America’s Killing Field
Drive half an hour north of Washington, D.C. and you will find verdant rolling hills and flat, rich farmland, broken here and there by granite outcroppings and dark poplar forests. A place of great beauty and serenity. Close your eyes a moment, efface the houses and stores and gas stations from your mind’s eye, and it looks pretty much as it did in July, 1863.
With one huge difference.
That summer its green fields were stained red with the blood of 50,000 Americans dead and wounded. 50,000. In just three days of slaughter in Eastern Pennsylvania, fully one-third as many casualties as during the three years of the Korean War.
The Battle of Gettysburg, fought July 1-4, 1863, was America’s Armageddon, the single, blazing moment when the Civil War’s central issue–would we be one nation, or two?–was decided. What happened is well known: after a smashing win in May, 1863 at Chancellorsville, Virginia, Robert E. Lee became set on dealing a death blow to the Union army, now in disarray, and staked everything on winning a huge victory on northern soil. Almost by accident, the two great armies made contact at Gettysburg, a site neither side chose nor wanted, and the greatest battle ever fought in the Western hemisphere began. The Union army was the first to reach Gettysburg, seized the high ground and, driven into the ropes by Lee’s body punches, never let it go.
While what happened at Gettysburg is well-documented, why it was done as it was done remains elusive. These are the questions Michael Shaara tries to answer in his 1975 Pulitzer prize-winner The Killer Angels, a sort of American Iliad that has in abundance what many historical novels lack: believable personalities, accurate minutia, genuine pathos. It is a dramatic work reminiscent of the best historical fiction, including William Styron’s The Confessions of Nat Turner and Gore Vidal’s Burr and Lincoln.
While Stephen Crane revealed both the boredom and the horror of the Civil War through the common soldier’s eyes, Shaara follows selected officers on both sides through the four-day slaughter, taking a novelist’s imaginative liberties to go inside their heads and hearts and track the decisions that evolved there. The best way to write about a battle is to tell it as the men who fought it saw it–and that’s just what Shaara does in this stirring, brilliantly interpretive novel in which he judges all, admiringly or with compassion for their mistakes.
Through Shaara’s simple but epic prose, noble figures wearing both blue and gray move through courses that seem almost predetermined. Such as the fateful clash of wills between Confederate commander Robert E. Lee, whom Shaara portrays as pious, aging, and gutsy, but also stubborn and dangerously confident, and his subordinate, General James Longstreet who, appalled by the reckless bravado of his comrades, favored more cautious tactics.
Longstreet said again, “Sir, I’ve discovered a way south that seems promising. If we would move–”
“General, the enemy is THERE–” Lee lifted his arm, pointed up the ridge in a massive gesture–”and there’s where I’m going to strike him. He turned and looked back at Longstreet for one long moment, straight into his eyes, fixing Longstreet with the black stare, the eyes of the General, and then turned away. Longstreet drew his head in, like a turtle.
In scenes like this, Shaara reveals a Lee, driven by an almost chivalric pride, who ultimately ignored Longstreet’s plea to maneuver to attack the Union lines from the rear and chose instead the doomed human wave, banzai charge in butternut and gray led by fanatical General George Pickett (”…long haired and perfumed. Last in his class at West Point.”), against the center of the Union positions on the battle’s climactic third day. Pickett’s Charge nearly succeeded–the rebel “Stars and Bars” flag flew briefly over the Union center. But, after terrible casualties on both sides, it failed, and what remained of Lee’s once powerful Army of Northern Virginia retreated, never again to touch northern soil. In those few hours on the 3rd of July, the Confederate tide had ebbed. The Civil War was, de facto, over although it would grind on for nearly two more years.
In recounting what happened at Gettysburg, Shaara provides no broad muck and blood panoramic view of the struggle, but creates instead an apocalyptic immediacy. When the 20th Maine counterattacks as Pickett’s men breach the Union lines at Cemetery Ridge, Shaara registers the horror and bravery of the moment as well as the balance between man and technology that made Gettysburg one of the last human battles.
Gaps in the front, the newly dead, piles of red meat. One man down holding his stomach, blood pouring out of him like a butchered pig, young face, only a boy…you could see the damn black balls bouncing along like bowling balls, and here and there, in the air, tumbling over and over like a blood-spouting cartwheel, a piece of a man…he saw the whole Regiment rising and pouring over the wall, his men were roaring animal screams…
hats coming off, hair flying, mouths making sounds…everything so quick he could not believe it. And now the canister, OH GOD, millions of metal balls, whirring through the air like startled quail, murderous quail, and now for the first time there was agonized screaming, very bad sounds to hear.
On the victors’ side, Shaara all but ignores the Union commander, General George Gordon Meade, and homes in instead on Colonel Joshua Chamberlain, a young professor of rhetoric from Maine who finds his destiny not in a Bowdoin University classroom, but atop a hill called Little Round Top, as he rallies his outnumbered men at on the fateful third day with an eloquence and power that Mark Antony might envy (”I never saw dirt I’d die for, but I’m not asking you to fight for dirt…We’re an army out to set other men free!”)
As if to confirm Shaara’s judgment, Chamberlain, who won the Medal of Honor, was also proclaimed the unsung hero of Gettysburg 15 years later by filmmaker Ken Burns in his acclaimed 1990 PBS documentary “The Civil War”.
Regardless of whose viewpoint he takes, Shaara is faithful to the zeitgeist of 1863. In evoking Lee, Longstreet, their lieutenants–or Chamberlain or tough Union cavalry commander General John Buford, a hard-edged practical counterpoint to Chamberlain’s idealism–Shaara, using the words of the men themselves drawn from their letters and documents, discloses only as much as they knew at the time.
And, as he tells it, none of them really knew very much. But, in particular, it was what Lee did not know, Shaara argues, that decided the outcome at Gettysburg–and, with it, the future course of the Republic. Things unknown and unsuspected are what this novel stresses. For example, Lee did not know until too late that the bumbling Joseph Hooker, whom he demolished at Chancellorsville, had been replaced by Meade, an unspectacular but dogged commander. He did not know, again until too late, that Meade’s army had crossed into Pennsylvania. Nor did he know the immense size of Meade’s forces. Had Lee, the war’s one true military genius, known these things, Shaara implies, he likely would have adopted different tactics that could well have produced a different result. There may have never been a Gettysburg Address four months later.
Shaara clearly shows us why the brilliant Lee was forced to flail blindly. His “eyes” (and his “right arm”), Stonewall Jackson, had been killed at Chancellorsville and his replacement, the vain and dashing J.E.B. Stuart, went off like an independent Roman candle, launching raids deep in Pennsylvania, and leaving Lee uninformed and undermanned. And the Confederate “Gray Fox” still barely lost. Thus, for the Confederacy, “it (Gettysburg) was, like Waterloo, a near thing.”
There are flaws, albeit minor, in The Killer Angels: Shaara’s rather portentous “You Are There” beginning, the lack of a cinemascope overview of the action (in spite of nearly a dozen maps), his giving more air time to Longstreet than to Lee, and his virtual dismissal of Meade. But these shortcomings detract little from this novel’s impact. Capturing both the horror and the heartbreak that was Gettysburg, Shaara turns one of the most familiar, studied events in American history into a powerful story–a strong, spirited, sad, bloody book equal to its subject.
Другие работы по теме:
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I am
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I am all for Capital Punishment. I think that if you kill someone you should be given the death penalty. I think that the death of the killer would give family and friends a bit of ease
Killer Angels 3 Essay Research Paper This
Killer Angels 3 Essay, Research Paper This is an outstanding book about the Battle of Gettysburg, even though it is fictional. The Killer Angels The Battle of Gettysburg brought the fighting North and South together to the small town of Gettysburg and on the edge of splitting the Union. Gettysburg could closely be compared to Judgement Day and this book gives a day-to-day account of the battle that made America s future.
SAINT PETER CLAVER Essay Research Paper Angel
SAINT PETER CLAVER Essay, Research Paper Angel Mendoza Saint Peter Claver St. Peter Claver was born at Verdu, Catalonia, Spain, in 1580. He descended from a very distinguished family . When
Poem Angel Essay Research Paper Once upon
Poem: Angel Essay, Research Paper Once upon a time, there was a child ready to be born. So one day he asked God, “They tell me you’re sending me to earth tomorrow but how am I going to live there being so small and helpless?”
Angels Essay Research Paper There are many
Angels Essay, Research Paper There are many good interesting things about angels. Many people in the world believe in angels , others do not. Whether you believe in them ornot , they are
To Kill A Mocking Bird Movie Review
Essay, Research Paper To Kill a Mockingbird – Movie Review To Kill a Mockingbird is an inaccurate presentation of the novel for three main reasons. The first main reason why it is inaccurate is because a lot of details in the novel are left out in the movie, as there is a lack of time. Two examples are the fire that burns down Miss Maudie’s house and the arrival of Aunt Alexandra does not take place in the movie.
Serial Killer Fascination Essay Research Paper Ultimate
Serial Killer Fascination Essay, Research Paper Ultimate Evil Serial killer, mass murderer, and psychopath are three words that should send people running in the other direction. Simply saying these words, people are immediately linking viscous acts with an ultimately evil person committing these crimes.
Book Reviews On Politics In 17Th Century
Europe Essay, Research Paper The two journals that I chose to use for my reviews were History and Theory: Studies in the Philosophy of History published at Wesleyan University, and Renaissance Forum. I will be looking at two reviews of historical Books written about two very different places and themes.
Because Essay Research Paper Becuase this is
Because Essay, Research Paper Becuase this is not my job, I decided early on to limit my reviews to one book per author. You can imagine, then, how hard it was to decide WHICH book of Charles Dickens to review. I mean, to choose between A Tale of Two Cities, Oliver Twist, and Great Expectations was downright cruel.
St Elizabeth Essay Research Paper I chose
St. Elizabeth Essay, Research Paper I chose the name Elizabeth for my confirmation name after Saint Elizabeth. I feel that she is a very important part in history.
Look Homeward Angel Essay Research Paper Erin
Look Homeward Angel Essay, Research Paper Erin O’Hara Kate Myers English 101 11/25/00 Look Homeward, Angel Review (Final draft, 5th essay) A culturally enriching experience is an experience that is related to the arts and an intellectual activity, which makes you become a better person or makes you feel you have become a better person.
Book Review Of The Killer Angels Essay
, Research Paper Between the days of July 1, 1863 and July 4, 1863, the Civil War?s outcome was decided. These four days have been known as the Battle of Gettysburg, the turning point of the war. In The Killer Angels, Michael Shaara brings us a vivid image of what the battle was like.
Tess Durbeyfield Guilty Or Not Guilty Essay
, Research Paper Grant Gardner- grantg103@hotmail CP English IV January 11, 1998 Tess Durbeyfield, Guilty or not Guilty In the book Tess of the D’Urbervilles by Thomas Hardy, Tess Durbeyfield suffers a great deal of tribulation in her tragic life. Although her life is filled with misfortune, she is not responsible for these tragic events.
Good Angel Vs Bad Angel Essay Research
Paper Iris vs. Memo, the everlasting battle of Good and Evil, Good Angel vs. Bad Angel. In The Natural the Angels take the form of women that interact with Roy. Iris the “Good Angel” has nothing but a positive influence on Roy and cares about him deeply. The exact opposite of Iris is the “Bad Angel” Memo who cares just about what she can get her hands on except poverty.
The Color Purple Essay Research Paper Byron
The Color Purple Essay, Research Paper Byron Hooper 11/18/96 The Color Purple film review The Color Purple The movie “The Color Purple,” directed by Steven Speilberg, was, in general, a
Angel City Essay Research Paper Angel
Angel City Essay, Research Paper ? Angel City? The most unique, magnificent, and extraordinary city that I would love to visit is the ?City of Angles?. Tucked away in the midst of our atmosphere, lies the beauty of having everlasting life, and dreams that come true. Baby- blue skies, and cotton candy clouds fills this entire city.
Serial Kill Essay Research Paper Who Is
Serial Kill Essay, Research Paper Who Is A Serial Killer? Who develops into a serial murderer? How does a serial killer operate? Is it genetics, biological, or cultural conditioning that makes these people killers? We all experience rage, yet we have all have the ability to control these behaviors. What sets us apart from a killer?
Serrial Killer Essay Research Paper SERIAL KILLERShaine
Serrial Killer Essay, Research Paper SERIAL KILLER Shaine Dolan The country has been gripped by fear and the serial killer has played right into that fear. The serial killer epitomizes the fear that police officers and the criminal justice cannot protect us. Serial killings account for less than one percent of annual homicides we have in America, yet they somehow touch the lives of almost every America.
Ordinary People Essay Research Paper Book Review
Ordinary People Essay, Research Paper Book Review of Ordinary People Ordinary People, by Judith Guest, is a novel about the difficulties and problems that occur in a seemingly normal family after the death of one of it?s members. The main character, Conrad, witnesses his brother, Buck, drown. After this tragic happening, Conrad attempts suicide by slashing his wrists.
The Chimney Sweeper Essay Research Paper The
The Chimney Sweeper Essay, Research Paper ?The Chimney Sweeper? From Songs of Innocence William Blake?s Songs of Innocence comprises ?songs of happy cheer? about field and flower, hill and stream, and the innocence of child and lamb, as seen through the eyes of a child (World Book vol.2 pg 314). In one excerpt, ?The Chimney Sweeper,? Blake, through religious symbolism, gives the image of an innocence child living a life of hardship and grief that gains comfort from the knowledge that God will deliver him to a better life in heaven.
Thomas Harris Essay Research Paper Thomas Harris
Thomas Harris Essay, Research Paper Thomas Harris is a man with many tallents, an a keen intrest in writing. He earned a major in English, he has written for many newspapers and is most known for his second book which became a major motion picture earning 5 Academy Awards for Best Picture , Best Actress, Best Actor, Best Director and Best Adapted Screen Play, Silence of the Lambs.
Saint Raphael The Archangel Essay Research Paper
Saint Raphael the Archangel The saint I?ve chosen for my confirmation is Saint Raphael the Archangel. Saint Raphael is also known as the Angel of Love and the Angel of Joy. A few things he is a patron of are the blind, love, lovers, travelers, young people, and guardian angels. His name means ? God has healed?, or ? Healer of God?.
A Book Review On Danny The Champion
Of The World Essay, Research Paper The book I have chosen to do a book review on Danny the Champion of the world by Roald Dahl. It was illustrated by Quentin Blake. The actual copy I have was printed in 1991. The
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book ReviewFor
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review For Whom The Bell Tolls Ernest Hemingway Pages Read: 74 (really busy) For Whom The Bell Tolls begins with a pyrotechnic for the Russian army reviewing the land where he must blow a bridge to stop enemy movement. He is a little overwhelmed by the task he is assigned to complete yet he is mentally sound in his manner and seems to know exactly how to handle himself in the situation.
Faust Book Review Essay Research Paper Faust
Faust: Book Review Essay, Research Paper Faust: Book Review Chris Davidson This novel written originally by Johann Wolfgang von Goethe and translated by Walter Kaufmann. There are 201 pages in this novel.. This book
Jay Leno Book Review Essay Research Paper
BOOK REVIEW The book I read was “Leading With My Chin”. The author is Bill Zehme. I enjoyed reading this book because of its excellent detail. I would definitely recommend this book to someone that is a Jay Leno fan or like to laugh a lot.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book Review
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review Eric T. LibeerPark Hill South High School Thursday, May 27, 1999 Book Review By Eric Libeer Homeland, John Jakes’s formidable noel about the final explosive events of the nineteenth century, is the first in a series that will focus attention on a new “Jakes” family, the Crowns.
The Killer Angels Essay Research Paper Response
The Killer Angels Essay, Research Paper Response to the “Killer Angels” The Killer Angels is a historical novel written by Michael Shaara. It is one of the best novels I ever read. It describes four days at Gettysburg, Pennsylvania in the summer of 1863 in what many consider to be the turning point of the American Civil War.
Hannibal Review Essay Research Paper Movie ReviewHannibal
Hannibal Review Essay, Research Paper Movie Review Hannibal Hannibal is a wonderful movie. I wonderful movie is a movie that is well thought out, and has a good flowing plot. Many people think this is a scary movie. I found Hannibal to be a very suspenseful and an intriguing film. Anthony Hopkins, a brilliantly outstanding actor, portrays a psychotic killer named Dr.