Kant Essay, Research Paper
Immanuel Kant was a sound, grounded philosopher of the Enlightenment. His explanations were black and white, clear-cut, which may be seen as his greatest attribute, as well as his worst flaw. The drive behind all of Kant’s ideas was reason. To Kant, morality was a matter of rational, acting morally equaled acting rationally. He challenged people to make their own ethical decisions using the power of reason instead of becoming pawns of circumstance, society, or our own emotions. Kant disregarded many previous ethical principles based on consequences of actions, such as Utilitarianism, and focused on the intentions behind the actions. Kant believed genuine good will stood at the heart of morality. He thoroughly examined this concept of good will and developed a way to measure it, called the categorical imperative. This dramatic reasoning of morality has been both praised and criticized.
Kant’s writing “Good Will, Duty, and the Categorical Imperative,” highlighted his philosophy. In this passage, good will is defined in terms of motivation and reason. In that good will can never violate reason and it can never be motivated by anything but itself. It is good in itself, without any other qualifications. It is not considered good because of what it affects or performs. Good will has no attachments and is unconditional. Here arises the first difficulty- how can one determine if the will is good? How can you tell when someone is acting out of good will? For Kant the answer is simple and followed with another question. Kant claims acting on good will is obeying duty, which means following the categorical imperative. To explain this aspect of good will, without moving into the categorical imperative, it is best to use an example.
Three people, all with the same physical and reasoning abilities, stand on a corner and are watching an elderly woman cross the street. From a distance they all witness an oncoming MAC truck heading straight for the old lady. The first person, Mike, runs out into the street and saves the woman whom he knows is his grandmother. He loves her very much and would not want to see her be hit, saving her out of sympathy. The second person, Stan, has no relation to the woman, but still runs out and saves her in hopes of impressing the third member of this trio, who happens to be a gorgeous supermodel. The third person, we?ll call her Amanda, just for namesake, runs out into the street and rescues the elderly woman purely because she knows it was the right thing to do. If Kant was to analyze this situation, he would claim that only Amanda acted on good will because she acted as her duty and will commanded. The other two people acted only due to circumstance, had the woman not been Mike?s grandmother, or had Stan not wanted to impress Amanda, they might not have committed such a courageous act. Their actions were not independent and could not stand on their own grounds. It is for this reason that Kant dismisses all circumstance and emotions. It is necessary to disregard feelings and individual situations from moral actions, in order to distinguish between the two. Kant?s methods allow no exceptions. Kant was an absolutist deeming it necessary to hold moral absolutes.
This example may also be used in differentiating Kant?s idea of good will and everyday conceptions of it. Most people believe good will means no more than acting righteously and behaving in accordance with moral standards. For instance, most people at the scene of rescuing the old woman would say all three acted with good wills. Kant, however, would strongly disagree. Good will, for him, is very specific, depending not solely on the action, but the absolute intention and motivation behind it. How may one test the intentions of will in determining if it was good or not? Kant derived a test called the categorical imperative.
The categorical imperative was a solution to figuring out whether an act was moral or immoral. Kant formularized a question to gauge all morality. Is this the kind of act everyone should perform? Could my action be made a universal law? If it could be made universal without canceling out the original intention or violating natural law, then the action would be deemed moral. Kant uses some examples in his writing. One example was in terms of borrowing money without intention of repaying it. If this were made a universal law, eventually no one would lend money to anyone due to the knowledge of never being repaid. The consequence of this universialization cancels out the original intention. Another example may be illustrated in the universalizing of never keeping secrets. If no one ever kept a secret, eventually everyone would stop telling secrets. The original intention would be undermined by the effect of making it a universal law. Yet, is this test successful in determining good will in all cases? Kant, as an absolutist, would have to say yes, but I along with many others disagree.
I completely agree with Kant and all his principles providing we were living in a utopia, a perfect world. The world we live in today, however, makes it near impossible to apply Kant?s theories. Kant is wonderful, in principle, but in practice his principles fall apart. Morality is too complex and cannot be simplified in such a way as Kant has simplified it. Kant is an absolutist, black and white. This would work if we lived in black and white, but our world is much more colorful. He allows no exceptions, which is commendable, yet unrealistic.
Aside from its simplicity, my main difficulty with Kant?s theory is that it takes away our human character. By ignoring individuals, circumstance, and emotions Kant takes away our humanity and individuality. While in attempt to preserve individualism and dignity, Kant ironically violates this directly. He asks us to think on our own two feet and to use OUR reason, but at the same time he asks us to follow HIS laws and principles. How can we be using our own logic, while we are following his? We are limited to his guidelines, therefore violating individual thinking, which is what he encourages. Kant?s process of weighing morality is emotionless. This is very dangerous and costly. Without emotions we are robots. Feelings are the main identity of our species. Reason can only take us so far.
My final criticism of Kant is his ignorance of variations of reason. Everyone does not reason in the same way. For instance, what if someone hated technology and wanted to rid the world of computers. Apply the categorical imperative to this situation. Would it be reasonable for everyone to smash his or her computer? For an anti-technology person, this universal law is practical. It accomplishes their goal of ridding the world of computers. This abuse of the categorical imperative may come in many forms.
Although I have many criticisms of Kant, he makes a strong argument, which is why people still follow his philosophy today. He presents clear and sensible explanations of good will. His absolute statements may be his strongest point or his greatest downfall. You may use your reason to decide.
30f
Другие работы по теме:
Kant And Freedom Essay Research Paper Immanuel
Kant And Freedom Essay, Research Paper Immanuel Kant was a man before his time. His philosophies, as outlined in Perpetual Peace, paved the way for modern political relations. Unbeknownst
Kant And Disinterestedness Essay Research Paper
“which we Disinterestedness has been a reaccurant theme in aesthetic thought throughout recent times. Kant was one of the first to discribe disinterestedness as an basic and universal part of the aesthetic judgement experiance. However the notion of disinterestedness did not origninate with Kant; it is to be found in the writtings of many Eighteenth centuray philosophers such as Stolinitz, Shaftsbury, Hutcheson, Gerard and Burke.
Kant Goodness Essay Research Paper Kant Goodness
Kant: Goodness Essay, Research Paper Kant: Goodness The philosopher I used is Immanuel Kant. He was very practical in his thinking of goodness. A quote of his was “I ought, therefore I can”. His view
The Architectonic Form Of Kant
’s Copernican System Essay, Research Paper The Architectonic Form of Kant’s Copernican System Human reason is by nature architectonic. That is to say, it regards all our
Morality Essay Research Paper This essay will
Morality Essay, Research Paper This essay will compare and contrast the moral philosophies of three people: St Augustine, Immanuel Kant, and Aristotle. Everybody has their own concept of what good is. Most people agree on certain things such as the morality of murder, stealing, etc. , however, as our conceptions are looked at with greater detail, why we do good, how we do good, and basically what good stands for, varies.
Kant An Act Of Moral Worth
Essay, Research Paper Jill had been driving down a deserted road when her tire became flat. With no one around for miles she struggled with changing the tire when Jack happened to be driving by and stopped to give her a hand. How and why is this an act of genuine moral worth?
How Are Synthetic A Prirori Ju Essay
, Research Paper Kant theorizes that synthetic a priori judgments are conceived before an event occurs. He makes the assumption that these synthetic a priori judgments are plausible without any empirical knowledge, exposure, experience, or any related comprehension. Ergo it is false to assume that synthetic a priori conclusions are not justifiable because the articulation of conscious and unconscious stimuli is an occurrence since birth.
Anselm
’s Ontological Argument Essay, Research Paper As a theologian and philosopher, Saint Anselm strove to prove the existence of God in reality. The bulk of his argument is found in Chapter II of Proslogium.
Kants Morality Essay Research Paper Kant starts
Kant`s Morality Essay, Research Paper Kant starts off making two distinctions regarding kinds of knowledge, empirical/rational and formal/material. Empirical or experience-based knowledge
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Can Feelings Play A Role In Moral
Reasoning? Essay, Research Paper Can Feelings Play A Role In Moral Reasoning? The discussion of how feelings affect morality is quite prevalent in both David Hume and Immanuel Kant’s works. While each philosopher touches on the topic of feelings, both men differ in their outlook on the role feelings play in our moral lives.
What Objections Would A Deonteologist Have Essay
, Research Paper Whereas a teleological theory of ethics holds that an action is right, depending on the consequences; a deonteological theory states that an action is right, depending on the nature of the act itself, or of the intention of the person performing the act. Immanuel Kant, a deonteologist, once said, “It is man’s ability to reason, his own ability to think objectively and apart from his own circumstances and doings, that distinguishes him from all other creatures.” Reason is an innate intellectual power, existing more or less equally in everyone.
Kant Essay Research Paper KANTKant begins to
Kant Essay, Research Paper KANT Kant begins to claim that there is nothing in the world that can be regarded as good without qualification except good will. He says that qualities of temperment such as
Hegel Essay Research Paper Georg Wihelm Friedrich
Hegel Essay, Research Paper Georg Wihelm Friedrich Hegel 1770- 1831 German Idealist Hegel was born in Stuttgart on August 27, 1770, which is now part of Germany. Hegel was the son of a revenue officer with the civil service. He studied the Greek and Roman classics while attending the Stuttgart preparatory school.
Rationality Essay Research Paper Mark KlassJune 1
Rationality Essay, Research Paper Mark Klass June 1, 2000 I believe rationality is incorrectly dictated by society. Generally when one is irrational he or she is contradicting the “normal” or what everyone is programmed to do. Kant says “Can you also will that your maxim should become a universal law.”1 In part I agree to the theory of universal law where “rational” is judged by universality or what everyone should do.
Positivism Essay Research Paper Positivism is a
Positivism Essay, Research Paper Positivism is a system of philosophy based on experience and experimental knowledge of natural sensation, in which metaphysics and theology are regarded as inadequate and imperfect systems of knowledge. (www.eb) The 19th-century French mathematician and philosopher Auguste Comte first called the doctrine positivism, but some of the positivist concepts may be traced to the British philosopher David Hume, the French philosopher Duc de Saint-Simon, and the German philosopher Immanuel Kant.
Metaphysis Essay Research Paper Hello I
Metaphysis Essay, Research Paper : Hello: : I need help, I have somes question would help me. 1. do the criticisms that hume makes of Design Arguments all apply to Thomas’ Teleological Argument?
Summary Of Kant
’s Life Essay, Research Paper Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) spent all of his life in K?nigsberg, a small German town on the Baltic Sea in East Prussia. (After World War II,
Immanuel Kant
– Enlightenment Essay, Research Paper What is enlightenment? Immanuel Kant attempts to clarify the meaning of enlightenment while composing the essay, “What is Enlightenment?”. This document was written in response to political and social changes brought about by King Frederick of Prussia. The goal of Kant’s essay was to discuss what the nature of enlightenment was.
Hume Vs Kant Essay Research Paper Hume
Hume Vs. Kant Essay, Research Paper Hume vs. Kant On the Nature of Morality From the origin of Western philosophical thought, there has been an interest in moral laws. As Hume points out in the Treatise, "morality is a subject that interests us above all others" (David Hume "A Treatise of Human Nature’).
Kant And Mill Essay Research Paper Kant
Kant And Mill Essay, Research Paper Kant: Universal Law Formation of the Categorical Imperative Mill: Utilitarianism Immanuel Kant?s philosophy frames the Universal Law Formation of the Categorical Imperative as a procedure for determining morality of actions. This method contains two vital components.
A Book Report On Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysic Of Morals Essay, Research Paper Kant states (38,) “act as if the maxim of thy action were to become by thy will a universal law of nature”. This “categorical imperative” forms the basis of his book, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals. Though at times his writing is confusing Kant lays out his logic as to what a categorical imperative is.
American Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper American TranscendentalismTranscendentalism
American Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper American Transcendentalism Transcendentalism as espoused by Ralph Waldo Emerson is essen tially an idealist philosophy, derived from Kant’s concept of the Tran scendental and opposed to the skepticism of Locke and the Empiricists. In the essay The Transcendentalist, Emerson wrote, “[Kant showed] that there was a very important class of ideas or imperative forms, which do not come by experience, but through which experience was acquired; that these were intuitions of the mind itself; and he denominated them Tran scendental forms.”1 According to Emerson’s understanding of Kant, Transcendentalism becomes a union of solipsism, under which the only verifiable reality is thought to be the self, and materialism, under which the only verifiable reality is the quantifiable external world of objects and sense data.
Discuss The Positive And Negative Aspects Of
Kant?s Idea Of League Of Nations? Essay, Research Paper Along the years, we have witnessed in recent decades the ongoing globalization of world trade, followed by vast rates of investment, and witnessed a new interdependence of the global economic system. The income gap is growing at an unstoppable rate, both within countries and between developed and developing countries.
Immanuel Kant Essay Research Paper Meetesh Patel
Immanuel Kant Essay, Research Paper Meetesh Patel Philosophy Immanuel Kant Immanuel Kant is one of the most influential philosophers in the history of western philosophy. His contributions to metaphysics, epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics have had a profound impact on almost every philosophical movement that followed him.
Asses The Value Of Kant Essay Research
Paper The ethics of Immanuel Kant are based on the belief that ethics stem from rules and reason much like the law of gravity, they are universal and applied always regardless of circumstances. He believed that the capacity to reason was unique to man and when exercised this was what it meant to be a moral human being.
Immanuel Kant Vs Joshua Wegner Essay Research
Paper Joshua Wegner Philosophy 101 12/07/00 Trentacoste Immanuel Kant vs. Joshua Wegner THE RIGHT TO PUNISH: RETRIBUTIVISM As a society we all accept the fact that if you do something wrong you must be held responsible for your actions and pay the consequences. We all accept the concept of punishment, even though we are aware that we, ourselves, could one day be subjected to answer for our actions.
Kant Essay Research Paper 18th century German
Kant Essay, Research Paper 18th century German philosopher Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) presents a criterion of moral obligation, which he calls the categorical imperative. Kant s account of morality fits squarely into the deontological tradition and is found in three principal books: The Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals (1785), The Critique of Practical Reason (1788), and The Metaphysics of Morals (1798).
Kant Essay Research Paper Immanuel Kant 17241804
Kant Essay, Research Paper Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) had an interesting ethical system for reasoning. It is based on a belief that the reason is the final authority for morality. In Kant?s eyes reason is directly correlated with morals and ideals. Actions of any sort, he believed, must be undertaken from a sense of duty dictated by reason, and no action performed for appropriateness or solely in obedience to law or custom can be regarded as moral.
Mill And Kant Tell Us To Think
For Ourselves Essay, Research Paper Immanuel Kant simply stated the creed of the enlightenment: ?Dare to know,? (Kant 1). To thinkers like Kant, to achieve enlightenment was to ?gain release from?self-incurred tutelage?[the] inability to make use of [one?s] understanding without direction from another,? (Kant 1).
Transcendentalism Essay Research Paper Transcendentalism was an
Transcendentalism Essay, Research Paper Transcendentalism was an important movement in literature that occurred during the years of 1836-1860. Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau were the best-known transcendentalists. Ralph Waldo Emerson gave the German philosopher, Immanuel Kant, the credit for making ?Transcendentalism? a familiar term.
Kant S Ethics Essay Research Paper Kant
Kant S Ethics Essay, Research Paper Kant s Ethics In the Metaphysics of Ethics (1797) Kant described his ethical system, which is based on a belief that the reason is the final authority for morality. Actions of any sort, he believed, must be undertaken from a sense of duty dictated by reason, and no action performed for expediency
Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysics Of Moral Essay, Research Paper Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Moral The central concept of Kant’s Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of