Paper
11. Evaluate the pros and cons of rent control and rent stabilization in NYC.
Rent control is the government imposition of price ceilings on rent for apartments in certain areas of a city. The goal is usually to protect the rights of the poor. Thus, in a rent controlled or rent stabilized building, the amount of rent will not increase as quickly as inflation. While the moral side of rent control may have some appeal, in the long run the disadvantages far outweigh the advantages.
Those who argue in favor of rent control say that it is the only way to protect lower-income tenants from landlords who overprice, and from being forced to move out of a neighborhood because they cannot afford the rent. Limiting the price that a landlord can demand helps maintain a city?s ethnic diversity and prevents the creation of slums on the outskirts of the main city. Another thing that proponents say is that by linking rent prices to apartment maintenance and material improvements, rent control actually improves the state of housing. Overall, they argue that the goals of rent control can be reached if they are administered in a careful and just way.
The opponents, though, have both theoretical and practical experience on their side. First, rent control creates a market that is unfair for everyone. Since the rent is set at a lower than normal level, an unsatisfied demand is created. This increase in demand leads to an increase in the cost of rents in the uncontrolled sector. Thus, two types of rents are created: those that are unfairly cheap, and those that are unfairly expensive.
Another problem that is created is that landlords who own rent controlled apartments are often not able to earn enough money to adequately maintain buildings. This leads to run-down, poor quality housing. In many cases, landlords lose so much money that they are not able to even pay the debt on the properties, and they abandon them. Both of these effects have been documented in New York and elsewhere, and go against the goals of rent control.
Finally, rent control has the bad side effect of turning away new construction. This is because even if rent controls don?t include new constructions, owners are afraid to build any new buildings if in a few years those too will be taken over by rent control. Rent control thus leads to less construction and an even greater unsatisfied demand. This, in turn, increases the rents of uncontrolled apartments even more. New constructions are also avoided because banks and insurance companies don?t want to invest in areas where rent control is in effect, because they know that it is likely that landlords will not be able to pay for the building, and they will lose their investment.
For all of these reasons, I believe that rent control should be abandoned in New York City. The situation we have is of many run-down buildings that are rent controlled, and other areas where rent is so expensive that no one from the middle class can afford to live in them. On top of all this, in New York, many people rent out their rent controlled apartments for a profit ? a practice which is opposite to the initial spirit of rent control legislation. Without rent control, the housing situation in New York would be more equitable for everyone, and the city would benefit.
3. Critically evaluate the issues in the people versus places controversy.
The people versus places controversy is concerned with two basic philosophies of distributing benefits with the goal of improving living standards and local economic development. In basic terms, the “people” approach tends to emphasize assistance to individuals, giving them tax breaks, financial help, job training, and migration (to areas of better employment) assistance. The “places” approach focuses on improving the quality of a place, in the hope that the people who live there will benefit from the change. In my opinion, both of the approaches have drawbacks, and a mixture of the two is the best way to solve the problems of local economic development.
The people approach, based on making individuals more prosperous, is based on the rationale that only people matter. Those who support it argue that if you improve the lives of people, it doesn?t matter where they live. Thus, they would argue for job training programs and not for strategies that would try to bring factories into a certain city.
One of the main negative effects of the people centered approach is that it encourages migration. This is a disadvantage in the big picture for three reasons. First, migration away from problem areas of the most qualified only worsens the situation of those areas. If a city spends money on training people to become more efficient and better skilled workers, and those people then move on to find better job opportunities, then that city hasn?t succeeded in its primary goal: to improve the quality of life in its borders. In the end, the skill level of the local population doesn?t improve, in fact, it may decrease.
Another disadvantage of migration is the fact that it leads to the disintegration of families and communities. When it becomes easy for people to move from one place to another, then the bonds which strengthen communities fall apart, and the nation as a whole loses a valuable asset. Finally, politicians, who rely on the support of their constituents to be elected, are not likely to support people centered approaches because of migration. There is no reason why they would want to spend tax money on training people when they cannot be sure that those same people won?t leave the community and enrich another city with their new skills.
Place centered approaches also have drawbacks. First, much of the benefits go to the non-poor. This is because the subsidies for industry or other incentives for growth and improvement are given to those who already have money. These are the people with enough capital to make a difference in the quality of a place. While the place centered approach does not foster migration, and therefore it has the support of politicians, it still is not very popular. Another problem is the fact that place centered programs often do not help the areas that are in the most need of help. This is because the aid from these programs goes to the places with the most potential, not the most need. Finally, a problem with place strategies is that they do not let the market function freely, and therefore many economists would argue that efficiency on a national level is reduced. This would defeat the goal of the program in the big picture.
Overall, both the people and place approaches have advantages and disadvantages. In choosing which one is best, it is wise to look at the particular needs of each community, and develop a mixture of the two solutions. For example, in an area that is very poor, where it is unlikely that business will invest, even with subsidies, then a people approach may be the only way to improve the local economic situation. On the other hand, in an area that shows some promise, and which could improve with the arrival of more jobs, the place approach may be best suited. In any case, it is impossible to say that one or the other is better in all instances; and it is essential to remember that neither of them can offer a perfect solution to the age-old problem of improving a community?s economic health.
Другие работы по теме:
Gun UnControl Essay Research Paper Gun Control
Gun Un-Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Control 1st affirmative speech Anyone who thinks that we have enough gun control laws is either NRA, or severly mistguided. And since I’m probably going to end up getting brushed off in the long run anyway, I’ll get my teams two cents in. There is really no place to begin, so I’ll dive on in head first.
Lord Durham Letter Essay Research Paper Dear
Lord Durham, Letter Essay, Research Paper Dear The York Sun, Hi my name is Andrew Archerbald. I am a thirty five year old banker and have been doing my job for ten years. I am married
Child Abuse 6 Essay Research Paper Child
Child Abuse 6 Essay, Research Paper Child Abuse Every day another innoncent American youth is abused by a mother, father, or abusive relative. The figures themselves are startling and can in no way be compromised with any reasoning for them. It seems that Americas parents are amoungst the least qualified to be having chilredn than anyone else in the entire world.
MY 16TH BDAY Essay Research Paper A
MY 16TH B-DAY Essay, Research Paper A good experience with my friends came on my sixteenth birthday. Earlier in the week, I had decided that I would rent a limousine and go into Boston with some of my friends. The day which we would go was my birthday. The day had finally come and we were all anxious to go. Before the limo came, five of my friends: Nick, John, Luke, Eric and Jay met at my house.
Renting A House Essay Research Paper Communicating
Renting A House Essay, Research Paper Communicating with people from other countries often makes me bother, and it happens when I am totally not expected about. This is not the first visit to the other country, but talking non-native language in non-native country is quite different from the long time study in my country.
Seregas Essay Essay Research Paper The life
Seregas Essay Essay, Research Paper The life stories of many today s New Yorkers are amazingly similar and different at the same time. For those of us who can call New York our new home, the choice to move to this city has certainly been one of the most important decisions of our lives. Whether or not we came from fifty or five thousand miles away, the hopes for success and brighter future were the sources of our motivation.
The Waterworks Essay Research Paper The WaterworksOver
The Waterworks Essay, Research Paper The WaterworksOver the course of the novel, The Waterworks, by E.L. Doctorow, Doctorow uses various comparisons. Both with the charachters and plot, Doctorow uses parallelism to give the reader a deeper sence of the corruption and its eventual downfall, during the post-civil war times in New York.
Housing Aid Essay Research Paper Interests are
Housing Aid Essay, Research Paper Interests are rising in Orange County on the issue of state and federal housing agencies. There is a big demand for Section 8 housing. There has been discussion of possible plans for housing aid to go to those who qualify.
Rent Essay Research Paper 1
Rent Essay, Research Paper 1. I spent my freshman year of college at Boston University. I lived in one of the dormitories the first semester. However, for the second semester two of my friends and I decided to live in an apartment. We began searching for an apartment near the campus and discovered many realities of apartment hunting.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Are you
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Are you ready to die? What?s more, are you ready to kill? When you hold a gun anywhere but the firing range you?d better be ready and able to use it or die. Don?t get me wrong; just because you carry a gun doesn?t mean people automatically start being violent towards you but if you get in a fight and someone realizes you have a gun it?s more than likely that they will pull one and shoot you if they have it.
Benificial Insects Essay Research Paper Beneficial Insects
Benificial Insects Essay, Research Paper Beneficial Insects Insects have been roaming the earth for millions of years. They have adapted to every climate and terrain on earth. No matter what we do they will always be amongst us. This is not necessarily a bad thing; insects are actually beneficial to us. Insects help pollinate our crops each year.
To Rent Or Not To Rent Essay
, Research Paper Renting a home to live in, rather than buying a home to live in is a much wiser decision. When renting a home you are able to have free maintenance, partially included utilities and the freedom to pack up and move at anytime you wish.
Mali Essay Research Paper Developing a CountryThe
Mali Essay, Research Paper Developing a Country The country of Mali is considered an under developed country. Our group had to think of a proposal that would help a town in Mali stay well off on their own. The
Pesticides Essay Research Paper Give an account
Pesticides Essay, Research Paper Give an account of the ways in which biological control can be used to control pest numbers. The effect of predator-prey relationship in regulating populations has been exploited by humans as a method of controlling various pests. Biological pest control is where the natural predators (agent) of the pest ((target) are used to reduce its population to a tolerable level.
Jeruselem Essay Research Paper Ariel David What
Jeruselem Essay, Research Paper Ariel, David. What do Jews Beleive. New york: Schocken Books, 1995. 8 Dec. 2000 . World history. D, G -. Torah. Egypt: G-D, 1515. 1 Jan. 1000 . The holy book.
Property Management Essay Research Paper In the
Property Management Essay, Research Paper In the past few years’ people have been saying that Oakland is going down the drain. Its true Oakland has gone from a peace full community to a society that strives on hate and drugs. I feel that if Oakland had professional Property management then it would no longer have the current problems of ghettos.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Topic
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Topic: Gun regulation 1. Do you believe firearms should be banned all together including police and military? 2. Do you believe firearms should be banned from civilians only?
Gun Control 2 Essay Research Paper We
Gun Control 2 Essay, Research Paper We the students of class 7-508 do not agree with the statement that people should carry weapons. We do not agree with this statement
Weed Essay Research Paper The Marijuana Reform
Weed Essay, Research Paper The Marijuana Reform Party believes: That adults who choose to use marijuana in the privacy of their own homes should not be subject to civil or criminal sanctions.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Everyone in
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Everyone in the United States of America has an opinion on gun control regardless of their age, race, or religion. From within those opinions arguments are formed. People are arguing about gun control at their jobs, at their schools, and sometimes at their places of worship.
Canadian Film Industry Essay Research Paper ConclusionWe
Canadian Film Industry Essay, Research Paper Conclusion: We as Canadians watch movies on a weekly basis. On average, most people rent videos or attend the local movie theatre to attend and view the latest film. However, Canadians are not aware that they have become desensitized to the global Americanization of the U.S. film industry, which has been turned strong by Hollywood.
Rent Control Essay Research Paper In theory
Rent Control Essay, Research Paper In theory rent control sounds like a perfect way to help the poor by setting the price ceilings on the rent, but in reality it only will hurt them. In the real world rent controls do not work like most people would expect them to, maybe its because not many people had their lesson in economics.
Kyle Swanson Essay Research Paper English 99
Kyle Swanson Essay, Research Paper English 99 1/1/99 New York I know of a interesting place where people flock to in hope of success. I on the other hand have been to this place twice as a tourist. People call
Romance And Love Essay Research Paper Romance
Romance And Love Essay, Research Paper Romance and LoveWhen I was assigned this topic to write about, I immediately thought of Eros. The ancient Greek word that describes the romantic side of love. Philos andAgape are really more spiritual in nature, but Eros, now that’s a physical love.I envision Eros as the sweaty fumbling in the back of old Chevrolets, and thefirelit evenings where everything seems to go just right and the sex is perfect,And even in the dark, rent by the hour hotel rooms where men and womenwith no names briefly join and then quickly part, never knowing the otherpersons name.
Romance Essay Research Paper Romance and Love
Romance Essay, Research Paper Romance and Love; an essay When I was assigned this topic to write about, I immediately thought of Eros. The ancient Greek word that describes the romantic side of love. Philos and Agape are really more spiritual in nature, but Eros, now that’s a physical love. I envision Eros as the sweaty fumbling in the back of old Chevrolets, and the firelit evenings where everything seems to go just right and the sex is perfect, And even in the dark, rent by the hour hotel rooms where men and women with no names briefly join and then quickly part, never knowing the other persons name.
Homeless Essay Essay Research Paper Homeless EssayOne
Homeless Essay Essay, Research Paper Homeless Essay One of Mayor Guiliani s promises early in his candidacy was to reduce the homeless population in New York City. He has not achieved his goal. There are 90,000 people in New York City living on the streets. The number is growing more rapidly. In order to reduce this number, the causes of homelessness must be examined.
Braveheart Essay Research Paper Braveheart The movie
Braveheart Essay, Research Paper Braveheart The movie Braveheart is based on the control of England over Scotland. England in that time was ruled by Longshanks who made it a very powerful country because the government very rich. The English would go around and kill harmless Scots and by mistake they killed William Wallace’s girlfriend.
Civil War Espionage Essay Research Paper Espionage
Civil War Espionage Essay, Research Paper Espionage, the practice of spying, held a major part in the victory of the Union and the defeat of the Confederates. Men and women spies became widely known for their spying. The plot to burn New York became a major event in the loss of the Confederates. And Civil War ciphers became the form of transferring messages between spies and officers.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.