To Make The Choice Essay, Research Paper
This paper will introduce a case study that results in an ethical dilemma. The ethical dilemma will be
clearly stated including obligations and conflicts. Using the Contemporary Utilitarianism theory I will
analyze the ethical dilemma. Finally I will analyze the same case using an Egoistic approach as an
alternative course of action.
Case Study
An apparent 19 year old male is brought to the emergency room by ambulance in respiratory
failure related to end stage cystic fibrosis. The patient is accompanied by his girlfriend who states that the
patient has a do not resuscitate (DNR) order. As the emergency room physician tries to contact the patients
primary care physician he finds that the patient is under the care of a pediatrician which makes him
suspicious of the DNR request. He confronts the girlfriend about the patients age because the patient is
unable to communicate due to his respiratory condition. The girlfriend breaks down and admits that the
patient is actually 17 years old. The physician immediately intubates the patient in an effort to stabilize his
respiratory condition. The patients respiratory condition is stabilized after a short time and he is extubated.
The patient relates to his nurse that he does not want to be intubated again or placed on a respirator. The
nurse relays this information to the ph!
ysician who at this point does nothing. The patients mother arrives at the emergency department and the
physician explains the patients condition and his request for a DNR order. His mother refuses to sign a
DNR order and this information is explained to the patient by the physician with the mother present. A
discussion insues between the mother and her son and she reluctantly agrees to sign the DNR order.
The physician is informed of her decision and assists the mother in signing the appropriate paperwork. The
patient soon confronts the physician and makes him promise to stick to the DNR order no matter what his
condition, the physician agrees. Shortly after the DNR is completed and all other appropriate paperwork are
in order, the patient goes into respiratory arrest. All the parties involved in this situation are present when
the respiratory arrest occurs. The physician stands by will all intentions of honoring the DNR but within 30
seconds of the arrest, the mother orders the physician to intubate. The physician looks to the patient as he
shakes his head indicating that he does not want to be intubated, the physician also is aware that the patient
will be 18 years old in three weeks.
Ethical Dilemma
Initially it appears as if the dilemma revolves around what the physicians next move should be.
When actually the real dilemma is who owns the rights to make this life or death decision. It is clear what
the patient wants for his course of treatment. It is equally clear what his mother will allow his treatment to
be. Each have equally selfish reasons for wanting their decision to be upheld. The mother does not want to
lose her son and will at all costs keep him alive. She feels he is romanticizing death and has no real concept
of what dying means. Her son lived with cystic fibrosis since age four and has seen many of his friends
placed on ventilators only to later die. He does not want that quality of life in his final days. The physician
is supportive of the patients request but is placed in an awkward legal position if he abides by the patients
request. The nurse who has acted as an intermediary throughout this entire process continues to acts as a
patient advocate an ensur!
e the patients rights are observed and that his wishes are acknowledged.
Ethical Analysis of Dilemma
Contemporary Utilitarianism is divided in to four basic principles, each principle will be used to
analyze this dilemma. The first principle considers which action will provide the greatest happiness for the
greatest number. As we look at the action in this case the patient should not be allowed to discontinue
treatment because his mother and girlfriend do not wish fort him dye. This action does not provide the
greatest good and it appears that the patient looses by a vote of two to one.
The second principle is based on what the consequences of this action are, not what or how its
done but how the chosen action effects the majority. Again we find that the patients requested action of no
medical treatment and death is not the consequence that the majority wants. So the chosen action in a
bottom line analysis would not be considered good.
The third and fourth principles appear to get more egoistic in nature by definition, but remember
the basis of this theory is the greatest good for the greatest number. The final principles are centered around
human happiness and minimizing suffering. It is known that what would make our patient happy is to be
left to die with no further medical attention. The question of suffering in his mind, would be reality if he
was placed on a ventilator. This suffering would not be so much a physical pain, but a suffering of his
quality of life. To provide happiness to the majority would mean complete medical intervention. As we
attend to their happiness issue, we have also addressed and alleviated the issue of their suffering (Ufema,
1995) by prolonging the life of their loved one.
Alternative Course of Action
As an alternative to Contemporary Utilitarianism we can apply a purely Egoistic approach to the
same ethical dilemma. Egoism is very self centered and is concerned only with what benefits the
individual. This individualistic approach takes no one else?s thoughts or feelings into consideration. From
this perspective it is completely within the patients legal and moral rights (Gostin, 1993) to request that no
further medical treatment be given. The patient knows first hand that if medical treatment were to continue
that his quality of life until his death (Halliburton, Manning, and Olney, 1996) would greatly diminish.
The physician and nurse are supportive of the patients decision (Lyndaker, 1996) but have
reservations about letting someone so young die. Both the patients mother and girlfriend are against the
discontinuance of treatment. The consequences of the patients actions will result in his death a right that he
feels is his decision. His mother and girlfriend will grieve and continue to feel his decision was selfish and
wrong.
As a final course of action the Egoistic approach is essentially the action that will be taken. If the
mother refuses to comply with her sons wishes it will only be three weeks until he can take control of his
own destiny. The right to refuse treatment (Halliburton et al., 1996) is a personal and individual choice of
every human being. We have the innate right to choose what care we receive or do not receive. The age of
this patient since so close to the legal age of consent is merely semantically both morally and legally. His
desires are based on his quality of life. An issue that can only be addressed on an individual basis. No one
can or has the right to determine what the best quality of life is for another. Cases of chronic terminal
illness are heart breaking for all
concerned, but until one actually lives with that illness the final outcome should be left to the afflicted
individual.
References
Gostin, L. O. (1993). Drawing a line between killing and letting die: The law, and reform, on
medically assisted dying. Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 21 (1), 94-101
Halliburton C. S., Manning D. M., Olney R. S. (1996). Cystic fibrosis deaths in the united states
from 1979 through 1991: An analysis using the multiple-cause mortality data. Archives of Pediatrics &
Adolescent Medicine 150 (11), 1181-1199
Lydaker, C. Z. (1996). Identifying ethical values conflicts in nursing education.
NursingConnections, 9 (1), 28-33
Ufema, J. (1995). Insights on death and dying. Nursing, 25 (1), 72-73
Другие работы по теме:
The Death Penalty 11 Essay Research Paper
The Penalty of Death In this essay, H.L. Mencken has two arguments that stand out in the beginning of this essay. These arguments are against the penalty of death, although his essay is in a way, for it. The first one is, That hanging a man (or frying him or gassing him) is a dreadful business, degrading to those who have to do it and revolting to those who have to witness it . (Mencken 455).
Capital Punishment 6 Essay Research Paper CAPITAL
Capital Punishment 6 Essay, Research Paper CAPITAL PUNISHMENTCapital Punishment or Life Imprisonment? I think that capital punishment should be use more often than just life imprisonment. Life imprisonment is just not working. The death penalty does have some cons but it has its share of pros too. Lets start with the pros.
Duino Elegies Life Or Death Essay Research
Paper If someone could point out a specific meaning in Duino Elegies what would it tell us? If someone say without a doubt what Duino Elegies is about, what would they say? They might say life, they might say death, or they might say neither. In either case they would probably be right, for Duino Elegies touches upon not only life and death but many others things having to do with human existence such as love, change, loss, and pain.
Comparative Essay On Deat Essay Research Paper
Death is an aspect of life that everyone becomes acquainted with sooner or later. From my own experiences I am more familiar with death than I could ever want to be. Poetry is something that is very difficult for
Death Of Ivan Ilynch Essay Research Paper
? The Death of Ivan Ilych ? ?The Death of Ivan Ilych ? tells the story of a man on his deathbed realizing that the majority of the things he?s done throughout his life was for social acceptance. Concerned only with the thoughts of other people, his own ideas and thoughts were dismissed from importance when it came to self-image.
Near Death Experiences Essay Research Paper It
Near Death Experiences Essay, Research Paper It all begins for us at birth. We are thrust into a world of constant activity from childhood all the way up to adulthood. Life is busy and we tend not to think about the fact of our inevitable death. It doesn?t seem to make any sense that we will no longer exist as we know it.
You Must See Now Essay Research Paper
Jesus Christ is the Lord of Heaven and earth. He died on the cross for your sins and forgave you of all of the sins you’ve ever committed and ever will commit. He loves you more than life itself! Without Jesus in your life, their is no way you can go to Heaven. If your life isn’t given fully to Christ, than you will spend the rest of eternity in hell! Please don’t make the mistake of not following Jesus! He is the only way you will ever experience REAL happiness and REAL joy and TRUE peace! Please don’t make the mistake of putting Jesus off, because you are never guarunteed tomorrow! You might wake up tomorrow in your eternal state of being! Know that He is Lord, and that He saved you from death…only if you accept Him! Do you want to know you have the assurance of eternal life after death with God Almighty? All you have to do is:
AudenS Musee Des Beaux Arts And Dylans
?Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night? Essay, Research Paper Both Auden’s “Musee des Beaux Arts” and Dylans “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” can be seen as having a theme of tragedy. Both concern the topic of death, although each has a different message. Auden is one side of the spectrum saying that death and suffering are natural parts of the life cycle, while Thomas wants to fight death because there is still much to be done.
I Heard The Owl Call My NameMargaret
Craven Essay, Research Paper Margaret Craver?s novel, I Heard the Owl Call My Name, is the story of an ill, Mark Brian, who learns about life, death, and the power of love. His bishop sends him to Kingcome, an Indian village. There he learns enough of the meaning of life to be ready to die. In life people should give and share.
Death Essay Research Paper Why must there
Death Essay, Research Paper Why must there be death? Death is sad. So why must we bare sadness? Because nobody can stop death. Why do people die? Why must our loved ones die?
Death Essay Research Paper DeathDeath is the
Death Essay, Research Paper Death Death is the thing most people fear the most. I myself however do not, death can mean a lot of things. To me death is a restraint on life, a barrier
The Death Of Ivan Ilyich Leo Tolstoy
– Rebirth By Death Essay, Research Paper The Death of Ivan Ilyich: Leo Tolstoy – Rebirth by Death Leo Tolstoy was a great humanist. Evolution of human character was a subject
Edgar Allen Poe Biography Essay Research Paper
This Paper is about Edgar Allen Poe. Through out his life bad luck and misfortune seemed to follow him until his death. It seems as if from women and through out his time as an author there was no escaping it. This paper will discuss some of the misfortunes and bad luck that was in Poe’s life.
Life After Death Essay Research Paper The
Life After Death Essay, Research Paper The Afterlife is an area of human consciousness we all enter upon leaving the physical world at physical death. Throughout history we’ve questioned if there is a life after death. Along the way, our religions and various philosophers offered beliefs and opinions to answer this commonly asked question.
A Friendly Enemy Essay Research Paper A
A Friendly Enemy Essay, Research Paper A Friendly Enemy “Death is my wish for myself, my enemies, my children” (Euripedes translated by Robinson Jeffers, Medea 11). Medea is hungry for death. She wants to taste it on her lips and wishes others to do the same. The value which Medea gives death is to use it as a weapon against her enemies.
Dialogue Phaedo Death Of Socrates By Phaedo
To Echecrates Essay, Research Paper The dialogue Phaedo is a narration of the death of Socrates by Phaedo to Echecrates. One of the themes in the dialogue Phaedo is Socrates perception of death. He and those who come to visit him on the day of his execution discuss this idea of his. Socrates believes that every philosopher awaits death because it is coupled with being a philosopher.
Death Penalty Essay Research Paper Is the
Death Penalty Essay, Research Paper Is the Death Penalty Right or Wrong? Should we be able to execute people that have been convicted of murder or should we give them a chance to break out of jail and maybe kill other people. Well the Death Penalty has been around for a while ever since the Old West use to hang people for punishment.
Dying Well Essay Research Paper
“Dying Well” Death is one of the main pillars to Life because it proves that nothing is living forever, and everything in life even life itself will end. Death is part of the life every creature in this earth. Everybody is written to die someday by God either a good death or a bad death. Although some people cause death by killing others and on the other hand some people die of natural causes.
Chronicle Of A Death Foretold Essay Research
Paper Chronicle of a Death Fortold, by Gabriel Marquez, is concerned with death in life and life in death. It was rainy on the day of Santiago Nasar’s murder, and yet by the account of others, it was not. His death is so mingled with illusory images that everything seems mystified: much like death itself. The fact that the story is about how a death consumes the lives of the entire town as well as the victim, shows that it is concerned with death in life and asks us to evaluate our own views.
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper EuthanasiaEuthanasia is just
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Euthanasia Euthanasia is just another word for ?mercy killing? as some people put it but it also means good death. I look at it as more of a good death if it is performed with the right procedures and if a person has a legitimate reason to be put to death but many people would not agree with me that it should be legal.
Michael FoucaultS Right Of Death And Power
Over Life? Essay, Research Paper Michael Foucault?s writing in ?Right of Death and Power Over Life? is one of the most confusing and difficult pieces of literature I have ever read. He thinks
The Sin Of Avarice Essay Research Paper
In life everyone is searching for something or someone. Sometimes we just do not realize we have found it until it is too late. What we find may not always be what we are looking for. This is what happens in the Pardoner s Tale by Geoffry Chaucer, the three rioters are searching for death in the physical form. They do find death or rather it finds them in the very end of the story.
Life Vs Death Essay Research Paper Life
Life Vs Death Essay, Research Paper Life verses Death You listen to the speeches, they draw up the ballot, and you vote. Simple you say? I hope you don t. The matter always depends on what is on that ballot. What if the ballot read: Should the Death Penalty be used to dispose of harmful criminals? Having a hard time on which box to check? Have you ever realized the irony involved when a convicted criminal is put to death? Most of the supports see this, and delight in the “eye for an eye” mentality.
Death In Literature Essay Research Paper Death
Death In Literature Essay, Research Paper Death has been portrayed in many ways in literature, from a dark mysterious stalker to a celebration of eternal life. Every person has their own view of
The Death Of A Salesman How Biff
Shows Irresponsibility Essay, Research Paper The Death of A Salesman: How Biff Shows Irresponsibility Have you ever felt as if you do not know what to do with your life?
Edwin Arlington Robinson And Edgar Lee Masters
Essay, Research Paper The Realist Poets incorporated the theme of death into their works. Edwin Arlington Robinson and Edgar Lee Masters both wrote about thetheme of death and is clearly shown in their works. Edwin Arlington Robinson wrote ?Richard Cory?. ?And Richard Cory,one calm summer night, Went home and put a bullet through his head.? Thisis clearly showing a theme of death because he went home and killed himself.
Annie Essay Research Paper In Edger Allen
Annie Essay, Research Paper In Edger Allen Poe?s poem ?For Annie? it illustrates Poe?s life as being an illness, which has finally come to an end. For example, on lines 29 & 30 Poe writes, ?With a fever called ?Living? That burned in my brain?. It?s odd how Poe reverses the ways of death and life. He feels that life is an illness and that death is a cure for the illness called life.
Hamlet The Social And Psychological Influences On
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper The Social and Psychological Influences on Hamlet In Shakespeare s Hamlet, the influence of Hamlet s psychological and social states display his dread of death but his need to avenge his father s death. In turn, these influences illuminate the meaning of the play by revealing Hamlet s innermost thoughts on life and death and the effect of religion.
The Dead 2 Essay Research Paper Life
The Dead 2 Essay, Research Paper Life After Death James Joyce states it best saying, Better pass boldly into that world, in the full glory of some passion, than fade and wither dismally with age (p.143). Not only is he talking primarily about the death of relationships, but also that of literal death and other mortalities and the way they take shape.
Masque Of Red Death Essay Research Paper
The Masque of Red Death: The Masque of Poe People don’t really have that much in common, but they do have one big thing in common, that is death. Death is the one thing that no one can
The Masque Of The Red Death 2
Essay, Research Paper “The Masque of the Red Death” is a very interesting story. It deals with the deadly red death that can kill in a half-hour. The ruler of the kingdom where the red death started is King Prospero. He was a selfish and cruel man. He basically left his people to die.
Death Of A Toad Essay Research Paper
People have many different ways of dealing with one of the most feared and respected portion of the human life cycle, death. Death is unavoidable, and we all meet our ends sooner or later. Many people react to the death of a loved one with remorse and sadness, some rejoice it as beginning of the afterlife, but no matter how we deal with death, we all come to accept it.
Is Emily Dickinson On Drugs Essay Research
Paper 4/26/98Is Emily Dickinson on Drugs? Emily Dickinson’s poems often make me ponder her mental stability. Sometimes I wonder if she was psychotic or on some kind of mind-altering drugs. In Dickinson’s poems “I felt a funeral in my brain,” “My life closed twice before its close,” and “Because I could not stop for Death,” we shall see whether or not Mr.
Antigone Essay Research Paper Antigone and The
Antigone Essay, Research Paper Antigone and The Mother Death surrounds us all. It is a common reminder of the life we have around us. Death is seen in people, nature, and animal’s everyday. It brings us sadness and pain. It is something that is not easily dealt with and sometimes may seem unjust. It helps us become better people by accepting death and learning from it.
The Human Comedy Essay Research Paper Human
The Human Comedy Essay, Research Paper Human Maturity William Saroyan s The Human Comedy, deals with ravages of life. Due to these trials, Homer is forced to mature. How he matures is a result of facing the challenges. Two very import themes that help homer mature are family and death.