Paper
Independence of Judiciary in Australia
a) How is the independence of the judiciary guaranteed in Australia?
While the Westminster system had largely developed because of the doctrine of
separation of powers, the Australian system of government is largely based on
the Westminster. This doctrine of separation of powers proposes that the three
institutions of government, the legislature, the executive and the judiciary
should be exercised as separate and independent branches. It is this doctrine
that stresses the need for the independence of the judiciary from the other two
government institutions in order to protect the freedom of individuals. It is
under this doctrine that no person can be a Member of Parliament and a judge at
the same time. The doctrine of separation of powers offers several advantages,
it proposes separate, specialized and efficient branches of government and it
also reduces the abuse of government power by dividing it.
a) Why is the independence of the judiciary an important feature of Australia’s
system of justice?
The judiciary is the government branch that is concerned with the administration
of justice. The judiciary is absolutely separate from the executive and the
legislature, so it can check the concentration of government power. The
independence of the judiciary is crucial of a democratic community because when
judges are presiding over cases, there must be no interference and intimidation
from the external forces. The independence issues touches upon the conflict of
authority and freedom. If the doctrine of separation of powers did not exist,
the authority would not be prevented from interfering in the administration of
justice, therefore the basic freedoms of the citizens would not be guaranteed.
It is up to the judiciary to exercise according to the law. It would be without
the independence of the judiciary that the principles of rule of law and natural
justice would be jeopardy and other institutions of government would interfere
in the administration of justice.
There are three main elements of the independence of the judiciary they are,
permanency of tenure, dismissal by parliament and fixed remuneration. Permanency
of tenure means that judges are appointed by the executive government and have a
permanent tenure until they have to retire at the age of seventy. It was a
constitutional referendum in 1977 that placed this requirement on federal judges.
Also state laws have been made, for the state judges to retire at the same age.
The only exception is the Family court justices; they have to retire at the age
of sixty-five.
Judges can only be dismissed on the grounds of proved misbehaviour or incapacity
and can only be dismissed by parliament representatives. This is a very serious
undertaking and has been used in the Australian parliament, but no federal
judges have ever been dismissed. The constitution provides that a salary of a
judge cannot be reduced. This is to prevent manipulation of salaries to a low
level, which would force judges to retire from the bench. This would be suitable
to an indirect interference in the independence on the judicature. However
parliament can increase judges salary if the wish to.
Judges also must not interfere with each other’s deliberations and decisions.
While judges hear and make judgments and administer laws, the doctrine of
precedent is so entrenched as a rule of conduct that it is the golden rule for
judges to follow legal principles created as precedents in superior courts.
Judicial independence is also necessary because a judge cannot hear an appeal
from a case that she or he have just presided over, this would lead to an
inconsistency in deciding the appeal.
Judges also have judicial independence. They have a law that protects them from
having threats of civil litigation for their statements in their judgments. It
is also a criminal offence for a person to interfere with a judge’s performance
while they are performing their duties. The rule of law is strictly applied; to
acknowledge that everyone has an equal standing before the law and accepted
judicial practices must be followed.
b) Give two examples how judges must comply with the rule of law.
The doctrine of precedent is a fixed rule of the judicial conduct. It is the
inferior courts that have the obligations to follow the legal principles created
in the superior courts. This when decisions made in the superior courts become
binding precedents on inferior courts and judges cannot ignore them. For example
if a District Court judge ignores the legal principle made in the Supreme Court,
then on appeal it certain that the decision will be reversed because accepted
judicial rules were not followed.
It is the principle of independent judiciary that conforms to the rule against
bias. Everyone expects their justice to be administered by a member of the
judiciary who is independent form the legislative and executive powers of the
government and completely impartial to the case before them for resolution.
Judges are expected to be disqualified themselves when they have any
interference with the financial or other interests in the outcome of a case.
This is the fundamental principle for the application of constitutional law as
it is to criminal law. For example a person, who is challenging the legality of
legislation at a great cost, would expect the judge to resolve the case on its
merit rather than the power of the government institution.
Другие работы по теме:
Revolutionary War 2 Essay Research Paper The
Revolutionary War 2 Essay, Research Paper The British lost and the Americans won the Revolutionary war. Though this is true there are arguments that the British lost the war more than the Americans won it. The Americans were under the control of the British and the Americans at first did not even have the intention of independence.
Australia In The VIetnam War Essay Research
Paper The only time Australia has come under direct attack from another country, was when Japan bombed Darwin and sunk a number of ships in Sydney, during World War 2. The question then has
History Of Australia Essay Research Paper History
History Of Australia Essay, Research Paper History of Australia 1901 2000 Between the years of 1901-2000, much occurred in the history of the proud, independent nation. Over more than 100 years ago, Australia fought the battle for federation against England. Australia proposed to be an independent, self-governed nation of six states and territories.
Racsim Essay Research Paper Racism is a
Racsim Essay, Research Paper Racism is a very big issue. I think most people say things without realising they are being racist. This doesn t excuse their behaviour but most people
Australia
– Monarchy Or Republic Essay, Research Paper Australia – Monarchy or Republic Even before James Cook discovered this continent that later would be named Australia, there where people living on this continent. They are being called Aboriginal and are the origin population of Australia. In the year of 1788 the first convicts are being sent to Australia because of over crowded prisons in Britain.
Marbury Vs Madison Essay Research Paper Marbury
Marbury Vs. Madison Essay, Research Paper Marbury V. Madison As the government was newly establishing its stronghold on the nation, forging its way to a powerful republic and instituting precedents for the future, a struggle to preserve the foundations of American Society instituted by Washington and John Adams existed as Thomas Jefferson took office.
Why Australia Joined World War I In
1914 Essay, Research Paper In 1914, Australia joined the First World War. Although it was seen as a European war, the Australia government decided that Australia should support its ‘Mother Country’, Britain. The prime-minister at the time, Joseph Cook, stated Australia’s position : “Whatever happens, Australia is a part of the Empire, right to the full.
How And Why Did Federation in Australia
) Occur? Essay, Research Paper Federation was the coming together in 1901 of the six separate Australian colonies to form what is now the Commonwealth of Australia. It occurred for many reasons including: to unite the defence of Australia; to make uniform bank laws; taxes and tariffs resulting in better trade and communication between states; and to put the ?White Australia? into practise.
Australian People Essay Research Paper Australian PeopleThe
Australian People Essay, Research Paper Australian People The population of Australia is 18,438,824.The Birth Rate is 13.73, per 1000 people. The death rate is 6.89 per 1000 people. Those two were per year on average. The migration rate is 2.71 immigrants per 1000 people. The Life expectancy is higher than the US at 79.64. (Male 76.69, Female 82.74) There are three major ethnic groups in Australia.
Decleration Of Independence Essay Research Paper NamedatehourMy
Decleration Of Independence Essay, Research Paper Namedatehour*My Declaration of Independence* In congress, July 4. The unanimous declarations of the thirteen United States of America, When during the course of people lives, people try eliminate political groups that have been combined with another political groups, and to assume the other countries that live on this planet, and to respect the God given rights to all people and creatures of this Planet, and that you would have a decent respect of the people, that you would lets us be separate from you.
Mexican Government Essay Research Paper Type of
Mexican Government Essay, Research Paper Type of Government The Mexican type of government is a presidential federal republic. The government has a president and a cabinet. It also has a bicameral legislature, and a judiciary. The government has the three traditional branches that the United States has- the executive, legislative, and judiciary branches.
Independance Essay Research Paper IndependenceIt is frightening
Independance Essay, Research Paper Independence It is frightening to be alone and to have to fend for yourself and make your own choices. Sometimes though it is a good thing to think for yourself and to not let other people tell you what to do with your life. When you are independent you do what you really want to do and stop letting others influence your decisions.
How And Why Australia
’s International Relationships Have Changed Through Its Participation In Overseas Conflict. Essay, Research Paper In this essay I will answer the question- how and why have our(Australia’s) international relationships changed by our participation in overseas conflicts ? The answer to this is that we have had changed international relationships, more independence, it ended Australia’s isolation, it gave greater social rights to women, it affirmed Australia’s alliances with the world powers and most importantly it gave Australia an identity.
The Importance Of Balance Of Power In
Europe Essay, Research Paper B.O.P. essay Without losers, there would be no winners. Moreover, if there were no evil in the world, then kindness would not exist. This is exactly the way the principle of balance of power in Europe operates. It prevented empires, and helped to aid lesser states in their times of need.
Australia Essay Research Paper Did you know
Australia Essay, Research Paper Did you know that Australia is its own country and continent? It is also the world s smallest continent and largest island with an area of 7, 671, 930 sq km. It is said to be the oldest country in the world, but it was discovered last. Australia is one of the most interesting places on the earth, because it has everything.
Declaration Of Independance And The Constitution Essay
, Research Paper Throughout the history of the United States of America, America has strived to find the best form of government to please its people. The founding fathers have felt firsthand the effects of bad government which is partially responsible for the need to establish their own country. The Declaration of Independence sets the standards for how a government should be set up.
Declaration Of Independence 2 Essay Research Paper
The Declaration of Independence The Declaration of Independence is made up of five distinct parts: the introduction; the preamble; the body, which can be divided into two sections; and a conclusion. The introduction says that the declaration will declare the causes that have made it required for the American colonies to leave the British Empire.
Executive Privelage Essay Research Paper exemption of
Executive Privelage Essay, Research Paper exemption of the executive branch of government, or its officers, from having to give evidence, specifically, in U.S. law, the exemption of the president from disclosing information to congressional inquiries or the judiciary. Claims of executive privilege are usually invoked to protect confidential military or diplomatic operations or to protect the private discussions and debates of the president with close aides.
President Roosevelt Essay Research Paper In 1943
President Roosevelt Essay, Research Paper In 1943 President Roosevelt suggested that Indochina come under the control of four powers after the war, proposing that the eventual independence of the Indo-chinese might follow in twenty to thirty years time. No one knew whether the policy would require American troops, but America was firm on the fact that independence could not be taken by the Vietnamese, but would be granted to the Vietnamese by the Great Powers at their convenience.
Australian Foreign Policy Essay Research Paper Australian
Australian Foreign Policy Essay, Research Paper Australian Foreign Policy Topic 2 Due Date: 26/5 Teacher: Br Smith Student: Luke O?Connor ?Australia was a good friend to the Indonesian independence movement in the years after World War 2, but Australia stood silently by as Dutch New Guinea was given to Indonesia.
Afl Essay Research Paper AFL football is
Afl Essay, Research Paper AFL football is one of the most loved sports in Australia. This popular game attracts over 13.9 million people a year. It has, according to research conducted in 1999 the 3rd highest number of registered players in any Australian sport with the figure standing at 447,436.
Independence Day Essay Research Paper After watching
Independence Day Essay, Research Paper After watching Independence Day the aliens should have won and taken over the earth easily, for many reasons. First when the aliens entered our atmosphere each space ship was fifteen miles wide. America has good weapons but enough to take out these spaceships that have a protective shield around them.
Eucalyptus Trees Essay Research Paper The eucalypt
Eucalyptus Trees Essay, Research Paper The eucalypt is one of the tallest trees in the world. There are more then 600 species of eucalypts in Australia. Blackbutt, jarrah, karri, stringybark, ironbark are common names of eucalypts that grow in various parts of Australia. More than ninety per cent of Australia’s trees are eucalypts.
Is Parliament Supreme Over The Judiciary And
The Executive? Give Reasons For Your Answer. Essay, Research Paper Parliament is supreme over the executive and judiciary in the way that it is the sovereign law making body. The parliament however is restricted within the constitution and it can not act outside of it. Although it does hold great power it does not have complete power due to the separation of powers.
Aboriginals In Australia Essay Research Paper ABORIGINIESHoW
Aboriginals In Australia Essay, Research Paper ABORIGINIES HoW WERE THEY TREATED? Since the beginning, Australia was said to be a colony of settlement, not of conquest. The legal fiction of terra nullius- the land belonged to no one with no official negotiations, no treaties was how the land is said to be the basic injustice on which modern Australia was built.
Welcome To Australia Essay Research Paper Welcome
Welcome To Australia Essay, Research Paper Welcome To Australia Australia is one of the most popular holiday destinations in the world. Thousands and thousands of foreign people come and visit Australia each year. This is due to our vast variety in our landscapes and animals. Also our weather is perfect in most places, especially on the coast.
Australian Report Essay Research Paper Essay Australian
Australian Report Essay, Research Paper Essay Australian Realm Why despite Australia?s visible advantages in natural resources, accessible ports and a huge educated population is Australia?s GNP growing at such a stunted
The English Language Essay Research Paper This
The English Language Essay, Research Paper This House affirms that the British Empire was a great success whose effects are still beneficial to the world. The world distribution of English users is divided into three categories : English as a native language; for example, UK, USA, Australia, English as a second language; for example, India, Singapore, Ghana, Philippines, and English as a foreign language; for example, France, Japan, Thailand.There are 72 countries with Englishs as an official language and 9 countries with English as a first language:Australia, Great- Britain, Canada, Ireland, Japan, Luxembourgh, Netherlands, New Zealand, and the USA.
Independence Day Relfection Essay Research Paper Independence
Independence Day Relfection Essay, Research Paper Independence Day! A day of celebration for all ages and races. Independence Day was the day in which the nation of Stars and Stripes became free and independent from the British. A day when the 13 colonies united to become one. It’s now a day when Americans commemorate the signing of the Declaration of Independence by kicking back and having a cold one.
Texas Independence Essay Research Paper What was
Texas Independence Essay, Research Paper What was the significance of Texas getting its Independence? After getting its independence Texas asked congress if it could join the union to become part of the U.S States. Congress accepted and so Texas became an official state. Mexico did not like the idea of Texas becoming independent and Texas wanted more land so they ended up having the war in Mexico.