In the novel Crime and Punishment, by Fyodor Dostoevsky, suffering is an integral part of every character’s role. Dostoevsky uses comic characters as instruments for competing ideological issues. A typical example is the loquacious bar room character Marmeladov, an alcoholic with an ironic abstract side to his personality. Through his behavior, Marmeladov draws the reader’s attention to questions about environmental and psychological influence and theology and specifically, the conflict between organized religion and personal spirituality. His confession to Raskolnikov sets the stage for a complex pattern of cross references to these ideas and their impact on the main characters. At the center of these related questions is Marmeladov’s self-assured claim that he knows that redemptive suffering will lead to salvation, such as when he tells Raskolnikov that he knows with certainty that God has a special place reserved in heaven for repentant drinkers: then He will summon us… Come forth ye drunkards… and He will hold out His hands to us and we shall fall down before Him… (Dostoevsky 20).
Connected to this theological side of Marmeladov, and the basis of a psychological subtext, is his enjoyment of self-induced suffering, such as the abuse of Katerina Ivanovna when he returns home after drinking. He says, This does not hurt me, but is a positive consolation. (Dostoevsky 23). Dostoevsky uses Marmeladov’s comic behavior to counterpoint the metaphysical guilt that Raskolnikov tries to suppress. His justification appeals to Raskolnikov not only because it vindicates the behavior of neglected, poor people, but more importantly because it offers an unconventional view of moral masochism right at the very moment when Raskolnikov is contemplating ruining his life with the lie of murder in the name of humanitarianism, or a crime in the name of a higher good.
However, it is Sonia, the holy fool who is forced to work as a prostitute, who will eventually bring this lie to the surface. In the meantime, Raskolnikov will be drawn into her family through the
actions of her father and due to his need to suffer and then seek atonement. The recurrence of the parallel of shame and redemptive suffering in Crime and Punishment is essential in understanding the role of suffering. Victimized and burdened people like Marmeladov lead to a kind of spiritual power through their eccentric personalities. A similar pattern of self-conscious shame and redemptive suffering is played out in several other situations, especially those involving Marmeladov s wife Katerina. She, too, like her husband, owns little except her complaints about an absurd world, and her symbolically bloody handkerchief. She blames her misfortune on the environment and social circumstances (Dostoevsky 14) . From the point-of-view of Dostoevsky’s Christian philosophy, she brings to light the Orthodox view of spiritual fallenness.
The voice of Dostoevsky, the man, is only heard on the level of the novel’s subtext. Dostoevsky never lets his Christian beliefs overwhelm a dialogue between two characters or direct the flow of an argument. Dostoevsky lets these ideological differences exist side by side, in irreconcilable tension. Thus, the conflict between personal guilt and unfavorable social circumstance can only sharpen the sense of the incompatibility between deterministic psychology and faith. This seems to be the reason Dostoevsky introduces the cases of suffering of Dounia and Sonia, giving up great aspects of their life for the greater good. As one struggles to keep her family together and surviving with few resources, the other must give up her name and respectability to become a prostitute and raise money to support her family. The similarity and significance are great in that they contrast directly to the reasoning and consequences of Raskolnikov s crime.
Raskolnikov is so torn apart by conflicting thoughts and desires that he often seems to be two characters. Indeed, Dostoevsky’s technique is to surround Raskolnikov with complementary or
opposing characters that mirror his repressed inner self. One side of his personality is aggressive and detached, like Svidrigailov, while the other is caring and compassionate, like Sonia. In a schematic sense, Sonia is a double that represents his spiritual, ethereal side, and Svidrigailov a double that stands for his physical, agnostic side. Throughout the novel, Raskolnikov moves, alternately, from one to the other as he attempts to resolve the burden of a guilty conscience.
After the crime, these two alter egos compete for Raskolnikov’s attentions. However, because of his pride, he tries to hide from any open acknowledgment of either one. This mask of denial is the basis of Dostoevsky’s irony in scenes where Raskolnikov is clearly drawn to the spiritual side of Sonia or the criminal side of Svidrigailov. Raskolnikov especially finds it hard to admit that he is drawn to a self-denying victim like Sonia because it violates his idea of the extraordinary person. It is easier to identify with an aggressive victimizer like Svidrigailov because he embodies the ruthless behavior of a man who has overstepped the laws of society. However, basically Raskolnikov is attracted to these opposing doubles, it is a conflict between innate feelings and ideology. Sonia represents Raskolnikov’s innate morality and the goodness of his heart, while Svidrigailov stands for the evil of abstract theories, and when Svidrigailov dies, the theoretical voice of Raskolnikov’s personality seems to fade out and the Sonya voice begins to speak with greater conviction, which becomes Raskolnikov s most important first step towards his confession.
Другие работы по теме:
God Suffering Essay Research Paper The MidWives
God Suffering Essay, Research Paper The Mid-Wives “feared God” and so the saved the baby boys. The story shows that if we voice our concerns and obey God then all of our hopelessness and anger will in time be relieved. As we discussed in class, they used civil disobedience. They resisted actively but not violently.
Sonnet About Death Essay Research Paper Death
Sonnet About Death Essay, Research Paper Death is full of sorrow and surprise Sooner or later it comes at anytime. Even though I do not remember my demise In my hearts I still remember my greatest crime.
Capital Punishment 6 Essay Research Paper CAPITAL
Capital Punishment 6 Essay, Research Paper CAPITAL PUNISHMENTCapital Punishment or Life Imprisonment? I think that capital punishment should be use more often than just life imprisonment. Life imprisonment is just not working. The death penalty does have some cons but it has its share of pros too. Lets start with the pros.
Drugs In Society Essay Research Paper The
Drugs In Society Essay, Research Paper The most significant problem facing young people in the inner city today is one problem but many problems put together. The use of drugs and the crime that occurs all intertwine and form one big problem. Also the lack of education doesn t help the young people either.
Ethnobotany Essay Research Paper An Available OptionTry
Ethnobotany Essay, Research Paper An Available Option Try to imagine yourself or someone you hold close to you being very sick, so sick that just being alive each day gives more pain and suffering than the previous day. Not one person should have to suffer from a disease that is incurable and leads inevitably to death.
Human Value Essay Research Paper The criminal
Human Value Essay, Research Paper The criminal mind of Raskolnikov- His inability to conquer his conscience after the murder. human ValueIs it acceptable for some human beings to suffer and die and not for others? In the novel Crime and Punishment, Dostoevsky offers his solution through the character of Raskolnikov.
Crime Essay Research Paper I m writing
Crime Essay, Research Paper I m writing an essay on crime and theories of crime and I will try and convince you the crimes are committed out of greed. I feel if there was no greed in the world, there would be no crime in the world. A lot of people would disagree with me and or feel that eliminating greed is impossible and will never happen during the course of life as we know it.
Effiecent Freeway Driving Essay Research Paper Hate
Effiecent Freeway Driving Essay, Research Paper Hate Crimes To what extent is a crime a hate crime? Aren t all crimes to some extent hate crimes? Should the consequences for a crime committed against a minority be more than that for one against a white person? The purpose for classifying a crime as a hate crime might be to raise awareness in the public to the intolerance against minorities but I believe the punishment should fit the crime and not the reason for the crime.
Crimonology Essay Research Paper If you look
Crimonology Essay, Research Paper If you look up the word criminology in the dictionary it would be defined as a scientific study of crime as a social phenomenon. Social phenomenon? Say what?
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In today
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, if you ask five people who Jack Kevorkian is then three or more would know who he is. The issue of euthanasia has been on the media’s forefront for several years. There are several pros and cons to this issue. Some of these pros are as follows: it would help to end pain and suffering, it allows a person to die with dignity, and it also helps the grieving process because the person knows when they are gonna die.
Assisted Suicide 4 Essay Research Paper ASSISTED
Assisted Suicide 4 Essay, Research Paper ASSISTED SUICIDE I feel that assisted suicide is a practice that should not only be legally acceptable, but socially acceptable as well. No one should be forced to live a life of pain and suffering. After all, aren’t we all guaranteed the rights of life, liberty, and happiness? If happiness means freedom from pain and suffering, then assisted suicide should be legalized.
Hungrey Essay Research Paper Global hunger is
Hungrey? Essay, Research Paper Global hunger is a major concern that effects the whole world. According to Peter Singer ?the whole way we look at moral issues-our moral conceptual scheme
Criminal Justice Essay Research Paper Jason C
Criminal Justice Essay, Research Paper Jason C. Clifton Clifton 1 Criminology CRJ 470 Nevelle Jones Assignment 20 July 17, 2000 High Tech Offenders What different kinds of high-tech offenders can you
Legalizing Euthanasia Essay Research Paper Legalizing euthanasia
Legalizing Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper Legalizing euthanasia in the United States gives rights to the people. Rights to those who endure the irrefutable agony of pain and suffering, rights to those who want to be cured of their pain, and rights to those that struggle to end their suffering. Euthanasia is the answer to end their suffering.
King Lear Suffering Essay Research Paper King
King Lear: Suffering Essay, Research Paper King Lear: Suffering Suffering takes on many appearances, depending on how it is received. In King Lear, suffering was very painful to two people, and the giver wasn’t
Capital Punishment 12 Essay Research Paper Capital
Capital Punishment 12 Essay, Research Paper Capital punishment is the penalty of death for a crime. It has been part of the world’s criminal justice system since the time of Babylonia’s Hammurabic Code. The system of capital punishment is full of injustices and inequalities. All the arguements for the death penalty ared filled with holes.
Handgun Essay Research Paper HandgunBecause the prison
Handgun Essay, Research Paper Handgun Because the prison population has doubled since 1984, it is really urgent for people to pay attention to the method of decreasing the crime rate. Basically, it is true that “locking people up is obviously not the answer to the crime problem. Training and educating people is one answer.” (Los Angeles Time, Joseph Mayfield) But training and educating people to lower the crime rate may only work under some conditions.
Raskolnikov S Suffering In Crime And Punishment
Essay, Research Paper Raskolnikov s Suffering in Crime and Punishment In Fyodor Dostoevsky s novel, Crime and Punishment, suffering is an integral part of every introduced character s role. However, the message that Dostoevsky wants to present with the main character, Raskolnikov, is not one of the Christian idea of salvation through suffering.
Th Scarlet Letter Essay Research Paper The
Th Scarlet Letter Essay, Research Paper The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorne, the heroine is admired becuase of her strong will, and disregard for other’s views of her.
Crime And Ethnicity Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Ethnicity Essay, Research Paper Crime and Ethnicity A crime rate difference among ethnic groups is probably a cultural universal. Chinese and Japanese Americans have lower crime rates then other Americans: Irish immigrants to England have higher crime rates. In Sweden, Hungarian and Yugoslav immigrants have a higher crime rate.
1984 Book Report Essay Research Paper Winston
1984 Book Report Essay, Research Paper Winston’s first act of rebellion is buying and writing in a diary. This act is known as a thought crime and is punishable by death. A thought crime is any bad thought against the government of Oceania. Winston commits many thought crimes and becomes paranoid about being caught, which he knows is inevitable (Greenblast 113).
Crime And Resources Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Resources Essay, Research Paper Crime in the United States (CIUS), published annually by the FBI, is a compilation of the Uniform Crime Reports (UCR) provided by over 16,000 policing jurisdictions. It represents one of the two primary sources of data about crime in the United States, the National Crime Victimization Survey (NCVS) being the other.
Organized Crime Essay Research Paper What underlying
Organized Crime Essay, Research Paper What underlying factors lead to the prevalence of organized crime? Organized crime by definition means crime that is committed by a number of people that are organized in a series of networks. These crimes that are committed are often well planned out and involve a number of people all working together under one, or sometimes a few, men in power and leaders of the group.
Motherless Brooklyn Essay Research Paper Motherless Brooklyn
Motherless Brooklyn Essay, Research Paper Motherless Brooklyn is about crime-scene detective Lionel Essrog. Lionel becomes diagnosed with Tourette?s syndrome. He?s unable to refrain from shouting obscene words to people who pass him on the street or he compulsively tabs people on the shoulder as he passes.
Crime And Punishment Essay Research Paper In
Crime And Punishment Essay, Research Paper In the novel Crime and Punishment, by Fyodor Dostoevsky, suffering is an important part of every character’s role. However, the message that Dostoevsky wants to present with the main character, Raskolnikov, is not one of the Christian ideas of deliverance through suffering.
Suffering Crime And Punishment Essay Research Paper
Suffering in Crime and Punishment In the novel Crime and Punishment, by Fyodor Dostoevsky, suffering is an integral part of every character’s role. However, the message that Dostoevsky wants to present with the main character, Raskolnikov, is not one of the Christian idea of salvation through suffering.
What Is Cruel And Unusual Essay Research
Paper Cruel and unusual, these two words have caused much debate on the issue of capital punishment. In the eighth amendment it states that cruel and unusual punishment should not be inflected. But what does cruel and unusual mean? Cruel means “causing pain and suffering” and the word unusual means “not usual; beyond the ordinary; not in common use; uncommon”.
Guns Problem Essay Research Paper These activists
Guns Problem Essay, Research Paper These activists are also taking the guns out of the wrong peoples hands. They work to pass laws that would take the guns from the law-abiding citizens. When we give people the right to defend themselves, criminals start looking for victims who are unable to do so. For this reason we must work to reduce crime in America and look at the problem realistically. develop plans that would address the real problem of crime.
Oedipus Rex Essay Research Paper Oedipus RexIn
Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper Oedipus Rex In the story of Oedipus Rex, Sophocles portrays the main character, Oedipus, as a good natured person that has bad judgment and frailty. Oedipus
Crime In Nyc Essay Research Paper i
Crime In Nyc Essay, Research Paper i think that crime is the most serious pronlem in nyc today because the have too much drugs guns rapiest pickpockets and hit and run drivers. Crime is very high in nyc.The people in nyc needed more cops in the subway parks maybe that qill lower crime.Some time you would call 911 if the drug activities in your area you have to qait at least halfhour for them to come to me more young pwople are getting involve in crines these days ages renges from 9-17yrs most of them ends rp in jail by the time they are twenty years old.