? Essay, Research Paper
In 1990 a movie was released, that movie was called The Silence of The Lambs. It starred Anthony Hopkins in the role of Dr. Hannibal Lecter M.D. In the film Dr. Lecter was called many things. A “monster,” a “psychopath,” “Hannibal the Cannibal,” “some kind of vampire,” a “thing” and many more labels were placed on him throughout the film.
The back story behind Hannibal is that he was a renowned psychiatrist until a bad habit of his was discovered. Hannibal ate people, even his own patients became victims. Prior to his capture only one of his victims survived. At one point he killed a musical performer and served his remains to a group of colleges with some sweet bread. Once officials finally put him into custody he then killed at least three more people.
Meanwhile in the outside world a serial killer called Buffalo Bill is murdering and removing the skins of young girls. A trainee in the FBI Clairice Starling is called on to interview Hannibal in order to find Buffalo Bill. Hannibal becomes a mentor to Clairice and Buffalo Bill is captured with the help of Hannibal. However during their encounters Hannibal is able to escape from captivity.
Hannibal is unquestionably evil to his victims, however he is also brilliant, cultured, a man of high class and honest even about his own past. In a letter he writes to Clairice in the second film Hannibal comments about his own disgrace stating that it never really bothered him “except for the inconvenience of being incarcerated.” He seems uncaring about his actions.
Aristotle seems incapable of accepting that men can simply be evil. He claims that if a person does bad things they either suffer from incontinence or intemperance. Aristotle describes incontinence as a weakness of the will. The person knows what they are doing is wrong, but they do it anyway. Intemperance as Aristotle describes it is a person who is unaware that what they are doing is wrong. However the idea of a person doing bad things because they enjoy it or because it feels right to them seems unattainable to Aristotle.
This leaves us with a simple question “What would Aristotle think of Hannibal Lecter?” Hannibal is intelligent so Aristotle must think he suffers from incontinence and simply can not help himself from eating his fellow man. Also given the lengths that Hannibal will go to in order to cook some of his victims it would seem he gains pleasure from the act. However he seems unable to see anything wrong with eating people. Clairice explains in the second film that Hannibal has two reasons to kill people. The first is to show his contempt for them. The second reason serves as a public service. Also it is stated that whenever possible Hannibal tries to eat the rude. This shows that he seems unable to understand that under no circumstances should one eat their fellow man. Thus Aristotle must believe Hannibal suffers from intemperance and just doesn t understand.
There is also a third option. When Aristotle was writing many Greeks saw the world in very black and white terms. There were the Greeks and the non-Greeks. This is expressed by the Greek ideas of Hubris vs. Sophrozyne. Hubris is a failure to recognize one s own limits and Sophrozyne is a knowledge of one s own limits. The non-Greeks were also known at suffering from barbarism. Aristotle continues to divide men into five groups. The first is the God-like man, next the Good man, man, bad man and lastly the brute. The brute sounds very similar to the barbaric non-Greek. Hannibal was not Greek, he was English. Aristotle could very easily write Hannibal off as being a non-Greek and unable to understand civilized culture. However that s a bit of a stretch so, let s assume Aristotle would put personal bigotry aside for Hannibal s sake.
Aristotle might have one last trick to use to prove Hannibal is neither incontinent nor intemperate. He is very clear when he states;
“Now each man judges well the things he knows, and of these he is a good judge. And so the man who has been educated in a subject is a good judge of that subject, and the man who has received an all-round education is a good judge in general.”
Aristotle praises the educated man, calling him a good judge. Aristotle then goes on to explain why an educated man can hope to become virtuous while the brute and child can not. However Hannibal is polite, cultured, familiar with women s skin creams and quality of attire, has a strong artistic ability, helpful and thoughtful in his own way, speaks both English and Latin, is a grommet cook, not to mention the fact he has a PHD and was a very successful psychiatrist. If this is not a well rounded man I don t know what is. So, it would appear Aristotle must psychoanalyze Hannibal Lecter as he would any other Greek.
Does Hannibal suffer from a weakness of the will? Normally when we think of a weakness of the wills we think about things we did that we knew we should not have done. Thus we do bad things and then we feel shame. In Hannibal s case he doesn t feel shame. One would normally think that a lack of shame would strengthen Aristotle s case against Hannibal. However Aristotle states that;
” . . . an older person no one would praise for being prone to the sense of disgrace, since we think he should not do anything that need cause this sense. For the sense of disgrace is not even characteristic of a good man . . .”
So, if the good man feels no disgrace or shame and neither does Hannibal is Aristotle somehow allowing us to compare Hannibal to a “good man?” Also Aristotle claims a good man shouldn t do anything he would feel bad about. Aristotle clearly has never met Ned Flanders (from The Simpsons, on FOX.)
However, shame or no shame it is clear that Hannibal enjoys what he does. Aristotle would point out that the good doctor clearly gains quite a bit of pleasure from what he does. Pleasure as Aristotle defines it is neither a good thing nor a bad. It is the extent that one consumes their form of pleasure that makes it good or bad. For example, one can enjoy eating. They gain pleasure from the action of eating and it fulfils a need in order to live. However is one abstains from eating they will surly die, or if one over eats to an excess they will become obese and may also die.
As Aristotle might praise some amounts of pleasure, he would never praise the eating of flesh of other people. However Aristotle being a Greek would believe in the idea of “Help Yours Friends, Hurt Your Enemies.” This is an idea that Hannibal follows closely. He has many times acted out vengeance on Clairice s behalf. After their first meeting the man in the cell next to Hannibal s threw cum unto Clairice. Hannibal acted quickly, first he gave Clairice information that lead to more evidence in finding Buffalo Bill. That night he committed his second form of vengeance, he convinced the fellow convict to kill himself. Another time Hannibal has hurt his enemies, was threw the direct eating of those who mistreated him while he was incarcerated. Had Antigone eaten Creaon rather than try to convince him to let her bury her brother perhaps both of their lives would have been better off?
The reason of course that Antigone didn t eat Creaon is that there is a normative idea that one does not eat their enemies. In Greek culture it is ok to kill one s enemies, but not eat them. Perhaps this was a reaction to rumors that Amazon women ate men? Throughout history very few groups have practiced cannibalism. Aristotle probably could never have even imagined a person who would commit the acts that Hannibal commits, while asking himself little more than if a butter sauce or mushroom sauce might be tastier.
Aristotle would almost definitely claim Hannibal is suffering from intemperance and simply doesn t understand one should not eat other people. However as it has been stated above humans as a group of beings know that when planning a dinner menu it s best to leave your best friend off the menu. To Hannibal this is a foreign concept. Aristotle claims brutes are as unaware of right and wrong as Hannibal seems to be. Aristotle shows this when he states;
“a brute has no vice or virtue, so neither has a god; his state is higher than virtue, and that of a brute is a different kind of state from vice.”
However we have shown that Hannibal is educated, making him not a brute. Hannibal understands right and wrong. He sees Clairice being hurt and commits vengeance in her name. If nothing else he understands the idea of helping friends and hurting enemies. If Hannibal is not a brute, perhaps Aristotle would have to in the end label him a god.
Greek gods are nothing like the Judeo-Christian God. Greek gods are powerful and strong, like Hannibal. The Greek gods are above vice and virtue. Hannibal doesn t hold himself to the same standards as the rest of humanity. The Greek gods demanded sacrifice. Hannibal simply took it for himself. The Greek gods punish those who cross them in inhuman ways. Hannibal eats those who cross him.
We will never really know what Aristotle would have thought of Dr. Hannibal Lecter M.D. Hannibal never really lived and he was only thought of thousands of years after Aristotle died, but it s fun to wonder what he would think.
364
Другие работы по теме:
Oedipus The King Essay Research Paper 3
Oedipus The King Essay, Research Paper 3. How Sophocles? Oedipus the King fits the description of tragedy provided by Aristotle? Why does Aristotle believe tragedy is superior to epic poetry?
Dream Deffered Essay Research Paper Dream DeferredHe
Dream Deffered Essay, Research Paper ?Dream Deferred? ?He knew as he stood there that he could never tell why he killed. It was not that he did not really want to tell, but the telling of it would have involved an explanation of his
Aristotle Essay Research Paper In Aristotle
Aristotle Essay, Research Paper In Aristotle’s Metaphysics, he discusses what he believes to be the theory of origin. One must differentiate Aristotle’s theory with that of creation. The word “creation” implies a biblical idea. Aristotle was not familiar with the biblical text and therefore did not understand the concept of “creation” in the biblical sense.
Aristotle 2 Essay Research Paper Aristotle s
Aristotle 2 Essay, Research Paper Aristotle s Life Aristotle (384-322 BC) was a Greek philosopher, educator, and scientist, and was also one of the most influential thinkers in Western culture (World Book 663). Through his writings, Aristotle considered, summarized, criticized, and helped to further develop many of these traditions from which he had learned from Plato, his teacher.
Aristotle Essay Research Paper AristotleAristotle was a
Aristotle Essay, Research Paper Aristotle Aristotle was a Greek philosopher, educator, and scientist. He was one of the greatest and most influential thinkers in Western culture. He familiarized himself with the entire development of Greek thought preceding him. In his own writings, Aristotle considered, summarized, criticized, and further developed all the intellectual tradition that he had inherited from his teacher, Plato.
Hannibal Of Carthage Essay Research Paper Hannibal
Hannibal Of Carthage Essay, Research Paper Hannibal of Carthage: “The Father of Strategy” Through out history there have been many great military leaders, Alexander the Great, Napoleon, Generals Washington, Grant and Charles Lewis Puller. The one however that sticks out the most is General Hannibal of Carthage.
Aristotle Essay Research Paper Aristotle The Most
Aristotle Essay, Research Paper Aristotle: The Most Influential Greek Thinker Aristotle was one of the most influential thinkers in western culture, and a Greek philosopher, teacher, and scientist. He was probably the most scholarly and learned of the ancient Greek Philosophers. Aristotle mastered the entire development of Greek though before him and employed this knowledge in his writings.
Aristotle 384 322 BC Essay Research Paper
Aristotle (384 -322 BC) ARISTOTLE’S LIFE Aristotle, Greek philosopher and scientist, is one of the most famous of ancient philosophers. He was born in Stagira, Greece to a physician to the royal court.
Hannibal
– Thomas Harris – Creating And Holding Tension Essay, Research Paper One book I could and have read many times over is “Hannibal” by the highly acclaimed thriller writer Thomas Harris. This book is a stylish, smart journey through the two relationships between Hannibal Lecter and his counterparts Mason Verger and Clarice Starling, its style of writing such that it makes it very difficult to put down, I speak from personal experience having read the 103 chapter book in a space of a few days, it was extremely gripping and exiting.
Hannibal Essay Research Paper HannibalTwentytwo centuries ago
Hannibal Essay, Research Paper HannibalTwenty-two centuries ago there lived a man named Hannibal, the son of Hamilcar Barca a Carthaginian. Hamilcar was a general in the Carthaginian military in the first Punic War. After the defeat of Carthage in the first Punic War, Hamilcar made Hannibal swear “eternal enmity” to Rome.
Punic War Essay Research Paper The Second
Punic War Essay, Research Paper The Second Punic War was lost because General Hannibal did not have the right engineering to conquer Roman Cities. If General Hannibal could not conquer Roman cities then he would never be able to conquer the Roman Empire. Hannibal had the right leadership and a large enough army to defeat the Romans.
Aristotle On Virtue Essay Research Paper Aristotle
Aristotle On Virtue Essay, Research Paper Aristotle’s Views on Virtue Aristotle explains virtue by first explaining what things are found in the soul. He says that the soul has three things-passions, faculties, and states of character, and virtue must be one of these. Passions are things such as anger, fear, longing, and joy.
Plato Vs Aristotle Essay Research Paper How
Plato Vs. Aristotle Essay, Research Paper How do we explain the world around us? How can we get to the truth? Plato and Aristotle began the quest to find the answers thousands of years ago. Amazingly, all of philosophy since that time can be described as only a rehashing of the original argument between Plato and Aristotle.
Case Study Hannibal Lecter Essay Research Paper
Dr. Hannibal Lecter Dr. Lecter is a 56-year-old man who has never before been married. He was ordered by the New York Supreme Court to seek counseling following his conviction for murder. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. According to police records, Dr. Lecter has killed nine people of whom the last six were killed in a brief spree of violence and whimsy.
Hannibal Essay Research Paper Hannibal was the
Hannibal Essay, Research Paper Hannibal was the son of Hamilcar Barca. He was a Carthaginian who was born twenty two centuries ago. He was actually born in Spain but spent most of his life in Carthage so
Hannibal Essay Research Paper Hannibal a Carthaginian
Hannibal Essay, Research Paper Hannibal, a Carthaginian general and one of the greatest generals that ever lived was renown for his strategies and courageousness, such as crossing the Alps and using the ?bottleneck strategy? at Lake Trasemene. He used strategies that a lot of generals at this time, especially Roman generals, would never think of and in doing this he almost destroyed the Roman republic.
Hannibal Essay Research Paper Hannibal written by
Hannibal Essay, Research Paper Hannibal, written by Thomas Harris, is a combination of a thriller and a mystery. From the first word that is read in this novel, until the last one, the suspense of Hannibal Lecter’s next victim or phrase is very entertaining.This book entails the struggle for a man to find true love, although he is fully deranged in every other aspect of his lifestyle.
Plato Essay Research Paper There are many
Plato Essay, Research Paper There are many ways in which the philosophy of Plato and Aristotle have reached that of that of Saint Thomas Aquinas, due to the fact that Aristotle thought the world that we live in today is the ultimate reality. While Plato thought the world that we see every day is real but is not the ultimate reality.
Aristotle Essay Research Paper Aristotle b 384
Aristotle Essay, Research Paper Aristotle (b. 384 – d. 322 BC), was a Greek philosopher, logician, and scientist. Along with his teacher Plato, Aristotle is generally regarded as one of the most
Aristotle On Politics Essay Research Paper The
Aristotle On Politics Essay, Research Paper The central concern of theorists is to establish a form of constitution that a society will likely succeed. Political success according to Aristotle is determined by the happiness of the citizens of the society. Aristotle’s vision of a perfect government all begins with the character of the citizenry leading to the happiness of a whole state.
Silence Of The Lambs The Battle Between
Two Evils Essay, Research Paper Silence of the Lambs: The Battle Between Two Evils Philosophy 101 December 18, 1996 In the novel, Silence of the Lambs, we see two different extremes of
The Silence Of The Lambs Essay Research
Paper The Silence of The Lambs Clarice Starling, a student preparing for a life in the FBI, hunts a serial killer by use of vague information given to her by an incarcerated
Silence Of The Lambs Essay Research Paper
THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS The novel The Silence of the Lambs by Thomas Harris is said to fall under the genre of psychological horror. The stories that fall under the genre of horror include a few essential elements: a villain or one seen as evil to create an initial story line. The foil is the next element; a foil is a person who tries to stop the villain from going through with the evil plan or plot.
Aristotle Essay Research Paper Aristotle analyzes the
Aristotle Essay, Research Paper Aristotle analyzes the goods and the virtues that lead to human beings toward happiness in book one of Nicomachean Ethics. According to Aristotle, every activity has an end (or goal); another way of saying this is that the aim of every activity is some kind of good. Concerning this, human existence itself must have some ultimate good.
Aristotle Essay Research Paper Aristotle 384 BC
Aristotle Essay, Research Paper Aristotle (384 BC -322 BC) was a Greek philosopher, logician, and scientist. Along with his teacher Plato (author of The Republic), Aristotle is generally regarded as one of the most influential ancient thinkers in a number of philosophical fields, including political theory.
Thomas Harris Essay Research Paper Thomas Harris
Thomas Harris Essay, Research Paper Thomas Harris is a man with many tallents, an a keen intrest in writing. He earned a major in English, he has written for many newspapers and is most known for his second book which became a major motion picture earning 5 Academy Awards for Best Picture , Best Actress, Best Actor, Best Director and Best Adapted Screen Play, Silence of the Lambs.
Hannibal Essay Research Paper Hannibal released in
Hannibal Essay, Research Paper Hannibal, released in 2001, is part three of the Hannibal Lecter trilogy. Edited by Pietro Scalia and directed by Ridley Scott, also known for ground-breaking films such as Alien, Blade Runner, and Gladiator, Hannibal stars Anthony Hopkins as the criminally-insane Dr. Lecter.
Hannibal Essay Research Paper HannibalFor those interested
Hannibal Essay, Research Paper Hannibal For those interested in seeing Hannibal, you ll find greater enjoyment of the movie if you avoid comparing it to Silence of the Lambs, its smashing predecessor. Hannibal has a different style, altered tone, and a sweeping change in story emphasis. In short, it s bigger, simpler, and a bit more predictable.
Hannibal Review Essay Research Paper Movie ReviewHannibal
Hannibal Review Essay, Research Paper Movie Review Hannibal Hannibal is a wonderful movie. I wonderful movie is a movie that is well thought out, and has a good flowing plot. Many people think this is a scary movie. I found Hannibal to be a very suspenseful and an intriguing film. Anthony Hopkins, a brilliantly outstanding actor, portrays a psychotic killer named Dr.