Review Of Two Essays Essay, Research Paper
During times in which there is increased social concern over the relative equality of men and women in various areas of study, there is a common desire to determine whether there is an appreciable difference in intelligence in relation to gender. Two essays which document various aspects of the relative intelligence of men and women are ?Women and the Mismeasure of Thought? by Judith Genova, and ?The Variability Hypothesis? by Stephanie Shields. Genova seeks to criticize measuring the difference in intelligence between men and women. Genova was unsuccessful with this article in that the questions she raised were not satisfactorily answered, and there was an overall lack of citation. ?The Variability Hypothesis? is an essay detailing the history and arguments against the purported greater variance in male intelligence. Though the argument of Shields? paper is to some extent banal, her criticism of the variability hypothesis is extensive and satisfactory.
The introduction of Genova?s essay is a criticism of historically accepted measurements of intelligence. In the past using brain size as a measure of intelligence was not altogether unacceptable. When this practice was discredited by the obvious lack of intellectual superiority of whales and elephants, a new physical measure of intelligence was sought. Other body dimensions were given brief consideration as measures of intelligence until the example of Negroes, Australians, and Eskimos denied that theory. Genova argues that prejudice over which groups are socially allowed to be intelligent leads to bad science in determining measures of intelligence. I agree that the highly stereotypical practice of craniometry has no relevance to modern studies of male and female intelligence, though Genova fails to adequately prove the existence of such stereotypes in modern science.
Genova cites the example of hemispheric specialization studies as an area of science affected by this same kind of social prejudice. Though traditionally men are seen as analytical (left-brained) while women hold a more holistic mindset (right-brain), studies have indicated that the exact opposite is true. Genova passes off the results of these studies as due to social influences where she has no right. According to Genova, this disparity in traditional views and modern studies can only be explained by intense prejudice on the part of the writers of such studies. On the assumption that this is true, Genova then seeks to hypothesize about such the computer as a trivial tool threatening to belittle the classically analytical intelligence of men, and explains that the newfound holistic intelligence of men is an attempt to avoid that belittlement. Genova explains the newfound analytical characteristic of women as an ?attack? based on ?keeping them out of the world of science and trivializing their achievements in any field as routine and studied? (Genova 103). I would argue, however, that the modern stereotype of female intelligence would still place them as the more creative and holistic of the two sexes. Genova?s comment on computers has no relevance whatsoever to male intelligence. If computers were a threat to male intelligence and a complement to female intelligence, it would make sense that men would be resistant toward the proliferation of computers, yet this is not at all the case. Conversely, computer science is a field dominated by men. Only 7.8% of computer science and computer engineering faculties are women, and a miserable 2.7% of tenured professors are female (Frenkel 38). Genova invalidates her own argument by professing that modern stereotypes about the role of women have led to views of decreased female intelligence. She is applying a stereotype of her own by implying without evidence that modern studies advocating a difference in male and female intellects are conducted and analyzed by men with overpowering prejudices. Genova?s next argument addresses the comparison of brain lateralization to general intelligence.
Brain lateralization is the term for the amount of specialization in the two hemispheres of the brain. A more lateral individual will have more specialization within each hemisphere (for instance, the left brain will control verbal skills more exclusively), while a less lateral or ?bilateral? individual will have no specific location of certain skills. Genova proposes that in general there is an accepted concept of greater laterality in male brains leading to greater intelligence. Genova?s only support for this claim is a citation that is far from a conviction that this concept is true. The quote Genova cites merely suggests that the decreased lateralization may be an explanation for their diminished eminence. Genova has extrapolated that this suggested possibility of one particular author is a fact believed by the mainstream, yet I am not convinced. The latter portion of Genova?s article is broken up into answering three distinct questions: whether or not proposed differences in brain structure are innate, whether these differences actually exist, and what assumptions are made about the nature of thinking in general.
The first question remains altogether unanswered in Genova?s conclusion. She extends a bizarre and altogether obscure metaphor relating the criticism of biological determinism to fire fighting and seems to conclude that due to science being terminally flawed by ?ideological infiltration? there is no validity to the claim that there are differences in brain structure. Again, I am not convinced by Genova?s answer – that science, as a form of discourse, is ineffectual. In relation to the second question, Genova?s claims are once again inconclusive. She picks apart the definition of a difference to mean ?the presence in one group of a trait which is absent in the other? (Genova 110) which is an altogether absurd definition. It is completely impractical to define true difference as two groups being completely independent of each other. Genova inserts at the end of her answer to the second question the equally incredible and unsupported claim that there is no statistical significance in the difference between men and women because of the high degree of overlap between verbal and spatial processing in men and women. Genova?s most relevant claim comes in reply to the third question, and is in need of further exploration. Genova disputes that it is possible that men and women are the same in terms of how they think; yet the environment in which they are raised trains them differently in the collection of information. The analogy implemented by Genova is the inferiority of the computer as thinking machine when compared to man. Though computers can have tremendous analytical flexibility in terms of the processes which can be programmed into them, but the information upon which they act is quite different from that which humans act upon. There is subsequently little difference in thinking, variation stems from differing training and capabilities in the input of information. On the whole I would say that Genova has failed to prove any of her substantial and weighty claims.
On the other hand, Stephanie Shields in her essay ?The Variability Hypothesis? makes less lofty claims and more fully cites those she does make. The article is more of a history than a philosophy paper, in that it documents the history of the variability hypothesis. The premise of the variability hypothesis is that men are more varied than women are in the bell curve of their intellectual prowess. The application of this theory is that since there is more variation among males, there is now explanation for the occurrence of towering geniuses who are male far outnumbering those that are female. Shields systematically proves, however, that the initial premise of the variability hypothesis has never been scientifically proven. Shields cites the example of Darwin in The Descent of Man where he matter-of-factly states that ??The cause of the greater general variability in the male sex, than in the female, is unknown?? (Shields 190). Shields goes on to prove that the variability hypothesis has been derived solely from a common belief being applied to slightly ambiguous data in order to gain expected results, among a slew of other concerns. The social sensitivity of the issue of male vs. female intelligence was an important motivator for both proponents and critics of the variability hypothesis. The variability hypothesis is generally unaccepted in modern times not only because of the prejudicial nature of its derivation, but because or poor statistical analysis. Initially, results were extrapolated from tests of physical prowess to imply mental ability. Even today, measures of mental ability are something that has never been completely verified as absolute measures. In addition, the assumption was made that the curve for variation in mental ability was a normal curve, completely symmetrical about the mean. By far the most absurd misuse of statistics was the comparison of different indexes of variance between different scientists. All of these factors pointing toward the demise of the variability hypothesis were thoroughly cited by Shields, and though the argument she proposed is an arbitrary one, it is a well defined criticism of the variability hypothesis.
Judith Genova?s article ?Women and the Mismeasure of Thought? is one that I don?t feel has proved any substantial points. A torrent of big ideas combined with a lack of substantial amounts of agreeing references makes it hard to accept Genova?s ideas. Shields? essay ?The Variability Hypothesis,? however, is successful in that it takes on a more specific subject and provides more extensive and applicable sources to her thesis.
Bibliography
Frenkel 1990
Frenkel, Karen A. “Women and Computing”. Communications of the ACM, November 1990, 34–46. One of two articles comprising CACM’s cover story
on women and computing. Has a good bibliography.
ai.mit.edu/people/ellens/Gender/pap/pap.html
Другие работы по теме:
Creating The Identity Of The Modern Woman
Essay, Research Paper Society has always placed a great emphasis upon the importance of a woman’s appearance, and through that emphasis women have instinctively been taught to measure their self-worth in terms of the image they present, even more so than their intelligence. They have been given rigid and challenging standards to live up to, standards that are usually unrealistic, unattainable, and disheartening.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Many times in
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Many times in our society intelligence is judged by test scores, careers, and success. Although these methods of measuring intelligence are not always accurate they are still used. IQ tests are given to people and the scores on these tests are supposed to reflect the level of intelligence a person has.
Absoluve Versus Relative Evil Essay Research Paper
Danny RheeEnglish IIIDecember 22, 1998 Absolute Versus Relative Evil As absolute evil is compared to relative evil, one can conclude that our society today, molds evil as relative. By trying to find the root of absolute evil, it may have been pronounced beyond the breech of our imaginations. An example of absolute evil has existed beyond our belief, absolute evil has been demonstrated in many aspects of life, one example would be during the anglo-saxon time period, in the short story Beowulf.
Jonathan SwiftS
“Gulliver’s Travels” Essay, Research Paper Jonathan Swift shows a woman’s place in society is without reason, but Mary Wollenstoncraft illuminates the fact that women have been shaped by a society in which they have no voice. In Jonathan Swifts, “Gulliver’s Travels”, he shows that women are uneducated, extravagant, melodramatic and untrusting in there own sex.
Richard Cory Essay Research Paper
The Barbie Doll and Richard Cory The way our culture has a tendency to view other individuals by there appearance will probably never change. In some way everyone has it set in his or her mind what makes a person “perfect”. These characteristics include personal appearance, wealth and intelligence. We do not always get the chance to get to know a person, but rather make assumptions.
Executive Women Substance Plus Style Essay
, Research Paper Executive Women: Substance Plus Style PSYC 4310 Executive Women: Substance Plus Style The article “Executive Women: Substance Plus Style” deals with the issue of
Why Are Women Always Put Last Essay
, Research Paper Ever since I was little, I have always looked up to my dad. I’ve admired him for his intelligence, his humor, his devotion, and his friendliness. But the one thing I have never neglected in my whole life is that my own father is a well-known, well-respected doctor. Whenever I walked down a street with him, people would smile at him, shake his hand, or give him a gift.
Niniane The Lady Of The Lake Essay
, Research Paper Do you think women hold powerful positions in today?s society? Would you believe that women were powerful as long ago as the fifth and sixth centuries? BELIEVE IT! Niniane, The Lady of the Lake, was one of the most powerful and influential women in King Arthur?s court. She used her intelligence and beauty to place herself at the right hand of King Arthur himself.
IQ Test Essay Research Paper Why IQ
I.Q Test Essay, Research Paper Why IQ tests don’t test intelligence The task of trying to quantify a person s intelligence has been a goal of psychologists since before the beginning of this century. The
Women In History Essay Research Paper Equality
Women In History Essay, Research Paper Equality has been a controversial issue ever since time began. Whether it be race, sex, or religion, it has always been an unsettled topic of concern. Equality between men and
Elizabeth Cady Stanton Essay Research Paper Elizabeth
Elizabeth Cady Stanton Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Cady Stanton Elizabeth Cady Stanton was born in 1815 to the affluent parents Daniel and Mary Livingston Cady in Jamestown, NY. Cady’s parents made it obvious that they preferred sons to daughters when they showed their mutual displeasure of the birth of the Elizabeth’s younger sister.
Intelligence Tests Essay Research Paper INTELLIGENCE TESTSIt
Intelligence Tests Essay, Research Paper INTELLIGENCE TESTS It s a sad but true fact that people are constantly being measured and tested everyday. This testing is not necessarily for themselves, but for others to rate and categorize the subjectee. That person is then placed and stereotyped based on the result of a test.
Medea Vs Lysistrata Essay Research Paper Medea
Medea Vs. Lysistrata Essay, Research Paper Medea vs. Lysistrata ? Contrasting two strong Greek females Both Medea by Euripides and Lysistrata by Aristophanes illustrate the injustices that women suffered. Each author uses strong-willed characters to protest social situations.
St Elizabeth Essay Research Paper I chose
St. Elizabeth Essay, Research Paper I chose the name Elizabeth for my confirmation name after Saint Elizabeth. I feel that she is a very important part in history.
Success Secret A High Emotional IQ Essay
, Research Paper This article keys in on a different type of intelligence called emotional intelligence. Psychologist Daniel Goldman wrote the book titled “Emotional Intelligence” in 1995. Emotional intelligence
Stress Essay Research Paper Coping with stress
Stress Essay, Research Paper Coping with stress and maintaining good health are important parts of maintaining and developing intelligence. (Nick can cope with stress very well. This, among other things, makes him very cool.) One cannot expect one s intelligence to develop if one is preoccupied with poor health or excessive stress.
Women Role In Society Essay Research Paper
How American culture defines a female or (male) What is the woman’s role in society? Men and women are by no means equal. There are always going to be certain attributes of each gender that the other gender cannot duplicate. This does mean that the one is better than the other. Even though we are seeing more and more women succeeding in life than men, American culture still defines a women as unequal.
Errors Essay Research Paper Absolute Errors Since
Errors Essay, Research Paper Absolute Errors Since no measurement is exact, there will always be the possibility of an error. Numbers are often rounded off to a certain number of significant figures or
Merchant Of Venice Essay Research Paper When
Merchant Of Venice Essay, Research Paper When William Shakespeare wrote, The Merchant of Venice, he included a female character that influences the play dramatically. In most of Shakespeare’s plays,
Intelligence Essay Research Paper Intelligence hereditary
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper Intelligence: hereditary or acquired? Is intelligence determined primary by heredity or by the environment? This issue has aroused intense debates because many believe it has a little bit of both, but to what extent? The ones that believe that believe that every person is born with a fixed amount of intelligence argue that there is little one can do to improve intelligence, so special education programs should not be expected to produce an increase in the children?s IQ.
Gender Apartheid Mus Stop Essay Research Paper
Gender Apartheid Must STOP One of the important ideas in a women?s life is expressing herself, individuality, and freedom. Every single day women in Afghanistan are being deprived of their rights as humans and as women. People around the world need to realize this situation and STOP the gender apartheid in Afghanistan by speaking their opinion and joining organizations.
Intelligence Essay Research Paper INTELLIGENCEIt is widely
Intelligence Essay, Research Paper INTELLIGENCE?It is widely debated whether psychologists define intelligence accurately, though most agree that intelligence is the global capacity to act purposefully, think rationally, and deal effectively with the surrounding environment. Their views stem from observing a rather small fraction of the brain’s measured activity, approximately 10 percent, and subsequently cannot actually categorize a person’s mental capacity, other than achieved levels of concentration.
Mr Essay Research Paper Aspects of the
Mr. Essay, Research Paper Aspects of the Perfect Female The ideal woman of today’s society would contain the following qualities: intelligence, honesty, a sense of humor, spontaneity, assertiveness,
Tale Of Genji Overveiw Essay Research Paper
1. The men expected the “hidden flower” to be from the upper class, however, middle class was acceptable. Being in the lower class was totally unacceptable. The woman must have flawless beauty, intelligence, faithfulness (even though this was hypocritical), and submission. Submissiveness is a wishy-washy characteristic because Genji was most attracted to those that rejected him and did not accept his advances as Murasaki and Aoi did.
Womens Brains Essay Research Paper English 104Essay
Womens Brains Essay, Research Paper English 104 Essay This is a brief summary of the essay “Women’s Brains” by Stephen Jay Gould, published in The Panda’s Thumb in 1980. Gould feals that the study of this is irrelevant to the field that they are studying and that the experiments should not have been conducted.
Sin Is Ignorance
– Socratic Definition Of Sin Essay, Research Paper Sin is Ignorance – Socratic definition of sin Sin is ignorance. This is well known Socratic definition of sin which, like everthing Socratic, is an opinion always worthy of attention. The difficulty with the Socratic definition is that it leaves undetermined how ignorance itself is to be more precisely understood, the question of its origin, ect.
GenderBased Differences In Fuel Metabolism Essay Research
Paper The objective of this study was aimed to determine gender-based differences in fuel metabolism in response to long duration exercise. Another way of saying is through a simple question . . . Which gender metabolizes a greater amount of fats vs. carbohydrates at the same relative intensity level?
Gay Marriage Essay Research Paper THE OPPRESSED
Gay Marriage Essay, Research Paper THE OPPRESSED GENDER It has been said that women are a universally oppressed gender. Unfortunately, I feel that this statement is totally true. The view that women are oppressed simply because men and most women too, have the wrong ideas about women can be too optimistic.
Growth Of Women On Rise Essay Research
Paper Education, voting, working were three things women could not do. Before the late 1800’s women had mimited rights. As the years past by women slowly gained priviledges that men already had. Although women cant handle some of the tasks that men take on, women have many other advantages.
Men And Women Are Different Essay Research
Paper Men and Women Different? Are women and men really that different? I think so. I am at a stage in my life where I think all men are after one thing. Sex. When I sit here and think about it, I really have to think, do women and men have anything in common. Women communicate in a completely different manner than women.