Flag Burning Essay, Research Paper
Flag Burning can be and usually is a very controversial issue. Many people are offended by the thought of destroying this country’s symbol of liberty and freedom. During a political protest during the 1984 Republican Convention, Gregory Lee Johnson was arrested for burning an American flag. Years later in 1989, Johnson got the decision overturned by the United States Supreme Court. In the same year, the state of Texas passed the Flag Protection Act, which prohibited any form of desecration against the American flag. This act provoked many people to protest and burn flags anyway. Two protestors, Shawn Eichman and Mark Haggerty were charged with violating the law and arrested. Both Eichman and Haggerty appealed the decision because the law was inconsistent with the first amendment to the Constitution. The right to petition the government for a redress of grievances is protected by the first amendment of the Constitution. Burning American flags and other such actions are not treasonous and should no be treated as so, as long as these actions are done to petition the government for a redress of grievances.
The dissenting opinion to the previous idea is that the government’s legitimate interest in preserving the symbolic value of the flag is, however, essentially the same that may have motivated a particular act of flag burning. The flag uniquely symbolizes the ideas of liberty, equality, and tolerance – ideas that Americans have passionately defended and debated throughout our history. The flag embodies the spirit of our national commitment to those ideals. To the world, the flag is our promise that we will continue to strive for these ideals. To us, the flag is a reminder both that the struggle for liberty and equality is unceasing, and that our obligation of tolerance and respect for all of our fellow citizens encompasses those who disagree with us – indeed, even those whose ideas are disagreeable or offensive.
While the Republican National Convention was taking place in Dallas in 1984, respondent Johnson participated in a political protest. The purpose of this event was to protest the policies of the Reagan administration and of certain Dallas-based corporations. The demonstrators marched through the Dallas streets, chanting political slogans and stopping at several corporate locations to dramatize the consequences of nuclear war. On several occasions they spray-painted the walls of buildings and overturned potted plants, but Johnson himself took no part in such activities. He did, however, accept an American flag handed to him by a fellow protestor. The demonstration ended in front of Dallas City Hall, where Johnson unfolded the American flag, drenched it with kerosene, and set it on fire. While the flag burned, the protestors chanted. No one was physically injured or threatened with injury, though several witnesses had said that they had been seriously offended by the flag burning.
Of all of the demonstrators, Johnson was the only person charged with a crime. The only criminal offense with which he was charged was the desecration of a venerated object. After a trial, he was convicted, sentenced to one year in prison, and fined $2,000. The Court of Appeals for the Fifth District of Texas at Dallas affirmed Johnson’s conviction, but the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals reversed the decision holding that the State could not punish Johnson for burning the flag in these circumstances in order to remain consistent with the First Amendment. This case went to the United States Supreme Court, in which the decision was made that punishing Johnson for burning the flag was unconstitutional.
The Flag Protection Act, which was passed in 1989 basically states:
A. 1. Whomever knowingly mutilates, defaces, physically defiles, burns, maintains on the for or ground, or tramples upon any flag of the United States shall be fined under this title or imprisoned for not more than one year, or both.
A. 2. This subsection does not prohibit any conduct consisting of the disposal of a flag when it has become worn or spoiled.
B. As used in this section, the term “flag of the United States” means any flag of the United States or any part thereof, made of any substance, of any size, in a form that is commonly displayed.
C. Nothing in this section shall be construed as indicating intent on the part of Congress to deprive any State, territory, possession, or the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico of jurisdiction of any offense over which it would have jurisdiction in the absence of this section.
D. 1. An appeal may be taken directly to the Supreme Court of the United States form any interlocutory or final judgment, decree, or order issued by a United States district court ruling upon the constitutionality of subsection (a).
D. 2. The Supreme Court shall, if it has not previously ruled on the question, accept jurisdiction over the appeal and advance on the docket and expedite to the greatest extent possible.
The Supreme Court cases of the United States v. Eichman and the United States v. Haggerty dealt with this bill. Both Haggerty and Eichman protested the passing of the act because they thought that it violated their freedom of symbolic speech. Only a year after this bill was passed, the United States Supreme Court said that the Flag Protection Act of 1989 was unconstitutional and therefore, rarely enforced.
Protesters have burned the American flag to express outrage at a political idea such as war, or even to challenge any objections to the burning of flags. Such behavior has outraged many Americans who feel that the flag is a symbol of the United States that should be protected from harm, and that burning flags should not be protected under the First Amendment. In a number of cases that came to the Federal district court, the courts dismissed the charges under the belief that the Act violated the free speech clause of the First Amendment. The government appealed the United States v. Eichman case to the Supreme Court in 1990.
The guiding principles for the Supreme Court are found in the Bill of Rights, which comprise the first ten amendments to the Constitution. The First Amendment outlines personal liberties in the freedoms of religion, speech, press, assembly and the right to petition the government or the redress of grievances. Since the Bill of Rights was adopted, conflicts over what types of speech or expression are protected by the Constitution have led the Supreme Court to provide some additional clarification. The definition of speech has not come to include only spoken words, but also symbolic speech as well as the two forms of speech together. This definition sometimes requires citizens to tolerate unpopular speech for the sake of preserving the spirit of the freedom itself.
The symbolic value of the American flag is not the same today as it was yesterday. Events during the last three decades have altered the country’s image in the eyes of numerous Americans, and some now have difficulty understanding the message that the flag conveyed to their parents and grandparents – whether they be native or from abroad. Also, the integrity of the symbol has been compromised by those leaders who seem to advocate compulsory worship of the flag even by individuals whom it offends, or who seem to manipulate the symbol of national purpose into a pretext for partisan disputes about meaner ends. United States Supreme Court Justice Brennan said that “Punishing desecration of the flag dilutes the very freedom that makes this emblem so revered, and worth revering.”
Burning the American Flag September 13. “www-c.pbs/jefferson/enlight/flag.htm.”
Texas v. Johnson September 13. “www2.law.cornell.edu/cgi-bin/foliocgi.exe/historic/query=[group+491+u!2Es!2E+397!3A]^[group+citemenu!3A]^[level+case+citation!3A]^[group+notes!3A]/doc/{@1}/hit_headings/words=4/hits_only?.”
United States v. Eichman September 13. “caselaw.findlaw/scripts/getcase.pl?navby=search&linkurl=&graphurl=&court=US&case=/us/496/310.html.”
Welch, Michael Flag Burning: Moral Panic and the Criminalization of Protest (Social Problems and Social Issues).
Goldstein, Robert Justin Burning the Flag: The Great 1989-1990 American Flag Desecration Controversy Asylum Books.
Другие работы по теме:
The Union Jack
The flag of the UK is officially called the Union flag, because it embodies the emblems of three countries united under one monarch. The Union Flag is commonly known as the Union Jack, although the exact origin of the name is unclear.
Racism In Flags Essay Research Paper Racism
Racism In Flags Essay, Research Paper Racism can be represented in many forms. Flags are on of them. Flags can be used torepresent something. Many flags mean different things such as freedom, democracy and respectfor something such as a country. However, some flags can been seen as something bad orsomething that they disprove of, but to another person it can be something they believe in.
Burn The Flag Essay Research Paper
Our right to protest can be conducted in many methods. By speech, by petition, by billboards, by sending letters, by holding up signs and walking around in circles, by televising concerns, by going on
Poems Essay Research Paper SnowAs the soft
Poems Essay, Research Paper Snow As the soft snow covers the earth like a blanket A supreme calmness comes over me Though the weather is cold i feel it not For the warmth of my heart is burning like a furnace
Freedom Of Religion Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom Of Religion Essay, Research Paper Freedom of Religion gives one the right to practice their religion without it being sanctioned by the state. Children should not be forced to salute the flag. The First
Barn Burning Essay Research Paper In the
Barn Burning Essay, Research Paper In the story ?Barn Burning? one question that sticks out to me is at what point should a person make a choice between what his parents and/ or family believes and his own values. In this story Colonel Sartoris is faced with the decision of either going along with the views and actions of his father or making the decision of running away and leaving his family behind.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper In William
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper In William Faulkner’s Nobel Prize Acceptance Speech, he says, “He writes not of love but of lust, of defeats in which nobody loses anything of value, and victories without hope and worst of all, without pity or compassion.” William Faulkner is referring to “He” as the typical writer today.
Confederate Flag In South Carolina Essay Research
Paper The Confederate flag that now flies atop the statehouse of South Carolina has been a controversial issue for over 30 years. Raised in 1962 to commemorate the Civil War?s 100th anniversary, it is the only Confederate flag to wave atop any state capitol in the country, and its presence has stirred quite a commotion.
Confederate Flag Essay Research Paper Living in
Confederate Flag Essay, Research Paper Living in this diversified country, the one thing that everyone has in common is the fact that we all live under the American Flag. It symbolizes that this is the land of the free and represents a part of this country s history just as the Confederate Flag does. In 1962, the Confederate Flag was raised at the Statehouse in South Carolina to commemorate the Civil War s centennial.
American Flag Essay Research Paper Betsy Ross
American Flag Essay, Research Paper Betsy Ross lived from 1752 to 1836. She was born to Elizabeth Griscom in Philadelphia. In 1773 she ran away with John Ross to get married. But her
Racism Still Burning In America Essay Research
Paper Racism: Still Burning in America Racism. This topic has been and will continue to be the controversial topic of every generation. Why? The answer is very clear. Racism is very much alive and is felt all over America. We, as a nation, continue to search for constructive ways to challenge racism and some even have the hope that someday all races will be able to experience the true freedom this country claims to have.
Flagburning Essay Research Paper IS FLAG BURNING
Flagburning Essay, Research Paper IS FLAG BURNING PROTECTED BY THE FIRST AMENDMENT? 2/17/00 “If a jerk burns a flag, America is not threatened. If a jerk burns a flag, democracy is not under siege. If a jerk burns a flag, freedom is not at risk and we are not threatened. My colleagues, we are offended; and to change our Constitution because someone offends us is, in itself, unconscionable,”
September 11 Essay Research Paper Todays military
September 11 Essay, Research Paper Today?s military has seen numerous changes that have taken place since Sept. 11 2001. Why is it before the 11th of September, the people that the military protects was basically badmouthing and putting us down? Why are they so proud to wave the American flag? Why wasn?t the flag flown high with pride before the 11th of September? It amazes the military because flags are often flown when terrorist?s acts take place and not when there is constitutional freedom.
The Sound And The Fury By William
Faulkner 1929 Essay, Research Paper “They took the flag out, and they were hitting. Then they put the flag back and they went to the table, and he hit and the other hit. Then they went on, and I went along
Battle Royal Symbolism Essay Research Paper In
Battle Royal Symbolism Essay, Research Paper In the story “Battle Royal” by Ralph Ellison, he uses a white, naked, exotic dancer as a big symbol in the story. Tattooed on the girl that the narrator is directing his attention to is an American Flag. The symbol of the American flag on the naked blonde girl relates to the many themes of the story such as the struggle for equality.
An Argument Against Burning The American Flag
Essay, Research Paper Having been called a bleeding heart leberal several times in my life, this is one issure that you could not accuse me of being wishy-washy about. The needs to be a constitutional amendment outlawing he burning of the Flag of the United States of America. In my mind, this is no debating this issue.
Flag Desecration Essay Research Paper Flag Desecration
Flag Desecration Essay, Research Paper Flag Desecration Flag desecration is not American. People who burn the American flag lack respect for themselves, America, and the many people who have died to preserve American freedom. The people who desecrate the American flag have no right to call themselves Americans.
American Flag Speech Essay Research Paper First
American Flag Speech Essay, Research Paper First I would like to include some information about our american flag and how it came about. In the British colonies of North America before the Revolution, each of the 13 colonies had its flag. On Jan. 2, 1776, the first flag of the United States was raised at Cambridge, Mass., by George Washington.
Puritans Essay Research Paper Why Puritans Came
Puritans Essay, Research Paper Why Puritans Came to America: Freedom When the English came to America to escape religious persecution, things commenced at a shaky start. For example, Puritans fled from England
Ban Flag Burning Ban Everything Essay Research
Paper Ban Flag Burning, Ban Everything? Citizens’ right to flag burning should not be deprived, as there is nothing illegitimate in principle about doing so for the purpose of demonstrating one’s dissent from government laws or practices. This is their fundamental right of doing everything they please, as long as it does not infringe on the rights of others.
Flag Burning Unconstitutional Essay Research Paper Flag
Flag Burning Unconstitutional Essay, Research Paper Flag burning is absolutely not a valid form of political expression under the first amendment. Though the Supreme Court, in the case of Gregory Johnson, ruled that it was in fact constitutional to allow people to burn the flag, the evidence against this ruling is overwhelming.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay The movie Sand Pebbles focus was on the flag. The flag was not only a symbol of a nation, but of nationalism, militarism and imperialism. During the 1800’s and early 1900’s there was a severe foreign influence in China. During this time period the European nations wanted to trade with the Chinese, but the Chinese had no interest in the European products for at the time China was self sufficient.
The American Flag And Its Growing Controversy
Essay, Research Paper The American Flag and its Growing Controversy Step 1: Details The American flag, to many, is the symbol of life and liberty. Freedom from oppression and the ability to run one’s own life with minimal government intervention is what our country fought for all those years ago. The day after the SpanishAmerican War was declared, schools mandated the worship of the flag (Kaminer).
Why Do People Want To Destroy Images
? Essay, Research Paper Religion Puritanism 16th and 17th centuries ? dispute over terms of the Settlement which banned artificial worship but did not specify decoration such as church windows and crosses in
The Red Badge Of Courage By Stephen
Crane Essay, Research Paper The red badge – The red badge, a blood stain, was a symbol of courage for other soldiers, however, for Henry, it becomes a sign of cowardice since he received his from a fight with
Burning The Flag Essay Research Paper The
Burning The Flag Essay, Research Paper The American flag is a piece of cloth that represents the United States of America. The burning of our flag has caused many controversies. Some citizens believe that
What Does The American Flag Mean To
Me? Essay, Research Paper What Does the American Flag Mean to Me? Freedom. Justice. History. The flag of the United States has a different meaning to it for every person. Whether it?s just standing up in class everyday
Us Flag A Symbol Worth Protection Essay
, Research Paper The Flag of the United States of America: A Symbol that Requires Protection Most people have at one point in their lives looked up at the American flag waving in the breeze on a light, clear day and thought about how lucky they are to live in the country that lies beneath that flag. And when you see those “broad stripes and bright stars” waving on the bow of one of our countries noble naval ships, you can?t help but feel proud of all those who have come before you and given their lives so that our lives might be better.
The Bad Flag Essay Research Paper Some
The Bad Flag Essay, Research Paper Some people think the confederate flag is a symbol of hatred and slavery. Others think it represents the history of America. It’s up to ever person to decide where they stand. The old saying is, “If you don’t stand for something, you’ll fall for anything.” Ever person has a duty to respect the other person’s opinion.
Untitled Essay Research Paper CANADA Did
Untitled Essay, Research Paper CANADA Did you ever stop and wonder how much we take the place we live for granted? If you were to take the time, you would discover how diverse are Canada’s history, geography, climate, economy, cultures and government. Did you know it is the largest country in the world now that U.S.S.R broke up.
History Of The Mexican Flag Essay Research
Paper History of the Mexican Flag The Mexican Flag has a rich and colorful history. Before the Spanish came, the Aztecan flag had snakes and panthers pictured on it. Following the conquest, a flag resembling that of Castille was adopted, and on August 13, 1530, the first flag parade was ordered by the Government of Don Alonso de Estrada to commemorate the fall of Tenochtitlan nine years before.
Barn Burning Essay Research Paper Use of
Barn Burning Essay, Research Paper Use of Blood in Barn Burning Barn Burning is about the struggle of a boy to do what is right during the Post Civil War era. The main character, Sartoris Snopes, is a poor son of a migrant tenant farmer. In the opening scene he is being asked by a circuit judge about the burning of a farmer s barn by his father.
Flag Burning Editorial Essay Research Paper Flag
Flag Burning Editorial Essay, Research Paper Flag burning can be and usually is a very controversial issue with people. Many people believe that the American flag stands for something important and shouldn?t be destroyed in that manner. Others believe that flag burning is a statement that one should be able to make without major repercussions.
My House
– Own Writing Essay, Research Paper Moving Have you ever moved from your home that you had lived in your entry life? Well, I had to. My home and neighborhood was where I lived for ten years. We moved there when I was three and then moved right after I turned fourteen. All my friends lived right around me and I knew everyone.