’ Argument Against Universals Essay, Research Paper
Boethius’ Argument Against Universals
In the essay From His Second Commentary on Porphyry s Isagoge Boethius discusses
the existence of universals.. By proposing two main arguments, he first shows why a view
such as that held by Plato (one claiming that universals exist independent of particulars
and that a universal exists wholly in each particular at all times) is false. Then he presents
his own view of the relationship between universals and particulars which is based on the
idea that the universals exist in the collectivity of the particulars.
Boethius first argument against a Platonic view of universals concerns how a
single universal can exist wholly and entirely in each particular thing to which it is
common. A universal is supposedly one entity existing in every particular to which it is
common at all times. But Boethius argues that if it is to exist wholly in several things at
one time, it cannot in itself be one entity. According to Boethius everything that exists
exists for the reason that it is one. And therefore, if the universal is existing in several
things at one time (and thus is not one in number) then it cannot exist in this Platonic
fashion.
Boethius second argument deals with universals if they are to be spoken of as
being many rather than one. He explains that to say is also false. For to say this is to
imply that there will be no last (universal set above the others). This is because there
will be a universal set over many things and will thus be multiple. And because it is in
many things, it has a likeness of what is a (universal). But it is a likeness that is not one
in number and therefore, another (universal) of that (universal) is also to be searched
for. Boethius explains that this is an infinite cycle and because of that the universal has
no real meaning in this context
Boethius tells that in order to exist and remain one in number, the universal must
instead exist either: in parts belonging to individual things (the universal is divided among
many particulars), in its entirety to one single particular at some given time (the particular
in which it exists changing over a period of time), or in that it is common to all particulars
at once but not in a way so that it is of the substance of what it is common to… (but
rather) as a stage-play, or some spectacle which is common to all the spectators. But the
universal cannot exist in any one of these ways, as Boethius explains; for it is supposed
to be common in such a way that both the whole of it is in all its singulars, and at one
time, and also it is able to constitute and form the substance of what it is common to.
Boethius finally presents his own understanding of the existence of universals.
Rather than a Platonic view where the particular things are dependent on the universals,
Boethius speaks of a theory where the universals are dependent on the particulars. That
is, it is the collective particular things which create the universals. Boethius uses the
example of individual man and his relationship to species and genus to illustrate this
concept: distinct individual men give the likeness of humanity. Boethius claims this
likeness to be the species. Likewise, the likeness of distinct species (those of a wide range
of different animals) make up a genus. In this example, the species and the individual men
are analogous to the particulars. The genus then, is analogous to a universal, thus
showing that it is from particulars that comes the universals.
Другие работы по теме:
Abelard on Universals
The Abelards solution of the problem of universals is neither a realistic no a nominalistic one, or, in other words, it is in the same degree nominalistic as it is realistic.
Таможенная политика во время правления Екатерины II
Изучение особенностей таможенной политики и таможенного тарифного регулирования в период правления Екатерины II. Значение отечественного исторического опыта использования таможенных правил и процедур для формирования современной таможенной политики.
Руны 2
Введение 1 Алфавит и термины 2 Символы 3 Рунические памятники 4 Происхождение рун 4.1 Греко-латинская версия 4.2 Северноэтрусская версия 4.3 Нетрадиционные версии
Древняя aнглийская проза (Ancient English Prose)
Ancient English prose The earliest English prose work is the law code King Aethelberht I of Kent . It was written in the very end of 6 century. The 7 and 8 century prose was practical in its character so a lot of laws and wills date back to this period.
Einhard
When one thinks of Carolingian reformation, and the people related to it directly the first person that comes to mind is the king Charles the Great, and along with him one involuntarily thinks of his faithful ‘servant’ Einhard because he is the one that introduces him to us. But on top of being a simple biographer Einhard has done far more greater things in life, and today one has the opportunity to study what kind of man Einhard was, what he’d done during his life, and why is he important through his works and documents related to him that survived until our time. 9
The origin and history of the English language
History of English language and literature. The progress of English literature in early times was slow, will not seem wonderful to those who consider what is affirmed of the progress of other arts, more immediately connected with the comforts of life.
The history of English
Historical background of the History of English. Assimilative Vowel Changes: Breaking and Diphthongisation. Old English phonetics and grammar. Morphological classification of nouns. Evolution of the grammatical system. Personal and possessive pronouns.
Kings Essay Research Paper Volume 1
Kings Essay, Research Paper Volume 1 : Inferno Cantos I – XI Canto I Halfway through his life, DANTE THE PILGRIM wakes to find himself lost in the dark wood. Terrified at being alone in so dismal a valley, he wanders until he comes to a hill bathed in sunlight, and his fear begins to leave him. But when he starts to climb the hill his path is blocked by three fierce beasts: first a LEOPARD, then a LION, and finally a SHE-WOLF.
Fortune In Troilus And Cressida Essay Research
Paper Lady Fortune: Friend or Foe? The face of Fortune in Chaucer’s Troilus and Criseyde. Lady Fortune and her wheel are two of the most enduring symbols in mankind’s history. Witness the popular game show, Wheel of Fortune. While it may seem silly, it proves that something of this concept has stayed with in our psyche, even today.
Kings And Aristocracy Essay Research Paper
Questions:?????? Explain the disappearance of the senatorial aristocracy (ONE geog area if you wish) (2000). ??????????????????????? Explain the growing involvement of bishops in secular government (2000). How far, and why, did the
Canterbury Essay Research Paper Are there many
Canterbury Essay, Research Paper Are there many ways that themes and symbols can be shown in stories? Geoffrey Chaucer uses many different themes, symbols and styles in writing all of tales in The Canterbury Tales. By using these things, Geoffrey utilizes several specific symbols to illustrate various central themes.
Pantheon Essay Research Paper Pantheon temple dedicated
Pantheon Essay, Research Paper Pantheon, temple dedicated to all the gods. The Pantheon of Rome is the best-preserved major edifice of ancient Rome and one of the most significant buildings in architectural history. In shape it is an immense cylinder concealing eight piers, topped with a dome and fronted by a rectangular colonnaded porch.
The Main Controversies Of Medieval Thought In
The 12Th And 13Th Centuries Essay, Research Paper The twelfth and thirteenth centuries were a time of great controversy for medieval scholars. New systems of thought were being developed and implemented that challenged the accepted teachings of the church. Some fought to preserve tradition, others fought to destroy it, while still others sought to find a common ground between the two.
How Was Alfred Able To Defeat The
Vikings Essay, Research Paper Question: Why was Alfred Able To Defeat The Vikings? In the autumn of 856, Danish Viking ships sailed to England and invaded what is now Norfolk in East Anglia. By Easter of 878, the Danes held control of all of East Anglia, Mercia, most of Wessex (all save Hampshire, Wiltshire and Somerset) and had set up a puppet ruler in Northumbria.
Boethius Essay Research Paper Throughout history every
Boethius Essay, Research Paper Throughout history, every society has searched for some way to express its feelings and beliefs. Music has been an integral part of virtually every culture, so it is quite natural for people to have
Boethius The Consolation Of Philosophy Essay Research
Paper Literary Patterns of European Developement Trinity College The Consolation of Philosophy was written in the early 6th century by Boethius. A statesman and intellectual, well educated in liberal arts, Boethius fell from the favor of
Song Of The Unsung Antihero Essay Research
Paper Abstract: The sober treatment of a lowly, unheroic protagonist in Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman flatters the audience. The more obvious way that it flatters us is by alienating us from the protagonist in his downfall so that we watch his destruction from a secure vantage. Less obviously, the form of the play, typical of modern American tragedy, romanticizes the protagonist through what I call the audience’s paradox, that tension created when a serious work of literature employs an obscure and lowly character as protagonist and so makes him the center of our attention, makes him famous.
Beowulf Essay Research Paper A Twist of
Beowulf Essay, Research Paper A Twist of Fate for the Great Hero Beowulf Fate seems to be an ongoing theme in the works of Boethius and Beowulf. Whether it is a belief of Christian providence or pagan fatalism, the writers of these works are strongly moved by the concept of fate and how it affects the twists and turns of a person?s life.
Chaucer And The House Of Fame Essay
, Research Paper QUESTION 7. DISCUSS THE CULTURAL NATURE OF FAME AND ITS TEXTUAL EXPRESSION WITH REFERENCE TO ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING: ORAL HEROIC POETRY, CHAUCER’S DEPICTION IN THE HOUSE OF FAME
Geoffrey Chaucer And His Works Essay Research
Paper Known as the Father of the English Language, Geoffrey Chaucer, after six centuries, has retained his status as one of the three or four greatest English poets. Throughout his assiduous life as a courtier and civil servant under the royalty of Edward III and Richard II, Chaucer has written many famous pieces that are still admired and praise today.
Chaucer Essay Research Paper Geoffrey ChaucerGeoffrey Chaucer
Chaucer Essay, Research Paper Geoffrey Chaucer Geoffrey Chaucer led a busy official life, as an esquire of the royal court, as the administrator of the customs for the port of London, as a participant in important diplomatic missions, and in a variety of other official duties. Before William Shakespeare, Geoffrey Chaucer was the distinguished English poet, and still retains the position as the most significant poet to write in Middle English.
Music history
Music in ancient times, iconography in music. Ancient Chinese music and Imperial Office of Music. The Hurrian Hymn to Nikal in the ancient Hurrian language. Ancient Hebrew music, Greek music, Western Music. Styles and tendencies of 20th century music.
Changes and specimens of the English language
Consideration on concrete examples of features of gramatical additions of the offer during various times, beginning from 19 centuries and going deep into historical sources of origin of English language (the Anglo-Saxon period of King Alfred board).
Анаций Манлий Торкват Северин Боэций
Боэций (Boethius, Boetius) Анаций Манлий Торкват Северин (ок. 480—524 / 526) — рим. философ, теолог и поэт. Был выходцем из знатного рим. рода, образование получил, по-видимому, в Риме, в доме близкого друга своей семьи патриция Аврелия Меммия Симмаха.