The Fine-Tuning Design Argument for God s Existence
The laws and constants of nature are so “finely-tuned,” and so many “coincidences” have occurred to allow for the possibility of life, the universe must have come into existence through intentional planning and intelligence. In fact, this “fine-tuning” is so pronounced, and the “coincidences” are so numerous, many scientists have come to espouse “The Anthropic Principle,” which contends that the universe was brought into existence intentionally for the sake of producing mankind. Even those who do not accept the Anthropic Principle admit to the “fine-tuning” and conclude that the universe is “too contrived” to be a chance event. Here are some examples of .finely-tuned x
Concerning the weak nuclear force:
If significantly stronger: fusion at the big bang would have proceeded directly to iron, giving us a
star-free universe.
The weak nuclear force must be extremely weak compared to the strong force, yet just strong enough
to make supernovas possible.
Concerning the strong nuclear force:
If 2 percent stronger: this would prevent the formation of protons.
If 1 percent stronger: all carbon would have been turned into oxygen.
If 1 percent weaker: no carbon would have been formed from beryllium.
Concerning electromagnetism:
If slightly stronger: all red stars, no supernovae
If slightly weaker: all fast-burning blue dwarves
Much more attention has been directed towards the apparent “fine tuning” of fundamental cosmic parameters: the strengths of physical forces, the masses of elementary particles, the expansion speed and degree of turbulence at early moments in the Big Bang, and so forth. For example, it appears that electromagnetism, gravity, and the two main forces which control the atomic nucleus, had all of them to have strengths which fell inside very narrow limits if there were to be any stars of the long-living, steadily burning sort: the sort which encourage life to evolve. For they re to be life of any readily imaginable kind, anything up to several dozen factors can appear to have needed fine-tuning. Because the number of factors to be listed seems so large, this supposed evidence of design could survive many doubts about what exactly should be on the list.
Many-Universes Objection
If by “universes” you mean Absolutely Everything, then there must be just a single universe. However, people often picture the cosmos as containing numerous huge domains, very varied in their characters and largely or entirely isolated from one another. Now, .universes x is what they typically call them nowadays. Understood in this way, universes can be used to explain any observed fine-tuning without introducing a divine designer. While most universes could well be hostile to intelligent life, observers would clearly have to find themselves in the life-permitting ones. Numerous universe-generating mechanisms have been proposed. Universes could be successive cycles of an oscillating cosmos (Big Bang, Big Crunch, etcetera). They could be huge areas of a gigantic, perhaps infinite cosmos. They could be the worlds of Many-Worlds Quantum Theory, which says that reality continually branches, every alternative allowed by quantum laws occurring in some branch or other. They could be quantum fluctuations in a pre-existing space or in space-time foam. Or form bubbles in which expansion speeds had slowed inside a cosmos that was perpetually inflating. They could even be born in the depths of black holes, then expanding into spaces of their own without disturbing their parent universes. All this could help an opponent of divine design only if the universes differed widely so that sooner or later, somewhere, one or several of them might be expected to be fine-tuned in life-permitting ways.
Anthropic Principle Objection
In the early 1970s, Brandon Carter stated what he called “the anthropic principle”: that what we can expect to observe “must be restricted by the conditions necessary for our presence as observers” (Leslie, J. (Ed.). (1990). Physical cosmology and philosophy. New York: Macmillan Publishing Co). Carter s word “anthropic” was intended as applying to intelligent beings in general. The “weak” version of his principle covered the spatiotemporal districts in which observers found themselves, while its “strong” version covered their universes, but the distinction between spatiotemporal districts and universes, and hence between the weak principle and the strong, could not always be made firmly: one writer s .universe” could sometimes be another s gigantic district. Moreover, the necessity involved was never — not even in the case of the strong anthropic principle — a matter of saying that some factor, for instance God, had made our universe utterly fated to be intelligent-life-permitting, let alone intelligent-life-containing. However, all these points have often been misunderstood and, at least when it comes to stating what words mean, errors regularly repeated can cease to be errors. Everything is thrust into confusion when people say that belief in God is supported by the anthropic principle, meaning simply that they believe in fine tuning and think God can explain it. As enunciated by Carter, the anthropic principle does not so much as mention fine-tuning.
Другие работы по теме:
Design Essay Research Paper The good design
Design Essay, Research Paper The good design nuances of Colors magazine ?lend? well to the Macsystems advert. Maybe this comes from the similar design goal that a magazine and advert
Self Life Essay Research Paper Welcome to
Self Life Essay, Research Paper Welcome to the world of Self Life Where a new way of living awaits you. Self Life estates has been designed with today’s consumer in mind. With poverty at an all-time high, we seek to provide cost efficient housing to the public while maintaining a high standard of building quality.
Terms And Conditions Essay Research Paper TERMS
Terms And Conditions Essay, Research Paper TERMS AND CONDITIONS The conditions for the design price quote are as follows: 1) This quote is for the above stated AppleWax Music, Inc. proposal only. Any changes will require a new proposal and price quote.
Bookreports Essay Research Paper ArchitectThe career that
Bookreports Essay, Research Paper Architect The career that I would like to pursue is Architect. Architecture Engineering has interested me, since I have heard and learned from it. One of the reasons why this field had surpassed my mind is because of the design architects use. Licensed architects sometimes specialize in one phase of work.
NanoTechnology Essay Research Paper One of the
Nano-Technology Essay, Research Paper One of the big problems not fully appreciated with current ideas in nano technology research is the energy requirement for the development of shuttles and using it to carry the bots to other planets. First of all, the design of the shuttle would have to be very intricate because it would have to be able to manage to intense cold since it has to travel farther and farther away from the sun.
Digital Revolution Essay Research Paper Graphic design
Digital Revolution Essay, Research Paper Graphic design was changed forever during the period of quickly evolving computer technology in the last quarter of this century. This time period, which came to be known as the “Digital Revolution”, was originally opposed by many designers. However, after numerous developments in technology, the opposition died down.
Paolo Uccello Essay Research Paper Paolo UccelloHe
Paolo Uccello Essay, Research Paper Paolo Uccello: He was born Paolo di Dono in 1397 in Florence and was apprenticed at an early age to the Florentine artist Lorenzo Ghiberti. In 1425, he traveled to Venice to design mosaics for the facade of Saint Mark s Cathedral. After his return to Florence, he painted a fresco of English mercenary Sir John Hawkwood for the city s cathedral in 1436.
A Streetcar Essay Research Paper Directing ConceptTennessee
A Streetcar Essay, Research Paper Directing Concept: Tennessee Williams A Streetcar Named Desire brings reality to a woman in desperate need of attention. In the production that this design team will put together from the lights to the set will be created a colorful outlook on life from the view of Blanche DuBois.
System Development Lifecycle Essay Research Paper System
System Development Lifecycle Essay, Research Paper System development lifecycle The classic model of software development was the Waterfall model, which considered the process as progressing through a series of stages from requirements analysis through specification, design, coding, testing to documentation and maintenance.
American Flag Essay Research Paper Betsy Ross
American Flag Essay, Research Paper Betsy Ross lived from 1752 to 1836. She was born to Elizabeth Griscom in Philadelphia. In 1773 she ran away with John Ross to get married. But her
The Design And Development Of My Circuit
Was A Task That Merged Into One Essay, Research Paper The design and development of my circuit was a task that merged into one. This is because in order to design a circuit to follow such
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
Circuit Switches Essay Research Paper Beloware a
Circuit Switches Essay, Research Paper Below are a variety of switches that are suitable for the circuit.Advantages: Slim design Illuminated versions CheapDisadvantages: Not easy activateAdvantages: PCB
Bangle Essay Research Paper In an article
Bangle Essay, Research Paper In an article from Harvard Business Review entitled How BMW Turns Art into Profit, Chris Bangle describes his goal to give the designers of this company direction and insight. This skillful man has developed a procedure to keep two completely different departments of the company happy and successful.
Computer Scientist Essay Research Paper The title
Computer Scientist Essay, Research Paper The title computer scientist can be applied to a wide range of computer professionals who usually design computers and the software that runs them, develop information technologies, and develop and adapt principles for applying computers to new uses. Computer scientists perform many of the same duties as other computer professionals, but their jobs are distinguished by the higher level of theoretical expertise and innovation they apply to complex problems and the creation or application of new technology.
Database Design Essay Research Paper Before you
Database Design Essay, Research Paper Before you use Microsoft Access to actually build the tables, forms, and other objects that will make up your database, it is important to take time to design your database. A good database design is the keystone to creating a database that foes what you want it to do effectively, accurately, and efficiently.
Ithaka By Botho Strauss Essay Research Paper
The play Ithaka, by Botho Strauss is an example of a postmodern play. In this paper I will discuss the relationship between the play and the times that the author has written this play with the emphasis of the director and costume designer in mind. To discuss this notion I will comment on the design elements, such as sound, lighting, stage, and costume design.
Scholarship Essay Essay Research Paper No greater
Scholarship Essay Essay, Research Paper No greater contribution can be made to a specific field than research that leads to the development of a new and superior technology. Universities and businesses constantly attempt to remain on the cutting edge of new design, manufacturing, and application systems through research and development.
Mall Of America Essay Research Paper David
Mall Of America Essay, Research Paper David Guterson’s narrative about the Mall of America delves into several facets that are embedded throughout the mall both physically and mentally. A vivid description about the mall’s interior design makes the audience feel like they have visited the mall. Guterson also writes about how people, individually and as a society, are effected psychologically by this pseudo-metropolis.
Argument From Design Essay Research Paper Hume
Argument From Design Essay, Research Paper Hume s criticism in regard to the Design Argument, although complex, can be summarized quite simply. It is first important to understand the main elements of the Design Argument. Hume s theory in opposition to that of the Design Argument contests the suggestion that the simple things in the universe must be compared with the greater to appreciate their complexity as a component of the system of the universe.
Persia Essay Research Paper Influence of Islamic
Persia Essay, Research Paper Influence of Islamic Art The art of Europe, or ‘Western art’ is of a totally different type and style as what is known as ‘Islamic art’. It is difficult to have samples of both together in one place, observe the patterns of one and the narrative form of the other and say, “Islamic art influenced the art of Italy”.
Privacy Essay Research Paper As laws policies
Privacy Essay, Research Paper As laws, policies, and technological design increasingly structure people’s relationships with social institutions, individual privacy faces new threats and new opportunities. Over the last several years, the realm of technology and privacy has been transformed, creating a landscape that is both dangerous and encouraging.
Contemporary Design Essay Research Paper Contemporary design
Contemporary Design Essay, Research Paper Contemporary design is usually client based. The designer usually focuses on the presentation of ideas and statements through the collection rather than designing for any specific occasion. Contemporary design is more conceptual, because of this I am going to concentrate on the concepts and imagery associated with the idea of modern, futuristic clothing.
Designer Comparision Essay Research Paper Armin Hofmann
Designer Comparision Essay, Research Paper Armin Hofmann s effect and significance as a Swiss designer included published the Graphic design manual: principals and practice in 1965. This book became a reference for many young designers and thus created a sort of design recipe that could be followed and repeated by others.
Intergration Of Cad And The Internet Essay
, Research Paper Integration of CAD and the Internet After recently reading two articles about the future of CAD, it is very apparent that the Internet is going to play a major role in the design process. One article dealt with the future of CAD in general and what is expected to be seen in up coming years. The other article was a how Auto desk is already preparing for the future with their new release of AutoCAD 2000i.
Recycling Essay Research Paper Why The Kids
Recycling Essay, Research Paper Why The Kids Won’t Recycle There are a few reasons why kids don’t think too highly of recycling. The first reason, haunting most of us, is the fact that we are lazy. Most kids will just throw their garbage away in the nearest garbage, no matter what it happens to be for. Another problem is that the paper recycling bins have the largest opening.
Adsl Essay Research Paper ADSL has been
Adsl Essay, Research Paper ADSL has been of interest to me for the past couple of years because it enables high-speed data on a single pair of local copper loop. It is phenomenal how it can allow voice and data to run concurrently over the same pair of wire.
Web Designers Essay Research Paper My choice
Web Designers Essay, Research Paper My choice of an ideal job is a web page design technician. YOu make lots of money and you have fun with your job, being creative. Whether it’s a large commercial web-site for business purposes, or a small personal web page about your hobby or family; the process of making it is the same.
What Is Autocad Essay Research Paper What
What Is Autocad Essay, Research Paper What Is AutoCAD? AutoCAD? software is a customizable 2D and 3D design and drafting environment and toolset. Architects, engineers, drafters, and design-related