Gay Marriage Essay, Research Paper
Discrimination is the Voice of Ignorance
Marriage is one of the fundamental establishments of the United States. As a young person, one looks forward to many goals in their lifetime: career success, a good life, and very often marriage to the person they love and a family together. This is one of the biggest parts of our “American life” and culture. Very few heterosexuals would be willing to put their right to marry on a ballot for voter approval, or even in their wildest dreams [nightmares?] have to consider doing that. However, in the past ten years that is a prospect gay men and women are facing all over our United States. Why is American culture so unaccepting of homosexual marriages and what are the reprocutions of this for homosexual couples and for all of our citizens?
Homosexuality, as a lifestyle has always been under great fire in our culture.
Homosexuality has been defined and termed in many contexts. The West Chester
University Lesbian, Gay and Bisexual Services states that,
Given the variable aspects of sexual orientation and given evidence that an individual’s sexual orientation may change over time, it is difficult to provide a precise and universally accepted definition of homosexuality. In general terms, homosexuality may be described as the capacity to find affection and or sexual satisfaction with someone of the same gender.
Focus founder and fundamental Christian leader, James Dobson, however, simply defines homosexuality as a sin and says homosexuals can be cured in God’s name (Egelko, 3/2000 p2). As one can see from these two examples alone, the definition of this lifestyle isn’t focused solely on what a homosexual is, but rather how individuals feel about the way of life.
In day to day living, the homosexual lifestyle is most likely not much different from the heterosexual or “straight” lifestyle. A homosexual still gets up in the morning and goes to work or to school. They still have dinner with family or friends, participate in sports and community organizations and events. And yes, they still hold stable relationships, just like a man and women would, they still go through the ups and downs of a relationship, facing the same joyous moments, and same hard times with an individual they love. The homophobia that has spread through our country like wildfire since the “outing” of homosexuals became more common and acceptable undermines these common variables between homosexual and heterosexual couples.
One of the largest differences for a homosexual is living a life of fear. Along with all of their day to day activities that mirror any heterosexual, they must also deal with the stress of being “different” and being “unacceptable” to the society which they are a part of. They must know the places they are welcomed as an “outted” gay person, and the ones where they must hide their true identities. As well, they are not granted many of the rights a heterosexual takes for granted. They cannot file for taxes along with their partner, cannot receive medical benefits or health insurance under their partners coverage, as most husband and wives do, and most essentially, they cannot create a bond of unity to express their love through a legal marriage (France, 2/2000 p2).
Marriage has been a unique part of our culture since its beginning. Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary defines marriage as “to join or unite a husband and wife.” As well, many churches quote like definitions. The Catholic Church, for example, relies on Jesus’ statement about a man and his wife becoming one flesh, never to be separated ( Egelko, 3/2000 p1). And West Virginia Governor, Cecil Underwood, just asked the legislature to put on all marriage licenses and applications: “Marriage is designed to be a loving and lifelong union between a woman and a man” (Bundy, 1/2000 p1). The debate comes over whether or not these definitions are simply traditional in their wording of “man and wife” or if that is truly the way it is meant to be. This brings up the issue of whether religious or secular definitions should prevail and how to go about changing or amending these definitions. If a marriage is truly a unity of two individuals in love, however, who is the final decision-maker in how far those lines can be drawn? Is it really the place of our government, or even ourselves to tell a couple, regardless of their gender or sexuality that they may not be united legally in their love?
This question, one of morality and of legality, has become a pressing issue in many states in the recent years. At the present day, no state in America has legalized the marriage of a same-sex couple (Swanson, 3/2000 p2). However, the latest trend in legislation is towards a ban on validating a marriage of a same-sex couple that has been legalized in another state or country.
The first step which initiated this proposition came in Hawaii and began in 1994. Hawaii’s courts have held that denying marriage licenses to same-sex couples is a violation of the state’s constitution (Gallagher, 6/98 p2). In 1997, gay couples in Hawaii petitioned for legal recognition and won a groundbreaking compromise: domestic partnership (Wolf, 2/98 p1). Although this is not a marriage license, it does promise a more valid partnership in the eyes of the courts and of the society for the future. At the same time, however, thirty states have now passed bans on same-sex marriages outright, and in 1996, President Clinton signed the Defense of Marriage Act, which denies federal recognition of gay marriages (Wolf, 2/98 p3).
The state of Vermont is also on the front page when it comes to the gay marriage movement. In a Vermont Supreme Court decision in December of 1999, Chief Justice Jeffrey L. Amestoy told the state legislature either to provide licenses or set up a domestic partner system “extending all or most of the same rights and obligations provided by law to married partners” (France, 2/2000 p1). The court’s decision was a huge win for proponents of gay marriage, however, it has not granted an actual marriage license yet, which is what a couple will really need in the eyes of federal and other state laws.
The latest and probably hottest debate over this issue has been in California. In the beginning of March 2000, California voters approved a ballot measure recognizing only those marriages between men and women (Tharp, 3/2000 p1). Entitled Proposition 22, this ballot won by a 61-39 percent margin. Until this point, state law had required California to validate unions legally performed in other states. This ban, however, will make any same-sex union invalid in California.
Ironically, same-sex marriages are not currently legal anywhere in the United States. Therefore, Proposition 22 is quite possibly “jumping the gun.” Opponents of P-22 state that “gays’ right to marry, though rejected by most churches, should be preserved in secular society—and an individualistic tradition that impedes political organizations” (Egelko, 3/3000 p3). It has also been called “barbaric” and “mean-spirited.” The individuals who have been backing this type of legislation include conservatives and religious leaders who have historically been undermining the basic individual rights of gays and lesbians for years; a fact that makes it very hard to believe this is not an attempt to hurt or discriminate against gay and lesbian people.
Whether the recent legislation is anti-gay or pro-straight is still to be decided. One thing is evident, though, it highlights an anxiety that may very well be produced by the marital state of our current society. As Naomi Wolf states in her article “Scenes from a Gay Marriage”:
With fifty percent of first marriages ending in divorce, the institution of straight marriage has broken down. Intensifying the heterosexual anxiety is the realization that just as straight people want out of marriage, gay people want in. And this is producing in heterosexual America a very real inferiority complex.
This may be a very true statement. Is it possible that heterosexual America fears that gay
marriages will be a new and better union than those of the past?
Through the recent actions of many United States legislatures and from the adamant anti-gay comments so many Americans hear and say every day, it seems as though there isn’t much hope left for equal rights and equal treatment of homosexuals, let alone gay and lesbian couples who hope to be joined in marriage. The issue will very likely go on, much fueled by a debate of right and wrong and morality versus science.
However, a few facts still remain. Homosexuality will continue to be a way of life in out American culture. Unfortunately, it will continue to be degraded, until we as a society take cold hard steps against that discrimination. Fear and ignorance will always be abundant in America to fuel debates over other people’s choices, much like this debate over gay marriage. Something to really think about though is the idea that marriage is intended as a unity and a lifelong commitment of love. Ironically, a ban on just that is somewhat of an oxymoron. As a society, we need to change the negative traditions of our culture from discriminatory to accepting. Douglas F. Nissing, an Episcopal priest officiates at gay commitment ceremonies. After describing one of his recent ceremonies, he states the following:
God was truly present. How could God be absent when there is such love? Every loving couple deserves the opportunity to have such a celebration. Yet the church, and many others continue to say that gay people don’t deserve this opportunity. This attitude is directly responsible for creating and supporting an environment in which hatred and prejudice can take root and grow. It is time that we let the world know that love transcends the narrow vision that our brothers and sisters often preach.
Pastor Nissing is correct. It is time for our culture, no matter how traditional, to stop fostering lines of hatred and fear and instead change focus to understanding and love, no matter what kind of love it may be.
Bawer, Bruce. “Family Valued.” The Advocate 20 Jul 1999: 72.
Bundy, Jennifer. “West Virginia Governor Faults Same-Sex Marriage.” Associated Press
13 Jan 2000: 1.
Coleman, Jennifer. “Methodists Drop Gay Wedding Case.” Associated Press 11 Feb
2000: 2-3.
Egelko, Bob. “Gay Marriage Ban Splits Community.” Associated Press 3 Mar 2000:
2-3.
France, Steve. “A Marriage Proposal.” ABA Journal 86 (2000): 28-29.
Gallagher, John. “The Other M Word.” The Advocate 23 Jun 1998: 53.
Nissing, Douglas F. “Standing on Ceremony.” The Advocate 8 Dec 1998: 11.
Swanson, Doug J. “Father’s anger at gay son led to California ballot initiative against gay
marriage.” Dallas Morning News 4 Mar 2000, early ed.: P1+.
Tanner, Robert. “California Passes Gay Marriage Ban.” Associated Press 8 Mar 2000:
1-3.
Tharp, Mike. “A ‘NO’ to Gay Marriage.” U.S. News and World Report 28 Mar 2000:
39-40.
Werner, Erica. “Opposition Vs. Proposition 22.” Associated Press 5 Mar 2000: 1-2.
Wolf, Naomi. “Scenes from a Gay Marriage.” George Feb 1998: 48-50.
Другие работы по теме:
Marrige Essay Research Paper Everyone agrees that
Marrige Essay, Research Paper Everyone agrees that respect is something very important and that it is the key to a lasting marriage. Annie Gottlieb wrote the essay Respect: At The Heart Of Successful Marriage and elaborated on how people interpret this in their own different ways. She basically explains exactly what the word respect means and through what methods it is applied to a marriage.
Discrimination Essay Research Paper Fred L Pincus
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Fred L. Pincus, author of “From Individual to Structural Discrimination”, is arguing that discrimination is still present among many individual and institutions. The reason why it is not unlawful, according to Pincus, is because the discrimination is so subtle and in some cases it is not done intentionally.
Marriage Essay Research Paper Most couples spend
Marriage Essay, Research Paper Most couples spend a great deal of time, energy and money on a wedding ceremony that lasts a couple of hours. It is much easier to prepare for a successful wedding than a successful marriage. Marriage is an exciting process that does not come with a clearly outlined instruction book.
Descrimination Essay Research Paper discrimination1 The
Descrimination Essay, Research Paper discrimination 1. The federal government attempted to use many laws to protect the rights of the newly freed slaves, such as the Civil rights Act of 1866, which gave African Americans the right
Discrimination Essay Research Paper Most people think
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper Most people think the United States is a good place to live, however the United States has more discrimination problems then any other nation. By eliminating, or reducing discrimination the United States would make living here pleasant for all of its residents. As a result, stopping discrimination would, make people feel safe to be then selves, allow an equal opportunity for everyone, and expand U.S culture.
Racism Essay Research Paper The understanding of
Racism Essay, Research Paper The understanding of prejudice can lead to us removing of racism and discrimination in our country. Stereotyping, or forming a set of characteristics thought to be common to all members of a certain group, leads to prejudice influencing the observer to be part of a group rather than an individual.
Making Adam And Steve A Reality Essay
, Research Paper Bigotry and discrimination are two things that should not be legally permitted in modern society, yet there are laws that permit, if not encourage discrimination against homosexual people. One of these laws is the inability for homosexual couples to be legally married. The simple truth is that homosexuals are religiously married everyday, but they are not entitled to the legal benefits of marriage such as tax breaks and legal inheritances.
The American Dream Essay Research Paper Americans
The American Dream Essay, Research Paper Americans have always had a universal dream ranging from marriage to freedom, and of course, money. Some Americans pursue them more diligently than others, while the others just sit and dream.
Marriage Essay Research Paper Marriage Relationships In
Marriage Essay, Research Paper Marriage Relationships In marriage realtionships we expected to learn a number of things including the comprimises couple must make with respect to such things as careers, finances, and children. Our initial impressions were that couples must be willing to make these sacrifices in order to have a long and fulfilling relationship with their spouse.
Implied Attitudes In The Work Of Kate
Chopin Essay, Research Paper ?The Story of an Hour? and ?The Storm? are two greatly appreciated pieces of work written by Kate Chopin. The two stories differentiate in attitude toward marriage and its
Discrimination Essay Research Paper When people think
Discrimination Essay, Research Paper When people think about discrimination, they usually associate it with prejudice and connect it with race and gender. But discrimination can take another form. For example, a person can gain an unfair advantage at a job interview by being attractive or by being able to talk about something that has nothing to do with the job, like sports.
Sex Before Marriage Essay Research Paper Wait
Sex Before Marriage Essay, Research Paper Wait To Have Sex Although there are many people having sex, you shouldn’t. I am going to give you some reasons on why you shouldn’t. First of all, you
Discrimination Against Gays Essay Research Paper discrimination
Discrimination Against Gays Essay, Research Paper discrimination against gaysAbout ten percent of the population is homosexually oriented and discriminated against. Discrimination denies lesbian and gay individuals or couples rights in today’s society. Problems that homosexuals face on a daily basis are employment in the military, encountering issues being a couple, and acceptance among others.
SameSex Marriage Essay Research Paper Samesex Marriage
Same-Sex Marriage Essay, Research Paper Same-sex Marriage The 8th Amendment talks about freedom of speech and freedom of living life. It is not true for everyone to live his/her life by choice. When one ask someone, he/she will tell that they are in favor of equal rights for homosexuals. They will all say that gay should have equal access to government benefits and equal protection of the law, but if someone ask them about gay marriage, all this talk of equality stops.
Argument Essay Essay Research Paper In today
Argument Essay Essay, Research Paper In today s society there are many couples that live together. Why let unmarried couples live together? There isn t a specific problem with unmarried couples that live out in the American Society. People are getting divorced left and right in today s age. More than 50% of marriages broke up during the decade of the 90 s.
Sex And Work Essay Research Paper Sex
Sex And Work Essay, Research Paper Sex and Work Women have made some strides in overcoming harassment and discrimination, but there is still a long way to go. When a corporate meeting is taking place, before the meeting, all the guys will be sitting around telling their little stories, until a woman walks in.
Marriage Essay Research Paper In the United
Marriage Essay, Research Paper In the United States most Americans have trouble understanding the concept of an arranged marriage. Arranged marriages not only affect individuals, but also society. I believe that arranged marriages are better then personal choice marriages. I came to this conclusion on the basis of other cultures other then the culture of the United States.
Discrimination Extinct Or Is Essay Research Paper
” Discrimination: extinct, or is it?” Who says discrimination doesn t exist in present day? Newspapers, television, and people all around us are methods of seeing that discrimination occurs everyday of our lives. There might be those people who say that it is extinct, but then again, do they come in contact with people outside their own race? Discrimination is something that is here with is for as long as we live.
Inequality On Women Essay Research Paper How
Inequality On Women Essay, Research Paper How USA differs from the world in discrimination.Discrimination may be defined as a treatment or consideration which is based on class or category rather than individual merit. People around the world discriminate between classes to their own certain extents.
Affirmative Action Reverse Discrimination Essay Research Paper
Affirmative Action = Reverse Discrimination We are all aware that discrimination took place over 50 years ago. What some might not be aware of is that because of the actions of our ancestors, we, white males, are held responsible and are penalized because of these actions. Affirmative action is a way to help minorities in sex and race to get accepted into colleges or get hired for jobs while the white males suffer from what took place over 50 years ago.
Supreme Court Bakke Essay Research Paper BakkeI
Supreme Court Bakke Essay, Research Paper Bakke I do not wish to reverse history and go back to the period of time, where discrimination was present and influential in every aspect of our society. However, I do wish to make sure that while making sure that the once oppressed minorities do not have to endure the discrimination ever again, the rights of persons such as myself are not violated in the name of doing the supposed higher good.
On Aids And Moral Duty Discrimination
Goes On Essay, Research Paper The two essays I read were On Aids and Moral Duty by Willard Gaylin and Discrimination Goes On by Robert H. Cohen. On Aids and Moral Duty says that HIV positive individuals have a moral responsibility to let others know they are HIV positive to protect innocent people from unknowingly contracting the virus.
Equality Essay Research Paper Equality
Equality Essay, Research Paper Equality I have a vision, that all people be treated equally. Race, religion, sex, age, and other petty differences should not mater. Every one has a rite to me
Marriage Easy Divorce Essay Research Paper Marriage
Marriage: Easy Divorce Essay, Research Paper Marriage: Easy Divorce Although I do not agree with getting married until you are positive that you want to have a huge commitment to another person, I favor the easier divorce.
Same Sex Marriage Essay Research Paper Same
Same Sex Marriage Essay, Research Paper Same Sex Marriage In order to address this issue, one must first define the concept or meaning of marriage. However, this is a rather subjective approach, because the way we define marriage depends on our own views and interpretations.
Discrimination In The US Essay Research Paper
Discrimination Discrimination in the U.S., I think has dramatically changed since the 1940’ s-1960. Black Americans have gained the right to eat at public lunch counters, vote, ride public buses, and attend public schools. There still is some racism in the United States. In this essay I am going to tell you some examples of racism that I have heard of.
American Dream Essay Research Paper scribes the
American Dream Essay, Research Paper scribes the defeat of the American dream, and that the American ideals differ with the actual social conditions that exist in society. For the American constitutions stands for the freedom, and equality among people, but the truth of the matter is that social discrimination still exists and the grouping among the classes can never be overcome.
Anne Bradstreet Essay Research Paper A Second
Anne Bradstreet Essay, Research Paper A Second Look Anne Bradstreet lived in a time when devotion in a wife to her husband was a social law. This poem, “To My Dear and Loving Husband,” is a loving tribute from Bradstreet to her husband. Certainly, in the early American, Puritan colonies, this work would have been seen as a wife’s duty as well as a lovely gesture.
Discrimination In USA Essay Research Paper The
Discrimination In USA Essay, Research Paper The 1920?s were a period of economic boom in USA, but most of all, of discrimination. There were two groups who, apart from remaining out of the economic boom, were discriminated and suffered poverty. These people were Blacks and Immigrants.
Racism Essay Research Paper RacismWhat is racism
Racism Essay, Research Paper Racism What is racism? Racism is the mistreatment of a group of people on the basis of race, colour, and religion. The term racism may also mean a blind and pointless hatred, envy or prejudice.
Legalizing Gay Marriages Essay Research Paper Would
Legalizing Gay Marriages Essay, Research Paper ?Would legalization of gay marriage be good for the gay community?? Sam Isaacson wrote an article analyzing the opinion of the gay community on legalizing same sex marriages. It is somewhat of a controversial issue with the gay community whether or not marriage is a good thing.