. . . Or Not? Essay, Research Paper
Computers in the Classrooms . . . or Not?
Should computers be the sole teachers of students in the classroom? The argument is whether or not students should be taught by live teachers or computers. Although there are many advantages from learning on a computer; there are many disadvantages. I believe that having a teacher in the classroom poses many opportunities for the students to learn life’s basics. I do not believe a computer can teach these basics as effectively as a live teacher. I think schools are trying to repair the problem but developing another one in the process, by using computers to teach.
In the article, “On Classrooms, With or Without Computers,” the author, Clifford Stoll discusses the differences between having live teachers and the teachings of computers. He believes that having physical teachers in the classrooms is advantageous because they can teach personal interaction, reading, and teamwork. They cannot teach these things accurately with a computer. Stoll counteracts his article with reference to parents and principals who want to use computers instead of keeping teachers in the classroom. Some concentration of his article deals with the large amounts of money spent on computer hardware and software. In the article, Stoll addresses sixteen specific schools: “The state of North Carolina spent seven million dollars to tie sixteen high schools with a fiber optic network” (Stoll 259). Although it is a good idea to spend money on technology for the classroom, it would better be spent on increasing teachers’ salaries (Stoll 259).
Another problem mentioned are homework assignments sent by e-mail to the professors. The student is not able to ask questions before handing in their assignment. Dr. Dave Cudaback is a professor of astronomy at the University of California at Berkeley who answers his own students’ questions but has difficulty finding the time to help, “students around the world” (Stoll 261) with their questions. Stoll continues to raise many questions about the changes of this controversy. He leaves his reader developing unanswered questions (Stoll 259).
There are some benefits of learning from a computer. For example, through the internet, a computer can offer hands on interaction if the class were learning about whales. It would be easier for you to learn about the natural habitat needed for the breeding and the rituals necessary for this to occur. This would give the student a better understanding because we cannot go out into the ocean and experience this for ourselves, “Sensation has no substitute” (Stoll 263). The impact may not be as great from a computer, but your imagination could help you learn. The computer can provide in depth looks into anything you are studying. For instance, grade school teachers use the computer to teach children how to navigate for information. This gives students a benefit in learning how to practice mathematics, writing, reading, and spelling. Some software that is used in the classroom promotes interactive learning. The computer is a good tool for teachers to use in the classroom much like a chalkboard; however, using this median as the sole purpose for teaching can develop some disadvantages.
When a computer has replaced a teacher, many things are lost. A teacher shows students how to be giving, use deductive reasoning, and learn to interact with one another. After all, we are human, not a machine. Having a teacher in the classroom is essential in a young person’s life. A teacher can offer on-the-spot corrections. A machine takes the satisfaction of personal contact away. When I was a child in grade school, I could not imagine being without a teacher in class. It would have been disastrous because there would not have been anyone there to correct my penmanship, spelling, or math. This could have caused me to fail in my schooling and prevented me from continuing my education; because of the teacher’s caring for me to learn, he or she gave me what I needed to be successful. During school, having a teacher enabled me to look for many answers to many questions. The problem with computers is that there is only one specific answer for one specific question. This is not reality in life. There can be many answers to one specific question. This is where the teacher comes in to explain how to use different answers for the same question. You learn how to use your head to answer the question.
Stoll refers to a child’s television show, “the social effects of ?Sesame Street,’ ” and whether they have documented it properly (Stoll 264). Children who watched this television show did not become rocket scientists, did they? As Stoll considers, “Learning isn’t easy,” his thought brings up the question, why do we encourage our children to sit still to learn (Stoll 264)? We, as parents, tend to use media as a babysitter so we do not have to bother with the kids. We allow our children to sit in front of a screen, watch television, and become couch potatoes. This is not how our parents brought up to teach our kids. I believe this world would be a better place if the television or the computer were never invented. Simply because it promotes laziness. Children do not have to work hard to learn. In this society we have been taught that learning from certain shows in the media is easier, rather than looking for and finding the answer the hard way.
Although computers in the classroom can provide some things to students that teachers cannot in the way of an infinite reference and resource tool, they should not substitute computers for real, live teachers. Computers cannot provide the personal interaction that children need in a learning environment. Computers cannot nurture a child’s natural curiosity to go beyond what is required the way some teachers can. Exclusive learning through computers will lead to children themselves becoming no more than machines and the ability to think and act as a human will slowly diminish. Just as though television was once thought to be a great way for people of all ages to learn about different things, as parents relied upon it to babysit their children, the computer will eventually be discovered to be nothing more than a “boob tube” where people rely on the information obtained from it and become nothing more than idiots. The only thing that would be worse, would be having computers rule the classrooms. Then, not only will we be breeding desensitized, information overloaded people at home, but in the classroom as well.
Works Cited
Kennedy, Mary Lynch, Kennedy, William J., Smith, Hadley M. Writing In The Disciplines: A Reader for Writers. On Classrooms, With or Without Computers. Clifford Stoll, 2000. (p.259-266)
Другие работы по теме:
Computers 2 Essay Research Paper People use
Computers 2 Essay, Research Paper People use computers everyday. Some people know how to use one some people don’t. But not too many people can understand how the computer works and its processing. I have been taught how it works and I understand it very well. The best way to explain it would be to compare it to the United States Postal Service and how it works.
Computers Essay Research Paper Computers make our
Computers Essay, Research Paper Computers make our lives much easier in a variety of ways. They save time and if used properly, money. Because of this, computer skills are now a necessity, not a convenience. This is a fact because the computer is a great reference source, a productive tool, and provides the invaluable use of the Internet.
Single Sex Classrooms Essay Research Paper Dear
Single Sex Classrooms Essay, Research Paper Dear Miss King, Your article introduces us to the new idea of having single sex classrooms as well as single sex schools. This examines the experiment that has been implemented in Mountain View California where they recently opened a middle school for girls. This school is primarily geared towards higher levels of math and science, which in the past have been viewed as male dominant subjects.
CAN TECHNOLY REPLACE SCHOOLS Essay Research Paper
We can’t see their smiles when we tell a joke nor can we see their frowns when they have a different point of view about something we say. So much information about how a person feels is transmitted through facial expressions. We can radiate massive amounts of information from a single smirk, smile, or frown.
Education Essay Research Paper Boundary Street Elementary
Education Essay, Research Paper Boundary Street Elementary School When I got to the school, the first thing I did was check into the office. There I met the school secretary, who was very nice and willing to help me in any way she could. I
Human Brain Essay Research Paper The human
Human Brain Essay, Research Paper The human brain and the computer in the past few decades we have seen how computers are becoming more and more advance, challenging the abilities of the human brain. We have seen computers doing complex assignments like launching a rocket or analysis from outer space. But the human brain is responsible for thought, feelings, creativity, and other qualities that make us humans.
Inclusion Essay Research Paper Since the 1980
Inclusion Essay, Research Paper Since the 1980’s, more and more schools have begun to practice the technique of inclusion and mainstreaming in their classrooms. These practices involve the integration of special education students into regular education classrooms. This is an extremely controversial idea because it relates to educational and social values, as well as our sense of individual worth (Educational Resources).
Computers In Our Society Essay Research Paper
Don t know anything about computers? Don t think they are a big part of your life? Think again! Computers are wondrous machines that improve our lives in many areas like education, entertainment, and work.(Paragraph)The use of computers in and out of school has made improvements in the way we learn. For instance, the use of computers in the classroom has freed up some of my time so I can give more individualized instruction to the needy, says Instructor Mary S.
Computers In Education Essay Research Paper Over
Computers In Education Essay, Research Paper Over the past ten years billions of dollars have been spent on computers for our nation?s schools. The goal was to improve and update our educational system but there is very little evidence of change through the years and taxpayers that have been paying for these upgrades in the schools want to know where the payoff is.
Personal Computers And Laptop Computers Essay Research
Paper The two types of computers that are the most common people use are the Personal computer, and the Laptop computer. Most people would say that there is not that much difference between the two, but they have no idea how wrong they are.
Computers Essay Research Paper Computers are found
Computers Essay, Research Paper Computers are found in practically every household today. Everywhere you look, people have access to a Personal Computer, someway or another. As computers get more advanced, the demand for a better computer gets greater.
Computers Affecting Our Lives Essay Research Paper
Computers Since the beginning of human life, we as a people have always strived to obtain machines or tools to make our lives easier. Before the computer was invented in 1822, people were performing boring, repetitive tasks that we now take for granted. The computer, a modern complex machine, now accomplishes things we never thought possible.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A hacker is
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A hacker is a person obsessed with computers. At the heart of the obsession is a drive master the computer. The classic hacker was simply a
What Should And Shouldn
’t Computer Be Allowed To Run Essay, Research Paper What Should and Shouldn’t Computer Be Allowed To Run Computers have always scared people. Not just because they can be
Ketchup Essay Research Paper October 30 2000Ms
Ketchup Essay, Research Paper October 30, 2000 Ms. Peggy Charen 5335 W. Lake Dr. Memphis, TN 65804 Dear Ms. Charen I received your letter concerning the new Ketchup labels. I can see where you are coming from, but can assure you that is not what is happening in our classrooms.
Computer Gave Technology A Bo Essay
, Research Paper The computer has come a long way since it was first invented, which put the power of technology in the spotlight. Through the years there have been many advances with the help of computers. Advances in which have been of great help.
Virtual Classrooms
– Article R Essay, Research Paper Virtual classrooms: coming soon to a computer near you (consult your local teacher for instructions) John Wallin +s article, +Web-Based Education Coming of Age, + refers primarily to the prospect of on-line astronomy courses, but the pitfalls and advantages he discusses can be applied to on-line classes of every discipline.
Y2k 6 Essay Research Paper Y2K is
Y2k 6 Essay, Research Paper Y2K is also called a bug. Y2K is one of the big problems for everyone. Y2K means many computer systems use software that tracks dates with only the last two numbers of years such as 97 instead of 1997. When 00 comes up for the year 2000, many computers will view it as 1900 instead, potentially leading to failures in business, transportation, utilities and other services.
Can Machines Think 2 Essay Research Paper
Can Machines Think? With the recent advances of technology, a computer being able to think for themselves is not a far cry away. But is it a reasonable analogy? Computers have been built as goal-oriented systems. Whether the goal is to beat the best chess player humankind has come to acknowledge or figure out the microscopic measurements for the distance between us and another planet.
The Internet And World Wide Web Defined
Essay, Research Paper Christopher L. Isaacs 1010 ? Technical Writing Extended Definition 00 March 6th The ?Internet? and ?World Wide Web? Defined In recent years the Internet and World Wide Web (WWW) have become more and more popular as an information resource. Many people believe that the WWW is the same as the Internet.
Will Computers Control Humans In The Future
? Essay, Research Paper Will Computers Control Humans In The Future? People always tend to seek the easy way out looking for something that would make their lives easier. Machines and tools have given us the ability to
Computers In The Classroom Essay Research Paper
Computers In The Classroom In Postman s essay, Virtual Students, Digital Classroom, he argues about the technology in the classrooms. Postman comes to the conclusion that high-technology (computers) in the classroom is just another thing that will not solve anymore of our problems and will also take over his job as a teacher.
Computers Essay Research Paper Computers Today
Computers Essay, Research Paper Computers Today computers are a part of our everyday life; can you imagine a world without computers? There are many kinds of computers. For example, there are desktop computers, laptop computers, and palmtop computers. These are the most popular ones. However, there are many other types of computers.
The First Generation Of Computers Essay Research
Paper The First Generation of Computers The first generation of computers, beginning around the end of World War 2, and continuing until around the year 1957, included computers that used vacuum
Computers Toys Not Tools Essay Research Paper
Due to the advances in recent computer technologies, computers are now sold with state-of-the-art, costly equipment that most people do not need. Most computers on the market these days are built to attract the eye of the consumer. They come loaded with hi-tech hardware and catchy tag words like mega RAM, quad-speed drives and digital processing, but the fact is, the computer has been exploited to the American public to attract a broader base of consumers and to change the way we view computers from tools to toys.