Germany: Still Divided Essay, Research Paper
The shocking fall of communism in Eastern and Central Europe in the late eighties was remarkable for both its rapidity and its scope. None more than for East and West Germany. ?The unification of Germany has been one of the most significant and moving events of the 20th century. Yet the euphoria of those heady days in autumn 1989, when the world watched in rapt attention as the Berlin Wall came tumbling down, has since fizzled. The process has proven to be far more painful than (then) Chancellor Helmut Kohl had promised Germans in 1990 on the eve of the first all-German elections since the Nazi?s rise to power.?(Ireland, 541) This resulted from the underestimation that was placed on integrating the democratic system of government and free-market economy of West Germany with the communist foundation of East Germany. The shift from communism took a whole new context in Germany. The peoples involved were not looking to affect a narrow set of policy reforms; indeed, what was at stake was a hyper-radical shift from the long-held communist ideology to a western blueprint for governmental and economic policy development. According to theories of modernization, higher levels of socioeconomic achievement facilitates an increase in open competition and, ultimately, assists in the establishment of democracy.
The problem inherent in this type of monumental change is that, according to Helga A. Welsh, ? the collapse of authoritarian rule has released national, ethnic, religious, and cultural conflicts which cannot be solved by purely economic policies?(27). Generally it has been theorized that the most effective fashion in which to remedy these many difficulties is by drafting a constitution. But, what seems to be clear in Germany is the unsatisfactory ability of a constitution to resolve the problems of nationalism and ethnic differences. Germany?s current situation gives validity to the statement that ? what works in theory doesn?t necessarily work in practice.? This is because the economic advancements that were anticipated to bring prosperity to East Germany didn?t occur as planned.
It was assumed that the integration of the economies would be a difficult but attainable goal because West Germany was one of the world?s most productive and prosperous economies. The last ten years have shown that this was not the case. Due to East Germany?s longtime adherence to communist policies, it faced great complexity in making the transition to a pluralist system as well as a market economy. As Preuss posits these problems were threefold: The genuine economic devastations wrought by the communist regimes, the transformation of the social and economic classes of the command economy and , finally the creation of a constitutional structure for political entities that lack the undisputed integrity of a nation state (48). The failure of the economic integration is at the root of the ills that have plagued the two countries since unification.
In regards to the economic aspects of unification, some major problems exist in the transition to a free-market economy. First, and probably the most significant factor is the epidemic of unemployment that has infected East Germany. Prior to unification slightly over half of East Germany?s 16 million people were employed and this figure has been steadily declining since 1989. Currently, ?the east?s unemployment rate of more than 17% is double that of the west?s (Aaland, r12). In a market economy these grim statistics breed frustration and discontent among the populace.
Another dilemma presenting itself to Germany is the enormous expense of upgrading the dilapidated infrastructure in the east. The east is decades behind technologically and hundreds of millions of dollars have been required to improve the roads, railroads, telecommunications, public services, postal service, and most importantly educational system. Along with this is the deplorable environmental conditions that were left by the old communist regime. These necessary conditions must be renovated before funding can stimulate the economy and is an important factor in the east?s current economic nightmare.
One other important issue that has contributed to the east?s depression is the economic policy of the privatizing of state property. This is a sensitive subject in any country?s transition from a command economy. For one, a system of procedures must be adopted simply to transfer such large amounts of property to private citizens. Also, there must be mechanisms put in place to both protect new owners form claims of previous owners and to satisfy former owner without alienating possible future investors. The problem arises in that private property laws do not always coincide with the fair concept of restitution. As Petra Bauer-Kaase states, ?East Germans still have difficulties in adjusting to a political system where individuals have a great deal of responsibility for there own life? (307). The former East Germans look upon this issue with contempt, because it is the Westerners who have control over the rules, as well as the enforcement of those rules. This is merely one of a multitude of instances where this mistrust between the sides manifests itself.
The failure in the economic and political integration has been the catalyst for numerous other social ills. The main being a backlash of violence against ethnic groups and a rise in right wing political groups that support this behavior. Many believe that the economic effects of unification, particularly the increase in unemployment, is causing Germans and foreigners to compete for jobs, housing, and other scarce commodities, and in turn generating resentment among the German citizens. As, Patrick Ireland adds,? high unemployment and uncertainty about job prospects during the transformation of a command economy into a market economy are seen as having produced disorientation and rootless ness among vulnerable people in the east?Grievances become politicized, with right-wing extremists mobilizing support and winning sympathy from the public. Existing social divisions widen, and those groups blamed for the perceived problems become favored targets?Thus East Germans, some of whom believed that they were competing with foreign contract laborers for consumer goods and other resources before unification, began to feel seriously deprived compared to their wealthy western neighbors after 1989. It became easier to make scapegoats of foreigners?(544).
This rise in racism and ethnic violence can be directly attributed to the ongoing economic saga that the east is experiencing. They envy their western neighbors but feel turn their cheek because of the strong traditional sense of nationalism. So their disappointment is taken out on any one who is not German. As Patrick Ireland writes the east Germans,? insecure and unsure of their role in a multicultural society, fear becoming permanent second-class citizens in united Germany. Foreigners have become the ?whipping boy?, the scapegoat for all the frustrations of the past, the disillusionment of the present, and the fears of the future?(545).
It seems that much more than the economies are diverging between the opposite sides of Germany. Although there are no really significant conflicts between Germans, the attitudes of the two sides are going in opposite directions. The Wall Street Journal reported that a German study showed that within the next five years westerners believed that their lives would improve while easterners fear it worsening. Also westerners were more satisfied with their careers, finances, and health while the easterner?s were happier than their counterparts when it came to their families, marriages, and children. Also, Dagmar Aaland reports that a majority of the easterner?s disappointments and pessimistic attitudes stem ?from joblessness and ?unrealistic expectations? of the time needed to catch up with the west?(r12).
While unification had occurred theoretically, in reality the Germany today is one of a de facto separate-but-equal citizenship. There is no denying that there have been many problems associated with the unification of East and West Germany. From the miserable failure of the implementation of a free-market to the social tribulations that evolved; .the transition from a communist state to a liberal democracy is a very challenging one, and there is no real way to predict how the German experience will turn out. As Preuss writes, ? The transition from an authoritarian political regime and its concomitant command economy to a liberal democracy and a capitalist economy is as unprecedented as the short-term integration of two extremely different societies into one state?(57). In other words, the unification of Germany is one of the most complex and unparalleled historical events, on a social and economic level, since the unification of Germany.
6f0
Aaland, Dagmar. ?A Nation Still Divided?, The Wall Street Journal. 27 Sept. 1999.
p.r12 & r18.
Bauer-Kaase, Petra. ?Germany in Transition: the Challenge of Coping with Unification.?.
German Unification: Processes and Outcomes. M. Donald Hancock and Helga A. Welsch, eds. Boulder: Westview, 1994. 285-311
Ireland, Patrick. ?Socialism, Unification Policy and the Rise of Racism In
Eastern Germany?. International Migration Review. Fall 1997. p. 541-68
Preuss, Ulrich K. ?German Unification: Political and Constitutional Aspects.? United
Germany and the New Europe. Heinz D. Kurz, ed. Brookfield: Elgar, 1993 p.47-58
Welsh, Helga A. ?The Collapse of Communism in Eastern Europe and the GDR:
Evolution, Revolution, and Diffusion.? German Unification: Processes and Outcomes. M. Donald Hancock and Helga A Welsh, eds. Boulder: Westview, 1994. p.17-34.
Другие работы по теме:
Adolf Hitler Essay Research Paper Hitler was
Adolf Hitler Essay, Research Paper Hitler was one of the most, if not the most cruel man to ever walk the face of the earth. His belief of the superiorority of the “Aryan” race made him hate all others. He believed that the slaws to the east should be made work for the German people. He thought of blacks as being “Sub-human”.
Alfred Wegener Essay Research Paper Alfred Wegener
Alfred Wegener Essay, Research Paper Alfred Wegener was an explorer and meteorologist, born in Berlin, who first came up with the “Continental Drift Theory” or the “Wegener Theory.” This theory stated that all of the continents came from one super continent, also known as Pangea, which spread apart gradually moving into their current positions on Earth.
Aims Of Germany And Japan Essay Research
Paper The Aims of Germany and Japan The 1930s were a tumultuous time. After World War I, the Allied powers seemed determined to preserve peace, but Germany and Japan held a shared
Koljiol Essay Research Paper AUSTRIAN AVALANCHESRecently deadly
Koljiol Essay, Research Paper AUSTRIAN AVALANCHES Recently deadly avalanches have occurred and are still occuring in austria and Central Europe. Who’s to blame, the antithesis of El Nino or La Nina? Snow storms that usually occur in Scandinavia, have moved further south to Central Europe.
Critical Essay On The Eagle Essay Research
Paper Critical Essay The name of the poem I am writing about is called ?The Eagle? by Alfred, Lord Tennyson. It is in figurative language form. The poem is divided into 2 Stanza?s with 3 lines each. And there are an
Genocide Essay Research Paper The Germans and
Genocide Essay, Research Paper The Germans and the non-Jewish world treated the Jewish people horribly. They looked for freedom, growth, and a better government after World War I. Instead, Jews became prisoners of their own country in Germany. They were put into concentration camps even though they helped Germany by fighting in World War I.
Germany
’s Government: Chancellor Democracy Essay, Research Paper Germany’s Government: Chancellor Democracy Steve Rice Political Science 90 Computer Project
Moments Essay Research Paper I know I
Moments Essay, Research Paper I know I said yes, But deep down inside, Divided, Undecided. Days passed. That night, Before the day, Sleepless, Full of thoughts,
Christa Wolf Essay Research Paper Wolf Christa
Christa Wolf Essay, Research Paper Wolf, Christa (1929- ), German novelist and essayist, known for her novels about Germany during World War II (1939-1945). Born Christa Ihlenfeld in Landsberg an der Warthe (now Gorz w Wielkopolski, Poland), she studied at the Universities of Leipzig and Jena from 1949 to 1953.
Norman Schwarzkopf Essay Research Paper Norman SchwarzkopfNorman
Norman Schwarzkopf Essay, Research Paper Norman Schwarzkopf Norman Schwarzkopf and I are alike in many ways. He and I both have family in Germany. His father lives in Germany and my great grandparents live in Germany. He served in Vietnam and so did my grandfather.
Authoritarian Government In Germany 18711914 Essay Research
Paper Authoritarian Government in Germany 1871-1914 The Unification of Germany under there the powerful leader Otto Von Bismark led to the Authoritarian style government in Germany for the next forty years through his aggressive and sometimes underhanded leadership qualities. Bismark united Germany too Prussia not uniting Germany as an equal and fair whole this was the main cause for this new authoritarian style government.
Word War One Essay Research Paper War
Word War One Essay, Research Paper War broke in 1914 due to a number of factors, and many of these dated back many years before the war. There were many things that contributed to the final war that was brought on by a certain catalyst. The arms race between Germany and Great Britain, the heated past of Germany and France, the tensions amongst the Balkan states, and between the Balkans and Austria-Hungary were all major contributing factors of the war.
Consequences Of The 30 Years War Essay
, Research Paper Consequences of the 30 Years War- Essay From the change of warfare, to the vast changes in government and dominance, the Thirty Years War had clearly resulted in many changes and effected many areas of life. These changes occur politically, religiously, socially and economically. As the most destructive event in German history, the Thirty Years War started as a conflict between the Protestants and Roman Catholics, yet ended up as a fight for political power.
Causes Of World War I 3 Essay
, Research Paper There were many immediate and underlying or fundamental causes of World War I. The difference between an underlying and immediate cause is that an underlying cause develops over a long period of time and indirectly leads to a specific event, and an immediate cause is a specific short-term event that directly leads to another event or series of events.
Versailles Treaty Essay Research Paper Treaty of
Versailles Treaty Essay, Research Paper Treaty of Versailles The treaty of Versailles was a peace treaty signed at the end of World War I between Germany and the Allies. It was negotiated during the Paris Peace Conference held in Versailles beginning January 18, 1919. The allies represented were the United States, Great Britain, France, and Italy.
Euro Essay Research Paper Tax breaks promised
Euro Essay, Research Paper Tax breaks promised by France and Italy to lorry drivers who mounted fuel price protest blockades in the summer looked to set to cause controversy among EU finance ministers meeting in Brussels today (19 January). The concessions are illegal under EU competition law and upset some of the countries? EU partners who were angry that the French and Italian governments gave in to the protesters.
Effects Of The Treaty Of Versailles On
Germany Essay, Research Paper The Effects of the Treaty of Versailles on Germany World War I was one of the bloodiest and deadliest wars of all time. Many agreed that there were to be no more wars hence a treaty was signed. However, the contents of the treaty were not to Germany?s favour. The treaty of Versailles had a great role in Germany?s decision and desire to enter into war.
French Government Essay Research Paper The modern
French Government Essay, Research Paper The modern French government is run very much like the government of the United States. France is a democratic republic that is divided into three branches,
Berlin Blockade Essay Research Paper After World
Berlin Blockade Essay, Research Paper After World War II, when Germany was defeated, it was divided into four zones, one for each of the Allies. The eastern part went to the Russians. The other Allied Powers, France, Britain and the U.S. divided the Western portion of the city among themselves. This arrangement reflected the Allied solution for the whole of Germany.
Speaker
#3 Essay, Research Paper He was born on Essen of Germany. He was an ordinary citizen of Germany. The keyword to this essay is that word “was.” After the NAZI came into power, he was treated as an “inferior race.” He did not beat anyone up or abuse anyone. So, why was he being treated badly? He was a Jewish person in a new era.
A Professinal Football Game Essay Research Paper
This is my essay about the NFL and its players. The NFL is divided into two leagues, the AFC and the NFC. In those divisions, they are divided into 3 conferences, the west, central, east. They both have about 14 teams each and they compete head to head.
WWII Why Did The US Get Involved
In The War? Essay, Research Paper WWII: Why did the U.S. get involved in the war? At the beginning, the United States expressed the determination to remain a neutral nation. When W.W.II began, opinions among the Americans were
Post War Europe Essay Research Paper The
Post War Europe Essay, Research Paper The Duality of Local and Regional Factors in the Rise of Dictators in Post-War Europe After World War I, a majority of Europe was left in utter shambles. The physical and economic structures of a once industrial area had been reduced rubble. The people of the nations cried out for help, but to little avail.
Heading Towards Ww2 Essay Research Paper Heading
Heading Towards Ww2 Essay, Research Paper Heading Towards WWII World War II was a result of how World War I was resolved. The Treaty of Versailles, signed at the end of the Great War, was supposed to bring about change and
Unification Of Germany And Italy Essay Research
Paper The similarities between the unification of Germany and the unification of Italy are: they both were unified after a series of wars and during both countries unifications France received the bad end of it. Other similarities were after the unifications both countries were ruled by a monarch and the people who were unified generaly felt more loyalty to their local government thanto the new monarchs.
Past Essay Research Paper Michelle Brandon My
Past Essay, Research Paper Michelle Brandon My Past: I was born in Calgary, Alberta in 1983 then in 1985 I moved to Germany. I stayed in Germany for 3 years then I moved to calgary for 2 years. Cakgary is a nice place to live it s a big city compared to Germany. Germany is a beautiful place to go, I would like to go back to Germany for a visit.
Three EmperorsS League Essay Research Paper 1
Three Emperors?S League Essay, Research Paper 1. Three Emperors?s League: In 1873 this league linked the monarchs of Austria-Hungary, Germany, and Russia in an alliance against racial movements.
How Did The Nazi Party Get So
Big? Essay, Research Paper Hitler’s Nazi party came to power almost entirely because of accidents. In 1929 the American Stock Market crashed, a powerful symbol of the growing
Hitlers Germany Essay Research Paper One reason
Hitlers Germany Essay, Research Paper One reason the people of Germany accepted Hitler’s orders willingly and without question was beause it was what they wanted to hear. At the time the depression
Hitler Essay Research Paper Hitler came to
Hitler Essay, Research Paper Hitler came to power the legitimate way, through participating in elections. True he broke or bent a few rules and cheated and lied but probably no more than any other politician. It is common belief that had Hitler come along at another less desperate time for Germany, history would have played itself out very differently.