Debates On Tax Cuts
The debates on tax cuts taking place in Congress are making the daily headlines of every radio station, newspaper, and television station in America. The issue at hand is what to do with the projected budget surplus estimated to total $2.9 trillion over the next decade. Republicans and Democrats of the House and Senate have come up with several tax cut proposals ranging from less than $300 billion to almost $800 billion worth of tax cuts. Opposing views from both party members in the House and the Senate are wrecking havoc over a budget surplus that may not be a reality and only a projection for the next ten years.
President Clinton unveiled his plan to use the estimated budget surplus to secure Social Security and Medicare first and far most, eliminate the national debt, while still having enough left over to compromise a deal with the Republican led Congress and their demand for tax cuts. A writer for The New York Times, wrote the president was willing to work with Republican leaders to use the $2.9 trillion federal budget surplus over the next ten years but was only willing to devote approximately $250 billion to tax cuts. He was quoted by The New York Times “The surplus is the hard-earned product of our fiscal discipline. We should use it to prepare for the great challenges facing our country: caring for our parents, caring for our children, freeing our nation from the shackles of debt so that we can have long-term sustained economic prosperity” (Stevenson 1999, A1, A14). President Clinton proposed a $250 billion tax cut to begin the negotiations before The Congressional Budget Office unveiled their own plan.
The Democrats were the first to submit an alternative proposal of $290 billion to the Senate. It targeted tax breaks for retirement savings, college tuition, health care, married couples, and buyers of health insurance with enough money left over to ensure the protection of Social Security, Medicare, new programs, and pay down the federal debt. The alternative proposal to President Clinton’s $250 billion tax plan ended in defeat when the Senate voted 60-39 against it. The Republicans of the House debated for a larger $792 billion tax cut before the Ways and Means Committee. The debate ended with a 223-208 vote and a Republican win. Their tax cut proposal called for across the board 10 percent cut in income tax rates phased in over a period of ten years. After 2001, annual increases would kick in only if total national debt dropped. It allowed for married couples to claim an increased standard deduction. Concerning capital gains, the House voted to cut the top tax rate for most investments held at least a year from 20 percent to 15 percent. The alternative minimum tax called to ensure personal credits that would not cause middle-class people to become subject to the tax and gradually repeal the amount over a period of ten years. Estate taxes would be phased down and eventually would repeal tax on inheritances. Pertaining to retirement, it would increase contribution limits to some employee benefit plans and reduce time for vesting in some pensions from five years to three years (Associated Press 1999, 1). While the $792 billion was being debated before the Senate, Richard W. Stevenson reports in The New York Times “Republicans suffered a symbolic setback when they were unable to sidestep a rule–written at a time when Congress was intent on limiting the growth of budget deficits–that makes it difficult to pass tax cuts that remain in effect for more than ten years.” It was also reported “Republicans asked for a waiver of the rule, a step that requires 60 votes. But they could muster only 51 votes, as all 45 Democrats and three moderate Republicans voted to keep the rule in effect” (Stevenson 1999, 3).
Proud of the Republican win, U. S. House of Representatives Republican Majority leader and Chairman of the Ways and Means Committee Dick Armey of Texas was quoted after the vote by an article in The Washington Times saying “See, I told you we had the horses in the barn” (Godfrey 1999, 1). The meaning behind this statement probably stemmed from an uncertain feeling he had at the beginning of the debate. There were a few moderate Republicans within the party who objected the proposal at first. After the provision of reducing the federal debt was added, the small percentage of the moderates who objected the proposal, along with six Democrats who made up for the four Republicans who voted against tax cuts were whipped around. The New York Times quotes Speaker of the House J. Dennis Hastert of Illinois “So Mr. President, we say, what’s wrong in letting American taxpayers’ keep more of their hard-earned money, we trust them to spend it right, and we think you should, too” (Stevenson 1999, 2). President Clinton has vowed to veto the Republican plan and repeated his view that “Republican plans to cut taxes by $800 billion or more over the next decade would make it impossible to revamp Medicare or add billions in new spending for education, the military and the environment” (Broder 1999, 2).
With the passing of the Republican tax relief proposal in the House, media reports I have recently read or heard claims that Democrats are accusing Republicans of offering huge tax breaks to businesses and investors at the expense of the poor and middle class. A recent headline from Time read “Clinton Stakes His Ground on Tax Cuts” in large red bold letters. Following the headline in smaller gray tone coloring was the subtitle “vowing to shoot down Republican proposals, the President styles himself champion of the middle class and the poor” (Karon 1999, 1). It is no secret President Clinton will veto the $792 billion tax cut as well as a $500 billion bipartisan compromise version being debated in the Senate if it reaches his desk.
Compromise tax proposals were also debated in the Senate as well. Among the sponsors of this bipartisan alternative compromise were Democrat Senators John Breaux and Mary Landrieu of Louisiana. John Breaux was quoted by The Washington Times, “We are here today to suggest there is a better way” (Godfrey 1999, 2). The Louisiana Senators along with ten other bipartisan Senators submitted a $500 billion tax cut proposal that collapsed on the Senate floor. The Washington Times reports “plans to cut federal taxes by $500 billion may be too meek for conservatives and too bold for liberals, but will be the framework upon which an agreement may be built if a compromise is reached this year” (Godfrey 1999, 3).
The Senate Republicans passed their $792 billion tax cut plan Friday, July 30, 1999. The vote was 57-43 in favor of the plan. The proposal included:
A reduction from 15 to 14 percent in the lowest personal income tax bracket, effective 2001,…provisions to reduce the marriage penalty, in part by slowly raising the standard deduction for married couple to double the amount allowed for individuals…to let investors exclude from taxes the first $1000 in long-term capital gains…more students would be allowed to deduct the interest on their education loans; limits deductible contributions to individual retirement accounts would rise gradually to $5,000…liberalized tax incentives for individual and corporate donors to charities…create a new deduction for the cost of long-term care insurance…raise the estate tax exemption already scheduled to increase to $1 million up to $1.5 million in 2007 (Associated Press 1999, 2).
Following the vote, Senators began efforts of forming a rapid House-Senate compromise to take place in the Conference Committee next week. Senate Majority Leader, Trent Lott, implied the bill titled S. 1429 will not be until September, after the congressional August recess, before it is presented to President Clinton.
With good reason, the name Alan Greenspan has been popular with the media these days. Greenspan is the chairman of the Federal Reserve which serves as the central bank for the U.S. The Federal Reserve also known as the Fed, is in charge of controlling the supply of money that is in circulation. The Fed’s primary way of controlling monetary policy is changing the discount rate which is the rate member banks have to pay to borrow money from the Fed. If the discount rate charged is increased, the money supply will decrease which cools down the economy. If the discount rate charged is decreased, the money supply will increase causing the economy to heat up. The latter is a concern for Alan Greenspan and the Fed and the reason why the rate was increased one-fourth of a percent recently. Giving his opinion to both the House and Senate in recent budget meetings, Greenspan was less than enthusiastic about the proposal for tax cuts. “The timing is not right” he was reported to have said by The New York Times (Stevenson 1999, 2-3). The New York Times reports Greenspan encourages Congress to place a hold on any big tax cuts until budget surpluses begin to unfold. He is in favor of allocating surplus funds to pay down the national debt. But he also said he would prefer a tax cut over using the surplus for spending on government programs proposed by President Clinton (Associated Press 1999, 2).
The past few weeks have been very trying for both the Republican and the Democrat parties. Only time will tell who will land on top of the issues at hand. Surpassed in the past in budget politics by President Clinton, Republicans remain suspicious but welcome some of his programs. It seems the surplus estimate suddenly enlivened a year in which political pressures from the 2000 elections had made agreement seem unlikely on such high-profile issues as Social Security, Medicare, and tax cuts.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Associated Press. 1999. “Greenspan Cautions Against Tax Cuts.” The New York Times On The Web, 28 July, 1-2. Www.nytimes/aponline.
Associated Press. 1999. “House, Senate Tax Bill Comparision.” 29 July, 1. www.government.aol.
Broder, John M. 1999. “Tax and Spending Talks Begin in Earnest.” The New York Times, 13 July, A14.
Godfrey, John. 1999. “Give and Take Wins for GOP’s Taxcutters.” Washington Times Internet Edition, 23 July, 1. www.washingtontimes.
Godfrey, John. 1999. “GOP Senators Defeat Bid to Lower Tax Cut.” Washington Times Internet Edition, 29 July, 2. www.washingtontimes.
Karon, Tony. 1999. “Clinton Stakes His Ground on Tax Cuts.” Time Daily Internet Edition, 26 July, 1. Cgi.pathfinder/time/daily.
Stevenson, Richard W. 1999. “Republicans Pass Tax Cut With Minor Shift to Win Moderate Support.” The New York Times On The Web, 23 July, 1. www.nytimes.
Stevenson, Richard W. 1999. “In Clinton Budget, A Deal Possible on GOP Tax Cuts.” The New York Times, 28 June, A1, A14.
Stevenson, Richard W. 1999. “Senate Republicans Turn Aside Democrats’ Plan for Tax Cuts.” The New York Times On The Web, 29 July, www.nytimes.
Другие работы по теме:
The Argument Culture Essay Research Paper On
The Argument Culture Essay, Research Paper On any given night when watching the news, there are bound to be a number of stories involving arguments. Usually there are two sides to each point of contention, and both sides seem unable to compromise. But there are also a large number of times when the media examines stories which are not argumentative, sometimes regarding fact, possibly human interest.
Raped Essay Research Paper I know about
Raped Essay, Research Paper I know about things I shouldn’t know about. Things most people dont know about, and dont want to. Rape.A word that haunts many. A year ago, I was at a party with my best friend. We were drunk, apperntly she was more than I. I wanted to leave, I didn’t want to go without her though. But, she wanted to stay with her new boy friend.
George Orwell
’s 1984 Essay, Research Paper George Orwell’s 1984 was a book on how the government, Big Brother, had total control over the people of Oceania. There are many reasons to believe that our own world is slowly becoming the nightmare. Since the publication in 1949, Orwell?s novel has consistently trigured heated debates about whether or not our society has become like Oceania, how accurate Orwell?s predictions were, and which political parties? philosophies most resemble Ingsoc.
Offensive Philosophy
– The Last Draw Essay, Research Paper Offensive Philosophy In the offensive side of my basketball program there are a few main factors that all my players must be able to execute to remain
Demolishing The Constitution Essay Research Paper Demolishing
Demolishing The Constitution Essay, Research Paper Demolishing the Constitution Few Policy debates have been as dominated by emotion as the one on gun control. Perhaps one reason why this issue is so heatedly discussed is because it tampers with our right to bear arms. The calls for gun restrictions or for bans on guns are calls for change in our social and constitutional system.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Citizenship Essay Research Paper 1 What is
Citizenship Essay, Research Paper 1. What is citizenship? According to The Citizenship debates, by the term citizenship, we must understand not only a bundle of formal rights, but the entire mode of incorporation of individuals and groups into the society (251). Citizenship is important because it has become a legal status carrying with it rights to certain things?perhaps immunities, perhaps possessions, perhaps expectations?available or available to many kinds of person for many kinds of reasons (37).
Tax In California Essay Research Paper Sharp
Tax In California Essay, Research Paper Sharp Eye on Tax Breaks You heard a lot about pork in those frantic days when the California Legislature was putting the final touches on the state budget. Compared with Congress’ largess, the pet projects in the state budget are relatively minuscule, of course: say $250,000 for a park in Calexico, $34,000 for the Lake Tahoe airport tower, $200,000 for the Bay Area World Trade Center and $250,000 to repair a lifeguard tower in Huntington Beach.
Bush Tax Proposal Essay Research Paper IPI
Bush Tax Proposal Essay, Research Paper IPI adresses the tax cut proposal that President Bush is presenting before Congress. IPI feels that althouh Al Gore had a good plan for the national tax cut by decreasing the national income tax, George Bush’s proposal was much better because it not only lowers income tax, but also eliminates estate and death tax (accounting for almost 66% of the 1,437.8 billion dollar cut).
The Ethics Behind The Challenger Explosion Essay
, Research Paper The explosion of the Challenger spacecraft is the greatest tragedy in the history of NASA. It is also one of the most heated engineering ethical debates available for analysis. The question of whether or not the astronauts had the proper information to consent the launch is one of the main aspects of the debate.
Socratic Method Essay Research Paper The Socratic
Socratic Method Essay, Research Paper The Socratic method The Socratic Philosophy is basically a quest for the virtuous life; the main pillar of the Socratic thought is a virtuous life. Although, to his death, he did not offer any definition of a virtuous life–his life itself is the answer.
High School Cuts Essay Research Paper Our
High School Cuts Essay, Research Paper Our principal recently asked for the student?s opinions on the ?school cuts? proposal. This proposition proposes that all extra curricular activities be cut until the money
Debate Essay Research Paper residential Debates are
Debate Essay, Research Paper residential Debates are a very important part of the electoral process in the United States. These debates help the people of the country understand where each candidate stands on several current issues that the United States faces, as well as to show the people what they plan on doing while in office.
Perfect Man Essay Research Paper The perfect
Perfect Man Essay, Research Paper The perfect man is said to be hard to find, but I believe there is someone for every person. Sometimes a man is not perfect when you meet him, but he may have some qualities you like. If you are young some men will grow and mature into someone, you love. Dating is a search for the perfect man and a soul mate.
My Room Essay Research Paper Every time
My Room Essay, Research Paper Every time I open the door to my room, waves of hot and musty scents of piss and sweat fill my nose. I have a contentious debate with myself whether or not to open my closet. I’m afraid that the dead mice of sugar hungry ants will invade my subconsious and give me bad dreams. Debates over, closet lost.
Effective Use Or Debates To Gain Voters
Essay, Research Paper Analysis: “ Effective use of debates to gain voters “ The Vice president Al Gore and the Governor G.W Bush are both in a rivalry to be the President of the United States. The conventional wisdom held that in their first presidential debate which was held on Oct.4th , Mr. Gore showed voters a warm and fuzzy side while Mr.
Election 1984 Essay Research Paper Thank you
Election 1984 Essay, Research Paper Thank you Let’s take a look back at the presidential election of 1984. The primary candidates in this election were Ronald Reagan for Republican, and Walter Mondale for Democratic.
Personal Experience Essay Research Paper I walked
Personal Experience Essay, Research Paper I walked into the house from basketball practice at six pm. The remains of the vase that was on the stand beside the door, lay at my feet. The furniture in the living room was tipped and topped over and anything fragile had been thrown and had shattered. Mother sat on the bottom step crying, her arms a mass of cuts and gashes.
Themes In Carver Essay Research Paper John
Themes In Carver Essay, Research Paper John W Mcgall Lit To Film Carver Essay In Short Cuts, by Raymond Carver, characters experience trials and problems in their lives, whether extreme such as in “ A Small, Good Thing” and “Lemonade” or nominal such as in “ Vitamins”. They all seem to depict these struggles as uphill battles which the characters cannot and mostly do not overcome.
Presidential Debate Essay Research Paper Another four
Presidential Debate Essay, Research Paper Another four years another presidential debate. Before I go on to the current debates let me state a few facts about past ones. The Lincoln and Douglas debate was in important because it started Lincoln presidential career. The Debates lasted from August 21 – October 15.
Debates 2000 Essay Research Paper The Third
Debates 2000 Essay, Research Paper The Third Debate The third Presidential Debate was between Vice President Al Gore and Gov. George W. Bush. The debate was in the format of a Town Hall debate. Both Vice President Al Gore and Gov. Bush performed well. An audience member asked the candidates a question and given two minutes to answer the question set forth.
Bill Clinton President Essay Research Paper A
Bill Clinton, President Essay, Research Paper A Victory For Clinton Another four years, another new president? The election of 1996 for president moves closer everyday as the republican Robert Dole, and the president
Executive Privelage Essay Research Paper exemption of
Executive Privelage Essay, Research Paper exemption of the executive branch of government, or its officers, from having to give evidence, specifically, in U.S. law, the exemption of the president from disclosing information to congressional inquiries or the judiciary. Claims of executive privilege are usually invoked to protect confidential military or diplomatic operations or to protect the private discussions and debates of the president with close aides.
Television Essay Research Paper Televised debates between
Television Essay, Research Paper Televised debates between the nominees of the two major parties have become standard fare in contemporary presidential election campaigns. The authors of this important volume maintain that television has altered the very nature of presidential debates profoundly, that the demands of television have dictated the structure and formats of contemporary debates, and that the visual content of presidential debates plays an important role in the way that candidates exercise influence in televised debates.
Presidential Debates Essay Research Paper Presidential DebatesMaking
Presidential Debates Essay, Research Paper Presidential Debates Making a decision is a very important part of life that every person, at one time or another, has to make. Options are always available when someone has to make a decision. In choosing a President for our country, we have to look at our candidates and decide which ones beliefs can help the country the most.
Presidential Debates 96 Essay Research Paper Philip
Presidential Debates 96 Essay, Research Paper Philip Rubacha October 22, 1996 American Politics-Essay #1 Essay-Debate The presidential debates between democratic President William Clinton and Republican Senator Robert Dole proved to be a game of “dodge-ball”. Bob Dole fired criticism and attacks while Clinton tried to “dodge” them.
Federalism Essay Research Paper David FederalismThe current
Federalism Essay, Research Paper David Federalism The current state of federalism in the United States is of one of peril, plagued with recent Supreme Court rulings, current debates over the devolution of Federal powers, and variance in State governing. The United States has always been troubled with the role of the Federal government V.
First 2000 Presidential Debate Essay Research Paper
First Presidential Debate For the first time face to face the first debate of the 2000 presidential election was held at the campus of the University of Massachusetts. For ninety minutes last night, Democratic candidate Vice President Al Gore and Republican Candidate Governor of Texas George W. Bush battled one another over tax cuts, prescription drugs, Social Security, energy policy, abortion, and education.
Budget Negotiations Essay Research Paper
——————————————————————————– In the midst of the current budget negotiations, there is one neglected question worth asking: what does the public really want? Tax cuts? Paying down the national debt? More spending? If so, more spending on what? The available polling data, analyzed in this report, helps answer these questions.
Colorado Elections Essay Research Paper Colorado s
Colorado Elections Essay, Research Paper Colorado s Presidential Elections I was assigned to research the 2000 presidential elections in Colorado. Colorado is a state where Republicans outnumber Democrats. Colorado has 2.8 million voters, have that approximately one million are Republicans; 967,500 are unaffiliated; 842,000 are Democrats; and the rest belong to minor parties.
Euthenasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaImmoral or Human
Euthenasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Immoral or Human Right? Recent debates over active euthanasia, “killing” a terminally ill patient, in Holland, has risen the question whether euthanasia is immoral or a simple human right. Doctors seem to have no doubt. They made an oath.