’s In Education Essay, Research Paper
Integrating Film and Television into Social Studies Instruction
By their own accounts and those of their critics, the current generation of
students is a video generation. They learned to read with Big Bird on “Sesame
Street” and their view of the world has been largely formed and shaped through visual culture. This familiarity can make film and video a powerful pedagogical tool. Visual media also address different learning modalities, making material more accessible to visual and aural learners. Add to this the rich array of diverse videos and documentaries available and it’s easy to see why these formats represent the second most popular source used in social studies classes.
However, the very qualities that make film and video so popular present problems as well. For students raised on a steady diet of media consumption, film and documentary footage used in the classroom often becomes “edutainment.” This does more than simply distort historical and social issues. It reinforces the passive viewing and unquestioning acceptance of received material that accompanies growing up in a video environment.
That passivity and lack of critical awareness is anathema to a democracy. An essential aspect of social studies education is the teaching of information and skills needed by people who are to participate actively as citizens in a democratic society. Thirty years ago this meant teaching students to read the newspaper critically, to identify bias there, and to distinguish between factual reporting and editorializing. Critical viewing skills must be added to this effort. One solution to the omnipotence of visual culture is to develop a
critical awareness of that culture.
The last ten years have witnessed many efforts combining media literacy and pedagogy. For social studies teachers, an excellent starting point is John E. O’Connor’s IMAGE AS ARTIFACT: THE HISTORICAL ANALYSIS OF FILM AND TELEVISION. O’Connor’s work discusses pedagogical approaches to film and video that have their antecedents in the philosophy of historical and social studies inquiry. He defines three basic types of questions that historians ask of any document and applies these to film and video. This is followed by an explication of four frameworks for historical inquiry concerning visual material. These approaches and techniques are neither sequential nor separate; rather they are complementary, designed to be combined and applied throughout the learning process.
THREE TYPES OF QUESTIONS
(1) Questions about Content. How is the information determined by the visual and aural mechanics of the film? This requires a basic knowledge of the language of film and narrative structure. Teachers should be familiar with editing techniques, camera angles, the uses of sound, and other aspects of the presentation. Similarly, they need some knowledge of film structure. Any number of introductory texts on film production can provide this. A good example is THE ART OF WATCHING FILMS (1996) by Joseph M. Boggs.
(2) Questions about Production. Beyond the cultural and social aspects of the film, what influences were at work in shaping the document? How might the background (personal, political, professional) of the producer, director, writer, actors have influenced the presentation? Interviews, trade magazines, and the national press provide good coverage for recent productions. Press kits and promotional materials are also an excellent, albeit biased, primary source. For older films, memoirs and biographies often provide insight.
(3) Questions about Reception. How was the document received at the time of its production? What factors influenced this reception? Has the critical reception changed over the years? Did this production influence other works? social movements? trends? This approach lends itself well to student projects researching historical reviews and other related stories. Journals and magazines covering mass media history are a particularly rich source.
FOUR FRAMEWORKS FOR HISTORICAL INQUIRY
(1) The Moving Image as Representation of History. This approach is often useful simply for acquainting students with a sense of time, place, and material culture. The judicious use of clips from one or several films can introduce students to such issues as living conditions, family relations, social customs, and commerce. For instance, a recent exhibit at the National Institute of Medicine showed scenes from Kenneth Branagh’s “Frankenstein” to illustrate early medical practices. Recent studies reveal that many teachers use video clips in this or similar fashions.
(2) The Moving Image as Evidence for Social and Cultural History. This approach represents a virtual gold mine for social studies and history teachers. Popular culture often reflects the social and cultural environment of its times more accurately than it reveals its subject. Laurence Oliver’s “Henry V” (1945),
made in England during the dark days of World War II, was a stirring paean to patriotism. Later versions stressed the horrors of war. Films involving national and folk heroes, in particular, often act as ritual myths
illuminating contemporary conflicts as they reenact a familiar story. The classic American conflict between Wyatt Earp, the Clanton gang, and Doc Holliday has been told as a mythic western, “My Darling Clementine” (1946), a psychological drama, “Gunfight at the O.K. Corral” (1957), and a revisionist put-down, “Doc” (1971). While film can serve as an engaging introduction to a subject, students should be aware of the constant shading and biases, why these occur, and what they accomplish. Filmmakers involved in recent biographies of George Wallace and Larry Flynt admitted to seriously sanitizing their subjects to fit narrative formats and audience expectations.
(3) Actuality Footage as Evidence for Historical Fact. A filmed record appears indisputable. Indeed, our very language supports this notion with phrases such as “seeing is believing” and “with your own two eyes.” This suggests that footage of a real-life event possess an unvarnished veracity. Documentary
footage, however, is never wholly objective. An examination of filming and editing, circumstances surrounding production and distribution, and the producer’s intentions are essential for studying such material. Students should be aware that much early newsreel footage was faked. Indeed, this questionable
practice continues today. Another essential question to ask: what was left out of the documentary?
(4) The History of the Moving Image as Industry and Art Form. The history and development of modern culture is inextricably intertwined with the growth of industry. In the twentieth century the growth of the communication and entertainment industries has been both progenitor and reflector of social change. Individual films can be treated as emblematic of changes within that industry. Broader topics could include: changes in distribution, financing, and ownership. For example, how is the current situation among independent filmmakers similar or different than the early days of movie making?
LOCATING MATERIALS
A wealth of material is available at libraries and video stores. Fortunately there is a corresponding boom in books providing lists, categories, and annotations on this material. Here are a few that should prove useful:
PICTURE THIS!: A GUIDE TO OVER 300 ENVIRONMENTALLY, SOCIALLY, and POLITICALLY
RELEVANT FILMS AND VIDEOS by Sky Hiatt, Chicago, Noble Press (1992); FILMS BY GENRE: 775 CATEGORIES, STYLES, TRENDS, AND MOVEMENTS DEFINED WITH A FILMOGRAPHY FOR EACH by Daniel Lopez, McFarland and Co. (1993); HOLLYWOOD AND AMERICAN HISTORY: A FILMOGRAPHY OF OVER 250 MOTION PICTURES DEPICTING U.S. HISTORY by Michael R. Pitts, McFarland and Co. (1984); FACETS AFRICAN-AMERICAN VIDEO GUIDE by Patrick Ogle, Facets Multimedia, Inc. (1994). Teachers interested in further inquiry and useful background information should check out BIO-PICS: HOW HOLLYWOOD CONSTRUCTED PUBLIC HISTORY by George F. Custen, Rutgers University Press (1992) and HISTORY BY HOLLYWOOD: THE USE AND ABUSE OF THE AMERICAN PAST by Robert Brent Toplin, University of Illinois Press (1996). Two different
perspectives are provided by George Macdonald Frasier’s lively and caustic THE HOLLYWOOD HISTORY OF THE WORLD: FROM ONE MILLION YEARS B.C. TO APOCALYPSE NOW published by Beech Tree Books, (1988), and the exhibition catalog HOLLYWOOD AND HISTORY: COSTUME DESIGN IN FILM organized by Edward Maeder, Los Angeles County Museum of Art (1987).
Educators interested in posting historical questions concerning the production and distribution of films and the industry can subscribe to the Film History listserv. To subscribe, send the message SUBSCRIBE H-FILM Firstname Surname, Affiliation (for example, SUBSCRIBE H-FILM Matthew Paris, Indiana University) to LISTSERV@msu.edu.
Net surfers may want to look at “Screening the Past: An International Electronic Journal of Visual Media and History” at latrobe.edu.au/www/screeningthepast and “Film & History: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Film and Television Studies” at h-net2.msu.edu/ filmhis/. More information on media literacy can be acquired through the Center for Media Literacy in Los Angeles, California, telephone: 213-931-4177; FAX: 213-931-4474; World Wide Web: medialit/.
Другие работы по теме:
Inventing Reality Essay Research Paper Inventing RealityHow
Inventing Reality Essay, Research Paper Inventing Reality How much of what the news media tells us is true, and how does it control our view of the world? In his book Inventing Reality, Michael Parenti examines the subtle but profound ways in which the media influence and manipulate the public’s perception of reality.
Censorship Essay Research Paper The negative messages
Censorship Essay, Research Paper The negative messages kids receive via the media have a damaging affect on their psyche and can create serious societal problems. In truth “[t]he violence to which American children are exposed in the name of
Mad City Essay Research Paper The movie
Mad City Essay, Research Paper The movie Mad City demonstrates to us how the media can control our lives. The media is willing to go to any length for the money a story can bring. Max portrays the role of humanity in this film. Max represents the humanity of the media. He seems to be the only trace of humanity in all of the media.
American Media Dominating Canadian Culture Essay Research
Paper American Media Dominating Canadian Culture The possibility of the American media taking over Canadian culture has always been an intimidating issue for Canadians over the past few decades. It has been known that the American model of life is one that is very different from ours and that the ?americanization? of Canada could prove to be a threat of losing our own values and beliefs.
Technology And Media Essay Research Paper Look
Technology And Media Essay, Research Paper Look around us today, what do you see? Technology being thrown at you from all kinds of places. For one the media has brought technology to another level. But if you really look at the whole picture technology is media. The both of them interact with each other. We are swamped by media and technology, having no control over it, and don’t know what to believe about technology anymore.
The Media And The Fear Of Victimization
Essay, Research Paper The Media and the Fear of Victimization Tonight’s presenter spoke on the images of crime that are presented on television and the media and how they affect the public perception on being
The Media And Sexual SelfConcept Essay Research
Paper The Media and its impact on Sexual Self-Concept The media plays a great part in the viewpoints of individuals involving sex. The media plays an especially major role in Americans sexual self-concept. As an individual, the media has played a major role in my personal views about sex. From the time, most people can remember some form of media has always been there, whether it was television, radio, or anything there has always been some form of media.
Media Selective Exposure Perception Essay Research
Paper The media needs to introduce something interesting so that instead of flipping channels over to some entertainment a person will stay on the news channel. So they devise a strategy based on selective exposure to get one?s attention and stop the channel surfing. What the public perceives can sometimes be based on how much of the story they have heard.
Media In Society Essay Research Paper The
Media In Society Essay, Research Paper The media in today?s society plays a very important role. There are two different kinds of media, written and non-written. Written media consists of newspapers and magazines. Non-written media consists of television and radio. These media?s differ in many ways. I am going to compare and contrast the two different types of media in today?s society.
What Is Critical Thinking Essay Research Paper
Critical thinking is taking the information that you receive from the media or any source of information, and analyzing it to determine its value. By determining it’s value, I mean differentiating between useful, cogent, information that will help you build your knowledge structures, and information that could be fallacious, and doesn’t have sufficient evidence or support to be cogent.
American History X Essay Research Paper In
American History X Essay, Research Paper In many ways, the media must be involved in ethnic and racial issues. The media is to provide the public with information useful to them. The media is on the public’s side. Racial stereotyping is a problem that is out in the public. Drugs, teen pregnancy, child abuse and rape are also problems that affect the people of the world everyday.
Time Warner And Disney Essay Research Paper
The dispute between Time Warner and Disney and the decision to pull ABC programs off the air on Monday and part of Tuesday has many viewers at Queens College thinking about how much media companies value money before their audiences.
Do The Print Media Have Power In
The British Political System, Or Essay, Research Paper The influence of the mass media on the electoral process in the western democracies, specially the television in the last years, can get to crush the daily life during the electoral period. Some maintain that the selection are won or are lost based on the performance of a party in the television and print media and, to a lesser extent, in the radio.
Mass Media And The Right To Think
Essay, Research Paper Mass Media and The Right To Think University admission costs are a deceitful practice that needs to be investigated and changed for the good of the honest student. After having a topic chosen for the past week this, sadly, is all I can come up with. I have written this essay many times, and it always ends with failure.
The Truman Show Essay Research Paper The
The Truman Show Essay, Research Paper The Truman Show is a movie about a man who is held captive inside a world that revolves around him. Truman Burbank, the main character has been
Questions Of 28 Kisses Essay Research Paper
Some Questions for 28 Kisses tackled the issues of the portrayal of Asian women in the media, their neglect of Asian men, and the topic of interracial dating. From the 28 films he finds, each includes a Caucasian male with an Asian female, each acting in a romantic fashion. These films depict Asian females in stereotypically exotic roles such as sultry masseuses and as seductive slaves.
Generation X Essay Research Paper I
Generation X Essay, Research Paper I believe that Generation X exists, however, I do not think that everyone in this generation fits the description peddled by the media. The media feels the need to hang labels on each generation and give them each their own characteristics, but I fail to see the reasoning in all the name calling and insults.
How The Media Affects My Life Essay
, Research Paper Donna Jirkovsky Professor Miller Media and Society Monday, September 25th 2000 How the Media Effects my Life One thousand six hundred and eighteen minutes. One thousand six hundred and eighteen was spent by me, on my computer, in three days. That seems to be a lot of time when you think about it, probably just about twenty seven hours.
Does The Media Have An Effect On
Our Society Essay, Research Paper Does the Media Have an Effect on Our Society? I don t believe the violence we experience today is due to video games, movies, music, etc. I think it s due to the media. For example, if the media hadn t publicized the first couple school shootings so heavily, I know these kids, that did the shootings at Columbine, wouldn t have gotten the idea to do so.
Censorship Of Television Essay Research Paper On
Censorship Of Television Essay, Research Paper On one hand parents argue that violence on television causes agression in their children, on the other hand, media figures, professionals, and figures of authority say that there is no proof that television influences children. There have been more than a thousand papers published on the effects of media on behavior.
The Internet And The Media Essay Research
Paper The Internet and the Media By: Kristen Kszos E-mail: Kris_1011@hotmail The media today can be scandalous and misleading. However, the media provides much needed information. It can be helpful, useful, and even entertaining. When you go online it s almost as if a world of information is opened to you.
The Print Media Is Less Effective Than
Other Media Types Essay, Research Paper The Print Media Is Less Effective Than Other Media Types The print media has little significance in shaping public reaction to
Difference Between Today
’s Media Coverage On The War And Past Media Essay, Research Paper Over different wars, media has progressed in its technology to show viewers more coverage. It has
Business Ethics Essay Research Paper As an
Business Ethics Essay, Research Paper As an editor of a weekly magazine, there are many responsibilities. Upper management recently came to the editor and told him that sales have dipped dramatically. He was also told, that if things do not turnaround soon, heads will roll. Along comes a story that he knows is ethically wrong, but will sell many magazines.
Diversity Essay Research Paper Diversity and the
Diversity Essay, Research Paper Diversity and the Mass Media The question of weather the media?s role in establishing racial and ethnic equality is not only very easy to answer but needs to be answered. People need to think of how important it is. People tend to under estimate this power and hate to admit that the media shapes our opinions about people.
Media Influences Essay Research Paper Before the
Media Influences Essay, Research Paper Before the late 19th century, there was only the printed word to convey information to the masses. Since then, the, the world has seen and embraced new technology, which not only enhanced society communication but mass media itself as well. We use mass media mainly to entertain, communicate and persuade these three factors are the motives that help influence society.
Media Influence Essay Research Paper MEDIA INFLUENCE
Media Influence Essay, Research Paper MEDIA INFLUENCE The media play an important role in our lives and influence us in our choices and things we value in life. We definitely live in an information society, large groups of people receive information and store it. There are many opinions about the mass media of communications served as a vehicle for rational discussion featuring the range of political and cultural perspective.
Sex Education Messages In The Media Essay
, Research Paper Sex Education Messages In The Media The media should not be blamed for the sexuality of american youth. First concern in sexual activity is too much media. Television is
Media To The Masses Essay Research Paper
Lucas Forgue 11-10-99 Media to the Masses What is the mass media? Mass media is defined by means of public communication reaching a large audience. It is a combination of television broadcasts, radio shows, newspaper headlines, and magazine articles. To some, it is a way of learning what is happening in the world.
Influence Of Media Essay Research Paper The
Influence Of Media Essay, Research Paper The media has affected me in a variety of ways. I am manipulated by the media through images and symbols which are portrayed through it. It has influenced my lifestyle, personality and opinions.
The Ethics Of The Media Essay Research
Paper The Ethics of the Media The purpose of the media has become an ongoing question since the large amount of conflicts between the consumer and media. Why is the original purpose of the media so damn hard to figure out? It is time to confront this issue instead of blowing it off by saying, “We can never change the media, so why bother?” What kind of chickenshit statement is that?! If there are so many people with so much power, surely one of them realizes the downward spiral of the ethics of the media.
TV: is it a good thing?
Mass Media are one of the most characteristic features of modern civilization. People are united into one global community with the help of mass media.People can learn about what is happening in the world very fast using mass media.
Mass media
Newspapers, the radio and television play inform, educate and entertain us. They also influence the way people look at the world and even make them change their views. In other words, mass media play a very important part in shaping public opinion.