Nazi Research Experiments Essay, Research Paper
?In the interest of…saving lives, is it acceptable to make use of data collected through mutilation, torture, and death? (Campbell, 16)? That is the question which has been rearing its head in scientific research since the end of World War II. As man has sought to quench his thirst for knowledge, lines of ethicality have been drawn to preserve the integrity of science, and provide a framework from which man can improve upon the quality of human life. In Nazi concentration and death camps, the gruesome sibling of science matured. Nazi scientists, physicians, and scholars tore down the ethical framework of science in order to eliminate the genetically inferior, and ultimately, attempt to forge a ?pure? race of ?super-humans?. Members of the Nazi scientific community were to serve as ?alert biological soldiers? (Crum, 33). These ?soldiers? conducted research on non-consenting camp inmates in order to ?demonstrate a hereditary basis for group differences in behavioral and physical characteristics? in humans (Caplan, 286). The most well known experiments in this regard were the experiments conducted on twins at Auschwitz.
The other goal of the Nazi scientists was to provide human data that could be applied to the war effort. Experimentation of this sort mainly probed the extremes, which the human body could tolerate in a hostile environment. The most famous experiment of this sort was the ?Dachau Hypothermia Study.? The rationale of the experiments was as follows:
?A consequence of air combat and air campaigns was that pilots were shot down and landed in cold water. In addition, the German Navy was losing a large number of personnel in the cold North Sea. There were no data available to document how long the downed pilots could survive in the frigid North Sea. The solution to these questions, as well as others, was considered important by certain groups of Nazi administrators and scientists. From a historical point of view, at that time, the number of papers that had been published that dealt with human response to cold water and/or air was very limited…therefore, the German scientists were seeking answers to ?legitimate scientific goals? (Caplan, 98).
The last line, ?…German scientists were seeking answers to ?legitimate scientific goals??, is the statement which is the prime concern of this paper.
In order to accomplish their ?goals,? Nazi scientists conducted human experiments, virtually all of which, ended in the subjects? murder. How can answers to ?legitimate scientific goals? be found in murder? Should these experiments even be considered ?science?? Furthermore, should these experiments be allowed to provide quotable data to the modern scientific community?
The debate on whether or not science should allow referencing to Nazi data rages. Objectors to using Nazi data, state that by using the data from the Nazis? human experimentation, researchers are not only endorsing, but also encouraging future unethical research. In addition, objectors maintain that the Nazi research was poorly designed and conducted so haphazardly, that it really doesn?t even qualify as ?scientific?. They state, ?scientific results depended upon protocols which were soaked in iniquity. In many experiments, it was ?control subjects?, denied treatment, who suffered most and died. ?Sample size? meant truck loads of Jews. ?Significance? was an indication of misery, and ?response rate? a measure of torment? (Dixon, 31).
Objectors to the use of Nazi research believe that nothing good will come from this research. They believe that using research gathered through murder endorses the methods used in the experiments. If this statement were to be contested, they would argue that to cite research is to say ?I believe in this work?. To believe in research, one must be inclined to repeat the original work and further investigate the topic. Objectors claim that this condition is never satisfied. They state, ?We do not, to be specific, replicate the Nazi experiments. ?We? do not do it. The Nazis did? (Campbell, 18). Objectors believe that a scientist above all else is a human, thus, he must recognize himself as a moral being. Since humans were murdered in these experiments, the data collected should be considered ?tainted?. No moral being should associate with tainted data.
Objectors also believe that the methodology of these experiments cannot be considered ?science?. In regard to the infamous hypothermia experiments at Dachau, United States Brigadier General Telford Taylor, claimed that, ?these experiments revealed nothing which civilized medicine can use? (Moe, 5). Further opinions from objectors dissect the reliability of the research. Arnold Relman, editor of the New England Journal of Medicine, states that Nazi experiments ?are such a gross violation of human standards that they are not to be trusted at all…how can you trust a man who would do that?? (Moe, 6). Therefore, obviously the Nazi data suffers from credibility issues. Another opinion expressed in Moe?s article was that ?If they [Nazis] had never done these experiments, science would be no different today? (6). It is clear that objectors do not believe that the research done by the Nazis was science. They maintain that the moral and ethical aspects of research must be the motivating factors behind scientific endeavors.
Proponents of Nazi research, on the other hand, argue that the information provided by the Nazis is indispensable to some areas of modern science. Most supporters concede that the data was obtained through gruesome, inhumane means. They point out, however, that such large-scale human experimentation has never been conducted elsewhere. Therefore, because the research is impossible to replicate, scientists have a need, in certain instances, to utilize this research in the interest of saving lives. They further point out that a significant majority of Nazi data ?satisfies all the criteria of objective and accurate observation and interpretation? (Moe, 6).
Proponents favor salvaging all the good that they can out of the murder of camp inmates. Angell states ?we should redeem whatever small benefits we can from the nightmare? (1462). An example would be the case of the Dachau hypothermia experiments. In these experiments inmates were outfitted in German pilot gear and then submerged at various depths in ice water pools. All of the subjects died. Today, the only documented data on human hypothermia has been either extrapolated from animal data, or gathered from accident reports. In the case of the animal data, researchers must make many assumptions that cannot be proven to be correct. Therefore, the data, which is generated, is subject to error. Accidental exposure to hypothermia that has been documented through accident reports gives greater insight but still suffers from a major problem. The core temperature of the victim is known only in two states, before and after the exposure. Therefore, only guesses can be made as to how the body reacts to deadlier temperature drops. John S. Hayward of the University of Victoria, uses the Nazi data. He uses it to obtain cooling curves, which help him, design protective suits which will protect people at deadly temperatures. He states, ?I don?t want to have to use this data, but there is no other and will be no other in an ethical world…to not use it would be equally bad. I?m trying to make something constructive of it? (Moe, 5).
Some scholars argue that Nazi research ending in murder is no different, in terms of outcome, too military service. They argue that the differences between war and Nazi research are a means to the same end. They argue, ?Some people were ordered to face bullets and storm a hill; others were…to take an injection and test a vaccine…[researchers] did not need to seek the permission of their subjects any more than the…field commanders? (Rothman, 1198). Hence, proponents might argue that to cite Nazi research would be very similar to citing the historical significance of a battle.
Proponents also argue that Nazi research was conducted through a scientific method, the data collected was accurate, and therefore, these experiments should indeed, be considered science. Proponents argue that propaganda was likely used to mold opinion in regards to the Nazi research. They believe ?denial of scientific validity of Nazi research may have become entrenched partly to distance the Nazi doctors from postwar researchers? (Moe, 5). In addition, proponents argue that the following conclusions can be made in regards to scientific validity of the research:
?1. There was a rationale for the experiments;
The experiments were conducted by trained scientists who had experience in [that] area of science…
The data was presented to various scientific audiences in Nazi Germany
The information has been referenced by scientists since World War II who are knowledgeable in this area; and
No one has scientifically debunked the major findings? (Caplan, 102)
From this evidence, proponents therefore adhere to their beliefs that the Nazi research should be considered science.
Supporting one view in this debate is most likely not the correct solution. Instead, researchers must determine on their own what significance their actions hold. In this way, the topic evolves.
To censor the use of Nazi data is retroactive to science. As Buchanan states, ?If exclude from use all the experiments now viewed as unethical, you?d have to tear up half the medical textbooks? (Moe, 7). However, some believe to cite Nazi research is ?to become an onlooker, and beyond that, an accomplice? (Campbell, 18).
Most uninformed individuals believe that this debate really has no significance to them. In speaking with peers, many are of the attitude, ?Who cares? The Nazis lost the War. It?s all in the past, its not like that stuff happened anywhere else.? It is important to note however, that even in a democracy such as the U.S., this kind of research has happened. This nation, which condemned the Nazis and passed Nuremburg Laws to safeguard science, has a checkered past of unethical research. Examples are widespread, ranging from the radiation experiments conducted on the victims at Nagasaki and Hiroshima, to the injection of retarded individuals (institutionalized U.S. citizens) with various diseases such as malaria, dysentery, and influenza. Clearly, the Nazi research is not isolated in time or geography.
Regretfully, a conclusion cannot be drawn from the argument of citing Nazi research. Being too quick to censor Nazi cited research could be deleterious not only to science but also to society as a whole. Crum warns that ?in the Western world there is a form of anti-Nazi ?bigotry?…that could lead us to adopt the same erroneous public policies ourselves? (31). Being too relaxed in the standards of scientific research, on the other hand, allows the possibility of repeating history. Safeguards, must be in place to discourage and punish acts of unethical research, otherwise people could once again find themselves in the grasp of horrific experimenters. It must be understood that the Nazis were human, their experiments had goals, and they sought knowledge much like scholars of the present. Therefore instead of censoring and debating, maybe, ?We should make an effort to stop using the experience of Nazism as a metaphor for ?The Cosmic Evil? and instead try to read it like a warning label on a bottle under our own kitchen sinks? (Crum, 31).
Другие работы по теме:
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper Holocaust
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper Holocaust Unit SummaryI was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of allthe unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kindenough to put their own lives on the line to save someone else’s. I didn’t understand,until the stories and the movies cleared it up, how the people could not figure out thatthere was something wrong when they were being pushed around by the Nazi soldiers.
Uncle Marcos Essay Research Paper The author
Uncle Marcos Essay, Research Paper The author Isabel Allende portrays a little girl named Clara who recalls her deceased uncle, Uncle Marcos. Clara reminiscently recalls all of his existence during her life, though out the story. She remembers how when he would
Nazi Essay Research Paper miles long They
Nazi Essay, Research Paper miles long. They would walk all this way, if they couldn?t keep up they would be shot. If they broke their ankle or leg or just couldn?t go on for any reason, they would either be shot or left there to die. If the Nazi?s thought they were just trying to fool them, so they could run when everyone else got far enough away, then the Nazi would shoot him or her in the leg or somewhere so they couldn?t move, and just leave them their to die.
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper I
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper I was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of all the unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kind
Inhumane Treatment Essay Research Paper When groups
Inhumane Treatment Essay, Research Paper When groups and nations come into conflict, they sometimes act in inhumane ways. They use cruel and harsh treatment toward others. Two conflicts that occurred between 1900 and 1945 that resulted in the inhumane treatment of people are the Nazi Holocaust and the Salt March.
Genocide Essay Research Paper The Germans and
Genocide Essay, Research Paper The Germans and the non-Jewish world treated the Jewish people horribly. They looked for freedom, growth, and a better government after World War I. Instead, Jews became prisoners of their own country in Germany. They were put into concentration camps even though they helped Germany by fighting in World War I.
Joseph Cebula Essay Research Paper Blessed Josef
Joseph Cebula Essay, Research Paper Blessed Josef Cebula Father Cebula lived in Poland and in the latter stages of his life his country was greatly affected by World War II. Over 107 polish martyrs died in the Nazi concentration camps during the war.
Response To The Nuremberg Laws And
Nazi Racial Ideology Essay, Research Paper Reponse to : The Nuremberg Laws and Nazi Racial Ideology The Nuremberg Race Laws of 1935 deprived German Jews of their rights of citizenship, giving them the status of “subjects” in Hitler’s Reich. The laws also made it forbidden for Jews to marry or have any relations with Aryans or to employ young Aryan women as household help.
Dwight BollingerS
“The Origin Of Language? Essay, Research Paper Essay Question I found Dwight Bollinger?s essay entitled ?The Origin of Language? to be a very interesting work. I especially enjoyed the section about the chimpanzees. Although we know
Nazi Essay Research Paper John Mendes 83000Critical
Nazi Essay, Research Paper John Mendes 8/30/00 Critical Thinking Philosophy 100 Singer?s Final solution Singer and the Nazis both took away the rights of other human beings. Both men took away rights because of physical ability, self-awareness, or intelligence.
Joseph Priestley Essay Research Paper Joseph Priestley
Joseph Priestley Essay, Research Paper Joseph Priestley was born in England on March 13, 1733, and showed a great talent for science and languages from an early age. Priestley performed many important scientific experiments, among them the discovery that the gas produced by the fermentation of grain (later identified as carbon dioxide) could be dissolved in water to produce the pleasant drink called seltzer.
Ethnic Cleansing Essay Research Paper The first
Ethnic Cleansing Essay, Research Paper The first and most important human right is the right to live, but sometimes others bend the rules, and this is when genocide begins. Crimes against humanity have been around for many generations, including ours. The genocide against the Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 was because the Turkish authorities wanted to eliminate the Armenian presence in the country.
Hmmmm Essay Research Paper Almost every day
Hmmmm Essay, Research Paper Almost every day of my life I am bombarded with concepts that are sometimes so incredible, my jaw drops and I am left in dazed wonderment. Sometimes the things I learn are so “out there” that I ask
Concentration Camps Essay Research Paper Concentration CampsThe
Concentration Camps Essay, Research Paper Concentration Camps The Holocaust was one of the most terrible catastrophes in modern history. Before world war II about nine million Jews lived in Europe. Six million died in the war and a lot of them died in the concentration camps.
Third Reich Essay Research Paper The Third
Third Reich Essay, Research Paper The Third Reich The Nazi state (Third Reich) was a brutal dictatorship established with Hitler s appointment as Chancellor in 1933. By 1936, Hitler had destroyed the government of the Weimar Republic established in 1919 at the end of the First World War), suppressed all political parties except the Nazi party, and consolidated the government of Germany under his control as Fuhrer (leader).
Stanley Milgram Essay Research Paper Obedience is
Stanley Milgram Essay, Research Paper Obedience is a basic part in the structure of society, and its destructiveness has been questioned throughout time. Stanley Milgram conducted an experiment to test the destructiveness of obedience; however, Diana Baumrind discredits Milgram and criticizes his experiments in her article Review of Stanley Milgram s Experiments on Obedience.
Hard Times Essay Research Paper hard timesBook
Hard Times Essay, Research Paper hard times Book Report Author: Anita Lobel Annas family was a typical Polish family in the 1930’s. Thier story is that the nazis came to poland in 1939. They took all of the Jewish families Anna’s family happend to be jewish. Annas family split up to make it harder for the nazis to catch them.
Modern Science Is Bullshit Essay Research Paper
Note: Less of an essay, more a branching statement. Recent medical experiments by some distiguished doctor person reveals that sun-light is actually good for your skin, despite medical evidence
Aushwitz Essay Research Paper AUSCHWITZBY CHRISTOPHER JAMES
Aushwitz Essay, Research Paper AUSCHWITZ CHRISTOPHER JAMES The Nazis establishes Auschwitz in April 1940, under the orders of Heinrich Himmler. Heinrich Himmler was in charge of two Nazi organizations. The camp at Auschwitz originally housed political prisoners from occupied Poland and various concentration camps from within Germany.
Ethics In Research Essay Research Paper The
Ethics In Research Essay, Research Paper The study of psychology often requires the use of experimental methods to gather important information for the betterment of the human race. Experiments often involve the use of humans and animals. What can be done to a human or animal in the name of science and research is a question of ethics.
Miss Everetts Boys Essay Research Paper Miss
Miss Everetts Boys Essay, Research Paper Miss Everett?s Boys My reaction to Miss Everett?s Boys is one of disgust and utter disbelief. I feel that the government is responsible for the colored men who lost their lives to syphilis during the time of the Tuskegee experiments located within Tuskegee, Alabama.
Naziess Essay Research Paper Nazi War Criminals
Naziess Essay, Research Paper Nazi War Criminals Still Out ThereAs you walk by and look at hundreds of people everyday, just think, one of these people could have helped Hitler’s Nazi Party. One of them could have been in charge of sentencing thousands of Jew’s to death each day. These heartless terrible people could be walking around in disguise.
Speaker
#3 Essay, Research Paper He was born on Essen of Germany. He was an ordinary citizen of Germany. The keyword to this essay is that word “was.” After the NAZI came into power, he was treated as an “inferior race.” He did not beat anyone up or abuse anyone. So, why was he being treated badly? He was a Jewish person in a new era.
Propaganda And Censorship Essay Research Paper Propaganda
Propaganda And Censorship Essay, Research Paper Propaganda and Censorship The Nazi=s used many different types of propaganda and used various methods to censor. These included, the press, the radio, loud speakers, books, theatre, art and music, rallies and campaigns and films.
Anne Frank Essay Research Paper In 1942
Anne Frank Essay, Research Paper In 1942, when the Nazi?s began to invade their country, the Frank family went into hiding in an attic of a warehouse. The Franks? daughter, Anne,
Dr Dre Essay Research Paper Not many
Dr. Dre Essay, Research Paper Not many producers, in the arena of hip-hop or otherwise, can boldly state that their sonic experiments twice (first with N.W.A, later with The Chronic) transformed the musical landscape. But, then again, every producer is not Dr. Dre. “Although I’m from the west coast, I try to make music that will have a universal appeal,” says Dre, whose latest disc Dr.
Swing Kids Essay Research Paper Swing Kids
Swing Kids Essay, Research Paper Swing Kids was a disturbing film exposing the techniques of the nazi dictatorship in Germany during the early 1900?s. Peter, the main character is a student arrested for a petty theft. he was forced to join the Hitler Jugen (Nazi youth group) in order to avoid casting suspicion on his family.
Split Brain Research Essay Research Paper Chad
Split Brain Research Essay, Research Paper Chad Stein PS 101 Dr. Rom 1. Gazzaniga, M.S. “One Brain or Two?” Scientific American. 1967. Rpt. In Forty Studies That Changed Psychology. Ed. Roger R. Hock. Engewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall, 1995. 2-11.
Use Of Nazi Experimental Data Essay Research
Paper Marc Hansen Philosophy 447 Should Unethically Obtained Nazi Data be used for Current Research? During World War II, Nazi doctors committed atrocious crimes in the name of research against their Jewish prisoners. This research done in such a way that never can or should be done again, plays an important role in science.
Cellular Life Essay Research Paper In this
Cellular Life Essay, Research Paper In this paper I will show my knowledge of many different topics of Cellular Life. I will explain the theory of biogenesis, cell theory, the history of both and how they tie in together. I will also state the scientific method and why it is important to science.
Animal Testing Essay Research Paper The American
Animal Testing Essay, Research Paper The American Medical Association has stated that it believes that research-involving animals is essential to maintaining and improving the health of human beings. They point out that all advances in medical science in the 20th century, from antibiotics to organ transplants, has been achieved either directly or indirectly through the use of animals in laboratory experiments.
Should Animals Be Used For Research Testing
? Essay, Research Paper Animal rights activists continually oppose the medical research that involves animals as test subjects. Too many people have come to the conclusion that medical researchers are cruel and inhumane. In many cases the good of the research is overlooked and the bad is used. Even though many people may believe that animal research is morally wrong, animal research should continue because it is critical to helping heal human lives.
How Did The Nazi Party Get So
Big? Essay, Research Paper Hitler’s Nazi party came to power almost entirely because of accidents. In 1929 the American Stock Market crashed, a powerful symbol of the growing