Relations In Brazil And The United States. Essay, Research Paper
Neither Black nor White by Carl N Degler (The MacMillan Company, New York: 1971) is a comparative analysis of the developments of slavery, with an emphasis on miscegenation between the United States and Brazil during the Colonial period. This work is an attempt to understand the nature of black and white relations in the United States by seeing such relations in a different national and social context. Mr. Degler’s original aim was to compare all of Latin American slavery to that of the United States, but after realizing the tremendous scope of such a task, chose to limit his analysis to a single Latin American nation. Brazil was selected because it rivaled the United States in size and because slavery played a major role in its history. Mr. Degler originally began exploring this topic with the intention of writing a scholarly essay to be published in a scholarly journal, but soon became fascinated with the topic and decided to turn the essay into a book. Mr. Degler engaged in writing this book with two questions in mind; Did slavery in Brazil differ substantially from that of the United States? And What accounted for the different development of race miscegenation in Brazil and the United States? Initially, Degler ascribed to the theory laid out by previous historians, that Slavery in South America was more humane, because of the sympathy of the Catholic Church towards slavery, and Portuguese Laws, which recognized the human rights of slaves. Believed to be in direct contrast with American slavery, which held that slaves were chattel property and possessed no rights the law was required to recognize. The Historians credited with advancing this position were; Frank Tannenbaum in his book Slave and Citizen: The Negro in the Americas (Alfred A. Knopf, New York: 1946) and Stanley M. Elkins in his book Slavery: A Problem in American Institutional and Intellectual Life (Chicago University Press: 1959). However, after further examination Mr. Degler changes his opinion and within the text of his book Neither Black nor White, presents data that substantiates the claim, that there was little or no difference in the legal definition of slavery between Brazil and the United States. He also argues that Brazilian slavery was physically harsher, thereby less humane, than that of the United States. The author offers six chapters in an effort to support his conclusions. Chronologically outlined the chapters are; The Challenge of the Contrast, Slavery Compared, The Outer Burdens of Color, The Roots of Difference, and A Contrast in the Future?
The purpose of chapter One is two define the contrasts in background between Brazil and the United States. Degler systematically examines several topics including: history, education, literature, visual arts, segregation, and engineering. Within each topic Mr. Degler gives concise examples of how Brazil embraced Negro contributions where American counterparts either suppressed or totally negated the possibility of Negro contribution. By illustrating the differences between the two countries, the author is preparing the reader to explore the question; how did countries with similar systems of slavery develop such different ideologies with regards to the acceptance of Negroes in society.
The Second and lengthiest chapter of Mr. Degler’s book is entitled, Slavery Compared. As the title suggests the author closely compares slavery between the two countries. The basis for his examination is the nineteenth century. The two factors that facilitated the selection of this time period where, that slavery was well established in both countries, and a wealth of evidence existed for making the comparison, during the time period. Under the sub-title, Who Protects the Slave’s Humanity? The author chronicles the fact that there was virtually no difference in the legal definition of a slave between the two countries. This is offered in contrast to one of the traditionalist arguments (Tannenbaum & Elkins), which asserts that Brazilian law did not consider slaves as chattel property like their American counterpart, thereby making Brazilian law more humane. As evidence he cites court records from both Brazil and the United States, which grants slaves dual status, as property and as persons. After acknowledging the superior clarity in which Brazilian law recognizes the human rights of slaves, he focuses on the protection of slaves from unjust treatment by their masters under the law in both countries, which he asserts meant nothing due to the fact that plantation owners operated with virtual anonymity with respects to the treatment of slaves, again in both countries.
The traditional view also holds that the Catholic Church was responsible for making slavery more humane in Brazil by allowing slaves to join congregations, form religious fraternal brotherhoods and recognizing marriages. In refute of this point, Degler argues that like the government of Brazil, the Catholic Church was not in any position to affect a significant number of slaves, citing the fact that many slaves only came into contact with pastors once a year. The author’s opinion seems to be that the differences between Brazil and the United States with regard to the law and religion existed on paper and in doctrine but not in actuality.
Brazil contained a significantly larger population of free blacks than that of the United States. Traditionalists espouse the large number of free blacks in Brazil to mean that Brazil was more accepting of free blacks. However, Degler attributes the large number of free blacks in Brazil to three factors. The first, being that there were simply more slaves in Brazil therefore resulting in more manumissions. The second factor being the practice of Portuguese slave owners freeing sick, elderly or crippled slaves in an effort to ditch future responsibilities, financially or otherwise. The third factor Degler attributes is the acceptance of free people regardless of color by the Portuguese; they did not fear agitation or reprisal from free blacks as their white counterparts in America. He offers the fact that there were jobs that needed to be preformed by free blacks and as a result, the Portuguese had no major qualms about manumissions. Chapter two concludes with the difference in slavery between the United States and Brazil being attributed to demographic, geographic and economic reasons, rather than as Tannenbaum and Elkins suggest, Religion or Law.
The third chapter is entitled The Outer Burdens of Color. This chapter seeks to compare the contemporary challenges faced by Brazilians and Americans with regard to racial qualifications. Within the sub-topic Who is a Negro, professor Degler clearly defines the term I the two countries. In North America the term is used to describe anyone who contains any measurable amount of black blood. In contrast Brazilians only classify individuals with pure African blood as Negroes, reserving special categories for anyone who fall in between. A term used to describe the various racial mixtures is Mulatto. This term has varying degrees according to Mr. Degler based on observable characteristics. The author does acknowledge the existence of negative attitudes towards blacks on Brazil. The author goes on to enumerate that discrimination in Brazil is more covert than in the United States and he cites the location of people of color at the bottom of the social and economic pyramids. He offers several first hand examples of discrimination in contemporary Brazil. Seeming extremely contradictory at best. Mr. Degler ends chapter three without concretely outlining the causes of discrimination in Brazil. Chapter four: The Inner Burdens of Color focuses on the psychological realizations that dark skinned Brazilians and Americans place on themselves. Degler contends that colored people in Brazil accept their place in society and do not try to make issues about being included or the lack there of. Dark skinned peoples are reported to have low self esteem, and harbor resentment toward being dark and having an affection for the lighter skinned individuals. Degler concludes that if a dark person improves his lot he will indelibly try to separate himself as far from similar complexes people as possible. A charge many no scholarly black folk have been making for years in the United States. “In Brazil, as in the United States, the better educated, the more skillful, and the wealthier portion of the colored population are mulattoes. Thanks to the mulatto escape hatch, however these natural, potential leaders are encouraged to see themselves as different-indeed better-Negroes.” Degler credits the separation of the colored in Brazil as the reason for the lack of movement or political organization in Brazil along racial lines. However the fact that all colored in the United States are considered Negro then this perpetuates the social and political formation of organizations aimed at improving the lot of all blacks. According to probate and literary evidence interracial marriage is frowned upon in Brazil as in the United States. Mr. Degler’s attempt describes and explains the causes for the nuances between black and whites in Brazil falls tremendously short. However an applaud able effort was given to the task.
In the remaining two chapters Mr. Degler confronts and recaps his arguments concerning The Historical Dimension, The Presence of the Mulatto and his escape hatch, and Political and National Ideologies.
In summation of Mr. Degler efforts to answer his two main question; “to determine if slavery in Brazil differed from that in the United States?” and to “account for the difference in race relations in Brazil and the United States?” Maxine Margolis in her critique of Mr. Degler’s book contends, “hHesucceeds in his first goal” but is “less successful in his attempt to explain the contrasting features of contemporary race relations in Brazil and the United States.” I agree with Mrs. Margolis’s opinion. It is my belief that he fails in the latter of his two questions because of the peculiarity and sensitivity of the question that in my opinion has no blanketing explanation but rather a series of circumstances and situation that form from various experiences that are perpetuated my discriminatory practices which continue to this day, both in Brazil and the United States. As for Mr. Degler himself he sees the key difference in race relations between Brazil and the United states as difference of the status of the mulatto. He feels that out of this racial divide separate race relations grew in each country. Degler was awarded the Pulitzer Prize, a distinguished literary award, for his study on race relations in Brazil and the United States. Professor Degler is married with two children and lives in Stanford California. He is currently a Professor of History at Stanford University. “ This work needs to be read by all those concerned with race relations in the Western Hemisphere.”
Critical Book Review
Degler, Carl N. Neither Black nor White: Slavery and Race Relations in Brazil and the United States.
Bibliography
Degler, Carl N. Niether Black nor White: Slavery and Race Relations in Brazil and the United States. The MACMILLIAN COMPANY,NEW YORK 1971.
Другие работы по теме:
Freedom Essay Research Paper After the Civil
Freedom Essay, Research Paper After the Civil War, state legislatures enacted codes to define or limit the freedom of the slaves. These Black Codes, as they were called, were in essence an extension another revised form of slavery. U.S. legislation declared all slaves free, and then allowed the individual states to enact their own regulations to control or limit that freedom.
Three Abolitionists Essay Research Paper Olaudh Equiano
Three Abolitionists Essay, Research Paper Olaudh Equiano, Abraham Lincoln, and Frederick Douglas have all been described as abolitionists. Equiano is the eldest of the three and his writings were a model for slave narratives. Douglas is very similar to Equianoe in a way that they are both descriptive. Lincoln is different because he is the only caucasian one out of the three.
Slavery In Us Essay Research Paper Slavery
Slavery In Us Essay, Research Paper Slavery, one of the most horrible experiences for blacks in the U.S. they were tortured and beaten. They had to do anything that their owner told them. Soon a man named Abraham Lincoln came to their rescue and freed the slaves. Soon after Blacks gained independence they were allowed to use public bathrooms, and most important their right to vote.
Plessy V Ferguson Essay Research Paper Plessy
Plessy V. Ferguson Essay, Research Paper Plessy v. Ferguson 1892 campus.northpark.edu/history/WebChron/USA/PlessyFerguson.html Abraham Lincoln’s success in the Civil War and the end of slavery sparked a new era for the Black race in America. The “Black Codes” passed following the Civil War, gave Blacks equal rights in the United States.
Elite African Americans Essay Research Paper During
Elite African Americans Essay, Research Paper During the Reconstruction period, congress sent to the states three important new amendments the Constitution. The Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery, while the Fourteenth Amendment made black citizens, equal to their white counterparts. The fifteenth Amendment states that no citizens could be stopped from voting because of their race or color.
The True Greatness Of Abraham Lincoln Essay
, Research Paper The True Greatness of Abraham Lincoln Abraham Lincoln is known as one of the greatest presidents in the history of The United States, mainly for his emancipation of slaves. But was Lincoln really an advocate of the rights of blacks? Lincoln had the intention of preserving the Union and satisfying the American people, yet he was indecisive about his racial views of mid-nineteenth century America.
Race Essay Research Paper Lori DinovitzCassandra HolcumbAfter
Race Essay, Research Paper Lori Dinovitz Cassandra Holcumb After reading three different articles, it was proven that race is still a major issue in the United States today. These articles include, Ginger Thompson?s (2000), ?Reaping What Was Sown on the Old Plantation,? about an old slave plantation that was sold of into a National Park. ?At the Slaughterhouse, Some Things Never Die,? by Charlie LeDuff (2000) talks about the racial segregation and discrimination found in a small town in North Carolina.
Slavery Essay Research Paper Slavery the practice
Slavery Essay, Research Paper Slavery the practice of one person owning another ? this type of practice has existed since ancient times. In the United States slaves from Africa were bought and sold like property. Although at first there were slaves in both the northern and southern part of the United States, by the early nineteenth century, slavery had died out in the North.
Race In The Context Of Reading And
Writing Essay, Research Paper Race In the Context of Reading and Writing Hurston is saying in effect, I am colored but I am different from other members of my race in that I am not different from my race ( Race, Reading, and Difference 319).
Beloved By Toni Morisson Essay Research Paper
Beloved is actually a quintessentially American story. Its topic slavery however may not seem to be a traditional one in American literature. The novel written by Toni Morrison is an American survivor?s tale, which depicts the collective experience of slavery defined by the identity of the black community in America for years.
Black Essay Research Paper Black Soldiers in
Black Essay, Research Paper Black Soldiers in the Union Army During the Seventeenth, Eighteenth and part of the Nineteenth Century the White People of North America used the Black people of Africa as slaves to benefit their interests. White people created a climate of superiority of their race over the Black African race that in some places, still lingers on today.
Everthing That Rises Must Converge Essay Research
Paper Everthing That Rises Must Converge In “Everything That Rises Must Converge,” Flannery O”Connor used two fictional characters, Julian and his mothers, to contrast with each other on how they react to different changes that were taking place in their lives. From the outlook, the story took place in a time when slavery was outlawed in America and when black people were allowed to ride on bused with white people.
The Emperor Jones Essay Research Paper The
The Emperor Jones Essay, Research Paper The Emperor JonesIn Eugene O’Neil’s play, The Emperor Jones, he presents a crucial lesson to mankind: one should not pretend to be someone who he is not. Multiple repercussions may occur to someone who denies their background and race. For example, in The Emperor Jones, the character, Brutus Jones, dissembles as a free white man (Jones was really black and was supposed to be in slavery during that time).
Of Mice And MenOutcasts Essay Research Paper
Of Mice and Men In the novel, Of Mice and Men, Crooks and Curley s wife could both be considered outcasts. Crooks could be considered an outcast because of his race. Curley s wife could be considered an outcast because most of the characters believe trouble always follows her. Both Crooks and Curley s wife are thought of as social outcasts for various reasons, such as race and reputation.
To Be A Slave Essay Research Paper
To Be A Slave Essay submitted by Anonymous The only things that come to my mind when I think of slavery and of the book To be a Slave are either misunderstanding or very negative. During the slavery years, African
Response To Balck Bourgeoise Essay Research Paper
Black Bourgeoisie Reading Response In the first section of Frazier?s Black Bourgeoisie, ?The World of Reality?, Frazier introduces his discussion of the interplay of class and race. He outlines the historical roots of the social place of most African-Americans in the U.S.A. and that of the black middle class.
Racism The Precedent To Slavery In North
America Essay, Research Paper Racism: The Precedent to Slavery in North America In tracing the origins of slavery or racism in either sense, one must keep in mind that neither is an event or circumstance that occurred in North America in the 17th through 19th centuries. We must examine slavery as an institution and racism as a mentality defined by the oppressor, independent to the oppressed.
Antigone Essay Research Paper The Significance of
Antigone Essay, Research Paper The Significance of Historical Setting Desiree?s Baby, by Kate Chopin, is not only a story about a mother and her child, but one of hatred and prejudices during the time in which they lived. Armand Aubigny, not knowing the origin of Desiree, fell madly in love with her as quick as a pistol shot.
The Race Of Devil Essay Research Paper
“The white race is a race of devils created by their maker to do evil, and make evil appear as good; The white race is the natural unchangeable enemy of the black man, who is the original man, owner, maker, cream of the planet earth.” This paragraph is taken from Soul on Ice written by Eldridge Cleaver. I think that the white race is not just the enemy of black men.
What Melville Is Sayng About Evil In
“Benito Cereno” Essay, Research Paper The story ?Benito Cereno? is one that puts the reader in the position of making sense out of total chaos. This is done literally in the beginning when Delano steps onto the San Dominick; and is done later when the reader is supposed to figure out who was good and who was evil.
Affirmative Action Reverse Discrimination Essay Research Paper
Affirmative Action = Reverse Discrimination We are all aware that discrimination took place over 50 years ago. What some might not be aware of is that because of the actions of our ancestors, we, white males, are held responsible and are penalized because of these actions. Affirmative action is a way to help minorities in sex and race to get accepted into colleges or get hired for jobs while the white males suffer from what took place over 50 years ago.
GrecoRoman History Essay Research Paper The extent
Greco-Roman History Essay, Research Paper The extent to which the debate over slavery was not really about black people but about whites can be seen politically, socially, religiously and economically.
Freedom Not Always The Answer Essay Research
Paper Freedom, not Always the Answer It is a popular misconception that the northern states, in pre-Civil War days, were not prejudice. In fact, in some cases, the opposite is true. The North and South both had their shares of racism. It didn’t matter where you were at. If you were a black, you weren’t human. Even free blacks were despised, feared, and thought to be less than human.
Race Essay Research Paper Race a
Race Essay, Research Paper Race ? a sense of identity What is the definition of race? We divide people into groups by their skin color – black, yellow and whites. Maybe it is time to change this. The Swedish population and other populations as well, are nowadays a mixed group of people. White people are black people’s neighbors, doctors and friends.
ANALYSIS OF THE ROLE OF BLACKSOLDIERS IN
THE CIVIL WAR Essay, Research Paper During the Civil War many blacks chose to fight for the Federal Army against the Confederacy. Black soldiers were discriminated against and at first restricted from combat. Later in the war the colored regiments saw some of the most extensive combat of the war. Thousands of blacks volunteered to fight to free their people from the horrors of slavery.
It Was A Year Essay Research Paper
It was a year Review of Before the Mayflower It was a year of funerals and births, a year of endings and a year of beginnings, a year of hate, a year of love It was a year of passion, a year of despair, a year of desperate hope. These words mark what could be any year known to man, no matter race or creed. Before the Mayflower is a book that opened my eyes about the history of the African Americans, before they were brought over to the US.
Song Of Solomn Essay Research Paper Guitar
Song Of Solomn Essay, Research Paper Guitar loves his race and will do anything for it. He wants to keep the number of black and white people equal so that the whites do not become the dominant race. Guitar wants the blacks to have the ability to achieve a better life. But his love and attempts to preserve and advance his race actually turn him against himself and his race.
Why Slavery Essay Research Paper Captivity bondage
Why Slavery? Essay, Research Paper Captivity, bondage, restraint, subjugation, and slavery. These words all mean one thing, enslaving someone against their will. Slavery was an episode in history that scarred, many African men, women and children. Slavery tore families apart, shattered dreams, and left African?s feeling shameful and hopeless.
Slavery 2 Essay Research Paper SlaverySlavery was
Slavery 2 Essay, Research Paper Slavery Slavery was the most common form of forced labor in History. Slavery was very bad and wrong. A slave was treated like property and not like a Human Being and owned by other Human Being s.
Frederick Douglass 4 Essay Research Paper Douglass
Frederick Douglass 4 Essay, Research Paper Douglass Portrayal of Women in Slavery in His Narrative Frederick Douglass portrays the black and white women in The Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass at two opposite extremes in his innovative way of using the literary device of contrast to make his views clear and distinct to his readers.
Is There Racism In Huck Finn Essay
, Research Paper Is there Racism in Huckleberry Finn? As we look into issues of racism in the South we have to look at the time and setting of this book. It?s before the Civil War and during slavery when black people were property and not people. Twain?s intent on writing is to show the adventures of Huck and his close friends, and not on the issues of slavery.
Color Of Water Essay Research Paper One
Color Of Water Essay, Research Paper One aspect of identity where feedback can be given almost instantaneously is race, as it involves a person’s skin color. Young children often ignore each others’ races unless they
Annotation Of Psych Article Essay Research Paper
Emily W. Goldfrank Assignment 3-3 11/14/00 Annotations Wegner & Crano, 1975 Subjects consisted of 144 students, equally divided with respect to race and gender, from a large Midwestern university. Experimenters consisted of 12 college students, also equally divided with respect to race and gender. Each experimenter tested 3 of each race-gender combination.