Religious Holidays Essay, Research Paper
Questioning the Constitutionality of Celebrating Religious Holidays at Public Expense. It is unconstitutional for local, state or federalgovernments to favor one religion over another? Government can show favoritism toward religion bydisplaying religious symbols in public placesat taxpayer expense, by sponsoring events like Christmasconcerts, caroling, or by supporting the teaching ofreligious ideas. It appears the United Statesgovernment has had a history of favoring Christianity. The United States government’s favoritism of Christianityis a clear violation of the First Amendment. This amendmentstates that “Congress shall make no law respecting anestablishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” There is another reference to religion in Article 6,Section 3. This clause states “the United States and the severalStates shall be bound by oath or affirmation to support this Constitution,but no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to anyoffice or public trust under the United States.” There have been several court cases on this and related issueswhich include Engel vs. Vitale, Everson vs. the Board of Education,and Lynch vs. Donnelly, the “Creche case”. In 1947, in the Everson vs. Board of Educationcase, the Supreme Court ruled that the 14th amendmentprevented the States and the and the Federal governmentfrom setting up a church, passing laws that favor any religion, orusing tax money to support any religion. Justice Hugo Black”incorporated” the First Amendment’s establishment clause into the14th Amendment which states that “the State shall not deny anyperson within its jurisdiction the equal protection of laws and dueprocess. After this trial, people began to question whether schoolprayer was constitutional (pg. 93-94, Klinker). The “creche case,” Lynch vs. Donnelly, came fromRhode Island in 1980. In this case, the city offical includeda creche, or nativity scene, in their city’s annual Christmasdisplay that included all traditional Christmas symbols. Chief Justice Warren E. Burger represented the court’s opinionwhen he stated that, “Nor does the constitution requirecomplete separation of church and state; it affirmativelymandates accommodation, not merely tolerance, of all religions,and forbids hostility toward any.” Justices Brennan, Marshall, Blackman,and Stevens dissented. They thought the “primary effect of including anativity scene in the city’s display is. . . to place the government’s imprematureapproval on the particular religion’s beliefs exemplified by the creche.”
They argued that it clearly violated the First Amendment (p. 99, Witt). These cases demonstrate a pattern of Constitutional thought by highcourts prohibiting the promotion of particular religious ideas, and thespending of tax dollars on events that promote particular religious views. A logical extension of this pattern can be made to the spending of taxdollars for decorating towns on religious holidays, such as Christmas. Local, state, and federal governments attempt to getaround the prohibitions of the Everson and Lynchcases by decorating the streets in town with non-religious symbolssuch as lights, trees, wreaths and other objects that symbolize theseason. But, religious people think the season itself has religiousmeaning. Using tax money to decorate for a religious holidaynot celebrated by everyone is unconstitutional becausethese symbols support one religion over no religion. The First Amendment prohibits this. We understand that public school prayer discriminatesagainst some religious views so it is prohibited in publicschools. Similarly, Christmas concerts play a role similarto the teaching of creationism and prayer. The Christmasconcerts subconsiously influence students toward the beliefs ofChristianity. To be fair to non-Christian groups, converting”Christmas” concerts to “Holiday” concerts would maintainthe “separation of church and state.” One could recognize the beliefs of many religions or none. Onecould play music from several religions or non-religious music. Religion is a personal belief. There are so manyreligions to choose from, including the choice of noreligion. It is impossible to decide that onebelief is right and another is wrong. So it isreasonable to say that it is unconstitutional forgovernment to favor Christianity over other religions,including Athieism. Instead of using tax dollars todecorate the streets for the holidays, we could usethe money for other things like playgrounds andhelping the homeless. Also, students could playmusic that has no religious meaning to pleaseevery belief or offend none. This way, governmentwould be prevented from favoring one religion over another. Henry, Richard, “Government in America”,Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, 1994pg.141, 146, 148. Klinker, Philip A., “The American Heritage History ofthe Bill of Rights”, Silver Burdett Press., 1991pg. 99-100, 109, 93. “Darrow, Clarence Steward”, “The American PeoplesEncyclopedia vol.6 “, Grolier Incorporated, New York1962, pg. 796. Witt, Elder ,”The Supreme Court and Individual Rights”,Second Edition, Congressional Quarterly Inc.,Washington D.C., 1988, pg. 99
Другие работы по теме:
Holiday in Russia
HOLIDAYS IN RUSSIA There are many national holidays in Russia, when people all over the country do not ,Twork and have special celebrations. The major holidays are: New Year's Day, Women's Day, May Day, Victory Day, and Independence Day.
HOLIDAY New Year
Beloborodov P. 113 My Last Holidays. Most of all I like New Year holidays. Because New Year is a holiday for everyone. People all over the world welcome the New Year at one moment, that’s why I think it’s the most uniting holiday in the world, because in this moment every person can say that he loves everyone.
English Themes - My favorite Holiday
My favorite holiday In Russia, the same as in every other country, there are many holidays: interesting and funny, patriotic and dedicated to any historical event. For example in Russia there are such holidays as the Women’s day, the Victory Day, the Independent Day, the April’s Fool’s day, and many other.
British traditional holidays
Great Britain is famous for its old traditions. Some of them existed in ancient times and survived through centuries. Some of them appeared when Christianity came to British isles. Speaking about religious holidays one can’t but mention Easter, Pancake Day and Mother’s Day. The dates of these holidays aren’t strict, they depend on the date of Easter, that varies every year.
Holidays
Which is the best way to spend your summer ? Well, I guess there exists a great number of different ways of spending summer holidays... But each person has his own preferences, so everyone likes the only way.
Fallacy Essay Research Paper At 130 in
Fallacy Essay, Research Paper At 1:30 in the morning you are driving down Walton Road when you pass the 7-11. You decide to stop in and treat yourself to a nice big slurpee. As you pull in
Church And The Media Essay Research Paper
INTRODUCTION : Many religious organizations, like the Christian Coalition, conduct experiments that try to link people’s church attendance with that of their television viewing habits. I have developed a study that focuses on the same subject matter. In addition, my study compares student’s grade level to their television viewing habits and how viewing specific types of television programs might influence there decision to attend church.
Miranda Vs Arizona Essay Research Paper In
Miranda Vs Arizona Essay, Research Paper In 1966 the Supreme Court made a ruling that every American would always know and remember. The case was Miranda versus The State of Arizona.
Religion Essay Research Paper ReligionReligion is a
Religion Essay, Research Paper Religion Religion is a set of practices and beliefs that allow human beings to search for the meaning of life and the purpose of their existence. These common practices set the foundation for such beliefs to have validity. Every individual must wonder why he/she exists on earth.
Halloween Essay Research Paper Many of the
Halloween Essay, Research Paper Many of the ancient peoples of Europe marked the end of the harvest season and the beginning of winter by celebrating a holiday in late autumn. The most important of these holidays to influence later Halloween customs was Samhain, a holiday observed by the ancient Celts, a tribal people who inhabited most of Western and Central Europe in the first millennium BC.
Beowulf Values Essay Research Paper Every culture
Beowulf Values Essay, Research Paper Every culture has distinctions that separate it from other cultures. That it what makes them so unique. The have different religions, foods, ceremonies, rituals, and holidays. The perceive the world in different ways, and also have certain values that they treasure very much.
Renaissance Essay Research Paper The Renaissance has
Renaissance Essay, Research Paper The Renaissance has been described as consisting of ?a rebirth of the human spirit, a realization of the human potential for development.? This quote, as well as the word, ?Renaissance? imply a massive change in society and tradition. Contributing to this change was 17th century poet, John Donne.
Passolini Essay Research Paper Passolini
Passolini Essay, Research Paper Passolini’s movie included short tales displaying the irony and humor that take place in Italian religious communities. For example, one tale was about a convent filled with devoted nuns that decided to hire what thought was a poor, deaf, mute man. They hired this man as the gardener for their convent.
William James Essay Research Paper William James
William James Essay, Research Paper William James, in the first lecture of his work the varieties of religious experiences analyzes the origins of religious phenomena. The theory mostly debated among others is that of medical materialism.
Spanish Holidays Essay Research Paper The Spanish
Spanish Holidays Essay, Research Paper The Spanish Culture has many holidays. They celebrate a lot of different occasions throughout the year. Many of their holidays are celebrated in a different way then those celebrated in America. They celebrate some of the same holidays as us, but they also have a lot of different ones.
The Scientific Understanding Of God Essay Research
Paper A Scientific Understanding of God Two eighteenth century movements, the Enlightenment and the Great Awakening, changed American colonists views on reason and wisdom. The Enlightenment, led by philosophers such as John Locke, emphasized abstract thought to acquire knowledge. The European and American thinkers research led to a greater understanding of scientific phenomena and the questioning of the government s rule.
Non-Religous Celebrations Of Easter Should Be Done
Away With Essay, Research Paper Non-Religious Celebrations of Easter Should be Done Away With Have you ever sat back and thought about the different traditions that we celebrate in America as well as all around the world? Some of these traditions may include holidays, sporting events, and weddings. We celebrate certain traditions for religious reasons, for memorial reasons, and just for the fact that what we are celebrating is a tradition, and we wish to keep it that way.
Night Essay Research Paper The NightNight by
Night Essay, Research Paper The Night Night by Elie Wiesel is a story of one of the few Holocausts survives. He and the many others are being persecuted for their religious beliefs. In the Jewish community of Sighet everyone was in disbelief for what was in store for them. Then the acts of cruelty to each other in time of need, to hoping to survive one day to the next.
American Religion Essay Research Paper The American
American Religion Essay, Research Paper The American Religious Experience In America today we all have choices to make in regards to our religious beliefs. Many young children are brought up today confused about religion and the significance it plays in their lives. There are many sanctions and rules now on what can and can t be thought or displayed to people on public property, but it wasn t always like this.
Spring Offensive Essay Research Paper SPRING OFFENSIVEWilfred
Spring Offensive Essay, Research Paper SPRING OFFENSIVE (Wilfred Owen) Wilfred Owens poem Spring Offensive explores the unnatural offensive of war against spring or nature. Opening with Halted against the shade of the last hill Owen suggests both the calmness of the shade and the deadly implication of last.
Indian 2 Essay Research Paper When comparing
Indian 2 Essay, Research Paper When comparing the cultural differences between European Americans and Native Americans, nothing can be said about Native Americans as a whole. Every tribe is different from every other in some aspects and similar in other aspects. In general we can express cultural differences; how differently we see things and vision things, look at things, language, religion, and cultural holidays.
Religious Edu Essay Research Paper Teacher
Religious Edu Essay, Research Paper Teacher: Raymen E. Grade Level: 6th Date: 08/26/00 Lesson Plan Book One ? Exploring and Discovering. Topic One ? Mapping the world.
Holiday Stress Essay Research Paper The holidays
Holiday Stress Essay, Research Paper The holidays! They’re supposed to be a time of warmth, happiness and excitement. For many people, they are. Although for some, the season can be a paradox. Joyous feelings, family and religious traditions can be overshadowed by stress, fatigue and gloom–”the blues.” In addition to all of the gifts, goodies, decorations and events, the holiday season can be filled with many pressures.
Commercialism Of Holidays Essay Research Paper HOLIDAYS
Commercialism Of Holidays Essay, Research Paper HOLIDAYS SHOULD BE ASPECIAL OCCASIONS THAT HAVE RELIGIOUS, HISTORICAL, AND CULTURAL SIGNIFICANCE. INCREASINGLY, HOWEVER, HOLIDAYS IN THE UNITED STATES ARE TURNING INTO LITTLE MORE THAN BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES. FROM COAST TO COAST, THE JINGLES AND BEEPS OF CASH REGISTERS DROWN OUT THE TRADITIONAL SOUNDS OF HOLIDAY OBSERVANCE.
A Parents Appearance Essay Research Paper The
A Parents Appearance Essay, Research Paper The relationship between a child and his parents will never change no matter if they do go through a divorce. Parents should always love their kids all the time, even if they don t live with them. Don t get me wrong there are many advantages with living with both the living with one, I know.
The Republic By Plato 427
– 347 B.C.) Essay, Research Paper The Republic is one of the foundational writings of Western philosophy and civilization. We see Platonic thought and Socratic methodology still vitally evolving in today’s world. Dialectic
Hawthorne And Symbolism Essay Research Paper Hawthorne
Hawthorne And Symbolism Essay, Research Paper Hawthorne and Symbolism Symbolism is a key in all or most writings. Symbolism is what the reader needs in order to use his imagination. In “Young Goodman Brown” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, through different symbolism, Hawthorne writes about a man who in his coming of age.
Native American Essay Research Paper The Native
Native American Essay, Research Paper The Native American s way of life was interesting and unique, describe to be savages, drunks and This paper will examine the Native American s character. During the 19th century, these peoples and their customs became well known, known as the stereotyped “Indian” customs the long feather headdress, the tepee (also spelled tipi), the stereotype ceremonial pipe, costumes, and dancing.
Latin American Influences On America Essay Research
Paper Latin America Latin America affects Florida, the Southwest and California in many ways. Three of the most obvious are food, holidays, and the people. These influences are mainly for the good though some can have negative influence as well.
The Christmas Carol Essay Research Paper A
The Christmas Carol Essay, Research Paper A Christmas Carol The main character is Scrooge. He is very mean to other people. He wouldn t give a dime to anyone. Scrogge is very
Oral Tradition Essay Research Paper Oral TraditionMy
Oral Tradition Essay, Research Paper Oral Tradition My family has many oral traditions. I m not real for sure that there any different than anybody elses. We celebrate every American Holiday. We have very strong Baptist
Каникулы /english/
Как лучше всего провести летние каникулы. Активные и пассивные виеды отдыха.