Julius Ceasar 2 Essay, Research Paper
Caesar’s Funeral Speeches – “Justification versus Manipulation”
In William Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, one of the most important and significant orations are the funeral speeches given by both Brutus and Mark Antony. At first glance, the funeral speeches seem to have no true significant meaning. However upon further investigation it is established that the speeches ultimately serve as the basis for the final outcome of the play. By exploring the speeches of both Brutus and Mark Antony we are able to focus on the key components which differentiate one from the other. Through this examination we are also able to comprehend why Brutus’ speech becomes one of justification and explanation, while Antony’s becomes one of manipulation and skill.
In order to evaluate each of the speeches, we must first distinguish the general purpose each serves. It is known that both Brutus and Antony desired to appeal to the Romans (or the people). However, the way in which each man went about it differs drastically. Not only did it influence the outcome, but each speech also offers a unique insight on each of the speakers.
Brutus’ speech becomes one of strict vindication, not only for the people of Rome, but for Brutus himself. He uses his “honor and nobility” as a shield to defend and justify his actions to the crowd. Brutus states that he has carried out this heinous act because of his love for Rome, and for the good of the people. (This is my answer, not that I have loved Caesar less, but that I love Rome more…” 3.2.21-22) In his speech he requests that the people use their “reason” to judge him. Although this captivates the crowd, it is not until after one of the plebeians cry “Let him be Caesar.” (3.2.51) that it is realized the speech is “merely too good for them.” (Goddard pg.322) Brutus begins to realize that liberty is not what the people wanted, but rather that they desire a powerful leader.
Although his speech serves the purpose for its practical effectiveness, Brutus later comes to discover that his lack of insight of human nature aided in the apparent hopelessness of his cause.
In comparison Mark Antony fully understands human nature and utilizes his awareness of it in his speech. Antony appeals to the passion and the distress of the people. What Brutus failed to recognize in the people, Antony used to his best interest. He realized that the people of Rome were completely incapable of acting with “reason” and he employed this inability to manipulate and control their emotions and actions. By using Brutus’ own explanations for Caesar’s death to begin his speech, Antony proves his validity to the crowd. By questioning Caesar’s “ambition,” yet never actually debasing the conspirators; He succeeds in “intentionally leading the crowd away” from any “rational” defense provided by Brutus. (Scragg pg. 78) Antony uses his own grief along with a series of fabrications to evoke the sympathy of the people. Through his eloquent and “honest” speech he is able to plant the seed of doubt into the minds of the people, and the crowd begins to contemplate the true motive behind Caesar’s murder. Antony understands the needs and wants of the people and uses this to prey upon their emotions and passions. He “dangles” Caesar’s Will in front of the people and then quickly “reels” it in again, knowing that the crowd will demand that it be read. Antony also recalls memories of the cloak Caesar now wears, while revealing his bloodied body, fully aware of the havoc it will reek, but unrelenting in his quest for revenge.
Although both of Caesar’s funeral speeches seem to serve the basic purpose of appealing to the people, their dissimilarity serves as a great significance. Brutus’ speech which appeared to be honest becomes a speech of “symmetrical structure, balanced sentences, ordered procedure, rhetorical questions and abstract subject matter, a speech of a man whose heart was not in his
words,” and ultimately became a speech of utter dishonesty.(Goddard 322) This along with Brutus’ lack of human insight aided in his inevitable downfall. Mark Antony’s speech on the other hand, “for all its playing on passions and all its lies,” proved to be at the bottom a truly honest speech because of Antony’s unconditional love for Caesar. (Goddard pg. 322) To that extent Antony had truth on his side, making him concrete and real rather then abstract, (Brutus) and with this aided in his successful victory.
Другие работы по теме:
Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar was
Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar was one of the most famous men of antiquity, who was dictator of Rome and “a man of letters”. Gaius Julius Caesar was born on July 12, 100 B.C. His family, the gens Julia was ancient and patrician, but at the time it was only beginning to reemerge. Caesar could not feel safe in Rome while Sulla was still alive.
Cleopatra 2 Essay Research Paper CleopatraOne of
Cleopatra 2 Essay, Research Paper Cleopatra One of the most popular pharos of Egypt has to be King Tut, The youngest ruler of Egypt. However, one of the most interesting is without-a- doubt Cleopatra. One of the intriguing parts about her was her son Ptolemy Caesar. Ptolemy Caesar, (The son of Julius Caesar), was one of main factors in the fall of Rome.
William Shakespeare 2 Essay Research Paper William
William Shakespeare 2 Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, is mainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The character who was in charge of the assassination was, ironically, Marcus Brutus, a servant and close friend to Julius Caesar. What would cause a person to kill a close friend? After examining Brutus’ relationship to Caesar, his involvement in the conspiracy, and his importance to the plot, the truth can be revealed that Brutus kills his close friend for the love of Rome.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper William Shakespeare
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper William Shakespeare writes the Tragedy of Julius Caesar. This tragic play is based on historical facts of the life of Julius Caesar. It displays the events before his death such as his conquest over Pompey’s armies and his coronation to be king and after his death. Furthermore, this play describes the minds and motives of Caesar’s assassins.
Julius Ceaser Essay Research Paper 2
Julius Ceaser Essay, Research Paper “Alas, thou hast misconstrued everything!”-Titinius “That one cry?might well serve as an epigraph for the whole of Julius Caesar.”-Marjorie Garber
Julius Caeser
– Brutus Essay, Research Paper Was Brutus a man of principle or a hypocrite? After reading the play Julius Caeser by William Shakespeare, I would conclude that Brutus was a man of principle and honor. Brutus, a servant and close friend to Caesar, has a strong relationship with Caesar but a stronger relationship with Rome and its people.
Julius Essay Research Paper There have been
Julius Essay, Research Paper There have been many great leaders in our history, one of who is Julius Caesar. Julius Caesar was born a leader and died a leader. From his uprising
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper In the
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper In the play Julius Caesar Shakespeare give up hints about what is going to happen though out the rest of the play. He uses foreshadowing in the use of his characters names. For instance Julius Caesar was born Julius but earned the name Caesar after many triumphs over his stellar career.
Caesar 4 Essay Research Paper English10B6299
Caesar 4 Essay, Research Paper English10B 6-2-99 2* Who is Brutus? In Shakespeare s play of “Julius Caesar” Brutus was a conspirator that favors Rome and it s high status. He is a very honorable man. Brutus is a character that has a lot of pride for Rome and would not let anyone change the way everyone looks at it s royalty.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarThere
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar There are a lot of examples of supernatural in the play Julius Caesar . In this play we see signs of the supernatural from the Soothsayer, Calpurnia, which is Caesar s wife, and Caesar s ghost after his death.
Julius Caesar As A Tragic Hero 2
Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar As A Tragic Hero In Julius Caesar William Shakespeare illustrated Caesar as a tragic hero by showing that he was a noble man of high rank, by showing that he was a historical figure with a tragic flaw which lead to his downfall, and by showing that Caesar accepted his fate of death & achieved honor and respect in his death.
Julius Caesar By William ShakespeareA Essay Research
Paper Julius Caesar by William ShakespeareSome tragedies are classified as classical tragedies and they may contain a tragic hero. This is true in William Shakespeare s Julius Caesar in which Brutus is the tragic hero. The play Julius Caesar contains many characteristics to classify it as a classical tragedy.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Born in
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Born in Rome on July 12 or 13, 100 BC, Caesar belonged to the prestigious Julian clan; yet from early childhood he knew controversy. His uncle by marriage was
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Larren San
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Larren San Pedro Julius Caesar Julius Caesar is a Shakespearean tragedy about the hunger for power. William Shakespeare explained the tragedy through the character development of hatred and envy. Caesar s life was cut short because several men around him looked at him to power hungry and weak.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar was a great military power. Much of Rome praised Caesar and triumphed at his victories and accomplishments. However, there were many dissatisfied Roman men and women that felt Caesar was too powerful and ambitious for his own good. Caesar’s growing power resulted in Marcus Antonius offering him the Crown of Rome three times, and all three times Caesar refused the crown.
Women In Julius Ceasar Essay Research Paper
In the theatrical work of Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare, the wives of key characters play a small but extraordinarily significant role. Female characters such as Portia the wife of Brutus, and Calpurnia wife of Julius Caesar, offer readers or viewers insight into the characters of their mates. Each wife shows different aspects of their companion.
Julius Ceasar 3 Essay Research Paper In
Julius Ceasar 3 Essay, Research Paper In Act Two of Julius Caesar, the reader was introduced to the characters of Portia and Calpurnia. They were similar in many ways.
Julius Caesar A Dead Man
’s Party Essay, Research Paper JULIUS CAESAR: A Dead Man?s Party In Shakespeare?s Julius Caesar, the character of Caesar remains a active force throughout the play, even after his assassination. Caesar is
Julius Ceasar Essay Research Paper At the
Julius Ceasar Essay, Research Paper At the beginning Caesar defeats Pompey in war. The conspirators believe Caesar is getting to powerful and fear him because of it. So they group together and plot a plan to kill him. The conspirators got Brutus, Caesars friend, to help them. At the Senate on the Ides of March the conspirators stab Caesar one at a time.
Julius Caesar Jealousy Essay Research Paper Julius
Julius Caesar: Jealousy Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar: Jealousy Jealousy causes many of the characters in The Tragedy of Julius Caesar to commit dangerous and foolish acts. Cassius’ jealousy drives him to kill
Julius Caesar Character Analysis Essay Research Paper
Julius Caesar In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, the title character’s three prominent characteristics, that he displays for the short time while in the novel, are his egotistical attitude, his intelligence, and foolish courage. During the second scene of the first act, we get an idea of what kind of man Caesar believes himself to be when Anthony declares “When Caesar says ‘Do this’, it is perform’d.” This lets us known that Caesar believes his word to be higher than any other persons, this was probably caused by the inflation of his ego.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper How Betrayal
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper How Betrayal Led to Downfall in Julius Caesar In the play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, William Shakespeare shows how friends often betray each other. Julius Caesar is about to be crowned king of Rome, when some well-known Romans decide that it is not a good idea for this to happen.
Julius Ceasar Essay Research Paper Julius Ceasar
Julius Ceasar Essay, Research Paper Julius Ceasar Julius Ceasar was born in the first century. He was deaf in his left ear and lacked physical strength. He was assasinated by many conspirators. The main ones being Cassius, Brutus, and Decius. They were all against an absolute monarch, and therefore feared the crowning of Ceasar.
Character Analysis Of Brutus In Julius Ceasar
Essay, Research Paper Character Analysis of Brutus in Julius Ceasar William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Julius Caesar, is mainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The character who was in charge of the assassination was, ironically, Marcus Brutus, a friend to Julius Caesar. What would cause a person to kill a close friend? After examining Brutus’ relationship to Caesar, his involvement in the conspiracy, and his importance to the plot, the truth can be revealed.
Downfall Of Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper
Sheena Deans Mr. Mason 3rd Period May 1, 2000 Report: Julius Caesar It can be concluded that the death of Julius Caesar was self inflicted due to his sense of pride , stubbornness, and naivity.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius Caesar10044
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar 100-44 BC Born in 100 BC, Gaius Julius Caesar became one of the most famous and remembered Romans of all time. His parents were Gaius Caesar and Aurelia. Julius Caesar’s most famous
Julius Caesars Women Essay Research Paper Portia
Julius Caesar`s Women Essay, Research Paper Portia and Calpurnia are the two main women in the story of Julius Caesar. They had two totally different parts in the story. One was kind of a servant wife and
Gaius Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Gaius
Gaius Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Gaius Julius Caesar Julius Caesar was a Roman general. He had an adopted son called Octavian (known as Augustus) who later participated n a plot to kill him. “Veni,
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarDo
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar Do you ever wander where the leap year was all started? While Julius Caesar took over the government as a dictator, he presented many contributions and achievements. One of them was adopting a new calendar based on the Egyptian year of 365 1/4 days. Many people believed that Julius Caesar was a tyrant who meant to end the republic and make himself king, although, I believe he was a very beneficial dictator who should have remained a leader.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Julius CaesarVeni
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar Veni, vidi, vici. ?I came, I saw, I conquered.? These are the words of the man who changed the course of Greco-Roman history, Julius Caesar (Bernard 34). Julius Caesar
Julius Caesar 5 Essay Research Paper Julius
Julius Caesar 5 Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar William Shakespeare s play, Julius Caesar, is mainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The various men who happened to object to his assassination had different personal desires for their actions. Depending on each of their actions, words or even tone of voice they may misrepresent them and may be misinterpreted.