Is carbon dating accurate?
Carbon dating, used since 1948, is currently the main method of testing artifacts for age. My objective through this essay is to disprove the accuracy of the Carbon 14 dating method.
William Libby invented carbon dating in 1948. It works on the principle that the carbon 14-C, is radioactive. It decays at a ?known? rate called a half-life. This is balanced by the fact that 14-C is constantly produced in atmospheric reactions. Because of this, 14-C and it?s breakdown product 12-C, typically stay in balance. Carbon is passed between the ocean, atmosphere, and living things in the ?Carbon Cycle?. When an animal dies it is taken out of the carbon cycle. After this, the proportion of 14-C to 12-C steadily declines. This supposedly allows one to date an object by the proportion of 14-C to 12-C.
The problems of Carbon 14 dating are endless. A test in ?Science? (vol. 141, page 636, August 16, 1963) showed the shell from a living mollusk to be dead for 3,000 years!
Tests of Hawaiian lava flows known to be less than 200 years old have been dated up to 3 billion years old! The truth is, the time range for 14-C is unknown1! That is, the scientists themselves do not know the effective range for 14-C. Also, All carbon dates have a ?plus-minus? probable error range. The older the item, the bigger the error range. An additional problem is that the true half-life of 14-C is unknown2! Scientists are drawing ?logical? conclusions from an assumption of 14-C?s half-life!. Surrounding soil, water, vegetation and/or animal matter can even contaminate samples! When this contamination occurs, it mixes the date for the item with the date of the contaminant. Exacerbating this effect, non-living items cannot be dated! There is also the human subjectivity in carbon-14 dating. For instance, if someone found a 9.5 million year old human in an area where there was a land bridge that was there 9.25 million years ago, they could say the person is 9.25 million years ? 0.25 million years.
I hope this brief essay has swayed your view of the Carbon-14 dating method. My final words on this subject are, that even from a scientific standpoint, carbon dating cannot be accepted. There are too many errors, and too many possibilities for error.
1. I have found over 20 different values for the time range of carborn-14 dating all in scientific papers. 3 of the papers said that the value was unknown
2. Most of the papers I read indicated differences in scientific communities value for the half-life of 14-C while 1 paper directly indicated this.
Другие работы по теме:
Origin Of Humanity Essay Research Paper Origin
Origin Of Humanity Essay, Research Paper Origin Of HumanityWe live on a planet believed to be 4.5 billion years of agewith millions of people covering all parts of it. Where did theycome from? Did the whole human population originate from oneof people or were we placed here and then improved or changed by an intervention? I believe that humanity on planet earth wascreated by evolution.
Social Ills Essay Research Paper Every society
Social Ills Essay, Research Paper Every society of every civilization known to man has had its share of social ills. Even dating back to biblical times people have struggled with an ever-increasing number of hardships. All of which have led to the downfall of its social structure. As we all know, nothing lasts forever, but with the help of strong minds and able bodies, societies can curb their ills and ?clean up their act?.
Rimbaud Essay Research Paper Part II
Rimbaud Essay, Research Paper Part II A man so confused and confusing as Arthur Rimbaud, it is a wonder that he can even be analyzed, critiqued, and judged by his literary works. Never the less it has been done, however how accurate can they be, when even Rimbaud said in his Lettre Du Voyant that for the I is someone else.
Dating Anxiety Essay Research Paper Dating AnxietyHave
Dating Anxiety Essay, Research Paper Dating Anxiety Have you ever been really stressed about something? Think of the time when you have been the most stressed out. Multiply that to the 10th power and you have me before a date. It seems to me dating and stress are like salt and pepper; you almost never have one without the other.
Relative Dating Essay Research Paper The Fundamental
Relative Dating Essay, Research Paper The Fundamental Principles of Relative DatingRelative dating involves placing events in their proper chronological sequence, that is, in the order of their occurrence (Dutch 1998). This type of dating tells us which geologic event happened first, but does not give an exact date to which something happened.
1984 The End Of Time Essay Research
Paper This date stands as a prediction, as a warning. Now, we know things didn?t exactly happen as they were detailed, can?t we give another meaning to the title, is it not just ironical? Orwell was definitely aware that this date would not be accurate, that this could not just be considered as a deadline, but a warning to open our criticism and vigilance, this title is nonsensical, you have to transcend the date to come to new questions, did it really need to be dated, as Orwell knew this would not be accurate, is it not a sign? It occurs through a study of the book that dates and time are a great theme in 1984, but not to show as time matters in development ,ageing or human predicament, but how it can be stopped, how time can be stopped to make human history and evolution forgotten.
Important Chemical Elements Essay Research Paper I
Important Chemical Elements Essay, Research Paper I believe that the three most important elements that exist are nitrogen, carbon and oxygen. Nitrogen is extremely valuable because it is such a large part of the food web. Carbon is important because it is also part of the food web due to the fact that it plays such an important role in the structure of all living things and many nonliving things.
God In The Details Essay Research Paper
‘GOD IN THE DETAILS’ The whole theory of various shrouds and their existence, is what this article is based on. His main focus is the shroud of Turin, which is believed Jesus Christ was wrapped in. But, radioactive carbon dating has proved that it was made in the Middle Ages, and yet, many people still go and visit it.
Faust By Goethe 1749
– 1832) Essay, Research Paper The legend of Faust is older than Goethe’s version, dating back to the early years of Christianity. The English poet Christopher Marlowe wrote his own version of the play several centuries
Physics Lab Essay Research Paper III ResultsAnalysisMy
Physics Lab Essay, Research Paper III. Results/Analysis: My lab partner and I worked diligently in this experiment to be as accurate and as precise in our measurements and calculations with the technology provided. In part one of the experiment, we calculated the amount of force on the planet at the closest distance to be approximately 18 F.
Biology Interpretation Essay Research Paper InterpretationStatistical calculations
Biology: Interpretation Essay, Research Paper Interpretation Statistical calculations made with the results obtained, conclude the null hypothesis previously made, is acceptable and there is in fact a relationship between percentage epiphyte cover and height from the ground. However, when studying the tables of results it is difficult to find a pattern in results obtained.
Perfect Man Essay Research Paper The perfect
Perfect Man Essay, Research Paper The perfect man is said to be hard to find, but I believe there is someone for every person. Sometimes a man is not perfect when you meet him, but he may have some qualities you like. If you are young some men will grow and mature into someone, you love. Dating is a search for the perfect man and a soul mate.
Oxygen And Carbon Dioxide Essay Research Paper
OXYGEN (O)Oxygen was discovered by a British chemist, Joseph Priestly in 1774, and independantly by Carl Wilhelm Scheele, a Sweedish chemist. Oxygen has many uses – it is used in welding torches, to assist in hospital patient’s breathing and in metal fabrication industries. Oxygen is also used for defense purposes as a propellant for guided misiles and rocketsCARBON DIOXIDE (CO2).Carbon dioxide was named ‘fixed air’ by a Scottish chemist, Joseph Black.
Carbon
– The King Of Elements Essay, Research Paper When you look at the periodic table, you see a lot of letters, some numbers, different colors, and areas divided into rows and sections. There is one element on the periodic
Courtship Vs Dating Essay Research Paper Courtship
Courtship Vs. Dating Essay, Research Paper Courtship – the act of wooing Woo – to ask in marriage; to court, to solicit eagerly; to seek to gain. You ask, ?What in the world is Courtship?? Let me start by saying it is our country?s dating problem solution. Not too long ago, Christian parents along with their youth had realized the need to re-map the route to fruitful, God-ordained marriages.
Ertwr Essay Research Paper Oxygenpoor blood from
Ertwr Essay, Research Paper Oxygen-poor blood from the body flows down through the RIGHT ATRIUM to fill the RIGHT VENTRICLE which pumps the blood out through the PULMONARY ARTERY to the lungs.
Bicarbonate A Good Buffer For Blood Essay
, Research Paper Bicarbonate: A good buffer for blood Most carbon dioxide generated during metabolism is transported in the form of bicarbonate ions, which result from the dissociation of carbonic acid formed in the red blood cells from the chemical union of carbon dioxide and water. Hydrogen ions from the dissociation are bound to hemoglobin and other proteins, serving to buffer the blood.
Carbon Dioxide Essay Research Paper Carbon DioxideRespiratory
Carbon Dioxide Essay, Research Paper Carbon Dioxide Respiratory gases-oxygen and carbon dioxide moves between air and blood in the lungs. The structure of the human lung provides immense internal surface that facilitates gas exchange between the alveoli and the blood in the pulmonary capillaries.
Carbon Dioxide Essay Research Paper Carbon is
Carbon Dioxide Essay, Research Paper Carbon is the basis for all life on earth. This essay will explain the role of carbon dioxide in v arious parts of the carbon cycle. This essay will examin three main, and
Carbon Dioxide Essay Research Paper CARBON DIOXIDECarbon
Carbon Dioxide Essay, Research Paper CARBON DIOXIDE Carbon dioxide is a gas comprising less than 0.04 % of the atmosphere.It is used by plants to make, directly or indirectly, all of the food that we eat.Increases in the concentration of carbon dioxide generally increase the growthrate of plants and decrease their water use.
Fossil Fuels Essay Research Paper We get
Fossil Fuels Essay, Research Paper We get energy from sunlight, wind, nuclear plants, and damns However, most of the energy that we use comes from fossil fuels. There are three major fossil fuels: Coal, oil and natural gas. These are composed of carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, oxygen and sulfur. Carbon is the major element in fossil fuels.
Cellular Respiration Essay Research Paper Cellular respiration
Cellular Respiration Essay, Research Paper Cellular respiration begins with glucose. Glucose is the primary fuel used in glycolysis, the first stage of cellular respiration. This molecule is found in the gel-like substance called cytoplasm that fills the cell. In glycolysis, glucose undergoes phosphorylation by ATP.
Divorce Essay Research Paper Till Death Do
Divorce Essay, Research Paper Till Death Do Us Part Today, many people believe marriage is almost like dating. Some men and women meet, and before they get to know one another they make the choice to be wed. That is why divorce rate is higher than it has been in history. Divorce is now a popular solution to problems that many American couples have.
Organic Chemistry Essay Research Paper Organic compounds
Organic Chemistry Essay, Research Paper Organic compounds are all different but they all share a similar characteristic. To start all organic compounds have carbon in their formulas; this is the main characteristic all organic compounds share. Next, some organic compounds are made up with a single covalent bond.
Supporting Big Bang Essay Research Paper Science
Supporting Big Bang Essay, Research Paper Science has hypothesized that the universe was created by a big bang. By researching stars and fossil records scientists have claimed that the earth is much older than it is said to be in the creation theory. The creation theory says that the universe is only several thousand years old, but carbon dating has shown that fossils on earth are millions of years old thus disproving part of the creation theory with evidence.
Dna Structure Essay Research Paper DNA Structure
Dna Structure Essay, Research Paper DNA Structure DNA is a double stranded molecule twisted into a helix. Each spiraling strand is comprised of a sugar phosphate backbone and attached bases connected to a complimentary strand. The complimentary strand is connected by non-covalent hydrogen bonding between paired bases.
Interracial Dating Essay Research Paper I
Interracial Dating Essay, Research Paper I’ve had my own share of relationships and experienced the ups and downs. Yet it never did it occur to me that the cause for such experiences would be because of what my boyfriend and I were born with: our races. Being biracial myself, (Japanese and Filipino) I have come across many different aspects of both cultures.