Paper
LAW AND SOCIAL THEORY
2000 SESSION ONE
TAKE-HOME EXAMINATION (NO. 2)
QUESTION 4
The process by which the bourgeoisie became in the course of the eighteenth century he politically dominant class was masked by the establishment of an explicit, coded and formally egalitarian juridical framework, made possible by the organization of a parliamentary, representative regime. But the development and generalization of disciplinary mechanisms constituted the other, the dark side of these processes The real corporeal mechanisms constituted the foundation of the formal juridical liberties
What is the thrust of Foucault s thesis set out in this quotation? What light, do you think, it throws on the nature and function of the rule of law and legal rights in contemporary western societies?
Foucault s thesis attempts to explore the ground-level operations in society that are a counterpart to the higher, and widely accepted, notions of the rule of law and representative liberal democracy. The thrust of his argument is that these notions which we take for granted work because each individual, by his or her interactions with others, is conditioned to make what they consider free choices, but within a framework of discipline, coercion and power imbalances. The real source of our legal rights and the source of legitimacy for the rule of law are not substantively derived from the top tiers of society (parliaments, courts, etc), though they may be formally and legally derived from these, but are supported by transparent interactions between the people who claim to be represented at the ground level that region of irregular bodies, with their details, their multiple movements, their heterogenous forces [and] their spatial relations . These are the people who, in exercising their free choices, are actually perpetuating the system which they live in ultimately they become the tools by which they themselves are governed. Foucault uses various metaphors to express this system of government that of the panoptic tower and the prison. As I will demonstrate in this essay, these metaphors are central to his exegesis.
Foucault uses the metaphor of the panopticon and the prison to explain what he perceives to be the real power structures in society. Perhaps the word metaphor here is too weak one senses that Foucault would prescribe, or at least describe, the panopticon and the prison as embodying the very structures upon which modern society is based. His panopticon is essentially a cylindrical ring with a tower in the middle. In the tower hides the supervisor or director , and in the ring are inmates . Each inmate is separated from the other, and each occupies the entire length of a slice of the ring. All the buildings have windows, but are positioned in such a way that the supervisor can see all the inmates, but the inmates cannot see the supervisor (or each other, for that matter). The supervisor is thus able to peer into the minutiae of each individual s daily existence. The inmates know this and by the fact of knowing this, adjust themselves accordingly. Thus they are governed. But upon deeper examination it is revealed that it is not the supervisor who is doing the governing, but the inmates themselves. The supervisor may or may not be there, but this is irrelevant. The mere threat is deterrence. And what might start out as external conditioning thereby resolves itself into the inner conscience and ideology of each person. No one with any particular skill or heredity need control the tower anybody can spy from it. And given that it is open to the public, everyone knows how the system works. The fact that someone can look creates inherent transparency amongst all.
This is exactly what the rule of law is. It is, by contrast, not the rule of man , but it doesn t have to be because, like a panopticon, a human being does not need to be present. No one can be subject to accusations of tyranny, and the rule of law becomes a weapon that individual persons can use against others. It is a weapon of deterrence the individual can call upon the aid of the courts if his/her rights are wronged. In using the system, one becomes very much part of it, and is ingrained into it, and rather than being a higher power like a king, against which there may be a general human tendency to rebel, the rule of law is invoked by individuals subconsciously in their relationships with others. When all individuals seek protection in the rule of law, and when all employ it against others as when necessary, it becomes clear that the rule of law governs more effectively than any other human can. It works perfectly with a liberal society, because individuals continue to think that they can still make completely free choices. The reality is that this is a freedom that is circumscribed by the freedoms of others (therefore a residual freedom), and the rule of law is the well-oiled joint that cushions this myriad panoply of individual activities and choices against each other. If there was real freedom, people could choose to kill others, or do any sort of act which society prohibits. The governance of the rule of law prevents this from happening, but its discreetness, like the shadowy observer in the panoptic tower, makes us forget that we are governed. By analogy, it is instructive to consider who is the governor and who is the governed, the drug addict, or the drug itself? Though it is the drug addict who is in physical control of an inanimate object, it is by using that object whereby he becomes not the ruler, but the ruled. The rule of law is just as intangible, but like the drug addict, the individual in the modern bourgeois society becomes addicted to it, yet thinks that he/she is making a truly free choice. The true formalistic power, at least, lies with the rule of law the drug of modern society.
Even having established that the rule of law operates almost subversively to make us think that we are free when we are in actual fact not (in the sense described above), the rule of law is itself somewhat illusory when we move from the formalistic levels to the substantive levels in the conception of the modern society. The rule of law, representative democracy and legal rights are all espoused as hallmarks of Western society, but, as Foucault points out, there is a darker side. This is what he calls the real corporeal disciplines . Despite what might be professed by the leaders and theorists, the reality of the modern individual relationship structure is one of power imbalances. Foucault gives the example of the work contract he states that the work contract itself is a fiction, and that the real power lies with the employer, to whom the employee is subjugated. What is professed is the rule of law, what happens is routine subordination of some people to others coercion. In America, for example, it might be declared that all men are created equal, but one knows that this is clearly not the case. The employee in most situations is inferior to the employee, the citizen inferior to the police in the sense of street power , the vice-president to the president in a club, and so forth. These are relationships of coercion and dominance which people agree to enter. Though they are supposedly free contracts between equals, as soon as the contract contains a mechanism of discipline , then the relationship becomes asymmetrical and non-reciprocal.
The rule of law and legal rights are backed up by a right to punish. Foucault argues that the existence of a prison structure actually gives legitimacy to the courtroom, and then ultimately, to the rule of law and legal rights. So society can actually be construed as being sourced ultimately from the prison house. Once again, this example demonstrates that legal rights in society mean nothing if there is no prison to lock up those who violate it. The legal right is then nothing more that a intangible assertion by one individual over another. However, I believe that Foucault goes too far in describing the prison as the real source of power. Though it is important to distinguish between real (or normative) and formal power, it is not logical to say that courts ability to punish are justified by the existence of prison. Perhaps their actual capacity to put someone away is facilitated by the existence of prison, but surely the real power is not in the prison but, as Foucault himself argued earlier, in the interactions between persons, mediated by the courts? Nevertheless it does go to show that a liberal democratic society needs illiberal non-democratic elements (prison) in order to function at a normative level.
Другие работы по теме:
The Levels Of The FFA Essay Research
Paper The Levels of the FFA The first level of the FFA is the local level. The local level is our school, Baren County High. Our local level belongs to a larger group called the
Experiment
#1 Essay, Research Paper Title:Logic Gates Objective:To analyze and become familiar with the operation of TTL Logic Gates. Equipment:Digital Trainer
I Have To Be With You Essay
, Research Paper I felt the breath of the wind tickling my back, I felt the cold hands of the clouds on my face. I could hear the whisper of the ground in my ear..echoing in my head.
Poem Fears Essay Research Paper To look
Poem: Fears Essay, Research Paper To look out on the world, and have no sense of direction, is a feeling of losing your every possession. Not just the materialistic possessions that you own, but the possessions of your heart, of your mind, of your soul. You have no where to turn, no where to run, or for that simple matter, no where to walk.
My Mother Essay Research Paper My mother
My Mother Essay, Research Paper My mother is like a rose. She is beautiful, gentle, something special, She is strong, deeply rooted in the ground, There’s no wind that could fold her.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper ally funny man
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ally funny man. Hamlet: why are you throwing up another skull. It could be a skull of a lawyer. So who grave is this man. Clown: It?s all mine.
Panopticon Essay Research Paper Knowledge and power
Panopticon Essay, Research Paper Knowledge and power hand in hand, but whose hand is it? Regardless from where a person comes from, one is always under constant surveillance by someone in society, which in return affects everyone’s individual actions and reactions. Foucault’s Panopticism proves that our ideals we have gained from society do manipulate how we act and behave without realizing it.
Ts Eliot
’s View On Poe Essay, Research Paper Cats Meets The Raven What is an author? What does it matter who is speaking? These questions posed by Michel Foucault lead the reader of his essay in many directions and to multitudes of questions. The ideas presented in T.S. Eliot s essay From Poe to Valery illustrate three different ways of examining Poe, his work, and also the influence of his work.
Panopticism Essay Research Paper In
Panopticism Essay, Research Paper In “Panopticism” Michel Foucault describes the “practices of investigation” which in turn gave rise to a society that was under constant surveillance. Soon the society became a “disciplinary” society. Michel Foucault explains the study and effect of “Panopticism” which gave rise to many social sciences, which included sciences of man, or human behavior.
La Madeleine Church Essay Research Paper La
La Madeleine Church Essay, Research Paper La Madeleine is a church in Paris that started during the reign XV, and designed by Constant d’Ivry using plans based on the St-Louis-des-Invalide church.
New Historicism In The Awakeni Essay Research
Paper Summary and Analysis to New Historicism in The Awakening The term New Historicism is not a well stated expression due to the word new. What is new today may be old tomorrow. New historicism is actually old,
Common Ground Essay Research Paper In the
Common Ground Essay, Research Paper In the video, Common Ground, several ways of alternative organic farming are discussed. Although the tape is somewhat outdated, it still is effective in showing what changes have been made in farming and the issues concerning farmers and the environment. The main objective of the video is showing the process of coming together and meeting in the middle between the farmer and environmentalist, just as it is titled, Common Ground.
Writing Reasons Essay Research Paper On Monday
Writing Reasons Essay, Research Paper On Monday nights I get together with a few friends to exchange ideas about writing and to exchange pieces that we have written. A few Mondays ago one of
Die Schone Mullerin Essay Research Paper Ich
Die Schone Mullerin Essay, Research Paper Ich gehe zu D?sseldorf! D?sseldorf ist „eine gute Adresse“ und ich habe viel f?r meine Reise geplant! D?sseldorf hat das Einkaufen, Sport, Museum, Oper, und viel mehr.
Saint Helens Essay Research Paper Tracie Knowlton7th
Saint Helens Essay, Research Paper Tracie Knowlton 7th period Many things can happen before, during, and after a volcanic eruption. A volcanic eruption is an extraordinary thing. You never know what is going to turn out as in the end.
Sports Essay Research Paper For this assignment
Sports Essay, Research Paper For this assignment I wanted to focus on baseball coaches. However, I was unable to attend two games each on a different level because at this point in time only the college season is underway. So instead of attending a game at a level other than college, I attended a high school practice session.
The Leaning Tower Of Pisa Essay Research
Paper The Leaning Tower of Pisa Built between the years of 1173 and 1350 as a bell tower the Leaning Tower of Pisa on a soft spot in the ground. With it being built only 2 meters above Sea Level the lean became obvious in the year 1178 when the third story was being built. There were three construction stops, one in 1178, one in 1185, and one in 1284, all caused by war.
Walden Journal Essay Research Paper Walden JournalI
Walden Journal Essay, Research Paper Walden Journal I sat one night and watched the white snowflakes falling against the dark back drop of night. The flakes reminded me of all the people ive seen comming together in conformaty. Each flake started out individually born in the skys and melting together to form one massive pile.
Michael FoucaultS Right Of Death And Power
Over Life? Essay, Research Paper Michael Foucault?s writing in ?Right of Death and Power Over Life? is one of the most confusing and difficult pieces of literature I have ever read. He thinks
Earthquake Essay Research Paper An earthquake is
Earthquake Essay, Research Paper An earthquake is a natural disturbance, characterized by a convulsion or concussion of the ground. Earthquakes originate at a point within the crust, when a force pushing on a mass of rock causes it to slip suddenly. Energy is released and travels, through rock, to the surface in the form of waves causing vibrations and shaking.
Michel Foucault And The Cultivation Of The
Self Essay, Research Paper Michel Foucault: The Cultivation of the Self Michel Foucault (1926-1984) spent much of the later part of his studies on the idea of the care of the self and cultivation of the self. He defined such care as using one s own reason to ascertain who one is and how he can be his best. Foucault takes several perspectives on this theme, from medical to phenomenological, to develop his focus on finding out who one is, the goal of the care of the self.
Wolf Spiders Essay Research Paper Wolf spiders
Wolf Spiders Essay, Research Paper Wolf spiders are a group of ground-dwelling hunting spiders. There are more than 2000 types of wolf spiders. They range from 2mm to 40mm. Some wolf spiders can even walk on the water of a pond. They can walk or run while chasing after it?s prey. They use their front legs to catch their prey, and then they bite and crush the prey with their powerful jaws.
Happiness Essay Research Paper Happiness is defined
Happiness Essay, Research Paper Happiness is defined in the dictionary as a pleasureable or satisfying experience. A person ability to acheive happiness is of their own free will to allow themselves to a moderate amount of the sense. EVeyrone has a different interpretation of the level of thei happiness.
Slow Dance Essay Research Paper S L
Slow Dance Essay, Research Paper S L O W D A N C E: *BR* *br* Have you ever watched kids*br* on a merry-go-round*br* Or listened to the rain*br* slapping on the ground?*br**br*
The Wretched Of The Earth A Review
Essay, Research Paper The Wretched Of The Earth: A Review Fanon’s book, “The Wretched Of The Earth” like Foucault’s “Discipline and Punish” question the basic assumptions that underlie society. Both books
Speech On Blacks Essay Research Paper Blacks
Speech On Blacks Essay, Research Paper Blacks on the Eastern Shore I enjoyed Clara Smalls presentation about blacks on the eastern shore. It was interesting to learn that in the early 1600?s blacks were primarily indentured servants. Blacks only worked for so long then could be released. Some blacks even owed land and had slaves of their own.
Field Study Report Essay Research Paper Field
Field Study Report Essay, Research Paper Field Study ReportIn the field study report the class was broken down into four groups, parking lot, grass, forest, and shrub areas. In this study students were asked to take 20 minutes out of every lab period and make a one meter plot that all measurements will be taken from.
The Rose Essay Research Paper The Roseby
The Rose Essay, Research Paper The Rose by Krystal Sedlak I look in the rose and see it’s tiny petals. They fall to the ground like tiny ashes of the love that was
Hydrologic Cycle Essay Research Paper HYDROLOGIC CYCLE
Hydrologic Cycle Essay, Research Paper HYDROLOGIC CYCLE The hydrologic cycle is a constant movement of water above, on, and below the earth’s surface. It is a cycle that replenishes ground water supplies. It begins as water vaporizes into the atmosphere from vegetation, soil, lakes, rivers, snowfields and oceans-a process called evapotranspiration.
Measuring Atmospheric Pressure Essay Research Paper Measuring
Measuring Atmospheric Pressure Essay, Research Paper Measuring Atmospheric PressureAim: To measure the atmospheric pressure in Jonkoping today, by a simple lab. Apparatus: One plastic hose. Water (colored with MnO4-). A bucket.Procedure: First, we filled a bucket and the hose with the colored water.
Low Level Waste Essay Research Paper Lowlevel
Low Level Waste Essay, Research Paper Low-level Waste facility Nuclear Fusion, a process in which two light nuclei combine to form a single heavier nucleus. An example of this is the sunrays they are the simplest form of