Freudian Slips Essay, Research Paper
Freudian Slips
Some would argue that all slips of the tongue are Freudian slips. Indeed Freud and his avid following of psychoanalysts would insist that all slips of the tongue reveal the presence of suppressed impulses or intentions. However, much evidence has been found to refute this psychoanalytical view; and it can be convincingly asserted that all slips of the tongue are not Freudian, and that there are other cognitive reasons to explain these verbal slips.
In Dr. Freud’s own words, “a suppression of a previous intention to say something is the indispensable condition for the occurrence of slips of the tongue” ( ). He would argue that slips of the tongue were never accidents, that they always revealed some underlying unconscious or repressed need or impulse. For instance, Freud once set up the scenario of a professor of anatomy who was lecturing on the female genitalia and was heard to declare “In the case of the female genitals, in spite of many temptations (Versuchungen)— I beg your pardon, experiments (Versuche)” ( ). Freud’s theory suggests that this professor’s slip of the tongue arouse because of some suppressed impulse or intention on the part of the professor. In Freud’s mind, this verbal slip could not have been accidental or based on any explanation other than the “indispensable condition” of suppression he had proposed.
Furthermore, Freud and his psychoanalysts would assert that this suppression of intent or impulse, which they made the cornerstone of all slips of the tongue, could operate at three different levels. On one level the suppression could be conscious and deliberate, on another the suppression can be identified afterward by the person who made the slip but was not intended beforehand, and at the deepest level the person absolutely denies the suppression. For Freudians, it really doesn’t matter what level the person who has made a slip of the tongue is operating at. For them “in all cases the slip is the result of the conflict between two forces— the underlying, unacceptable need and the tendency to keep it hidden” ( ). Therefore if there was no other evidence or authority on the subject, it might seem that all slips of the tongue were Freudian, that they all happened due to some suppressed impulse or intention. However there is much evidence to rival Freud’s theory; while some slips may be Freudian, this is certainly not always the case.
Modern cognitive psychology offers more convincing evidence for the occurrence of slips of the tongue. First and foremost, slips of the tongue can occur due to strong habit intrusions(banalizations). “Forms which have a more archaic, more high-flown, more unusually stylistic expression, and which are therefore removed from the cultural-linguistic heritage of the person, tend to be replaced by forms in more common use” ( ). This basically means that people may make slips of the tongue accidentally, due to habit. So some slips of the tongue could happen merely because the person is so used to expressing a word in a different way. For instance, many people misquote Shakespeare’s line “All that glisters is not gold” as “All that glitters is not gold” ( ). Since “glitters” is more familiar to us than “glisters” we might switch the more common for the less common. Certainly this slip of the tongue is not due to some suppressed impulse or intention as Freud would suggest, but instead occurs as the result of a banalization or strong habit intrusion.Therefore, it is not wise to suggest that all slips of the tongue are Freudian.
Furthermore, contemporary cognitive psychology disputes the psychoanalytical idea that all slips of the tongue are Freudian by exploring the idea of the Need System and the Intention System. Precisely with regard to slips of the tongue, the Need System is able to function independently of the Intention System through the Word Store. This means that………(a person may say something solely based on a need with or without having an intent???)…… For example, a person expecting a dinner guest with a large nose briefs himself to avoid making any reference to nose at dinner. Then dinner comes and he says “Pass the nose” instead of “Pass the salt” ( ). While Freudians would argue that the slip had to occur due to a repressed intent to say “nose,” this is not necessarily the case. First, the host could have slipped and said “nose” because of his need to avoid embarrassment and not because of some suppressed intent to say the word, as Freud would believe. Cognitive psychologists could therefore argue that the slip occurred because the word nose was primed in the host’s brain through “need priming.” In other words, the host attached an importance to the word nose in his mind, not because he was suppressing an intent or desire to say it, but because of the fear and worries he needed to avoid. In addition to this explanation, it could also be argued that the host said the word nose because of strong habit intrusion. He had simply rehearsed the word so much in his head to avoid saying it, that it slipped out as a result. This accidental slip was not due to suppressed intent or impulse, which would constitute a Freudian slip. Thus Freud and the psychoanalysts most definitely do not offer the last word on all slips of the tongue.
Moreover, though some slips of the tongue may in fact be Freudian, not all of them are. Some slips of the tongue may simply be due to strong habit intrusions and not due to the suppressed intent and impulse which characterize a Freudian slip. And, while Freud’s theories on slips may be more interesting(and certainly more sexual), they are not always correct. Modern cognitive psychology offers much more solid, straightforward, scientific evidence for the occurrence of slips of the tongue and proves once again that Mr. Freud, perhaps much to his dismay, is not the be-all, end-all authority in this realm of psychology.
Другие работы по теме:
Psychoanalytic Therapy Session Essay Research Paper Classical
Psychoanalytic Therapy Session Essay, Research Paper Classical Psychoanalysis. Situation: Billy Bruce has been suffering a mild form of manic depression, or bipolar disorder and finally decided to seek help from a classical psychoanalyst, Michelle, who was a strict Freudian. Following is an excerpt of the conversations between Billy and his psychoanalyst during a typical therapy.
Psychoanalytic And Gender Perspectives In Great Expectations
Essay, Research Paper Criticisms of Great Expectations: Psychoanalytic and Gender Perspectives Psychoanalytic and gender literary criticisms are important as individual analyses and are similar in some respects, namely sexual and gender issues, which make them ideal choices for analyzing Great Expectations.
Bettelheim Essay Research Paper In Bruno Bettelheims
Bettelheim Essay, Research Paper In Bruno Bettelheim?s essay, The Uses of Enchantment, he explains the fairy tale of Snow White in a way which makes the reader think critically. He makes the reader explore their mind to better understand a tale in a way, which they have not explored.
Critique Of Bruno Bettelheim
’s And Karen Kolbenschlag’s Interpretation Of “Cinderella” Essay, Research Paper As is well known, the famous storytale Cinderella has many variants across cultures and time periods. These variants have been found to have the same general plot, which is characterized by the persecuted heroine, the meeting with the prince, the revealing of an inner identity, and marriage with the prince.
Know Thyself Essay Research Paper How does
Know Thyself Essay, Research Paper How does one really know themselves? You could recognize the exterior and know your own reflection. Sure you are 6 2 with brown hair and eyes. Not a bad-looking individual. But you are not your physical characteristics but your spiritual ones. If you could look into something and see your internal reflection would you want to? What would you see? What would you learn? What would that something be? What could possibly dig deep into your soul and reveal your innermost person?
Clouds Essay Research Paper CloudsI
Clouds Essay, Research Paper Clouds I’VE OPENED THE CURTAIN of my east window here above the computer, and I sit now in a holy theater before a sky-blue stage. A little cloud above the neighbor’s trees resembles Jimmy Durante’s nose for a while, then becomes amorphous as it slips on north. Other clouds follow, big and little and tiny on their march toward whereness.
Why Do Females Ask Males The Question
They Do? Essay, Research Paper Every day males are faced with questions that, in a females perspective, are punishable by death if answered incorrectly. Why do they do this to us and what can males do to evade them? The questions seem basic enough at first glance. When examined further, the questions are without a resolution.
Funeral Blues Essay Research Paper WH Auden
Funeral Blues Essay, Research Paper W.H. Auden wrote Funeral Blues the poem. Wystan Hugh Auden (1907-1973) was born in York, England, and later became and American citizen. Auden was the founder for a generation of English poets, such as C. Day Lewis, and Stephen Spender. Auden s earlier works were composed of a Marxist outlook with a knowledge of Freudian Psychology.
The Scooby Doo Theory The Governess
’ Sanity And Early Ghost Appearances Essay, Research Paper The Scooby Doo Theory: The Governess’ Sanity and Early Ghost Appearances in The Turn of the Screw
Oedipal And Electra Complex Essay Research Paper
Not So Complex: Understanding the Oedipal and Electra Complex Sigmund Freud’s psychoanalytic theory on human sexuality introduces the Oedipal and Electra complexes as a psychological approach in understanding the origins of sexual orientation. Most people disagree with his theory and throw out the concept of the Oedipal and Electra conflicts altogether.
Dream Interpatation Essay Research Paper DREAM INTERPRETATIONThere
Dream Interpatation Essay, Research Paper DREAM INTERPRETATION There are many different interpretations of dreams and dreaming. These interpretations tend to fall into two main categories. There is the physiological approach or the psychological approach. The physiological approach deals with the brain’s interpretations of nerve actions.
Dada Vs Surrealism Essay Research Paper What
Dada Vs. Surrealism Essay, Research Paper What elements of dada and surrealism suggest the influence of Freud? The 20th Century marked a changed in how people viewed the known world. Since its beginning art has played a major role in how people were able to express themselves. The early 20th century brought rise to new and exciting art forms.
Freudian Defense Mechanisms Essay Research Paper All
Freudian Defense Mechanisms Essay, Research Paper All people use defense mechanisms, whether they be consciously or unconsciously. Anxiety may arise from an intense situation or even past experience. It is then the ego’s job to displace anxiety so as to protect the rest of the mind. Through defense mechanisms such as sublimation, repression, fantasy, compulsive fun-seeking, and negativism, the ego eliminates anxiety caused by surroundings which in effect tries to prevent insanity.
Jack Merridew Essay Research Paper Jack Merridew
Jack Merridew Essay, Research Paper Jack Merridew “He was tall, thin, and bony, and his hair was red beneay the black cap. His face was crumpled and freckled, and ugly without silliness.” A cruel and ugly bully, he early develops a taste for violence. He is a leader of the choir at first, and then of the hunters.
James Joyce Essay Research Paper In the
James Joyce Essay, Research Paper In the Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, James Joyce creates a deeply personal and emotional portrait to every man. Joyce’s main character, Stephen Dedalus, encounters universal feelings of detachment, guilt, and awakening. Rather than stepping back and remembering the characteristics of infancy and childhood from and adult perspective, Joyce uses the language the infant was enveloped in.
David Herbert Lawrence Essay Research Paper David
David Herbert Lawrence Essay, Research Paper David Herbert Lawrence As a twentieth century novelist, essayist, and poet, David Herbert Lawrence brought the subjects of sex, psychology, and religion to the
Case Study Of Bill Clinton Essay Research
Paper Freudian Perspective Bill Clinton s early childhood did not show many signs of him one day becoming president of the United States. He was from a small town family which was not the usual rich family that is needed to produce a president. The only things that may suggest his drive to become president are the thoughts implanted in his superego(Sdorow, 1995) by the troubles of an alcoholic step-father and the usual troubles of daily life that children must deal with.
A Freudian View Of Cruel Inten Essay
, Research Paper A Freudian View of Cruel Intentions In a movie like Cruel Intentions which is filled with sex and sexual relations between its characters, a man such as Sigmund Freud would relish in the realization that the characters have about their own sexuality. The two main characters Sidney and Sebastian begin the movie with little more than a basic yearning to fulfill the desires of their ID.
Freud
’s Oz: Freudian Views In The Wizard Of Oz Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Oz: Freudian Views in The Wizard of Oz The film The Wizard of Oz is definitely about the concept of returning
Psych Review Of American Beaut Essay Research
Paper April 2001 American Beauty Psychology Analysis American Beauty depicts modern dysfunctional families that appear to be happy on the outside, while on the inside they have tremendous deep-rooted problems. The movie begins to show many Freudian psychotic traits when unhappy Lester Burnham loses his job and begins a stereotypical male mid-life crisis by buying a red sports car, smoking marijuana, exercising maniacally, and fantasizing about younger women.
Lord Of The Flies The Id Ego
Essay, Research Paper The ID, Ego and Super EGO Many have looked at Freud’s description of the human mind as something that describes people and the way of their behavior. Freud s division of the human mind consists of three things: the ID, the Ego and the Super Ego. In William Golding s novel, Lord of the Flies, these Freudian concepts can be compared to the characters of Jack, Piggy, Simon, and Ralph.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper Slips of
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper Slips of Fate In the short story "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson, the author uses irony to expand on a theme of traditions that continue although they are ludicrous and barbaric. "Like a lamb to slaughter" comes to mind for both the characters in this story and the reader.
Sigmund Freud Essay Research Paper Sigmund Freud1856
Sigmund Freud Essay, Research Paper Sigmund Freud 1856 – 1939 Sigmund Freud was born in the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1856, it was in the Czech Republic. His father was a small time merchant, and Freud’s mother was his second wife. Freud had two half-brothers some 20 years older than himself. His family moved to Vienna when he was four years old, and though he often claimed he hated the city, he lived there until it was occupied by Germany in 1938.
The Banquet When Banquo
’s Ghost Returns Essay, Research Paper Whilst Macbeth is entertaining his guests, unseen the ghost of Banquo slips in and sits in Macbeth’s place. When the guests asks Macbeth to sit down, he takes one look at his place and sees Banquo sitting there.He says, “Which of you have done this?”. And they answer him,”What my good Lord?” He asks his guests where there is a spare place and they point to where Banquo’s ghost is sitting.
Macbeth Character Analysis Of Lady Macbeth Essay
, Research Paper MacBeth In The Tragedy of MacBeth, Lady MacBeth has strong id characteristics, and is not well balanced because her superego is severely out-weighed by her id. The id, superego, and ego are the
Freudian Theory Essay Research Paper Freudian TheorySigmund
Freudian Theory Essay, Research Paper Freudian Theory Sigmund Freud was a Viennese physician, whose psychoanalytic theory is the best-known psychodynamic approach today. He believed that behavior revealed unconscious internal forces. His work shows there are probably three parts that make up individual personality.
Winston And Julia Essay Research Paper Winston
Winston And Julia Essay, Research Paper Winston and Julia: an unlikely pair Ever since the fist time Winston laid eyes on Julia he really didn?t like her all that much. What would bring two very contrary persons together? Julia is a vibrant young woman that is a member of an anti-sex league. To Winston, Julia looks like a stuck up girl with important things to do.
Meat Facorties From The 1920S (The Jungle)
) Essay, Research Paper Meat Factories! How Disgusting! Meat factories have been recently under sedge because of how things are done. The whole ordeal started with the unions? workers strike for more pay. From there this situation just got worse. Labor spies had been infiltrated into the union, meaning that the executives knew what was going on before it happened.
The Lottery By Shirley Jackson Essay Research 2
The Lottery, By Shirley Jackson Essay, Research Paper The Lottery by Shirley Jackson The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson, is about a small-minded village that savors on tradition. The town holds a lottery once a year where all the families gather around in a big crowd in the Village Square. The lottery is conducted by Mr.