Drug Testing and Corporate Responsibility: The “Ought Implies Can” Argument Drug testing has become a hot topic under the microscope recently. The problem is the question whether or not it is morally wrong to test employees for illegal drug use. In order to justify drug testing in the work place one must look to rights, among other things, to determine what sorts of controls are morally permissible. In order to really determine whether or not drug testing is needed one must evaluate the connection between drug testing and the prevention of drug related harm. One theory that that many people use to justify the morality of Drug testing in the work place is a theory that is called “Ought Implies Can”. Showing that a person was incapable of doing something otherwise blocks the normal moves of praise or blame and therefore absolves the agent of responsibility for a given act. Basically, we believe that persons can not be obligated to do things that they are not capable of doing. If they fail to do those things then they can not be held accountable. To imply the argument to drug testing is not as broad as the previous example. If corporations are responsible for harms caused by employees under the influence of drugs, they must have the ability to prevent these harms. They must therefore, have the ability to test for drug use. This argument is vague to say the least. In the argument there are four distinct senses of “Responsible” that appear with some regularity in the argument. They are being legally liable, culpable or guilty, answerable or accountable, or bound by an obligation. The first argument is legal liability. If the employee causes harm to a third party while preforming on behalf of the company, the company has to compensate the third party. This is because the firm was acting through the employee thus, the company is held accountable. This is often called Respondeat superior. This doctrine is grounded not in fault, but in concerns of public policy and utility. Because it does not imply fault, legal liability can not be used successfully as an “Ought Implies Can” argument. Another words, holding corporations legally liable for harms committed by intoxicated employees while at the same time forbidding drug testing is not inconsistent. It can be viewed as another instance of liability without fault. We must be able to attribute more than legal liability to corporations if the “Ought Implies Can” principle is to be applied. Corporations must be held accountable in one of the other three arguments in order for the argument to work. The culpable or guilty argument takes a different approach. This argument states that an agent, in this case the corporation, should be held morally responsible if the act can be imputed to the corporation. This requirement could be satisfied if it could be shown that the firm intended the resulting harms, ordered their employees to work under the influence of drugs, or ignored the fact that there were employees that were working under the influence of drugs. However, this argument tends to be a little drastic and really can not apply to make the “Ought Implies Can” theory work either. Clearly in most cases drug use would not simply be ignored. In fact, drug use is quite likely to be prohibited by company policy. Therefore this argument does not justify drug testing. In this third argument corporations could actually be held accountable for the harmful acts of there employees. Through a series of agreements, the corporation delegates its employees to act on its behalf. For these reasons it could be argued that corporations could be held responsible for their employees negligence. If this is the case then corporations should have the right to test their employees for drugs. This last argument which is called bound by an obligation supports drug testing as well under the “Ought Implies Can” theory. If corporations have an obligation to prevent danger to all of its employees and consumers then they should be able to do what ever is needed to prevent drugs and overall prevent danger. Another words, if corporations have obligations they must be capable of carrying them out, on the principle of “Ought Implies Can”. Corporations have an obligation to prevent harm in the work place. Drug use is like to cause harm thus, corporations must be able to take steps to eliminate that harm. As a result, drug testing is an effective way to eliminate drug abuse, which in essence causes harm. Therefore, they must be permitted to test for drugs. Finally, does the “Ought Implies Can” theory work? It really depends on what argument one uses to support it or argue against it. Clearly, if a corporation has an obligation to prevent harm to others some sort of control is in order, but not total control. If drug testing is morally permissible than why would it stop there? It could get out of hand and employers could start administering polygraph tests or even psychological manipulation. There has to be another way to prevent harm or at least create an atmosphere where corporations can not be held accountable. The fact is that drug testing is skeptical at best. Most of the time when drug testing is administered it is very unreliable. There has always been a high rate of false negatives and false positives. For instance, drugs are sometimes not picked up by the test. Because of this situation, if the test is given to an employee, and he passes but then causes harm on the job due to intoxication, the corporation can not possibly be held responsible. If the corporation is held responsible what good did the drug test do in the first place? The fact is that if corporations are going to be held responsible then they are obligated to do something but not drug testing. Drug testing is clearly not the answer because they are highly ineffective. In addition, if this type of situation occurs more often than not when the test is administered, than all the test is really doing in most cases is wasting the employees time and the employers money.
Drug Testing 2 Essay Research Paper
Drug Testing 2 Essay, Research Paper DRUG TESTING Drug tests are a chemical analysis used to detect the presence of drugs in a small sample of urine or sometimes in blood. There are six types of drug testing: Pre-employment, Random, For-cause, Periodically Announced, Post-accident, and Rehabilitation.
A current issue that is going on today is welfare recipients that are drug abusers. Welfare is supposed to meet the basic needs. Drugs seem far from one of the basic human needs to me. If the recipient gets all the benefits from the programs
Genetic Testing Essay, Research Paper At the start of the 20th century, genetic research was in its youth. Today, our society is in center stage of a genetic revolution. Rarely does a week go by without the media reporting the discovery of a gene that is believed to be accountable for some disease or some aspect of human behavior.
Essay, Research Paper Drug Identification with Gas Chromatography Mass Spectrometry Drugs are used everyday by people in many different ways for many different reasons. Drug testing has become a standard in pre-employment testing, because of the wide variety of drug use in today s society. Drugs tested for by a possible employer include Cocaine (crack), Amphetamines (crystal), Opiates (codeine, morphine, heroin), PCP (phencyclidine), and Marijuana.
MDMA Essay, Research Paper The popular rave drug, MDMA (3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine) or ecstasy, has had a fascinating history dating from the 1910s to the present. This designer drug was originally used as a diet pill and later in psychotherapy. The recent use of MDMA recreationally has increased interest and research on the drug and its effects on humans.
Drug Epidemic Essay, Research Paper I read this question and immediately one answer came to mind, yes we are in the midst of a drug epidemic. Drugs seem to be a huge problem to this present date. You can walk down any side street in New York City and buy pot or several other drugs. I would call that an epidemic. Everywhere you look you see the issue of drugs being brought up, and the topic of legalizing certain drugs.
Ritalin Essay, Research Paper Ritalin is a drug used to quell HYPERCATIVE children and perk up the inattentive. Six times as much ritalin was used in 1995 than in 1990
Paper In Issue 13 of Taking Sides, the controversial question Have Antidepressant Drugs Proven to be Effective is analyzed. Psychiatrist Peter D. Kramer argues in this issue that antidepressant drugs “can transform depressed patients into happy people with almost no side effects” (p.212). On the contrary, professors of psychology Seymour Fisher and Roger P.
Drugs Essay, Research Paper For several decades drugs have been one of the major problems of society. Not only has the drug problem increased but also drug related problems are on the rise. Some people are born addicts, while others become users. The result of drug abuse is thousands of addicts in denial. One controversial solution to the drug problem is the proposal of legalizing drugs.
Batch Essay, Research Paper Discuss your stately for testing this algorithm, making sure that you include any problems that you think you may encounter. Also give examples of test data and expected results of your test data.
Heroin Essay, Research Paper Heroin Heroin related deaths and arrests among young pop culture musicians has not been this visible for decades. ?We observe pop culture making this drug-
Regional Drug Taskforce Essay, Research Paper Northeast Texas Regional Drug Taskforce has increased activity 60 percent last year. The additional drug busts were not easy as the area’s most widely manufactured drug – a cheap form of methamphetamine called “crank” – is now produced literally on the road in automobiles.
The Drug War Essay, Research Paper Everyday someone is thrown in state prison for anywhere from 3 years to life for the “illegal” use of the drug known as marijuana. It has come down to it that thousands of pounds of marijuana are smuggled over the border of Mexico and into the United States. Regardless of the fight or struggle of people to insure the so said safety of our younger generations from the use of these drugs more and more comes into the Unites States.
Violent Kid Profile Essay, Research Paper ?THE VIOLENT-KID PROFILE? Are students being judged by the way they act, by what they say, or even by the way they dress? Sadly, the answer is yes. Not by their peers, but
Panic Disorders Essay, Research Paper Since panic disorder often goes undetected, experts hope to heighten awareness with a new drug called selective
Drugs Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, drugs have been a very obvious problem espescially amongst teenagers and young adults. . I feel that an answer can be found if people stop
Drugs And AIDS Essay, Research Paper Hopkins University. In the U.S gay men still make up the primary risk group,although 750,000 to 1 milliondrug addicts are believed to be at risk to AIDS nationally. The problem here is thesharing of needles, which is causing the spread of AIDS. IV drug abusers arekilling our nation at an amazingly fast speed.
Specific Purpose – To persuade my audience that animal testing is wrong and how other safer alternatives should be taken. Central Idea – By going the extra mile in using safer alternatives when experimenting with animals will not only prevent conflicts from pro-life activists, it will minimize lawsuits and morals will be preserved.
Preventing Hiv Transmission Essay, Research Paper Preventing HIV Transmission from Mother to Child Thesis Statement: The percentage of HIV transmission from mother to child can be prevented in a number of ways.
LSD Essay, Research Paper LSD is a hallucinogen. In fact, it is the most potent hallucinogen known to man. LSD is 100 times more potent than psilocybin or psylicin and is 4000 times more potent than mescaline. It was synthesized in 1938 by a chemist who worked in Switzerland. There were no benefits for this drug that were found, so its study was discontinued.
Drug Dependence Essay, Research Paper Drug Dependence In order for a chemical to be considered a drug it must have the capacity to affect how the body works–to be biologically active. No substance that has the
Animal Experimentation 2 Essay, Research Paper Lab experimentation involving animals is inhumane. Animal testing is cruel because an animal s life is just as important as a human s life, people are exploiting animals, and animal testing doesn t show whether or not a product is safe for humans.
Employment Drug Testing The use of pre-employment and random drug testing by companies in the United States has grown rapidly during the past decade. Drug testing in the workplace has become an issue of great concern to people on both sides of the employment equation. The increased popularity of drug testing in the workplace, specifically in private sector employment, has created an unclear ?tug-of-war? between the desires of employers and the rights of employees.
UNLV DRUG TESTING: POSITIVE OR NEGATIVE Drug testing at UNLV is not as effective as originally thought, and have many students-athletes very upset. At the beginning of each academic year student-athletes must sign a drug testing consent form prescribed by the NCAA Committee. Student-athletes are not forced to drug test for the NCAA or intercollegiate athletic drug-testing program.
Paper Drug Testing of Student Athletes Mandatory and random drug testing of student athletes violates their right to privacy. The right to privacy is guaranteed under the fourth amendment.
, Research Paper Drug Testing in the Workplace When the question of drug testing in the workplace arises, many problems tend to come along with it. For employers, the solution is simple; drug tests are mandatory for employment. When it comes to employees, however the response might be more along the lines of It s none of your business or That s a violation of my rights .
Animal Testing Essay, Research Paper The American Medical Association has stated that it believes that research-involving animals is essential to maintaining and improving the health of human beings. They point out that all advances in medical science in the 20th century, from antibiotics to organ transplants, has been achieved either directly or indirectly through the use of animals in laboratory experiments.
Drug Testing 2 Essay, Research Paper Should High School Students be Drug Tested? Many schools feel that the students that play sports are the leaders in their schools and should have to take a drug test to be eligible to play sports. The schools do not want drug users on high school sports teams because in many cases, students on the teams are the ones that are looked up to in their schools and are supposed to set the example for others.
, Research Paper How To Pass A Drug Test. To pass a drug test it is very important to estalish the length of time which the metabolties will be in your body. If you can establish this and then cease
Drugs In Sport Essay, Research Paper The topic I am going to discuss today is Drugs in Sport. My contention is that drugs should not be made legal in sports.
, Research Paper In almost every career job, before a new employee is hired, drug testing is administered. However many jobs stop at that point; not believing, or choosing to ignore the fact that employees may be using drugs. Random drug testing in the work place is a good practice. Although people complain that it is a violation of privacy, companies have a business to run and don’t need the responsibility or the hassle of a drug addicted employee.
Drug Addiction Essay, Research Paper Drug addiction can be something that will ruin your life. Abusing drugs can lead to serious damage to your body and it can be deadly. You might lose your family
Paper Argument Essay Where would we be Without Animal Testing? Is the use of animals in research justified? Should animal experimentation be permitted? Should these animals be liberated? A logical person would say the benefits justify the research. Without animal testing, products would be based on theory.
Paper Be Healthy and Drug Free To be healthy and drug free means much more than it sounds. It means turning down peer pressure, not using drugs, and not feeling the need to use
Drug Legalization Essay, Research Paper Essay Questions April 28, 2001 Drug Legalization The debate over drug legalization has existed for decades. It is a hot topic for