Paper
Did King Arthur Truly Exist?
Who was King Arthur? Most people would tell of a great King; a devoted circle of heroic knights; mighty castles and mightier deeds; a time of chivalry and courtly love; of Lancelot and Guinevere; of triumph and death. Historians and archaeologists, especially Leslie Alcock, point to shadowy evidence of a man who is not a king, but a commander of an army, who lived during the late fifth to early sixth century who may perhaps be the basis for Arthur. By looking at the context in which the stories of King Arthur survived, and the evidence pertaining to his castle Camelot and the Battle of Badon Hill, we can begin to see that Arthur is probably not a king as the legend holds.
While stories about the places that Arthur has lived, visited and fought at are numerous, attempts at pinpointing many of these sites have been futile. Arthur’s most famous battle, the Battle of Badon Hill, cannot be ascribed a location. Depending on the historian, the Battle of Badon Hill could have been located at many different places: According to Alcock, the battle at Mount Badon took place on a hill near Bath; while Wood attempts to pin the battle at Liddington castle. If we are unable to be sure of a location at which a massive battle took place (and indeed, his most famous), how can we be sure that Arthur truly existed?
Attempts at pinning down Camelot have also proved fruitless. Wood describes the difficulty in locating Camelot, saying, “A late local tradition connected Arthur with a hill fort, and when the Camelot Research Committ dug there, they caused a sensation…The Excavators did not, in fact find Camelot, nor was anything turned up to connect the place specifically with King Arthur” (51). This serves to highlight not only the fact that local tradition can skew a story in order to make it more exciting for those hearing it, but it also helps us see that Camelot may only be fiction. It has proved to be nearly impossible to find on of the grandest courts in all of England.
Arthurian history is vague to say the least, and written records are not always entirely factual. The brief Annals of Wales tells two things of Arthur: he fought at Badon, and he was killed at Camlann in the same battle. These Annals were composed centuries after the time of Arthur, and were compiled from other, earlier sources. A battle between Arthur and Medraut (Modred) is recorded for the year 539 AD. This entry was made after Arthur had already become a legend, and the spelling of the name with an “h” would suggest this, as the evidence from the earliest reliable sources spells the name without an “h”. So it is reasonable to believe that this is a very late and unreliable entry indeed.
Since very few individuals could write, stories of Arthur were mainly told by word of mouth. Oral stories did not get written down until later; Geoffrey of Monmouth wrote down the stories as one of the first written manuscript of Arthurian legend in 1139. Word of mouth was the way in which Arthur’s story is passed down through the years, and it is safe to assume that during that time, the story transformed and evolved. Stories are embellished and added to, depending on the audience, in order to make it more exciting. As discussed before in this paper, local tradition had placed Camelot in an area that was proven not to be Camelot. Exaggerations were undoubtedly made about King Arthur’s supposed feats of war, for what man could possibly single-handedly kill 470 men with his sword Caliburn as he does in Monmouth’s account? Legendary accounts written centuries after the man’s death will go into great detail regarding his battles and conquests, and elaborate even to the point where they can almost tell the color of his hair. Except where one can find the few references to real contemporary historical figures in the legends, as evidence they are worthless. In addition to these two legendary sources, there are countless myths and poems which abound in Wales and elsewhere. None can be regarded as evidence as they almost certainly all originate after the 12th century AD.
Which brings us to the man himself, Arthur. Little is known about Arthur besides what has been passed down by word of mouth and inscribed in annals. Although fables present Arthur as a king, historians argue that he was, in fact, only the commander of an army. According to Alcock, “[Arthur] was not a king…He was instead the leader of the combined forced of the small kingdoms into which sub-Roman Britain had dissolved” (359). Arthur was not as king, as was previously thought, but a commander of an army whose legends and fame grew out of real battles and deeds. Wood supports the theory, saying, “yet through myth shadows modern historians think they have distinguished a remote war leader, a real-life British hero…whose fame, it is thought, grew from successful battles” (40). Wood goes on to say, “Reluctantantly we must conclude that there is no definite evidence that Arthur ever existed” (60).
However, if we are to consider these facts as an argument that Arthur existed from Leslie Alcock’s point of view, we must also consider the fact that history points to the fact that there was an Vortigern, probably the same one who exists in Geoffrey of Monmouth’s account of Britain. According to Alcock, Vortigern “ruled with a group of consiliarii like a Roman – or for that matter, a Visigothic – provincial governor” (357). If there was a Vortigern, it is possible to imagine that there may be a chance that Arthur was a king –- after all, he was related to Vortigern, and Vortigern was, by Alcock’s definition, royalty.
Who was King Arthur? Most people would tell of a great King; however, historians and archaeologists, especially Leslie Alcock, point to shadowy evidence of a man who is not a king, but a commander of an army. By looking at the context in which the stories of King Arthur survived, and the evidence pertaining to his castle Camelot and the Battle of Badon Hill, we can begin to see that Arthur is probably not a king as the legend holds.
Другие работы по теме:
Heroes 2 Essay Research Paper Revision EssayHeroesHero
Heroes 2 Essay, Research Paper Revision Essay Heroes Hero. When we think of a hero, what automatically comes to mind? To some it may be someone legendary. Others might think of a hero as someone of great strength or ability. Perchance an illustrious soldier or warrior. Perhaps someone admired for their achievements and great qualities.
Leadership Skills Essay Research Paper Leadership Skills
Leadership Skills Essay, Research Paper Leadership Skills There are many qualities that a leader needs. If a leader has all the qualities, often they will be a better leader. In the novel, The Once and Future King by T.H. White, Merlyn, a highly educated wizard and Arthur s tutor, teaches the soon to be known King Arthur many of these qualities.
The Chivarlric Code Of Le Morte D
’ Arthur Essay, Research Paper The Chivalric Code of Le Morte d’Arthur Throughout the tales of King Arthur, stories of brave knights and noble lords captivated the society of the European Middle Ages. These stories gave a criterion for
Imagination In Morte D
’ Arthur Essay, Research Paper IMAGINATION IN MORTE D’ ARTHUR A recurring theme in Sir Thomas Malory?s Morte d? Arthur is the use of imaginative descriptions of characters and settings. Imagination is what the reader of the
Connecticut Yankee Vs Le Morte D
’arthur Essay, Research Paper King Arthur’s Britain, a vastly different Britain than we know today, is revealed through many timeless classics in literature. Two of these pieces of literature are Thomas Malory’s seriously toned Le Morte D’Arthur and Mark Twain’s satirical A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court.
Chivalry Essay Research Paper It is apparent
Chivalry Essay, Research Paper It is apparent in today s society that the definition and application of chivalry has changed through history. During the Middle Ages, chivalry was a code of brave and courteous conduct for knights. According to this system of morals and manners, a knight was to remain faithful to God, loyal to his king, true to his lady-love, and helpful to their less fortunate kinsmen.
A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur
’s Court By Mark Twain (1835 – 1910) Essay, Research Paper Mark Twain was fascinated by Sir Thomas Malory’s “Morte d’Arthur.” According to his notebook, Twain dreamed one
Sir Gawain 2
Sir Gawain & Dame Ragnell Essay, Research Paper “The Wedding of Sir Gawain and Dame Ragnell” is a medieval romance poem written by an anonymous author. Sir Gawain is one of the major characters in the poem. He is a very likable personality. Sir Gawain represents an ideal knight of the fourteenth century. Throughout the story, we see Sir Gawain portrayed as a very courteous and noble knight, always trying to help King Arthur.
Niniane The Lady Of The Lake Essay
, Research Paper Do you think women hold powerful positions in today?s society? Would you believe that women were powerful as long ago as the fifth and sixth centuries? BELIEVE IT! Niniane, The Lady of the Lake, was one of the most powerful and influential women in King Arthur?s court. She used her intelligence and beauty to place herself at the right hand of King Arthur himself.
Valiance In The 21St Century Essay Research
Paper Valiance in the 21st Century And suddenly earth and sky were dazed by a pounding roar! And suddenly through the dawn an army began to pour! And lo! Ahead the army, holding aloft his spear came Lancelot to save his dear Guenevere! Camelot, Guenevere
Sir Lancelot Essay Research Paper Sir Lancelot
Sir Lancelot Essay, Research Paper Sir Lancelot Lancelot was the son of King Ban of Benwick. King Ban became involved in a war with the neighboring kingdom of King Claudus. Claudus defeated Ban and forced the king and queen to flee. As they fled, Elaine, Lancelot’s mother, puts baby Lancelot beside a lake and the Lady of the Lake steals the child away from her.
Beowulf Essay Research Paper During the medieval
Beowulf Essay, Research Paper During the medieval era, many different heroes proved to be chivalric. Three of these heroes are Beowulf, Sir Gawain, and King Arthur. All these men have won great battles, which in turn endow them with hero status among their faithful subjects. These three heroes possess chivalric qualities, but none of them are perfect.
Beowulf Essay Research Paper In comparing the
Beowulf Essay, Research Paper In comparing the heroic qualities of Beowulf, and the heroic qualities of King Arthur, we will cite the main differences between the two. Beowulf battled for glory, honor, and to prove his masculinity. King Arthur, on the other hand, battles to preserve the rights of his people, and to uphold justice.
Gilgamesh And King Arthur Essay Research Paper
The Epic of Gilgamesh has many similarities to The Legend of King Arthur. Although Gilgamesh and King Arthur have comparison they also have differences. The main difference is that one is an Epic and the other is a Legend. To compare and contrast The Epic of Gilgamesh and The Legend of King Arthor, one must first know what the words, “Epic” and “Legend” mean.
Sir Lancelot Du Lake Essay Research Paper
Sir Lancelot du Lake was quite possibly the bravest and most gallant knight in the world. His battles were pretty much lopsided, due to his extreme skill. He was King Arthur’s best knight. He was very adventurous and prone to getting into trouble, which he always came out of without a scratch. Why was Lancelot honored so? In the last four paragraphs, I will try to explain this to my best ability.
A Comparison Of Arthur Becomes King And
David And Goliath Essay, Research Paper A Comparison of Arthur Becomes King and David and Goliath Two of the most renowned leaders of all time, King Arthur and King David, have
Excalibur Essay Research Paper ExcaliburExcaliburIn Arthurian legend
Excalibur Essay, Research Paper Excalibur Excalibur:In Arthurian legend, the sword belonging to King Arthur. The sword with jeweled hilt and magic powers, of King Arthur of the Britons. One legend says the ?Lady of The Lake? gave it to him. Another says it is the sword fixed into the miraculous stone, to be removed only by the man that would become King.
Human Nature In The Legends Of King
Arthur And His Noble Knights Essay, Research Paper When John Stienbeck translated the tales of King Arthur he realized that he needed to maintain the elements of human nature that appeared through out the original stories. There are many examples of human nature in the sections of the book that we have read, there are good and bad aspects of human nature portrayed through the book and I will only mention a few.
Reflections Of Knights And Their Archetypal Damsels
(King Arthur) Essay, Research Paper 495 words Reflections of Knights and Their Archetypal Damsels In The Acts of King Arthur and His Noble Knights, there are many different relationships between knights and their damsels. The damsels, in some ways, reflect in different ways throughout the knights. Some example of knights and their damsels are Merlin and Nyneve, Ewain and Lyne, and Sir Accolon and Morgan Le Fay.
Article 4966 Essay Research Paper An Epic
Article 4966 Essay, Research Paper An Epic Hero for Modern Times In about 1470, Thomas Malory finished Morte d Arthur , the first if many legends written about King Arthur, even in modern times, King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table are favorite subjects in movies, books, and plays. Oftentimes this is so because the medieval period in general, and King Arthur in particular, have an air of mystery, romance, fantasy, and adventure that are popular themes in all times and cultures.
Beowulf Vs Arthur Essay Research Paper A
Beowulf Vs. Arthur Essay, Research Paper A man/woman of distinguished valor or enterprise in danger, or fortitude in suffering; a prominent or central personage in any remarkable action or event; hence, a great or illustrious person. We know of them as Superman, Batman or Spiderman. We call them heroes today and children very well know them.
Beowulf Vs King Arthur (COMPARE CONTRAST)
) Essay, Research Paper Sir Thomas Malory brings forth a courageous character , “King Arthur”, utilizing weaponry and leadership, to enlighten the reader of the unique characteristics of a true hero, on the other hand, the unknown author of “Beowulf”, depicts the Anglo-Saxan era to tell a story of one who fights to better society.
Arthur Ashe Essay Research Paper BiographyArthur Ashe
Arthur Ashe Essay, Research Paper Biography Arthur Ashe was a truly an important athlete in history. Ever since he was discovered at age 10 he had success written all over him. As a child Arthur won many awards. In high school there wasn?t really any competition. Arthur was so good that no one could even come close to beating him.
King Arthur And The Knights Of The
Round Table Essay, Research Paper King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table By Howard Pyle The book King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table, was written by a scholar named Howard Pyle in the late 1800 s. Mr. Pyle spent seven years researching all the existing information about King Arthur. He rewrote them into four volumes and created this wonderful fantasy.
The Real Arthur Essay Research Paper The
The Real Arthur Essay, Research Paper The Real King Arthur Arthur had been identified as the son of British king Uther Pendragon, who was the son of Constantine. Whatever else Arthur is, he is a composite figure of many different legends and beliefs. Some have even related his adventures to Greek mythology.
Versions Of King Arthur Essay Research Paper
Versions Of King Arthur In The Once and Future King by T.H White and ?Le Morte d?Arthur? by Sir Thomas Malory, the author?s writing techniques vary. King Arthur and the other characters involved in his life are portrayed differently by the two authors in the different books because of the differences in the techniques.
An Epic Hero For Modern Times Essay
, Research Paper An Epic Hero for Modern Times In about 1470, Thomas Malory finished Morte d’ Arthur, the first of the many legends written about King Arthur. Even in modern
King Arthur And The Catholic Church Essay
, Research Paper Daniel Cappadora Monsignor Farrell Ms. Brickey The Catholic Church has many influences on King Arthur and the rest of his Knights of the Round Table. The knights depended on the church for its teachings and the great power the church held in society. The Knights of the Round Table pledged great loyalty to the church.
King Arthur Essay Research Paper There has
King Arthur Essay, Research Paper There has been a lot of material written about the legendary King Arthur and although he has been a popular figure inliterature for over 800 years, not a lot is known about the real Arthur. It is believed that Arthur was a 5the-century British King named Riothamus (meaning “high king”) who ruled from 454 – 470 A.D. and led an army into Gaul where he was defeated by the Goths of Burgundy.
Morgana Essay Research Paper Morgana fe lay
Morgana Essay, Research Paper Morgana fe lay ( From the Arthurian cycle )My brother, king Arthur is nothing but a na ve idealist. His dream, or should I say fantasy of Camelot is nothing but an illusion. All dreams must end when one awakens. When Arthur dies and is replaced our son Mordred, the people will awaken from this dream created by him and by his charisma and the magic of Merlin.
King Arthur Essay Research Paper Arthur s
King Arthur Essay, Research Paper Arthur s plan for a round table signified truth and equality. It was to end competition between his knights. By having a round table there were no heads of the table and therefore no seat was more important than another. Arthur expressed his desire to encounter all of the evil in the world…so that if I conquered there would be none left.
King Arthur Essay Research Paper Real King
King Arthur Essay, Research Paper Real King Arthur In The Once and Future King, Portayal of the Middle Ages is thought to be made of magnificent castles, beautiful clothing, great kings and queens everything and everyone perfect. No proof of the.Towns back then were not pretty. Dirt thrived in cities there were diseases and crud everywhere.
Chester A Arthur Essay Research Paper Chet
Chester A. Arthur Essay, Research Paper Chet Arthur, President of the United States? Good God! That is what many of us were saying when former President Garfield died and