Kierkegaard?s Notions Of Risk, Faith, Passion, & Truth Essay, Research Paper
???? Soren
Kierkegaard puts forth a unique form of existentialism. He chooses to use the
questions of subjectivity, objectivity, and the search for truth, in
existentialist thought as a means for the justification of his faith. Through
this he comes up with one of the purest definitions of what faith really is.
The question is then; can he through his discussion of ?the paradox of truth?
be susceptible to Nietzschian relativism, given this conception? The conclusion
is that it is not; Kierkegaard?s definition requires a passionate belief in
something. One cannot believe that everything is relative, in true Nietzschian
style, and hold a passionate belief in a specific something at the same time. ???? ?The
Paradox of Truth? is one of the base conceptions in Kierkegaard?s theoretical
framework and is core to his conceptions of faith and risk. ?A paradox results
from the relationship between the eternal (the essential truth) and the
existing individual.?[1]
This is expanded to ?The Ultimate paradox is: That the eternal truth has come
into being in time, (the infinite has become finite). To believe this paradox
(the Absurd) is to be in the highest state of truth. Christianity has declared
itself to be the eternal essential truth which has come onto being in time; it
has proclaimed itself as the paradox, and it has required of the individual the
inwardness of faith with respect to the absurd.?[2] To further
understand what Kierkegaard is saying when it comes to his ?paradox of truth?
one must understand Kierkegaard?s beliefs, when it comes to the notion of
truth. Kierkegaard seems to believe at the base of things that Truth equals
Passion, or that truth requires passion. For if you are to believe that
something is the truth, you must have passion in that belief to truly believe
it. Otherwise you do not truly believe, you simply believe because the choice
has already been made for you and you believe because you should. Which is not
true belief. True belief comes about when you have made a decision for
yourself, and believe out of your own violation, choosing to have faith even in
the face of uncertainty. ?Passionate inwardness is the mark of truth even if,
or rather when, the truth is objectively uncertain.?[3]
Kierkegaard believes that subjectivity, inwardness, and faith are synonymous
and that their definitions are an expression for truth. ?the objective
uncertainty, held fast in an appropriation process of the most passionate
inwardness is the truth.?[4] ???? The
type of uncertainty that Kierkegaard talks about my be less obvious when
considering, day to day truths, but we must remember that Kierkegaard is most
concerned with his definitions of truth and faith as they relate to him and his
relationship with God. Kierkegaard asserts that we should most concern our
selves and our hunt for truth with questions that are close to us, and so he is
concerned with the nature and basis of his faith. This preoccupation with his
faith must be taken into account as the main paradox when one reads the
following passage about the eternal truth. When the eternal
truth is related to an existing individual, truth becomes a paradox. The
paradox repels the individual because of the objective uncertainty and
ignorance towards inwardness. But since this paradox in itself is not
paradoxical, it does not push the spirit far enough. For without risk there is
no faith, and the greater the risk the greater the faith, and the more
objective reliability, the less inwardness (for inwardness is precisely
subjectivity). Indeed, the less objective reliability, the deeper becomes the
possible inwardness. When the paradox is in itself paradoxical, it repels the
individual by the power of the absurd, and the corresponding passion, which is
produced in the process, is faith.[5]???? It
is through this understanding of the paradoxical and its effect on the
individual that we come to understand Kierkegaard?s conception of faith. For
Kierkegaard one of the base truths of faith is that it requires risk. If there
is no risk that what you believe is untrue, that is that it has been proven to
you objectively, through objective evidence then you have no need of faith for
you know it is true. ?By its very nature, faith involves risk, the risk that
what you are believing is not objectively true. In fact, it is only after one
recognizes the death of God, the intellectual recognition that God does not
exist, that on is free to become genuinely ethical and existentially self
aware.?[6]
That is that when we have admitted to ourselves that based on purely
intellectual grounds there is no objective evidence to say that God exists,
only once we have come fully to the belief that there is absolutely no reason
for us to have faith in God, it is then when we take the risk of having faith
in spite of all the reasons to the contrary that we truly become self aware.
For it is when we look inward and through our inwardness choose to believe and
have faith in god in spite of the risks that we truly achieve passionate truth.
?Faith is precisely the contradiction between the infinite passion of
inwardness and objective uncertainty. If I can grasp God objectively, I do not
believe, but because I cannot know God objectively, I must have faith, and if I
will preserve myself in faith, I must constantly hold fast to the objective
uncertainty, so as to remain out upon the ocean?s deep? and still believe.?[7]
Thus faith by its very nature requires a lack of objective security. To bring
his concept of faith to even clearer, let?s consider the movie analogy of faith
presented in Indiana Jones. When Indiana is moving through all the tests of a
true believer on his way to find the Holy Grail he reaches a seemingly uncross
able chasm and is simply given the instruction that with faith he will be able
to step out and cross the gap. A leap of faith is required. Now if Indiana
objectively knew when he first got to the chasm that there was a bridge there
which blended in with the chasm walls, that he could easily step across on,
then no faith would be required. He does not however find out the objective
reason for his faith, until he has taken the risk and exercised it. Faith only
exists when there is no objective evidence. The greatest uncertainty produces
the greatest faith. Thus Kierkegaard states that the Christian faith is the
purest faith, for there is no way to ever prove it objectively and thus it
gives ?rise to the greatest degree of inwardness because it is based upon the greatest
degree of uncertainty.?[8] ???? From
here we must now face the question as to whether or not Kierkegaard?s notions
give rise to Nietzschian relativism, given this conception of truth? Nietzsche
states that ?we should be open to all views, not just our own.?[9]
So Nietzsche leaves room for Kierkegaard?s theory and allows for him to hold
it, so the two views are not exclusive from Nietzsche?s point of view. The
decision to have faith is relative to ones own choice and free will, something
that Nietzsche tells us to exercise at every opportunity. For according to
Nietzsche ?the moral earth too, is round?[10]
Does Kierkegaard?s view however, prevent relativism? The conception would be
yes. Kierkegaard?s views by their very basis in faith and passion require one
to pick a view and then have faith in it, in this case specifically, the view
that God exists, as truth. Nietzsche?s views require that one come to the
conception that there is no fixed truth, where as Kierkegaard?s beliefs in the
paradox of truth and the conceptions of faith, require that we pick something
to passionately believe in, even if it is not the true faith in God, but the
pagan wisdom that Socrates held. One way or another the framework requires that
one hold passionate belief and make decisions ?ultimately based on passion and
not on reason.?[11]? If Nietzschian relativism is to become a
problem, then one does not have a passionate belief, and thus has not
subscribed to the notions of faith, risk, and truth as Kierkegaard has outlined
them. For when you are a relativist, then you no longer have passionate faith,
and if you no longer have passionate faith then you no longer have truth, for
?passionate inwardness is the mark of truth.?[12] ???? Kierkegaard?s
philosophy has a quality to it that makes it very appealing to a believer,
whether one is a believer in God or something else, it allows someone to
justify their faith in whatever it is they choose to have faith in, be it God,
Allah, or pagan systems of faith. For according to Kierkegaard one only has to
truly and passionately believe in something. An ability to believe, given by
few if any other existentialist theoretical frameworks. Kierkegaard?s theory
thus, gives power to the human mind and the potential for finding truth of some
kind, in a universe that most of his colleges were offering no truth for, and
nothing to believe in. It is this latent understanding of the power of passion,
and the given ability to allow one to believe in something, or someone as a
means for finding truth, which prevents Kierkegaard from falling into the trap
of Nietzschian relativism given his conception of truth. References Oaklander, Nathan. ?Existentialist
Philosophy? 2nd Ed. Prentice Hall Inc, NJ, USA. 1996. Wilks, Anna. Handout #4 Kierkegaard,
?Either/Or.?Wilks, Anna. Handout #9 Kierkegaard,
?Concluding Unscientific Postscript.?Wilks, Anna. Handout #7 Nietzsche,
?Selections.? [1]Kierkegaard Handout, ?Concluding
unscientific postscript? [2] Ibid. [3] Oaklander
P.17. [4] Oaklander
P.18. [5] Ibid. P20. [6] Oaklander
P.18. [7] Oaklander. P
18. [8] Ibid. P.19. [9] Handout, #1
on Nietzche. [10] Ibid. [11] Oaklander.
P 19. [12] Oaklander.
P.17.
Другие работы по теме:
Faith Essay Research Paper WHAT IS FAITHWhat
Faith Essay, Research Paper WHAT IS FAITH? What is faith? Faith is something different to everyone. If you asked a hundred different people, it is possible that you would get many diverse answers. Religious faith and non-religious faith are two very distinct terms. Faith holds an extremely complex meaning when discussing it in the context of religion.
Faith Essay Research Paper 2
Faith Essay, Research Paper “Take up the shield of faith, with which you can extinguish all the flaming arrows of the evil one” (Ephesians 6:16). Goodman Brown did not have faith. He did not have religious faith nor faith in his fellow human beings in Salem. And because he didn’t have faith he was became vulnerable to the “flaming arrows of the evil one”.
Untitled Essay Research Paper I am afraidI
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I am afraid. I am lonely. I want to be at home now. I hate the silence. I hate the circumstances. I want to feel love now. I want to feel passion not emptiness.
Not A Christian Fallacies Essay Research Paper
Ignore fact and reason, live entirely in the world of your own fantastic and myth-producing passions; do this whole-heartedly and with conviction, and you will become one of the prophets of your age. Bertrand Russell wrote this controversial statement in his essay, How to Become a Man of Genius. Bertrand Russell was a man who some deemed one of the most provocative philosophers of his time.
Does God Exist Essay Research Paper Are
Does God Exist Essay, Research Paper Are You A Man or A Monkey ? A Disturbing Movement of Anti-Intellectualism in America ?It?s more valuable to see with the eye in one?s heart,
A Changed Goodman Essay Research Paper A
A Changed Goodman Essay, Research Paper A Changed Goodman “Young Goodman Brown” is universally accepted as one of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s best short stories. It deals with such themes as good versus evil, loss of innocence, and coping with reality. The internal struggle that Brown goes through leads him to an emotional roller coaster.
Faith Vs Temptation Essay Research Paper Faith
Faith Vs. Temptation Essay, Research Paper Faith vs. Temptation Temptation, at one time or another, has touched all of our lives. What made us choose one path over the other? Was it your faith in God, your knowing of what was right and wrong, or was it the influences of the loved ones you not only surround yourself with, but the one you have trusted to lead down the straight and narrow.
Corrie Ten Boom
’s The Hiding Place Essay, Research Paper Corrie ten Boom recounts her horrific tale of her experiences during World War II in Holland, in her novel, The Hiding Place. The real life nightmare begins with the 100th anniversary of her families watch shop. From the first paragraph it is evident that ten Boom is a warm hearted, kind individual who puts her own needs behind those of her friends and family.
Qualities OfGandhi Essay Research Paper What Qualities
Qualities OfGandhi Essay, Research Paper What Qualities of Gandhi make him a hero of faith? Ganghi was a great man, the quintessance of a hero of faith. In all religions nowadays Gandhi has attained an almost mythical status for being one of the most loving and good man that most can remember, but there are three certain qualities which allow him to be presented with this mythical “hero of faith” stature, these qualities of Gandhi, which make him a hero of faith are, his courage because he was willing to die in order to bring his country together.
Elie Weisel Night Essay Research Paper The
Elie Weisel Night Essay, Research Paper The advice the young polish prisoner gave seemed to be very sound advice. He told them that they needed to remember they were all in it together, and that they had to help each other out when they could. He also told them not to loss hope, they needed to have the faith to keep going everyday.
Kierkegaard Essay Research Paper Kierkegaard felt that
Kierkegaard Essay, Research Paper Kierkegaard felt that subjective reflection was more crucial to the individual life than objective reflection because it focused on passion and human existence instead of logic and impersonal truth. The objective world is the world of facts and truth independent of the perceptions of humans.
Bless Me Essay Research Paper Bless me
Bless Me Essay, Research Paper Bless me, Ultima Essay What is faith? Does everyone have faith? Is faith believing in something you haven?t seen but you think is true? All of these questions have
Bad Faith Essay Research Paper
“…No fate, no bad luck, no excuses, simply man, his choices, and the situation in which he finds himself…” -Anonymous The concepts of existence and human freedom have been presented by Jean-Paul Sartre in his book entitled Being and Nothingness. However, Sartre also presents other related concepts, such as bad faith which has been referred to as a device that protects us from the anguish of realizing that we are freer than we like to think we are.
Role Of Faith Essay Research Paper Role
Role Of Faith Essay, Research Paper Role of Faith Society’s investigation for adequate evidence to sustain rational belief in God may seem unsatisfactory. Throughout history, people have been appealing to reason and looking for evidence to substantiate these beliefs. However, we have not yet taken into consideration the role of faith.
The Art Of Euclid
’s Writing Essay, Research Paper In Elements book one, Euclid incorporates stylistic devices in the process of proving a series of mathematical theories. One stylistic aspect of Euclid?s writing is his use of common notions, such as the whole being greater than the part, and postulates, such as drawing a line from any point to any point.
Bronte Essay Research Paper emotions
Bronte Essay, Research Paper emotions — both joyful and sad. By creating an emotional see-saw from the encounters between Jane and Rochester, the novelist indicates that these intense emotions define true love. Bront ’s emphasis on the importance of passion in a good relationship adheres to some of the doctrines of the Evangelical religion, which dominated the Victorian age.
Elemental Imagery In Jane Eyre Essay Research
Paper The use of elemental imagery in Jane Eyre, revealed throughout the novel both literally and metaphorically, is one of Charlotte Bronte s key stylistic devices. The opposition of the two elements, fire and water, highlights the need for the characters to find equilibrium between the two. Fire can describe passion and warmth, but it can also burn.
Fahrenheit 451 Essay Research Paper
“We don’t read and write poetry because it’s cute, we read and write poetry because we are members of the human race and the human race is full of passion.” Mr. Keating said this to try to get his class to look beyond writing poems because the teacher told them to and because that is what they have done for years. But to write poems that meant something and had passion.
College Essay Essay Research Paper College EssayThroughout
College Essay Essay, Research Paper College Essay Throughout the years, I have had to deal with many trials, and challenges. Growing up BI-racial had a big affect on both my parents? relationship, my relationship with my parents (which later on lead to their separation). There were cultural clashes within my household; my mother who was from Korea, and my father who was from Panama.
St Augustine Postmodernity Essay Research Paper What
St. Augustine- Postmodernity Essay, Research Paper What does St. Augustine have to say to post-modern culture? I think that the most vital aspect in Augustine’s Confessions, more specifically his books “Student at Carthage” and “The birth-pangs of Conversion”, is the concept of True Love. Augustine tells us that love is paradoxically balanced between reason and passion, as both reason and passion can be both good and evil at some time or another.
John Keats Romantism Essay Research Paper Identify
John Keat`s Romantism Essay, Research Paper Identify and discuss the elements of Romanticism as given expression in John Keats’ poem Lamia and William Wordsworth’s excerpt from The Excursion. The term
Immortality Essay Research Paper I think that
Immortality Essay, Research Paper I think that the immortality of the human soul can be established in a demonstrative way by philosophical reason, through a sufficiently deep analysis of intellectual knowledge, of free will and of disinterested feelings such as that “immortal instinct for beauty”, of which Poe and Baudelaire spoke.
Sgt York Life Legend And Legacy Essay
, Research Paper Sgt. York His Life, Legend, and Legacy Book Review Sgt. York: His Life, Legend, and Legacy, John Perry, Nashville, TN, Broadman and Holdman Publishers, 1997, 349 pgs, $16.99. In his thought-provoking book Sgt. York: His Life, Legend, and Legacy, John Perry details the life of Congressional Medal of Honor winner Alvin C.
Young Goodman Brown Essay Research Paper A
Young Goodman Brown Essay, Research Paper A True RomanceVS. Young Goodman Brown Nathaniel Hawthorne, in his short story, “Young Goodman Brown”, generates a relationship in direct contrast with that of a true romance among the roles of Faith and Young Goodman Brown. Whereas, a
Young Goodman Brown 2
Young Goodman Brown – Losing Faith Essay, Research Paper In the book Young Goodman Brown by Nathaniel Hawthorne, Goodman Brown wife’s name is important to the story because Goodman Brown loses his faith but his wife Faith keeps her faith. The story takes place in a puritan town in Salem back when there believed to be witches.
The Faith Of Young Goodman Brown Essay
, Research Paper Timothy Wenk Bailey Engl. 1302 16 Feb. 2000 The Faith of Young Goodman Brown Faith, and the struggle to keep it, is the theme of Nathaniel Hawthorne’s “Young Goodman Brown.” In this story, Hawthorne gives Goodman Brown’s wife the name of Faith for the obvious symbolism and irony it creates.
Commentary On The Bhagavad Gita Essay Research
Paper Commentary on the Bhagavad Gita by Farhan Abbasi This modern day translation of the Bhagavad Gita, written by Barbara Stoller Miller, focused briefly on Krishna’s Counsel in Time of War. It was a fairly short yet in depth description of Hindu beliefs and the conflicts that humans encounter when deciding which path to follow.
Perceptions Of Faith In Young Goodman Brown
Essay, Research Paper Perceptions of Faith in ?Young Goodman Brown? Throughout ones journey in life, our individual perceptions of faith in God, in mankind, and in ourselves, guide us along our path. In the absence of clarity of our faith, one is led to believe the norm is what proves to be popular within a society.
The Power Of Faith Essay Research Paper
“The Power of Faith” Faith is a word of many synomns. The Webster dictionary states that faith is trust; confidence – the complete acceptance of a truth, which cannot be demonstrated or proved by the process of logical thought. The Bible dictionary reveals that faith is belief; trust – especially in a higher power.