, Research Paper
Susan Sontag, in ?Against Interpretation,? takes a very interesting critical
standpoint on the idea of literary interpretation. Unlike most literary critics,
Sontag believes that literary criticism is growing increasingly destructive
towards the very works of art that they, supposedly, so greatly ?appreciate?
and ?respect.? Her standpoint could not be more accurate. Reading her work
generates numerous questions, the most important of which is quite possibly,
?How are we to take her final statement, ?In place of a hermeneutics we need
an erotics of art.?? In the light of her previous statements, made
throughout the work, one could only see this particular statement as an attempt
to reach through the fog that blinds the majority of modern critics. According
to Sontag, no work of art, especially literature, can escape the surgical eye of
the modern critic; therefore, what is to stop her own work from coming under
this blade of criticism? Sontag?s preparation for this criticism shows in the
inclusion of her final statement. She has, in effect, laid a trap for the modern
critic (who just happens to be you, me, and practically every other reader) with
her final statement as the bait. Once the critic picks apart that last sentence,
he will see, with greater clarity, the veracity of her work. Throughout this
work, Sontag makes many statements that invite interpretation. Critics may
analyze her repeated references to Greek literature or possibly her use of
sexual imagery, but none could ignore the simplicity, brevity, and word choice
that characterize the concluding sentence. The brevity of the final section is
what catches the critical eye and the lurid choice of words is what pulls the
critic in. The first question that the interpreter finds him/herself asking is,
?Why ?hermeneutics? and why ?erotics?? There must be some significance
to these terms.? Analysis of these terms reveals the two extremes which Sontag
has been comparing throughout her piece; ?hermeneutics? being an ideal term
to describe the type of over-intellectualization that takes place with modern
interpreters, and ?erotics? being ideal for describing to just what extreme
Sontag thinks art should be experienced. When the critics finally
?excavates? this statement and, ?…digs ?behind? the text, to find a
sub-text, which is the true one,? he finds, low, and behold, the reinforcement
of the very statement that Sontag has been inculcating throughout this piece. It
does not take long for the critic to realize that he/she has been duped.
However, should this critic feel guilty or bad in any way? The first instinct is
to say, ?Yes, Sontag meant to make just such a jab at the modern
interpreter.? Nevertheless, when adequate thought is applied to the situation
one is forced to ask how else she could have more effectively driven home her
point. It is practically necessary to meet someone on their terms first if you
hope to convert them to yours. Sontag has done this because she has little other
choice. She has so effectively made her point, with the proper amount of
respect, that her target, the modern critic, is in no position to resent
Sontag?s statements without first acknowledging their veracity.
Другие работы по теме:
Glatiator Essay Research Paper Review by Susan
Glatiator Essay, Research Paper Review by Susan Granger 3? Stars out of 4 Copyright ? 2000 Susan Granger “Are you not entertained?” charismatic Russell Crowe roars scornfully to the cheering crowd in the Roman Colosseum. Certainly there hasn’t been this kind of awesome sword-and-sandals spectacle since “Spartacus,” “Ben-Hur” and “Cleopatra.” Set in 180 A.D., Crowe plays Maximus, a Roman general who promises his aging mentor, Caesar Marcus Aurelius (Richard Harris) that, as his appointed successor, he will return power to the Senate, thus restoring the Republic.
Rebuttal Susan Essay Research Paper RebuttalSusan she
Rebuttal Susan Essay, Research Paper Rebuttal Susan: she is trained and it would be a disgrace for her not to work. Rebuttal: It has been observed that most girls at highschool are not really concerned about their studies and they just play around. They are filled with ideas of some man coming up to them as long as they are beautiful.
Ecclesiates 318 Essay Research Paper Interpretation of
Ecclesiates 3:1-8 Essay, Research Paper Interpretation of Ecclesiastes 3:1-8 The Bible verses Ecclesiastes 3:1-8 are Solomon?s words as he is telling of the relationship that we may have with God and of His master plan. We are to understand God?s impeccable timing, absolute control, magnificent grace, and eternal glory.
Booker Goes Global Essay Research Paper Booker
Booker Goes Global Essay, Research Paper Booker goes globalProvincial, insular, philistine, conservative: these are some of the epithets The Observer has deployed to characterise the British literary establishment. Occasionally, I have wondered if these terms were not – shall we say? – a trifle exaggerated, a shade unjust.
Mayor Of Casterbridge Essay Research Paper Mayor
Mayor Of Casterbridge Essay, Research Paper Mayor of Casterbridge In the beginning of the novel, Michael Henchard sells his wife Susan and their baby daughter Elizabeth-Jane to a sailor for five guineas after drinking a great deal of rum-laced furmity–a sort of gruel made of wheat, milk, sugar, and spices.
Ethical Decision Making Essay Research Paper Chapter
Ethical Decision Making Essay, Research Paper Chapter One Case Study Debbie Richardson is in her fourth year at Lamb Consulting and has recently been approached by Susan Gatewick, a project manager for Bob Hachet. Susan confided to
You Belong To Me By Mary Higgins
Clark Essay, Research Paper You Belong to Me is Mary Higgins Clark’s fifteenth novel. It is about a young clinical psychologist named Dr. Susan Chandler who hosts a radio talk show. One day the topic of the show is lonely women who disappear and who are later discovered dead. She brings up one specific case of a lady named Regina Clausen.
Friendship Essay Research Paper Honesty companionship and
Friendship Essay, Research Paper Honesty, companionship, and loyalty are the components that configure a true friend. First, honesty includes both persons remaining truthful, sincere, and frank to one another. If there is not a trust between two persons than it is impossible to maintain a friendship.
Susan Faludi Essay Research Paper Susan Faludi
Susan Faludi Essay, Research Paper Susan Faludi and Backlash I AM NOT A BARBIE DOLL. Before you even start reading, these capital letters catch your eye. To add more, she tells us it was held up by a little girl, which plays with our emotions.
Gender Essay Research Paper On July 19
Gender Essay, Research Paper On July 19, 1848, one of the most important conventions for womens’ rights was held in Seneca Falls, New York. This was the first convention of the kind ever held. Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony were the main hosts. Their purpose was to convince the American citizens, men and women, of the inequality of women s current position in the American society.
Killing Mr Griffin Essay Research Paper Killing
Killing Mr. Griffin Essay, Research Paper Killing Mr. Griffin In the book Killing Mr. Griffin two of the students are involved are Susan and Betsy. I believe that Susan was a much stronger character of the two. I believe this because Susan seems to has a higher moral sense and doesn t need people to think she is cute and wonderful like Betsy does.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Lisa WilsonEnglish 101Story
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Lisa Wilson English 101 Story Outline 1 December 2000 1. Intro A.The story of ?The Jilting of Granny Weatherall? by Katherine Ann Porter is portrayed in two different ways by the video and story version.
My Presentation Of Macbeth Act 3 Scene
4 Essay, Research Paper 10Hn This essay will show my interpretation of Act 3 Scene 4 from Macbeth. This scene is a turning point in the play because we see the first glimpse of Macbeth?s guilty conscience, which becomes the cause of
Biology Interpretation Essay Research Paper InterpretationStatistical calculations
Biology: Interpretation Essay, Research Paper Interpretation Statistical calculations made with the results obtained, conclude the null hypothesis previously made, is acceptable and there is in fact a relationship between percentage epiphyte cover and height from the ground. However, when studying the tables of results it is difficult to find a pattern in results obtained.
I Stand Here Ironing Literary Interpretation Essay
, Research Paper The first time I read “I Stand Here Ironing” by Tillie Olsen, the emotions it provoked made a tight ball of fear and guild appear in my stomach, I broke out in a sweat and my heart began beating triple time. There were so many similarities between the mother’s story and my memories of the last six years tat it amazed me.
Jefferson Vs Hamilton Essay Research Paper Between
Jefferson Vs Hamilton Essay, Research Paper Between Jefferson and Hamilton the two both wanted what was best for the newly formed country but just had different opinions on how to go about it. Hamilton wanted the United States to be governed by an aristocracy while Jefferson had his faith in the people and disagreed with Hamilton.
Annie Oakley Essay Research Paper On August13
Annie Oakley Essay, Research Paper On August,13 1860, Pheobe Ann Moses was born to Jacob and Susan Moses in their one room cabin in Patterson, Ohio. When Annie was around 6, her father contracted pnemonia while traveling the 18 miles home from town in a blizzard, and died in the spring of 1866. Afterward, Susan had trouble supporting the six childen.
John Minnie And Petie A Love Triangle
Essay, Research Paper Karen Rayne Mrs. Wolf English 102.004 2 March 2001 John, Minnie, and Petie, A Love Triangle: Comedy and Tragedy in Susan Glaspell’s Trifles
Jim Morrison And Susan Sontag Essay Research
Paper Jim Morrison is the lead singer of the classic rock and roll band “The Doors”. Jim Morrison not only was the lead vocalist in the famous sixties band, he was also the writer of most
Susan Smith Essay Research Paper Susan SmithWhen
Susan Smith Essay, Research Paper Susan Smith When turning on the television, radio, or simply opening the local newspaper, one is mess with news of arrests, murders, homicides, serial killers, and other such tragedies. 1994 must be a great year to be alive if you are a criminal! Nobody takes liability for his or her own actions anymore.
Elizabeth Cady Stanton And Susan B. Anthony
Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Susan B. Anthony Susan B. Anthony is the most well known name in women’s rights from the 1800s. Most people who are not familiar with the history of this time are aware of Susan’s reputation and nearly everyone of my generation has seen and held a Susan B. Anthony silver dollar.
Susan B Anthony Essay Research Paper Susan 2
Susan B. Anthony Essay, Research Paper Susan Brownell Anthony was a magnificent women who devoted most of her life to gain the right for women to vote. She traveled the United States by stage coach, wagon, and train giving many speeches, up to 75 to 100 a year, for 45 years. She went as far as writing a newspaper, the Revolution, and casting a ballot, despite it being illegal.
The Lion The Witch And The Wardrobe 2
The Lion, The Witch, And The Wardrobe: An Analysis Essay, Research Paper The Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe: An Analysis The main characters in this story are Peter, Susan, Edmund, and
A Stereotypical Media Essay Research Paper A
A Stereotypical Media Essay, Research Paper A Stereotypical Media The media of today?s society plays the peddler to the stereotypes that plague our country. However, the media is not solely to blame. Susan Sontag states in her essay ?The Image World?:
Happiness Essay Research Paper Happiness is defined
Happiness Essay, Research Paper Happiness is defined in the dictionary as a pleasureable or satisfying experience. A person ability to acheive happiness is of their own free will to allow themselves to a moderate amount of the sense. EVeyrone has a different interpretation of the level of thei happiness.
A Comparison And Contrast In Both A
’s Worn By Hester And Dimm Essay, Research Paper A Comparison and Contrast In Both A’s Worn By Hester and Dimmesdale The two A’s worn in the novel by both Hester and Dimmesdale are dramatically
In Cold Blood By Truman Capote Essay
, Research Paper On In the book In Cold Blood, Truman Capote engages in an analysis of both the murderers and the people who surrounded the Clutter family. Capote goes through
Killing Mr Essay Research Paper Killing Mr
Killing Mr Essay, Research Paper Killing Mr. Griffin I read the book Killing Mr. Griffin, by Lois Duncan. There was an English teacher, Mr. Griffin, which nobody liked. Especially one particular group of
Pornography Essay Research Paper Susan JacobyA First
Pornography Essay, Research Paper Susan Jacoby ?A First Amendment Junkie? Censoring pornography is wrong. Pornography should not be censored just be cause some people find it offensive. I cannot recall the last time someone made me look at a pornographic picture, or made me buy a pornographic magazine or movie.
Blind Mans Bluff Essay Research Paper Blind
Blind Mans Bluff Essay, Research Paper Blind Man s Bluff Sometimes in literature, the characters in the story make an important contribution to society. In the novel, Blind Man s Bluff, by Sherry Sontag and Christopher Drew, the brave men and women that served in the Navy s Secret Service did just that. If it wasn t for them, many more lives would have been lost and more land would be destroyed.