Oleanna And Trifles Essay, Research Paper
Engl. 105
3/14/2000
Gender Roles and Stereotypes in Trifles and Oleanna
Individuals commonly address the issues of gender roles, gender stereotypes, feminism, and political correctness in everyday conversation as well as in modern literature and modern drama. Questions have arisen concerning the differences between men and women other than obvious physical variance. Are men and women inherently different? If so, are they equal? Should men and women fill different societal roles? Are potential differences a result of gender roles and the stereotypes associated with these roles? Two modern plays, Oleanna by David Mamet and Trifles by Susan Glaspell address these types of issues. Both plays address the above themes of gender roles, stereotypes, and the differences in the way men and women perceive each other. More specifically, in both plays, all of the female characters take advantage of gender roles and stereotypes in a manner that allows them to reverse the roles of subservient females and dominant males.
In her play, Susan Glaspell blatantly comments on feminist ideals and criticizes female gender roles and stereotypes. Throughout the play the reader is able to find examples of the playwrights feminist ideals. As early as the description of the setting, the criticism of ownership and property rights typically associated with males is shown. By describing the house as “the farmhouse of John Wright” Glaspell expresses her distaste for the male-dominated culture found during this period and rural area. Also early in the play, the reader is given the names of the dead man and the woman accused of murdering him-Minnie and John Wright. The name Minnie may symbolize the sense of inferiority felt by women during this time period, while the name of the insensitive Mr. Wright may be a sarcastic play on the term “Mr. Right”. Also regarding the use of names, the fact that the women are never addressed by their first name at any time in the play may express the male attitude that women are not supposed to act individualistically. The next feminist ideal shown to the reader comes in the form of a negative male stereotype-that men are uncaring and trivialize serious situations. The playwright illustrates this stereotype of male insensitivity through the constant laughing among the male characters. The speech of the Sheriff and County Attorney are described by Glaspell as “chuckling” and “scoffingly”. Also, in the beginning of the play, “the men laugh” when Mrs. Hale questions whether Mrs. Wright is going to quilt or knot her piece of fabric. In a more subtle criticism of male dominance, Glaspell makes the comparison of the bird, non-existent cat, and birdcage, to Minnie and John Wright and to John Wright’s house. Much like a bird, Minnie Wright is described as “happy and fluttery”, at least until John Wright chokes the spiritual and emotional life out of her in the “quiet and gloomy” house that can easily be compared to the now empty birdcage. Finally, and most importantly, the play views women as being more likely to pay attention to detail. According to Mr. Hale, “women are used to worrying over their trifles”.
Because of this propensity to look more carefully at seemingly insignificant details, the women of the play are able to use this stereotype in order to find the truth surrounding the murder of John Wright. The women notice the mental decay of Minnie Wright through the messiness house, and more obviously through the increased shoddiness in the stitching of one of Mrs. Wright’s quilts. “All the rest of it has been so nice and even. And look at this! It’s all over the place! Why, it looks as if she didn’t know what she was about! (After she has said this they look at each other )” The women’s fears are realized when they discover the dead bird that has been strangled much the way John Wright had been murdered. After coming to the realization that Mrs. Wright is indeed the killer, in an act of sisterhood, the women decide to protect her by not divulging the evidence that they have discovered. By not telling the men, the women are able to reverse the dominant role from male to female. The women ultimately hold the power of the situation-they are the ones that are able to determine the fate of Minnie Wright, not the male sheriff or the male judge.
Much like the play Trifles, gender roles and stereotypes are also prevalent in the play Oleanna. In the first half of the play, Carol personifies the stereotype of women as helpless, stupid, and constantly needing men to take care of them. Because Carol is too helpless to figure out material for herself, she decides to go to her superior, male professor for help. Carol states “But I don’t understand. I don’t understand. I don’t understand what anything means.” The second stereotype of women that Mamet shows the reader of the play is that of women taking the role of homemakers. Several times throughout the play, when the topic of John’s new house comes up Carol becomes immediately excited and exclaims “oh. You’re buying a new home!” These exclamations give the reader the impression that Carol longs to have a house and family much like John’s wife who is the stereotypical female homemaker. John on the other hand works and fills the stereotypical male “breadwinner” role.
Carol abuses both these female stereotypes as well as male stereotypes in order to reverse the dominant gender role from male to female. First of all, it should be noted that I read the play in a way that Carol actually took advantage of John from the beginning of the play. Carol appears to be an angry student who exaggerates her existing incompetence in order to satisfy her need to get back at the professor and at higher education in general. I came to this conclusion not only because there exists an inexplicable change in vocabulary and speaking ability between the first and second acts, but also because of the fact that she had no reason to ruin John having satisfied her two requests-to learn more and to receive a better grade. Looking at Carol’s character in this way, one can argue that Carol plays the role of the stereotypical, helpless woman, and that she abuses this stereotype in order to trap John. By acting helpless and pathetic Carol fools John into taking a comforting and almost patriarchal role. Furthermore, due to the existing gender stereotypes of males, John’s actions are easily misconstrued. Carol takes advantage of the stereotype of men being sexually driven and twists John’s actions and words in a way that make them seem at least flirtatious in nature. Yes, John did say that he liked her, and that if she came to see him more outside of class he would raise her grade; however, it is the sexually driven male stereotype that causes individuals to interpret those actions in a sexual way when taken out of context.
Both of these plays inarguably delve into the theme of gender and more specifically the use and abuse of gender roles and stereotypes. The difference in the two plays lies in the intentions behind the authors’ use of these stereotypes. Susan Glaspell uses these stereotypes in order to criticize the male-dominated culture described in her play while David Mamet uses these stereotypes in order to attack the overly feminist and politically correct views of today’s society. Despite their differences in social commentary, both of these plays revolve around the use of stereotypes in order to reverse the dominant role from male to female. The women in Trifles act in a stereotypical manner which allows them to ultimately control the fate of a woman that would normally be controlled by men, while Carol in Oleanna abuses modern gender stereotypes in order to ruin John.
Другие работы по теме:
Trifles Essay Research Paper Susan Glaspells
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Susan Glaspells’s Trifles is a little gem of a play. In one short act, the playwright presents the audience with a complex human drama leaving us with a haunting question. Did an abused Nebraska
Rae We Pray For You Essay Research
Paper Rae, We Pray for you ?Murder in the murderer is no such ruinous thought as poets and romancers will have it; it does not unsettle him, or fright him from his ordinary notice of trifles; it is an act quite easy to be contemplated.?
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Trifles Essay Research Paper Are we Living
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Are we Living in a Chauvinist Male Society? Gender roles are attitudes that a society links to each sex. They are basically prejudicial descriptions of who men and women are. In today?s society, men and women are divided into two stereotypical gender-roles; the feminine code and the masculine code.
All About Triffles Essay Research Paper Triffes
All About Triffles Essay, Research Paper Triffes of fate On the surface, Susan Glaspell’s play Trifles focuses on a wife murdering her oppressive husband. The husband is abusing his wife emotionally out on a lonely secluded farm isolated from society in the Midwest. Under the surface, the behaviors of Mrs.
Aids Essay Research Paper Engl 118 April
Aids Essay, Research Paper Engl. 118 April 14, 1996 I. Introduction Thesis- Practicing safe sex is essential in a world where diseases like AIDS exist. II. Body
A Battle Against Sexism With Feminist Drama
Essay, Research Paper Susan Glaspell wrote in a time when women were supposed to be submissive to the men of the society, especially their husbands. She bucked the system and fought traditional gender roles with her plays, short stories and essays.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Mis Essay Research Paper Trifles was written
Mis Essay, Research Paper Trifles was written in the early 1900 s by Susan Glaspell. This occurred far before the women s movement. Women were generally looked upon as possessions to their husbands. Their children, all wages, and belongings were property of their husbands. In Glaspell s story it is easily depicted as to what role the men and women portrayed in society at this time.
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Apparent Feminisms In The Play Trifles Essay
, Research Paper Apparent Feminisms in the Play Trifles Male domination in 1916, when Susan Glaspell’s play Trifles was written, was the way of life. Men controlled most women and women were not very outspoken during that time period. Mr. Wright in her play was no different from the rest, but she made him a symbol of all the men in the community.
Trifles Essay Research Paper Trifles written in
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Trifles, written in the early 1900’s by Susan Glaspell, is a one-act play illustrating how women can overreact to their own emotions, allowing these emotions to cloud their judgment. This is shown by describing the feelings of two women who are willing to defend a suspect, blame the victim, and go so far as to hide evidence, to protect another woman from being charged with murdering her husband.
Trifles By Susan Glaspell Essay Research Paper
Steven FiorilloThe thesis of this paper is to prove that the title of Susan Glaspell’s play “Trifles” represents how men considered women’s duties and their opinions to be of little importance compared to a man’s role in society. The dictionary defines the word trifle as something of little importance or value, or to deal with something as if it were of little significance or value (The American Heritage Dictionary).The play opens in Minnie Wright’s kitchen.
Trifles Essay Research Paper TriflesMention the word
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Trifles Mention the word feminist and most people think of the modern women’s movement. Long before the bra burning of the 60?s, however, writers were writing about the lives and concerns of women living in a male dominated society. Susan Glaspell’s play, Trifles, was written in 1916, long before the modern women’s movement began.
Todays Women Vs Yesterday
’s Essay, Research Paper Today’s Woman Vs. Yesterday’s Women of today have come a long way since the periods portrayed in the dramas “Trifles,” written by Susan Glaspell, and “Doll House,” written by Henrik Ibsen. In both dramas, the characters
Trifles
& The Glass Menagerie Essay, Research Paper Short Answer #1- In Susan Glaspell?s Trifles, the dialog between characters creates the deep meaning of the story. The attitudes of the men is much different than that of the women, thus adding to one of the major themes. The speech of the women when they are alone conveys a completely separate attribute of the play.
The Treatment Of Women In Trifles Essay
, Research Paper The Treatment of Women in Trifles “Trifles,” a one-act play written by Susan Glaspell, is a cleverly written story about a murder and more importantly, it effectively describes the treatment of women during the early 1900s. In the opening scene, we learn a great deal of information about the people of the play and of their opinions.
Symbolism In Trifles Essay Research Paper Susan
Symbolism In Trifles Essay, Research Paper Susan Glaspell wrote Trifles in the early 1900 s long before the modern women s movement began. Symbolism is used in the play so that the audience is able to see through the eyes of Minnie Wright, and determine why she killed her husband. Character s names, the bird, and a quilt are three key symbols Glaspell uses in the play to provide the audience with the insight on the never heard, or seen characters, Minnie and John Wright.
Trifles Essay Research Paper Little Trifles Add
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Little Trifles Add Up to a Big Case Detectives are always looking for little pieces of evidence when investigating a crime. After all, it is this evidence that can turn a trial around, whether be it for the good or bad. This is especially the case in Susan Glaspell’s Trifles. When Mrs.
Oleana Essay Research Paper Enl 102Rough draft
Oleana Essay, Research Paper Enl 102 Rough draft Oleanna The ending of Oleanna could have been prevented. I t didn t have to end with John loosing control. The story is based on miscommunication. Carol could have told John from the beginning that she felt uncomfortable instead of going behind his back and press charges.
Critical Analysis Of Oleanna Essay Research Paper
Critical Analysis The most straight forward gender conflict in the movie Oleanna is that between the Professor and the student. She accuses him of sexual harassment. He denies it and they go before the Tenure Committee who find him guilty. The question at hand is what is sexual harassment? Must the harasser intend to harass?
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
John Minnie And Petie A Love Triangle
Essay, Research Paper Karen Rayne Mrs. Wolf English 102.004 2 March 2001 John, Minnie, and Petie, A Love Triangle: Comedy and Tragedy in Susan Glaspell’s Trifles
Woman S Justice Essay Research Paper Woman
Woman S Justice Essay, Research Paper Woman s Justice Susan Glaspell s Trifles misleads its readers into the impression that its focus it the investigation the murder of Mr. Wright. Glaspel goes much deeper then the Murder-she-wrote version of a mid-western game of clue; instead, readers are drawn into a good old day s version of Men are from Mars and Woman are from Venus .
The Motive Of Two Murders Essay Research
Paper The Motive of Two Murders Victor Guadalupe Caban M,W,F 8:30 am 02/3/2000 In the play “Trifles” the main character Mrs. Wright was accused of killing her husband while he was sleeping. As the play goes along we learned that she was motivated by certain situations that happened when she lived with her husband.
Trifles Essay Research Paper Trifles was a
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Trifles was a play based on a real life tragedy. A tragedy in which a man was found strangled in his bed while the wife unknowingly sleeps. The author, Susan Glaspell, was on staff at the Des Moines Daily News when the murdered occurred. The play is said to draw upon a detective s story.
Trifles Essay Research Paper Susan Glaspell was
Trifles Essay, Research Paper Susan Glaspell was born in 1882 in Davenport, Iowa. She graduated from Drake University and worked as a journalist on the staff of the Des Moines Daily News. When her stories began appearing in magazines such as Harper’s and The Ladies’ Home Journal, she gave up the newspaper business.
A Doll House Essay Research Paper In
A Doll House Essay, Research Paper In Isben’s A Doll House as in Glaspell’s Trifles, the women in the play are seen as subordinates to their male counterparts. The men believe that the women are not capable
Oleanna By David Mamet Essay Research Paper
?Oleanna? by David Mamet The Birmingham Stage Company, directed by John Harrison. The Old Rep Theatre, Wednesday September 29th The Birmingham Stage Company is the resident company of the Old Rep Theatre. Its patrons are Sir Derek Jacobi and Paul Scofield. The company is unfounded and relies mainly on box office income.
The Faith Of Young Goodman Brown Essay
, Research Paper Timothy Wenk Bailey Engl. 1302 16 Feb. 2000 The Faith of Young Goodman Brown Faith, and the struggle to keep it, is the theme of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown.” In this story, Hawthorne gives Goodman Brown’s wife the name of Faith for the obvious symbolism and irony it creates.
Realism In Drama Essay Research Paper Realism
Realism In Drama Essay, Research Paper Realism in Drama Realism in drama is a kind of writing in which fictional events and people are presented in language that resembles everyday external reality and human experience. Realistic plays such as the drama, Trifles by Susan Glaspell reflect reality and are faithful to lived experiences.