’s Belief Of Preferential Treatment Essay, Research Paper
Dworkin’s Belief of Preferential Treatment
For many years, preferential treatment has been used to try to make up
for past wrong-doings to minorities. There have been many cases tried over
racial discrimination, with verdicts of both innocent and guilty. Ronald
Dworkin attempts to argue that preferential treatment is socially useful and at
the same time does not violate people’s rights. This is wrong for many reasons;
here I shall illustrate how preferential treatment hinders racial equality,
violates people’s rights, and can lead to a lower opinion toward a particular
race.
Dworkin believes that continuing preferential treatment will decrease
racial consciousness and the importance of race. This is the total opposite of
what truly happens. If a person were to consider America’s past, as an example,
he would see how racially diverse people were. Now look around. Just walking
across any given area, groups of people of the same race are seen walking
together. Most people do not notice this, but very rarely are groups of
ethnically diverse people seen. Although there are no longer any laws stating
that there must be a separation between different races, people still practice
it unconsciously. Dworkin states that the long-term goal of preferential
treatment “is to reduce the degree to which American society is overall a
racially conscious society (294).” Preferential treatment does nothing of the
sort. It was used widely in the past and still exists in some areas today. It
has not reduced racial consciousness, but increased it by making people think
more about how many spaces are reserved for their particular race. Instead,
people should think of what their chances are of getting something on account of
their personal knowledge over someone else’s, not even considering their race as
a factor. This is evident in a black’s point of view of getting into the
medical school of the University of California at Davis. Sixteen places are set
aside just for blacks and other minorities, no matter how low their test scores
are. That way, minorities don’t even have to worry about competing with whites
for a position. This does not, in any way, reduce racial consciousness by
setting two tracks for admission to medical school, one for the minorities, and
one for the majority.
Mr. Dworkin supports the idea that preferential treatment does not
violate people’s rights. His argument is weak here because he attempts to prove
this by saying that if two things do not violate people’s rights, then neither
does a third. The two things that supposedly do not violate rights are the
denial of someone to medical school because of their age and because their test
scores are just below the cutoff line of admission. He then assumes that
because these two do not violate rights, then neither does denying an applicant
because he will not reduce racial consciousness as much as an individual of
another race would. By taking this argument apart piece by piece, it is evident
that all three parts of his argument violate rights. Preferential treatment
violates a person’s right to be “judged on merit and merit alone(299).” Dworkin
says that another definition for merit is qualification, and for some jobs, race
can be a qualification. Given a specific job, certain human characteristics are
more desirable than others. People with these preferred characteristics are
more likely to get this job. For example, a desirable quality for a surgeon is
steady hands; therefore, a person with steady hands is more likely to get this
position than a person with shaky hands. Using race in a similar example,
preferential treatment would be just if there were a job where one race is more
qualified than another. The problem with this is that there are no such jobs.
Dworkin says that denying a person admission because of his age does not violate
that person’s rights, but then, is the individual being judged on his merit and
merit alone? No. It is therefore wrong to discriminate against someone
because of their age because it violates his rights.
A second objection to Dworkin’s belief that preferential treatment does
not violate people’s rights is that people have the right to be judged as an
individual. Preferential treatment supports grouping people together according
to race and then judging them as a whole. Dworkin agrees with Colvin when he
says that people have the right not to be disadvantaged because of one’s race
alone. Many colleges set cutoff limits to the applicants’ scores that they
admit. Some applicants that barely fall below the line have much more
dedication and enthusiasm than those above the line, and would make better
students by these attributes. Unfortunately, these students are not even
considered because they are not looked at as an individual, but judged solely by
their scores. Now imagine a situation similar to this where race is the
determinant of whether a person is accepted or not. If a person were to be
turned down from a college because of his skin color before he was given a
chance to be interviewed, the college may loose a very smart student. Skin
color should not be used to group people because within one skin color, many
different kinds of people can be grouped together. A possible alternative to
this approach is similar to it, but with one slight change?create a range around
the cutoff line where the students are considered on an individual basis. Those
inside this zone with admirable qualities are accepted and those without are
rejected.
The third objection that preferential treatment does not violate
people’s rights is that a person has the right not to be excluded, disadvantaged,
or denied some good because of race alone. In Bakki’s case, Dworkin agrees that
he would have been accepted had he been a minority, but says that he was not
disadvantaged because of his race. He says that Bakki would also have been
accepted had he gotten better test scores or had been younger, so his color is
not the only thing that kept him from being accepted. Here, Dworkin is
comparing apples and oranges. A person’s color is no determinant of whether he
should be suitable for a job, and neither should his age (although I will not
discuss this here). His knowledge is what is important. A doctor should not be
turned away because of his race or because he may be a few years older than
another, but he may very well be turned away because he is not performing his
job to the necessary degree because he lacks the needed knowledge. A person’s
color or age has nothing to do with his intelligence. This is yet another weak
argument given by Dworkin.
One more disadvantage to preferential treatment is how people feel when
they work with people who have been helped by preferential treatment. If a
black man were to apply to medical school and be accepted only because of his
skin color, what kind of business would he run if he were to make it out of
medical school for the same reasons? There would be a great disadvantage to
giving him a little extra leeway because of his race. During college, he might
not try as hard on his studies because he knows he will make it by and therefore
not gain all the necessary information to be a good doctor. Then, after he
graduates and works with other doctors, he may not only give his race a bad name
by not knowing what he should have learned in college, but he may also lose
patients from being misdiagnosed. It is clear that giving racial preferences
can lead to great problems in the future, and should therefore not be used.
Many people have explained both advantages and disadvantages to
preferential treatment since the racial injustice campaign began in 1954. One
of whom is Ronald Dworkin, who spoke on the side for preferential treatment. He
argued that while decreasing racial consciousness, it does not violate anyone’s
rights. When trying to prove his side, he uses examples that are
uncharacteristic to racial preferences such as race being a qualification for a
job. Although Dworkin argues his point well, he uses examples that just do not
back up his beliefs as well as they should and do not draw a distinct line of
why preferential treatment should be used.
35b
Другие работы по теме:
COnstruction Of Female Sexuality Essay Research Paper
“The construction of female sexuality and it is position in heterosexuality drawing upon recent feminist discussions” An area of great focus in contemporary feminist theory has been looking at the construction of female sexuality, particularly its
Do People Have Some Rights Just By
Being Human? Essay, Research Paper Do people have some rights just by being human? This question is concerned with whether or not it is possible for ‘natural rights’ to exist. ‘Natural’ rights are rights which we have ‘naturally’ as humans, in other words rights which we inherently have, just by being human.
MD-Assisted Suicide
& The Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Dr. K: Physician-Assisted Suicide & the Death Penalty Liana R. Prieto (November 1997) We are faced with a case involving two morally disputed issues that involve life and death. Questions will arise as to the morality of physician-assisted suicide, and though I will address them, they are essentially irrelevant in this case because it is presently illegal.
Is Censorship Justified Essay Research Paper Ever
Is Censorship Justified? Essay, Research Paper Ever wondered the reason behind racial discrimination, sexual discrimination, children committing crime or violence? The main reason is that censorship is not properly imposed or there is a need of censorship in the society. Censorship is the suppression of ideas and information that certain people, individual, groups or government officials find it objectionable, offensive or dangerous on others.
Letters From A War Zone Essay Research
Paper "Letters from a War Zone" deals with the controversy between men and women banning pornography. In this essay there are many strong personal views on pornography
The Distributive Justice Of The Market Essay
, Research Paper Sam Vaknin’s Psychology, Philosophy, Economics and Foreign Affairs Web Sites(1) Each person is to have an equal right to the most extensive total system of equal basic liberties compatible with a similar system of liberty for all.
Physicianassisted Suicide Essay Research Paper Introduction
Physician-assisted Suicide Essay, Research Paper Introduction The history of physician-assisted suicide began to emerge since the ancient time. Historians and ancient philosophers especially had been debating over this issue. Thus, this issue is no longer new to us. However, it seems little vague because it has not yet been fully told.
Porn Essay Research Paper Pornography otherwise defined
Porn Essay, Research Paper Pornography, otherwise defined as vulgarity and obscenity, is an issue that has and will continue to call upon much debate. While there are many people who see pornography as degrading, sinful, and disgusting, there is also a large amount of people who see it as a turn on, a form of sexual expression, and entertainment.
Affermative Action Essay Research Paper Affirmative ActionThe
Affermative Action Essay, Research Paper Affirmative Action The idea that different subcategories of humans exist, and that depending on one’s point of view, some subcategories are inherently inferior to others, has been around since ancient times. This concept eventually gained the label of “race” in 1789, a “zoological term generally defined as a subcategory of a species which inherits certain physical characteristics that distinguish it from other categories of that same species.” (Tivnan 181).
The Supreme Court And Government By The
People Essay, Research Paper Jason I. Explain the distinction between substance and process and the importance of the distinction for the issues discussed in this course.
1991 A Disasterous Year Essay Research Paper
circumstance across the country may not affect you personally, but it can affect your thoughts or views on a particular subject. No year is flawless, happy times and tragedies create a roller coaster in which the world has no choice but to ride out the twists and turns. But 1991 seemed to be a “plague” year, where the bad seemed to far outweigh the good in every possible way.
Abortion Essay Research Paper AbortionOf all of
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Abortion Of all of the issues being debated in the world today, perhaps the most controversial and intensely debated is abortion. This issue has forced its way into living rooms across the country through television, newspapers, and especially political campaigns. It has divided the community on many principles including people’s morals, ethnic background, and especially religious beliefs.
The War Of Freedom Of Expression Essay
, Research Paper The War of Freedom of Expression “Taking on anti-Semites and Holocaust deniers in the sanctified courtroom environment is like responding to someone who calls your mother
PornoA Essay Research Paper Term Paper for
Porno(A) Essay, Research Paper Term Paper for “Free Speech, Pornography and the RelationshipBetween Law and Morality”Suppose one accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin’s suggestedstatutory definition of pornography. How does one whogenerally accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin’s views on thepervasively harmful effect of pornography, and who accepts a needfor legal redress of the harms perpetrated by pornography, dealwith pornographic material? The ordinance proposed by MacKinnon and Dworkin would dealwith such material by enacting legislation which gives peopleadversely affected by the works, which clearly fit theirdefinition of pornography, a cause of action against theproducers, vendors, exhibitors or distributors for”trafficking”, or for an assault “directly caused by thespecific work.
Are We Ever Morally Justified In Disobeying
Laws We Consider To Be Immoral? Essay, Research Paper Are we ever morally justified in disobeying laws we consider to be immoral? The answer to this question depends very much on our understanding and opinion on the status of the law. On this issue it is likely that everyone falls into one of two broad categories.
To The Lighthouse And Lady Oracle
– Gender: Society?s Restraint Essay, Research Paper Time and time again gender-conflict is brought to the attention of the public in various forms. In our time someone who wants to make a point about gender-conflict and the inequality that is present will be more likely to use television or song to reach their audience.
Griswold V Connecticut Essay Research Paper On
Griswold V. Connecticut Essay, Research Paper On June 7th 1965, married couples in the State of Connecticut received the right to acquire and benefit from contraceptive devises. In a majority decision by the United States Supreme Court, seven out of the nine judges believed that sections 53-32 and 54-196 of the General Statues of Connecticut , violated the right of privacy guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Kenneth Cauthen Copyright
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Kenneth Cauthen Copyright ? 1999. All rights reserved. frontiernet/~kenc/pros.htm If Ann Landers is for legalizing prostitution, then how far out can the notion be? (1) In 1949, the United Nations adopted a resolution in favor of the decriminalization of prostitution, which has been ratified by fifty countries but not by the United States.
The Effects Of Pornography Essay Research Paper
The Effects of Pornography More and more Internet sites are portraying pornography. Playboy gets about 5 million hits , or visitors daily. More than 266 new pornography sites are created every day. With the help of technology pornography has become more and more accessible regardless of the age of the viewers.
Larry Flint Essay Research Paper Larry FlyntInfamous
Larry Flint Essay, Research Paper Larry Flynt Infamous pornographer and free-speech activist Larry Flynt has brought about controversy for nearly 30 years. As the editor of Hustler magazine, Flynt has publicized pornographic obscenities in several manors. By doing this, he has challenged America?s interpretation of the First Amendment, insisted that freedom of speech include obscenities and pornography, and made the anti-porn activists and feminists fight for constitutional protection from obscenity.
NonConsensual Speech Lying Essay Research Paper Lies
Non-Consensual Speech: Lying Essay, Research Paper Lies injure those who believe them. If a lie is about a person, and the lie is believed and acted upon, the person lied about is also injured. Thus lying involves at least one non-consenting party. By lying, of course, I do not mean fiction. Reasonable people (becoming scarcer all the time) know that fiction is not literally true.
Porno Essay Research Paper Suppose one accepts
Porno Essay, Research Paper Suppose one accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin’s suggested statutory definition of pornography. How does one who generally accepts MacKinnon and Dworkin’s views on the
Liberty And Paternalism Essay Research Paper LIBERTY
Liberty And Paternalism Essay, Research Paper LIBERTY AND PATERNALISM John Stuart Mill and Gerald Dworkin have distinctly opposing views on legal paternalism in that Mill is adamantly against any form of paternalism, whereas Dworkin believes that there do exist circumstances in which paternalism is justified.
Devlin Dworkin And Mill Essay Research Paper
In this essay, I will discuss the beliefs of J.S. Mill, Patrick Devlin and Ronald Dworkin. These three men hold different, yet similar positions on freedom of speech, privacy and society. First, I will illustrate how Dworkin s idea of a free society includes more details than Devlin s. Also, how Dworkin s moral reasoning is an important aspect of freedom.
Moral Position Essay Research Paper What
Moral Position Essay, Research Paper . What is a moral position according to Mr. Dworkin? Dworkin’s moral position is reasons, foundation theory and self-evident. Moral position has to give good (articulate) reasons for moral position to be valid. Things like prejudices and emotions are not justifiable characteristics for a moral position.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Euthanasia formerly know
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia, formerly know as ?mercy killing,? means intentionally making someone die, rather than allowing them to die naturally. In an online article by the International Anti-Euthanasia Task Force says that euthanasia means killing in the name of compassion. Euthanasia is one of the most important public policy issues being debated today.
A Discussion Of Feminism And Lesbianism Essay
, Research Paper During the 1970s and 1980s, much lesbian theory turned towards the questione most influential, and also controversial writers was Adrienne Rich, whose work of a lesbian history, and why it has been covered up for all this time. They began to consider that women’s subordination under men, and the necessity for men to preserve the institution of heterosexuality by whatever means available (this ranges from marriage and romantic literature to domestic violence and rape), was where the answer to this question lay.
Pornography And Violence Essay Research Paper Pornography
Pornography And Violence Essay, Research Paper Pornography and Violence In today s society women are viewed very often as objects of sexual pleasure. This view has been around for many years and because of it many groups have popped up throughout the past fifty years. Does pornography lead men to commit violent acts towards women or is something that we will never find the cause for? In order to try and help ourselves, we must try to find out if it is true or not or if we just don t like it because it may make us uncomfortable.
Feminist Backlash Essay Research Paper Feminist Backlash
Feminist Backlash Essay, Research Paper Feminist Backlash: The Unconscious Undermining of Genuine Equality American people come in a variety of shapes and sizes; their thoughts, fears, and convictions differ widely. It is usually necessary for Americans to choose a status in politics and community; but it is obvious that among specific groups and organizations, a person?s beliefs and opinions differ dramatically from the next.
Cinderella
– Grimm Version Vs. Traditional French Version Essay, Research Paper Cinderella Comparison: Grimm version vs. Traditional French version I feel that these two stories very nicely represent Allison Lurie’s views of fairy tales. I feel this way because Lurie stated that fairy tales are “stories of magic and transformation”.
The Ethics Of Euthanasia. (Arguments
Against Euthanasia) Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia nowadays, constitutes a moral issue that from time to time comes into view mainly from its supporters who, contrarily to more traditional opinions, believe that the man is the master of his life and that nobody else can force him to stay alive, especially when his life has become unbearable from the illness and the pain.
Is Law An Autonomous Discipline Essay Research
Paper The autonomy of law and in particular the alleged separateness of law and politics has been the subject of debate since time immemorial. Many legal theorists have made the assertion that law is autonomous and is different from politics; many others have gone as far as to call the supposed separation of law and politics a mere myth.