Mechanistic Thinking Essay, Research Paper
Introduction
Organisations are tools to aid in achieving a set goal. Organisations same as corporations have been developing and improving with time to improve profitability through increased productivity and quality. Most organisations are run like machines 24 hour a day, 7 days a week. All complex tasks and goals have been subdivided into simple 1-step operations that can be controlled with machine precision. Mechanistic way of thinking supports centralised hierarchy where everybody follow set rules and procedures without even thinking, creating unhealthy bureaucracy which slows down or even stops any attempts of change and innovation. However, today s world is becoming very turbulent. Like a living organism, it needs to react instantaneously to number of inside and outside inputs in order to stay operational. This paper will discuss the issues and problems with mechanistic thinking and it effects on managers performance in today s organisations.
Mechanistic Approach
In the mechanical age it was believed the universe was understood and everything could by analysed by inquiry. Russell Ackoff (1993) describes it as a tree step process: take it apart, understand the pieces and put it together. Many aspects of the mechanistic world-view were to be reinforced in the Industrial Revolution in Europe. The mechanisation of work had spiral like effect on production. The production could be skyrocketed by simplifying production tasks. This was achieved by dividing every operation into simple steps. Every worker was in charge of one step to keep production at peak.
Strengths
Mechanistic thinking has number of strengths. It can provide an efficient working environment. Using its three step analyse by inquiry process it can break any tasks into simple one step processes, that can be mastered to perfection. This gives the tasks unrealistic processing speed and unbelievable accuracy. Mechanistic organisations have tight control of power and order. It has well defined hierarchy and order of command. Everyone in an organisation knows their space , the tasks to do, the responsibilities they have. If a problem develops it is automatically evaluated, broken down and tasks and responsibilities associated to appropriate personnel.
Weaknesses
Mechanistic organisation can only be successful in a stable well-defined environment. This on its own causes a problem as most organisations work in organic like randomly changing environment. Any unpredictable changes can push the system out of equilibrium and the whole organisation falls apart.
Another problem with mechanistic view is the human relation perspective. People can produce meaningless tasks for a limited time. They loose focus and inspiration when stretched for too long.
The centralised hierarchy is another problem where it can provide a barrier to communication.
Is it still used
Change & innovation
To better visualise the problem lets see an example of a task, for example submission and evaluation of a suggestion in OfficeWorks. The staff that finds a way to improve a service needs to submit its suggestion to its supervisor or suggestion box. Than the manager of the relevant department needs to approve it and resubmit it to the store manager. If approve it is then passed on to the state manager who needs to submit it to the central national office for evaluation. There a store is picked for a trial and if successful national policy is updated across all offices. This process can be seen as long and it will take some time before innovative idea can be implemented. It would have been easier if the store manager could initialise the evaluation in his store and pass the findings to the national office directly. This was the cycle could be shortened and the organisation would become more innovative and competitive.
Conclusion
When the rate of change in both the organisation and its environment is relatively low, it can be productive to view an organisation and its people as a great machine with precisely interlocking parts, and this is the essential mentality, which underlies classical management thinking. But in rapidly changing environments, mechanistic thinking is not productive, and it becomes essential to recognise that social and biological entities have much more flexibility and adaptiveness than machines.
Organisations and human beings are complex systems, whose behaviour can neither be precisely predicted nor precisely controlled. At best, we can learn to gradually influence the behaviour of such systems as they continuously modify themselves and their actions in relation to the continuously changing environments in which they exist. In healthy living systems, the process of continuous change results in a dynamic balance between having structure on the one hand and having flexibility on the other. Today’s managers need to focus on identifying and enhancing their own and their organisation s ability to maintain their appropriate balance
References
cfam/pages/aboutthemodel.htm
Ackoff, R., (1993). From Mechanistic to Social Systemic Thinking. April 2001. [on-line] mngt.waikato.ac.nz/depts/mnss/courses/emba/ackoff/tsld001.htm
Другие работы по теме:
Moon Essay Research Paper Conclusion on the
Moon Essay, Research Paper Conclusion on the Moon Watch When I first got this assignment I was thinking I am never going to be able to do this every night for a month. I surprised myself once again. This class has made me doubt myself many times but I always seem to pull myself up to do it. I believe I did very well on this experiment and I achieved the purpose.
Writing A Poem Essay Research Paper Writing
Writing A Poem Essay, Research Paper Writing a Poem It is beyond reason; there is no motive, no explanation Why it is, I do not know because there is cause, no clarification.
Two Hearted River Essay Research Paper In
Two Hearted River Essay, Research Paper In this story Nick and the fish at the bottom of the river share many similarities. Of course the do not look alike but they seem to think the same in a way. They both have reasons to be where they are.
Your Smile Essay Research Paper I see
Your Smile Essay, Research Paper I see you across the room, Laughing with your friends. Not noticing me watching you, Staring at you. Not noticing me. I?ve grown to the point of obsession
Tapping Essay Research Paper Do you hear
Tapping Essay, Research Paper Do you hear the tapping at my window pane? They who hear it are insane Sharply tapping, slightly screaching I can feel it getting closer, now its reaching
Dumpster Diving Essay Research Paper Dumpster DivingHow
Dumpster Diving Essay, Research Paper Dumpster Diving How many time have you or someone you know thrown away items that could be given to goodwill or recycled. I know I have done this many times without thinking that these
A Tunnel Of Light Essay Research Paper
As I look at the stars above Thinking about my life I might make the first cut With this silver knife People ask me why I’m like this And I don’t know why Someone drove me to it
Thinking Essay Research Paper The young man
Thinking Essay, Research Paper The young man trying to figure out the opposite sex in an incredibly hard task. Although as the years go by it becomes easier whith every relationship that goes by. Considering now I’m twenty and if I knew when I was sixteen what I know now, I probably could have saved myself from a lot of aggravation, frustration, and much devastation.
Three Vitures Of SelfControl Moderation And Independent
Thinking Essay, Research Paper People possess many virtues. They can vary from person to person. Some of them are good and others aren?t. The three best virtues to have would be self-control, moderation and independent thinking.
Can We Ever Reach Certainty Essay Research
Paper First, I would like to quote Descartes: “Cogito, ergo sum” – I think, therefor I am. He said this, because he didn’t know weather he knew if he existed or not. Descartes thought like this: I know that I’m dreaming, but I don’t know if it’s reality or dream, I doubt. But because I doubt, I think, and if I am thinking, I am a human, thinking, being, and therefor – I exist – “Cogito, ergo sum”.
Fantasy Story Essay Research Paper Thinking that
Fantasy Story Essay, Research Paper Thinking that it maybe was about time for something not so spectacular, I grabbed this book by Iain Not-M Banks while I was at the bookstore (getting The Naked God). Good thing.
Crew Resource Management Essay Research Paper More
Crew Resource Management Essay, Research Paper More up-to-date thinking has given us much improved facilities on the aircraft, and Crew Resource Management (CRM). At the very least, CRM is intended to ensure that the Pilot receives information and advice from not only the other crewmembers, but also from external sources such as ATC and FSS.
Binary Thinking Essay Research Paper Binary thinking
Binary Thinking Essay, Research Paper Binary thinking related to Salem Witch Trials The Puritans were European settlers that established home in Salem Village in the 1630s. They believed that they were a dominant group because of their practices. They saw their religion as superior to any other religion.
Rational Thinking Essay Research Paper The Change
Rational Thinking Essay, Research Paper The Change in Rational Thinking Before 1750 The idea of rational thinking has been debated ever since the beginning of human existence. As humans we base what we think on what we know, during the 1600’s if a person was black than they must have been inferior. This thinking seemed “rational” to the people of this period because they didn’t know any better.
Him Essay Research Paper I think about
Him Essay, Research Paper I think about him day and night The though won’t go away And, oh, how I would hold him tight every second of the day He is perfect, that is true, not an average me or you
Critical Thinking Essay Research Paper Critical thinking
Critical Thinking Essay, Research Paper Critical thinking would be important to the well being of our society for many reasons except for the fact that hardly anyone ever uses it. If people used critical thinking all the time society would be a very different place. People would actually think about what they were going to say and what it means before they said it.
Mechanistic Organismic And Contextualist Essay Research Paper
1) Mechanistic, Organismic, and Contextualist, world views all approach understanding lives differently. Explain. Theories that share worldviews may differ on the particulars and may even be in opposition on some points, but they still share a set of basic assumptions or building blocks that each has used in arriving at it’s conclusions (Goldhaber, 9).
The Road Essay Research Paper Oh how
The Road Essay, Research Paper Oh how many times i have driven this road with butterflies in my stomach, a gleam in my eye. Just knowing i was going to see you.
Personal Mission Statement Essay Research Paper I
Personal Mission Statement Essay, Research Paper I believe that the following statements are very true for my personal mission statement. Hear both sides before judging. This statement most people should remember. So often people judge and say what they are thinking at the spur of the moment before really thinking the situation over and hear other sides before speaking.
MindBody Distinction Essay Research Paper MindBody distinction
Mind-Body Distinction Essay, Research Paper Mind-Body distinction We usually view the mind as the brain and body as something physical. The mind may be better known and understood when one is thinking. When thinking, the mind is made up purely of thoughts and the body is an extension. The mind is telling the body what to do.
Metaphysics Essay Research Paper METAPHYSICSTHEORY OF KNOWLEDGE
Metaphysics Essay, Research Paper METAPHYSICS THEORY OF KNOWLEDGE AND BEYOND The complex knowledge of metaphysics ? once comprehended ? is capable of helping an individual reach self-realization. Aristotle, a renowned man of thinking, conjured metaphysics to help understand the theories of intelligence – - it?s core of existence and where it comes from, truth, and cause.
Creative Thinking Essay Research Paper 12 STEPS
Creative Thinking Essay, Research Paper 12 STEPS TO CREATIVE THINKING by James Lund Do you ever get thinker’s block? You have to come up with a great idea for a project, buy the perfect gift, write a sermon, develop a solution to an on-going problem – and nothing comes to mind? Your frustration at not having a ready response can inhibit any further creative thinking.
Good Earth Essay Essay Research Paper The
Good Earth Essay Essay, Research Paper The Good Earth Essay The Good Earth by Pearl Buck provides an excellent form of archetypal structure. It shows how nature is clean and pure, while the mechanistic world is corrupt and evil. There are many ways that it can be proven, yet only three are really stressed throughout the novel.
Perception Of Others Essay Research Paper Perception
Perception Of Others Essay, Research Paper Perception of others and myself has played a big role in my life. It has changed the way society thinks. It has us thinking twice about someone or something, before we can make an assumption. Without perception everyone would probably be boring. It was my first day at Walter J.high school.
Math Essay Research Paper Math seems to
Math Essay, Research Paper Math seems to be one of my stronger subjects. All through elementary school, junior high school, and high school, I have always shown strong points in mathematics. Majority of the time, math was a class that I did not mind going to. I definitely did not find it boring because you are always doing something.
Dinquent Essay Research Paper When things go
D|inquent Essay, Research Paper When things go wrong, When things don’t go the way you wanted, You know it’s the right time To call it quits. He or she wouldn’t know what you have in mind,
Hamlet 12 Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Hamlet 12 Essay, Research Paper Hamlet’s “Tragic Flaw” Hamlet’s famous soliloquy (Hamlet, act III, scene 1) shows his depth and ability in thinking, and shows Shakespeare’s ability to manipulate language. Throughout the play, Hamlet stops to think before acting on anything. The more he thinks, the less he does.