A new
Internet Privacy Essay, Research Paper A new report was written on the privacy issue of consumer reports to large companies. This is an issue which has been debated for some time and has been the subject for many parliamentary bills. Consumers, in exchange for their shopping statistical information, are rewarded.
Cyber Porn And Internet Privac Essay Research
Paper Cyber Porn and Internet Privacy Two computer ethic controversies There are many controversial questions about computer issues today but there are many debates with cyber porn and internet privacy. The Internet is accessed by millions of people everyday, especially children. Cyber porn is all over the Internet and can be accessed by anyone from anywhere whether in school, home, or on the job.
The Cookie Controversy Essay Research Paper The
The Cookie Controversy Essay, Research Paper The Cookie Controversy Most of us know cookies as tasty treats that are baked in the oven but now there is a new kind of cookie and it is stirring up privacy issues with Internet users. A cookie is a text-only file that gets entered into the memory of a web browser. Various web sights use cookies to help with on-line sales and services, tracking popular links, and demographics.
Internet Privacy Essay Research Paper Introduction I
Internet Privacy Essay, Research Paper Introduction:- I have been using internet for the past five years. I have heard quite a lot about Credit Card Fraud’s,Internet Privacy,etc but i never really thought it was true. I thought it was just some bunch of amateur’s who didn’t really knew how to use the internet.
One Place Essay Research Paper IF I
One Place Essay, Research Paper IF I COULD VISIT ONE PLACE IN THE WORLD I WOULD GO TO THE GREAT PYRAMIDS OF EGYPT. THE PYRAMIDS AMAZE ME THE WAY THEY WERE BUILT. THE WAY THE EGYPTIANS DESIGNED AND CONSTRUCTED
Cookies Invading Our Privacy Essay Research Paper
Cookies now constitute a real threat to personal privacy, but they are perfectly legal. A cookie is a tiny file that a Web sites place on the user’s hard drive when the user accesses the web page. Each cookie has a specific identification number. The cookie can gather personal information such as email addresses, full names, mailing addresses, and phone numbers, and then it sends the information back to the web site (Samborn 26).
Are Teenagers Respected Essay Research Paper Are
Are Teenagers Respected? Essay, Research Paper Are teenagers respected? Some may agree they are and some may not. However, the majority of teenagers will respond, that they don t receive the respect they deserve. Most teens feel they are disrespected mainly by their parents, other adults and by the school boards in North America.
Sex And Work Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex And Work Essay, Research Paper Sex and Work Women have made some strides in overcoming harassment and discrimination, but there is still a long way to go. When a corporate meeting is taking place, before the meeting, all the guys will be sitting around telling their little stories, until a woman walks in.
What Should And Shouldn
’t Computer Be Allowed To Run Essay, Research Paper What Should and Shouldn’t Computer Be Allowed To Run Computers have always scared people. Not just because they can be
Social Work Essay Research Paper Social Workers
Social Work Essay, Research Paper Social Workers in the United States have many roles and needs to fill in society. They are seen as the people that nurse the homeless, unemployed, hunger-stricken, and destitute back to life. It is their choice to help those more unfortunate than themselves, and although it is considered a “job”, it is really a way of life.
Papparizzi Rights Essay Research Paper Does the
Papparizzi Rights Essay, Research Paper Does the Paparazzi threaten First Amendment Rights and Privacy? The question of paparazzi threatening privacy and First Amendment rights is often to situational to argue in a conventional manner, but certainly there are many facets of the issue which can be addressed in a quite straightforward manner.
Privacy Essay Research Paper A person has
Privacy Essay, Research Paper A person has a right to solitude and freedom from prying public eyes, in other words, to privacy. The definition of privacy in the Webster’s Dictionary is defined as
Supreme Court Row V Wade Essay Research
Paper Supreme Court Row v Wade Roe v. Wade I believe that it is outrages that the states could turn a matter of personal liberties and privacy into a tool used to promote itself as a non-federal government dominated body. By refusing a woman to have the right to terminate a pregnancy, the state abridges that woman’s right to privacy, which is supported by the constitution in more then one Amendment such as the first, the fourth, the fifth, the ninth, and of course the famous fourteenth.
Technology Vs Privacy Essay Research Paper In
Technology Vs. Privacy Essay, Research Paper In a society where technology is rapidly growing, controversy over our privacy rights has also cultivated. With the popularity of the Internet, cell phones, ATM and credit cards it is evident that Americans enjoy the convenience that has come along with technology.
Privacy And Personal Security On The Net
Essay, Research Paper Privacy and security are two things that are hard to find on the Internet today. Many debates have risen concerning the personal aspects of the Internet. Should you have privacy on the Internet? Or should companies have the privilege to gather information about you? I believe that your privacy and personal security should be top priority on the Internet.
Bartender Essay Research Paper If you want
Bartender Essay, Research Paper If you want to make a lot of money and have fun doing it, then becoming a bartender would be a good choice. The only thing you really need to do to become one, is go to a vocational school. Even then, that can t set you back too far. You would only have to take a couple of classes, then you re in.
Dorm Rooms Essay Research Paper Dorm RoomsI
Dorm Rooms Essay, Research Paper Dorm Rooms I had lived with my parents for twenty years when I decided to move into the dorms at Western Oklahoma State College. There are three major differences between living at home and living in a dorm room. The differences are in privacy, living space, and meals. One thing that I really miss about living at home is the home cooked meals.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Electronic Monitoring vs
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Electronic Monitoring vs. Health Concerns Is privacy and electronic monitoring in the work place an issue that is becoming a problem? More and more employees are being monitored today then ever before
Abortion ProChoice Opinion Essay Research Paper One
Abortion Pro-Choice Opinion Essay, Research Paper One of the basic questions every society mustface is which areas of behavior to leave to private choice and which to regulate in the interest of public good. It has been already been decided by the Supreme Court in Roe v.s. Wade that “the fundamental right to privacy protect6ed by the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment is broad enough to encompass a qualified right to abortion”.
Privacy Essay Research Paper As laws policies
Privacy Essay, Research Paper As laws, policies, and technological design increasingly structure people’s relationships with social institutions, individual privacy faces new threats and new opportunities. Over the last several years, the realm of technology and privacy has been transformed, creating a landscape that is both dangerous and encouraging.
The Cause Of Being Unhappy Essay Research
Paper People sometimes become unhappy. Although I spend pleasant time with my host family and friends, I also have something that makes angry, disappoint, and sad. There are three major causes which make people unhappy; the violation of their privacy, failure, and sickness.
Computer Privacy Essay Research Paper Today a
Computer Privacy Essay, Research Paper Today a profound shift in the privacy equation is under way. Technology brings enormous efficiency to the collection, sorting and distribution of personal information. This efficiency has revolutionized countless organizations but it has also increased opportunities for snooping.
Computer Privacy Essay Research Paper Computer PrivacyIn
Computer Privacy Essay, Research Paper Computer Privacy In the information technology world today there is a problem that can ruin a company. Bad publicity and finger pointing usually precede the problem. After this the federal government steps in and regulates things. The problem I am referring to is computer privacy.
My Bedroom Essay Research Paper My favourite
My Bedroom Essay, Research Paper My favourite place in the entire world is my bedroom. My bedroom and I are one. My bedroom personifies me. It is the only place that allows me to be me. My bedroom is mine. I have complete control over it and everything in it. The only regulations in my bedroom are those I decide on.
Business Ownerships Essay Research Paper Will RushIntro
Business Ownerships Essay, Research Paper Will Rush Intro. To Business Summary 2-6-01 Sole proprietorships have numerous advantages and disadvantages. They are easy to start, needing only a license and a bank account. You are your own boss, and in turn make the rules. You also keep what you make and pay taxes at a lower rate than a corporation.
Drug Testing In The Work Place Essay
, Research Paper In almost every career job, before a new employee is hired, drug testing is administered. However many jobs stop at that point; not believing, or choosing to ignore the fact that employees may be using drugs. Random drug testing in the work place is a good practice. Although people complain that it is a violation of privacy, companies have a business to run and don’t need the responsibility or the hassle of a drug addicted employee.
Attitude Essay Research Paper Does Attitude Affect
Attitude Essay, Research Paper Does Attitude Affect What Happens? Attitude is more important than facts. Attitude how does it affect people? It affects people by changing their mood. According to Charles Swindell, people are now convinced that life is ten percent of what happens to people and ninety percent of how people react to it (1).
The Right To Privacy Essay Research Paper
The word “privacy” does not appear in the U.S. Constitution, though a number of Supreme Court opinions have held that the Fourth, Fifth, Ninth, and Fourteenth Amendments offer some constitutional backing for a right “to” (as opposed to an enumerated right “of”) privacy. This right has been applied to cases involving privacy versus law enforcement, voyeurs, freedom of the press, the release of personal information, and personal choices.
Privacy Essay Essay Research Paper Privacy is
Privacy Essay Essay, Research Paper Privacy is the right to be let alone to do what you want in secret. All across our nation privacy is being exploited by companies, hardened criminals and drug users. They use or invade privacy for their own personal gain. We need to change our view of privacy when considering a recidivist criminal to make it easier for them to be prosecuted again.