One of the oldest traditions in religious ethics is that of the just war. In the monotheistic religious traditions of Christianity and Islam, one role of God (or Allah) is to limit or control aggressions among humankind. In these religious traditions, God establishes an ideal or standard for the righteous use of force by followers of the faith. These standards, or just war traditions, address details of when to use force to solve disputes, to what extent the force should be employed, and whose blessing is required to insure that the use of force is appropriate in the eyes of God.
If a situation satisfies the just war tradition in that culture and the aggression is carried out for religious reasons, the action can be further classified as holy war. Many Americans connect the concept of holy war only with Islam. In fact the Christian crusades during the middle ages were just such a holy war being waged by Christians against Muslims. Whether a particular situation qualifies as a holy war or not, the focus of the just war tradition is to ask God for approval. “Appeals to ‘holy war’ or ‘religious crusade’ in one or another tradition are one type of appeal to divine authority regarding the use of force.”
In recent history numerous conflicts, border skirmishes, battles and wars have arisen in which governments have decided to apply military force to varying degrees. Inevitably, politicians, policy-makers, religious and military leaders seek divine authority on which to base the struggle of their population and the loss of life. Have religious ethical values or theological aspects of the just war tradition influenced the nature of these military actions? Have the prevailing religious values kept military actions any more humane than they might otherwise have been? This paper will examine the theological roots of the just war tradition in the Christian and Islamic cultures. In addition, it will try to ascertain how religious ethics, and the just war tradition in particular, was used during the conflict between Iraq and the United States (as part of the United Nations Security Council) in the 1991 Persian Gulf War. Finally, this paper will demonstrate that the true religious doctrines on just or holy war are often left far behind when political leaders from predominantly Christian and Islamic nations try to find moral high-ground on which to base their military actions.
Islamic Just War Ethics
The Islamic concept of jihad, often mistranslated as “holy war,” plays a strong role in Muslim just war tradition. Jihad more correctly refers to a “holy struggle” or “striving”. Unfortunately, jihad has been used as a means for justifying everything from defense of the right to worship Allah to blatant aggression against neighboring countries. Some of the confusion over jihad is the result of Western Both Sunni and Shi’ite Muslim scholars recognize that jihad is a term to be used cautiously as it seems to be in some sense applicable to fighting anyone whose faith in Allah can be questioned. Political leaders on the other hand have had a tendency to use the term whenever it increases their popularity or their people’s patience for enduring conflict.
Iraq is one of numerous Middle Eastern nations that could be classified as dar-al-Islam, or “the abode of Islam,” defined as a nation in which Muslim law or Shari’ah dictates much of everyday life. On the other hand, the United States can be classified as a predominantly Christian nation if not by ethical values, then certainly by population. While the significance of the Christian ethics of just war in the response to the invasion of Kuwait could certainly be questioned, public opinion in the United States was much more clearly affected by Christian ethics. Numerous Christian organizations in the United States expressed deep concern to the government about the dangers of retaliatory aggression and of wrong intentions. From the Iraqi perspective, Sadaam Hussein employed the Islamic concept of jihad or “struggle” against the enemies of Islam to gain popular support for the occupation of Kuwait and to rally the citizens to stand firm during the constant bombardment from United States air strikes.
In Islamic tradition, just war theory rests in jihad. Unfortunately the term itself is somewhat elusive in nature. On the most fundamental level, Islamic states denounce any war other than jihad, and in the loosest sense jihad is defined as a holy struggle. The term is almost analogous to the phrase “just war” in English. The term’s elusive nature stems from the inconsistancy with which it is applied to an act of military aggression. In the situation of the Christian Crusades, Muslims called for a jihad to repel Christians moving into the Islamic Ummah and killing Muslims as heretics. This action would clearly have been in defense of the faith, which seems to be where the Quaran draws a line. Aggression to protect the religion or people’s right to practice it takes precedence over other kinds of conflict. In addition there is frequently a distinction between theological and activist interpretations of jihad. For this reason, we will examine some of the influences on Arab thought that led to the many interpretations of jihad.
As Islam grew in popularity throughout the Middle East, Islamic territories expanded into what used to be Persia, the Ottoman Empire, most of North Africa, and elsewhere. As these geographic territories were converted to Islam, certain aspects of culture became ingrained in the interpretation of Islamic doctrine. Byzantium and Persia had militant cultures that lent themselves to a broad interpretation of jihad once they became part of the Islamic Ummah. They were both already expansionist societies and, as they grew, the culture adopted jihad as justification for expanding boundaries even further and converting as many people to Islam as possible along the way. The conversions were usually not coerced in a violent way, but the territories were taken over in the name of Allah and all residents were required to pay a poll tax.
In addition, the Shi’ite Muslims have a more liberal sense of the word jihad. Their belief is that the Imam or carrier of the prophetic light is currently in hiding and will return again someday
Christian Just War Ethics
Christian Theology has no clear term like jihad for a defensible use of military force, but theologians including Augustine and Thomas Aquinas have addressed the issue, and so it is reasonable to discuss a Christian theory of just war. As we examine the Christian theory of just war, it should be clear that many of the concepts it details are as viable in modern Christian ethics as they were in the first millennium. In addition, the Christian theory of just war has much in common with Western secular concepts of the same. They share much in the way of philosophy
After early Christians determined that there might be a long wait for the return of Christ and the end of time, they resumed a participatory role in worldly affairs that had been absent for most of the first century CE. This role included discussing moral and ethical dilemmas in matters of state and politics. The following is a very brief attempt to summarize the Christian theory of just war.
Augustine, and perhaps earlier his mentor Ambrose, first identified the concept of a good Christian coming to the aid of a neighbor having harm inflicted on him by an unjust aggressor. In their theory, the aid provided could even consist of the use of force when necessary, with the response of the Christian limited by the fact that Christ died for the assailant as well as the victim.
Aquinas added to this concept in the Summa Theologiae by stating that just war required that three conditions be met: the war must be fought on right authority, with just cause, and be waged with right intentions. By right authority, Aquinas meant that the actions must be endorsed by the highest political and religious figures in the land. Just cause implies that the object of the aggression is committing some intolerable act of harm on a primarily helpless victim. Right intention means that the objective of the aggression needs to be peace and not retribution or hatred. At its most fundamental level, this theory rests on the moral duty of love of neighbor and adds the limitations of protecting the innocent and minimizing the damage done to the aggressor.
1991 Persian Gulf War as a Brief Case Study
In the example of the Persian Gulf War, both Christians and Muslims used just war theory to solidify the moral ground for their actions. Iraq had only marginal success in convincing other nations that their cause was holy. Not even many Islamic nations felt that Iraq had legitimate claim to invade Kuwait. Despite this fact, Sadaam Hussein called his people into action by claiming that Kuwait had become a stronghold of capitalist and an enemy of Islam (despite Kuwait’s 10 Billion U.S. dollar contribution to Iraq’s war against Iran).
The United States, on the other hand, used Christian just war theory to claim that our response to Iraq was out of love for our “neighbors” in Kuwait, and therefore just. In reality our foreign interests in the area run so deep that no action by the United States in the Middle East could be thought to be undertaken purely out of Christian love. Despite our fossil fuel interests in the area’s politics, the rhetoric of religious ethics was indeed used by United States politicians as George Bush publicly prayed over his decisions regarding the American response to the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. When a response came from the U.S., it was announced by Bush as a careful and measured response to the Iraqi aggression against it’s neighbor, with the clear goal of getting Iraq out of Kuwait and removing their ability to further terrorize the region. Clearly all three of Aquinas’ bullet points were ostensibly addressed in the response, we fight on right authority, with just cause, and with right intentions. Whether or not United States motivations were pure, it was clear that they were being sold to the public as just and righteous.
Conclusion
Just war is an elusive concept since the evil and violent nature of war defies being classified as righteous, but both Islam and Christianity have clearly taken theological steps to apply religious ethics to the politics and execution of war. While they base their claims for justice quite differently, the objective seems the same in as much as they both attempt to fit war into the context of a righteous and holy society.
Bibliography
Encyclopedia of Islam; New York: International Union of Academies, 1960.
Esposito, John L. The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Modern Islamic World. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995.
Fisher, Mary Pat. Living Religions. 4th Ed. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall, 1999.
Glasse, Cyril. Concise Encyclopedia of Islam. San Francisco: Harper Press, 1991.
Hunt, Arnold D. and Crotty Robert B. Ethics of World Religions. Minneapolis, Minnesota: Greenhaven Press, 1978.
Johnson, James Turner and Weigel, George. Just War and the Gulf War. Washington D.C.: Ethics and Public Policy Center, 1991.
Kelsay, John. Islam and War, The Gulf War and Beyond. Louisville, Kentucky: Westminster Press, 1993.
Kelsay, John and Johnson, James Turner. Just War and Jihad, Historical and Theoretical Perspectives on War and Peace in Western and Islamic Traditions. Westport, Connectiut: Greenwood Press, 1991.
Quasen, Muhammad Abul. Ethics of Al-Ghazali: A Composite Ethics In Islam. Peninsular Malaysia: Muhammad Abul Quasem, 1975.
Vaux, Kenneth L. Ethics and the Gulf War, Religion, Rhetoric and Righteousness. Boulder, Colorado: Westview Press, 1992.
335
Другие работы по теме:
Alfred Wegener Essay Research Paper Alfred Wegener
Alfred Wegener Essay, Research Paper Alfred Wegener was an explorer and meteorologist, born in Berlin, who first came up with the “Continental Drift Theory” or the “Wegener Theory.” This theory stated that all of the continents came from one super continent, also known as Pangea, which spread apart gradually moving into their current positions on Earth.
September 11 Essay Research Paper During the
September 11 Essay, Research Paper During the summer of tenth grade, I took a number theory course at Johns Hopkins University with students from Alaska, California, and Bogota, Colombia. My attendance of the New Jersey Governor’s School in the Sciences is another accomplishment that exemplifies my dedication to knowledge.
The HerseyBlanchard Situation Essay Research Paper The
The Hersey-Blanchard Situation Essay, Research Paper The Hersey-Blanchard Situational Theory One of the most widely followed leadership models is the situational leadership theory of Paul Heresy and Kenneth Blanchard. Situational Leadership Theory is a contingency theory that focuses on the followers.
Pyramids 3 Essay Research Paper Pyramids are
Pyramids 3 Essay, Research Paper Pyramids are one of the world s greatest mysteries, which are located in Egypt. There were a lot of theories of how the pyramids were built, but no one was sure. The Greeks came up with the theory, that it took 100, 000 men and 20 years to build the Great Pyramid of Gizeh. That theory was proven wrong because it was believed that it took 5 times that amount of men.
Game Theory Essay Research Paper Game TheoryStrategic
Game Theory Essay, Research Paper Game Theory (Strategic Thinking in Everyday Life) Have you ever been faced with having to live with a decision you made knowing that had you taken the time to analyze the outcomes you may have made a more intelligible choice? Most likely the answer to that question was “yes”.
Islamic Spread Essay Research Paper From its
Islamic Spread Essay, Research Paper From its beginnings in Arabia to its extensive empire encompassing the Middle East, parts of Asia, North Africa, and parts of Europe,paul duffy is fat the
William James Essay Research Paper William James
William James Essay, Research Paper William James, in the first lecture of his work the varieties of religious experiences analyzes the origins of religious phenomena. The theory mostly debated among others is that of medical materialism.
Positivism Essay Research Paper PositivismPositivism is the
Positivism Essay, Research Paper Positivism Positivism is the belief that “scientific naturalism” is the foundation of knowledge and truth. Leszek Kolakowski wrote “Positivism is a normative attitude, regulating how we are to use such terms as knowledge , science , cognition , and information . Positivism rejects the theories of theology and metaphysics because they don t have proof that they are true.
Islam Expansion Essay Research Paper The Islamic
Islam Expansion Essay, Research Paper The Islamic civilization spread to such an extensive empire through many techniques. They conquered neighboring areas rapidly. They spread Islam onto the people in three ways. One practice that caused them to spread was their expertise on war. Another would be the forced conversion of Islam to the people.
Copernicus Essay Research Paper Copernicus
Copernicus Essay, Research Paper Copernicus’ work on planetary motion stood an a very high mathematical level for his times. His theory explained how all the celestial bodies move around the Sun. It took Nicolaus 30 years of mathematical research to form a theory about planetary motion. The three most popular instruments which Copernicus used were quadrant, armilla, and triquetrum.
Byzantine Islamic Empires Comparison Essay Research Paper
Byzantine and Islamic Empires q Introduction Both the Islamic and in the Byzantine Empires had very important social structures. There are differences between the two Empires in all aspects, however both were successful. The Byzantine was part of the great Roman Empire and the Islamic Empire was built on religious belief.
Islamic Women Essay Research Paper Many times
Islamic Women Essay, Research Paper Many times when feminists looked at Islamic women they criticized the man for not treating women properly. However, as Jane I. Smith states, women of Islam are not really offended by that fact, on the contrary, they believe that it is better for them.
Divine Command Theory Essay Research Paper Divine
Divine Command Theory Essay, Research Paper Divine Command Theory The divine command theory is the view that moral actions are those which conform to God’s will. Charity, for example, is morally proper because God endorses it, and murder is wrong because God condemns it. One way to test to see whether any action is right or wrong is first to determine if it conforms to God’s will, it is morally permissible, if it does not, then it is impermissible.
Douglas M Mcgregor Essay Research Paper Douglas
Douglas M. Mcgregor Essay, Research Paper Douglas M. McGregor Mr. McGregor theorizes that management views an employee s motivation toward work in two distinct ways Theory X and Theory Y. Theory X managers believe the following: (1) The average worker naturally does not like work and will avoid it whenever possible. (2) Managers must always control, motivate, and direct their employees to perform well. (3) Most workers prefer being directed, avoid responsibility, and seek job security.
Pluralism Essay Research Paper PLURALISM AS THE
Pluralism Essay, Research Paper PLURALISM AS THE MOST DESCRIPTIVE THEORY OF AMERICAN GOVERNMENTThere are several different theories as to the question of how America is governed. Thereare those who still espouse the civics book theory, in which the individual is representedby his vote; those who advocate various elitist theories, claiming that we as individualshave no voice, and are merely pawns in some larger game, and there are those others whosupport what is known as the pluralist theory.
Islam Affects Our World Essay Research Paper
The Islamic religion, founded by Muhammad, has affected this world with a variety of ways. In 732, the religion was in full effect with people from the Middle East to North Africa learning about Islam and the Koran. The Islamic people, Muslims, had different attitudes toward life and what life was about compared to other religions across the globe.
Islamic Rugs Essay Research Paper Wendy JenkinsAR
Islamic Rugs Essay, Research Paper Wendy JenkinsAR 103 AQuiz #1February 25, 1999Islamic Prayer Rugs Once inside the Mulvane Art Museum, my eyes became fixed upon beautiful rugs that lined the wall. As our tour guide, Frankie Parmen, explained these rugs are used in everyday life of Muslims. They are called Prayer Rugs.
Sasanian Silver Essay Research Paper In the
Sasanian Silver Essay, Research Paper In the broad world of islamic art its not always easy to tell were the piece your looking at comes from, what period it was created in and what materials were used to make it. It can be complicated as islamic art differs from country to country and in some cases from city to city.
Persia Essay Research Paper Influence of Islamic
Persia Essay, Research Paper Influence of Islamic Art The art of Europe, or ‘Western art’ is of a totally different type and style as what is known as ‘Islamic art’. It is difficult to have samples of both together in one place, observe the patterns of one and the narrative form of the other and say, “Islamic art influenced the art of Italy”.
Islamic Holy Days Essay Research Paper The
Islamic Holy Days Essay, Research Paper The Islamic religion’s holiest city of Mecca (also known as Mekka or Makkah) is located in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. It’s importance as a holy city for Muslims harks back to it being the birthplace of the founder of Islam, Mohammed.
Islamic Religion Essay Research Paper I do
Islamic Religion Essay, Research Paper I do not agree with the Islamic beliefs that God is the enemy of unbelievers. As an outsider to this religion this does not sit well with me. I believe God has no enemies. Wait, I mean he loves everyone, but I?m kind of unsure of his feelings towards child molesters, rapists and murderers.
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Personality Theory The development of gender roles in deifferent forms of feminsm gives us a revealing overview of Freud’s personality theory. It is relatively
Is Evolution A Fact Or A Theory
? Essay, Research Paper Is Evolution a Fact or a Theory? Both. In Darwin’s day, and before, many naturalists theorized that living things were somehow related in a manner beyond that of their obvious common differences from non-living matter. These speculations, including those of Darwin, are appropriately termed theories: speculations about nature that were informed by observation and subject to test by additional observations.
Supporting Big Bang Essay Research Paper Science
Supporting Big Bang Essay, Research Paper Science has hypothesized that the universe was created by a big bang. By researching stars and fossil records scientists have claimed that the earth is much older than it is said to be in the creation theory. The creation theory says that the universe is only several thousand years old, but carbon dating has shown that fossils on earth are millions of years old thus disproving part of the creation theory with evidence.
Big Bang Essay Research Paper Before The
Big Bang Essay, Research Paper Before The Big Bang Every since scientists came up with an idea of how the universe started and was created, through the Big Bang, there has always been discussion and questioning on what the universe was, before it was created. Was there nothing because there was no time and no God, or was there something we haven t discovered yet.
Sociology 101 Essay Research Paper Sociology 101By
Sociology 101 Essay, Research Paper Sociology 101 By: Chris Reeh This article is about Spanish rabbi-poet named Judah Halevi. He lived in a society in which Jews were socially powerless. They were also influenced heavily by the dominant Islamic culture. He wrote many poems and books. His poetry brought a deeper sense of the Jewish spirituality to many people.
Ramadan Essay Research Paper RamadanRamdan the ninth
Ramadan Essay, Research Paper Ramadan Ramdan, the ninth month of the Islamic year, is a holy month of fasting ordained by the Koran for all adult Muslims . According to the Koran, the fast of Ramadan has been
Islamic Art
& Architecture Essay, Research Paper Two dominant features of Islamic art and architecture, the importance of calligraphic ornamentation and the form of the mosque, are intimately related to the Islamic faith and were developed in the early days of the religion. The part about Islamic art and architecture that stands out the most is it’s uniform style, its symmetrical and stands out more boldly than other buildings and art work.
Grand Unified Theory Essay Research Paper Final
Grand Unified Theory Essay, Research Paper Final essay 7 Essay 7 There are many laws to help us understand motion and the way things move and work. Most of the modern excepted theories were either thought up by Sir Isaac Newton or Albert Einstein, and Greene?s theory tried to tie them all together.
Inherit The Wind Essay Research Paper In
Inherit The Wind Essay, Research Paper In our Consititution, citizens have many righhts, but do we have the right to think? In the play Inherit the Wind by Jerome Lawrence adn Robert Lee, a man is on trial for teaching his students about the theory of evolution. Drummond, the lawyer for this man, said “With all respect to the bench, I hold that the right to think is very much on trial.”