Modernization Vs. Dependency Essay, Research Paper
MODERNIZATION VS. DEPENDENCY
The modernization perspective is behavioral or microsociological the primary focus is on individuals or aggregates of individuals, their values, attitudes, and beliefs. The dependency perspective, by contrast, is structural or macrosociological its focus is on the mode of production, patterns of international trade, political and economic linkages between elites in peripheral and central countries, group and class alliances and conflicts, and so on. (Valenzuela & Valenzuela, 1978)
Each perspective has its own strengths and weaknesses in attempting to explain either development or underdevelopment, and it is important to take into consideration that any theory, once explained, can make sense. The difficulty in debating over these two theories arises in that they both seem relatively accurate. Then again, each theory examines the complete opposite site of the debate. Dependency theory suggests that underdeveloped nations depend on the advanced nations to grow; that the economy of certain countries is conditioned by the development and expansion of another economy to which the former is subjected. (Dos Santos, 1970) This theory takes a broader look at the development of the economy, and examines it on a much larger scale. Dependency theory takes into account mainly external factors, and looks at how internal factors contribute to those benefits obtained through external means.
At the same time, Modernization theory scrutinizes the smallest details of how a country functions, by looking at the actual people who occupy that country. Values, beliefs, and culture are all important determinant of how that country can and will function. The country s potential is determined by its people and how willing they are to work hard.
I feel that the Dependency perspective takes a lot of information into account when analyzing the economic situation of a country. While this theory maintains that mainly structural factors are relevant in the development of a country, I feel it implies that social and cultural relationships are influenced by the components of dependent growth. Increased international trade, control of the means of production, group and class situations, and the political atmosphere all would affect the social and cultural environment. While the Modernization theory focuses mainly on the people, it seems to me that Dependency theory does take that into account in some small way, as is determined by the more powerful influences such as trade, politics, class conflicts, etc. Dependency theory seems a little more involved and complex, and examines numerous factors in determining the development or underdevelopment of a certain country, and how each country is affected by another advanced or backward.
Другие работы по теме:
Factors Lat Amer Independence Essay Research Paper
I agree with the statement that the growing acceptance of ideas and attitudes associated with modernization and Europeanizism that essentially caused the movement toward Spanish American Independence, but disagree that, no other factors were involved. There was a huge underlying factor involved and that was the resentment of Peninsulars by the Creoles.
Was Confucianism Responsible For China
’s Failure To Modernize Essay, Research Paper Was Confucianism Responsible for China’s Failure to Modernize? How significant was China’s more than 1000-year tradition of a stable, hierarchial, Confucian society in keeping China from seeing the need to modernize?
Social Duty Essay Research Paper Social Duty
Social Duty Essay, Research Paper Social Duty. Society invents morals, morals that are used to determine what is right and what is wrong. Morals differ as societies differ. However, in today s environment, more and more societies grow alike, although in doing so they have conflicting views and morals. This is defined as social modernization, where societies climb over obstacles and choose their uniform morals and views of what is right and wrong.
Mao Zedong Vs Deng Xioping Essay Research
Paper Mao Zedong was one of if not the most famous communist leaders in the history of China. His views of modernizing his country won him millions of followers. After his death in 1976, a man by the name of Deng Xioping attempted to win over Mao’s former followers and rule China. These two men were probably the most influencial people in China inthe 1900’s.
China Reforms Essay Research Paper Section II1
China Reforms Essay, Research Paper Section II 1.) There have been numerous attempts to reform China in the late 19th century to build up China’s strength and make it a world power once again. There have been many prestigious intellectuals and organizations that have attempted to do this. One of these intellectuals who had a great influence on other reformers was Yan Fu.
Global Cutlture Essay Research Paper George ZellarsSociologySession
Global Cutlture Essay, Research Paper George Zellars Sociology Session V Paper #3 Global Culture Modern technology has extended human life spans and levels of comfort. But it also destroys thousands of remote cultures. Today the world’s people speak about 6,000 languages, a good measure of diversity; by the year 2100 the number of languages could drop to 3,000 as traditional cultures change.
Maya Civilization Essay Research Paper The Maya
Maya Civilization Essay, Research Paper The Maya are probably the best known of the classical civilizations of Mesoamerica. Originating in the Yucatan around 2600 B.C., they rose to prominence around A.D. 250.
Drug Testing Essay Research Paper IntroductionIndustryPrecision Machine
Drug Testing Essay, Research Paper Introduction Industry Precision Machine Tool is a machine tool company that primarily manufactures for the automobile industry. The machine tool industry is self-sufficient in that they use their resources to manufacture products; that is, they use their own tools.
The Meiji RestorationS Affect On The Peasant
And Working Class Essay, Research Paper Eugene Yu HILD 11 Yuko 1:25 03/06/00 The Meiji Restoration?s Affect on the Peasant and Working Class The Meiji Restoration, despite all the good it created, negatively affected the lives of peasants and laborers in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The restoration is characterized by modernization, a term that symbolizes the use of present day ideals over ancient times and holding progressive opinions over earlier ones.
Impact Of Imperialism Essay Research Paper Impact
Impact Of Imperialism Essay, Research Paper Impact of Imperialism Imperialism had a big impact on both the Western and Non-western countries. During the age of Imperialism a truly global economy emerged. The western industrialized nations dominated, especially the United States, Britain, France and Germany.
Men In The Workplace Essay Research Paper
TED LEWELLEN, Professor of Anthropology at the University of Richmond, received his B.A. from Alaska Methodist University, his M.A. from New York University, and his Ph.D. from the University of Colorado. He has done field work in Peru
California Utility Essay Research Paper Chris Parker
California Utility Essay, Research Paper Chris Parker 482.004 Dr. Singer In 1996 deregulation allowed California utility companies to sell power plants and collect over 19 billion dollars in ratepayer subsidies. The money was used to purchase plants in other countries, reward executives with huge pay raises and buy back stock.
Islamic Women Essay Research Paper Many times
Islamic Women Essay, Research Paper Many times when feminists looked at Islamic women they criticized the man for not treating women properly. However, as Jane I. Smith states, women of Islam are not really offended by that fact, on the contrary, they believe that it is better for them.
Women In India Essay Research Paper The
Women In India Essay, Research Paper The Changing Role of Women in India Women in India are beginning to follow the direction that the women of the Western world took more than eighty years ago; demanding treatment as human equals. However, it has become more and more evident as the revolution ages that Indian women may have to adapt the Western feminist method to their very traditional and religious culture.
LongTerm Cause Of The Russian Revolution Essay
, Research Paper In 1812 Czar Alexander the First had sworn an oath that Russia would never make peace as long as an enemy stood on Russian soil. Little did he know that not much more than a century later the enemy was those who were native to the Russian soil-the people. The Russian Revolution was an event that shaped the rest of the 20th century worldwide.
Modernization Of Computers Essay Research Paper Since
Modernization Of Computers Essay, Research Paper Since the first computer was made in the late fifties, the technology has developed extremely. Computers which took the place of a living-room then, are now being made in creditcard-formats. More and more areas are being taken overby the computer.As computers are capable of handling large amounts of data in a very shorttime, they are well suited for wordprocessing.
Gender Inequality Essay Research Paper Many people
Gender Inequality Essay, Research Paper Many people have many different viewpoints on the question Are the sexes separate and unequal? First I will talk about the historical views, In China the people have the opinion and feel very strongley about it that women are not to be praised or even recognized. In China being a women is like being a prisoner of society.
Maxism Essay Research Paper Perhaps if I
Maxism Essay, Research Paper Perhaps if I believed strongly in the work of one theorist, this paper would not prove to be so difficult. The truth is, I find each classical theorist?s work to hold certain underlying principles, which justifies their ideology- therefore, I can not disagree. Whether it is Smith, Marx or Weber, they all have some basic premise, which it would be difficult for opponents to negate.
A Continuous Decline In India Without Modernization
Essay, Research Paper A Continuous Decline in India, Without Modernization Hypothesis: Modernization is the Key to economic growth for India. If modernization occurs, then the economic status of India will increase
Modernization And Medicine Essay Research Paper On
Modernization And Medicine Essay, Research Paper On the first day of class, we discussed how modernization has brought the institution of medicine so far. Although the cost of modernization is seen as the “social germ”, modernization has also brought enormous improvement in health. Modern medicine defies all ancient reason.
Problems Of Modernization In Developing Nations Essay
, Research Paper Problems of Modernization in Developing Nations The economic situation which exists in the developing world today, is the result of the relationship between the modern, and developing nations of the
The Modernization Of America Essay Research Paper
The Modernization of America The Transcontinental Railroad was completed in 1869. The telephone was invented in 1876. The first practical system for a radio was developed in 1895. The Wright brothers created a flying machine in 1903. The first gas powered automobile, the assembly line and the refrigerator were produced in the early 20th century.
Ameratsu Essay Research Paper Amaterasu is the
Ameratsu Essay, Research Paper Amaterasu is the supreme deity of the Japanese religion of Shintoism and the legendary ancestor of Japan’s imperial family. The full name of this deity is Amaterasu Omikami. This means in Japanese the Great Spirit Illuminating the Heavens.
Transportation Essay Research Paper The industrial era
Transportation Essay, Research Paper The industrial era of America helped to bring about modernization of transportation in urban areas. Many factors contributed to the rise of the modern city, including economics, politics, and technology. The ancient cities of Europe were very small in size and had a relatively small population.
Controlling Corruption Essay Research Paper Corruption is
Controlling Corruption Corruption is the method government officials implore to extract rents from businesses. This paper uses the functionalist-modernization theory of corruption to examine governmental corruption. The primary argument is that the functionalist-modernization approach is the most efficient method of controlling corruption.
America And The Disabled Essay Research Paper
Is it right for America to treat the disabled the way they do? America ignores the need to modernize public facilities for the disabled. However, the government provides for these facilities. Supporting the disadvantaged is something that may not be to the financial advantage of our government. Thus, America tends to treat disabled unfairly.
Consensus Vs Urbanization Essay Research Paper The
Consensus Vs. Urbanization Essay, Research Paper The process of modernization contains many elements, which work together in many ways. The two elements that I will be discussing are consensus and urbanization. Consensus is when a group or groups of people come to an agreement with each other. Urbanization is the development of cities.
The Roots Of Dependency Essay Research Paper
Reemy Reem Anth. 307 The Roots of Dependency 1. The Navajos, Pawnees, and Choctaws all had to endure European, political, economical, and environmental threats to their own culture. When the life and subsistence system (hunting and gathering) of an Indian Nation is affected; in one way or another it has an affect on an Indian population as a hole.
The Graduate Essay Research Paper Veronica CombsThis
The Graduate Essay, Research Paper Veronica Combs This paper will be both a critique as well as an analysis of the relationships between both my generation and the time period in which the movie took place. In the critique, I which to look at the movie score and the dependency that I felt Ben and Katherine had for each other.
Hinduism Essay Research Paper HinduismHinduism was developed
Hinduism Essay, Research Paper Hinduism Hinduism was developed in India and is one of the largest religions in the world. Over centuries Hinduism has spread to Africa, Southeast Asia and England. Around six hundred and fifty million people practice Hinduism. Not only does it have a gigantic number of believers, it has greatly influenced many other religions.
Chinese Book Report Essay Research Paper China
Chinese Book Report Essay, Research Paper China Book Report Book: China Since 1945 Author: Stewart Ross (Note: This book is not described in full depth and detail but is just explained in a very general way, therefore Mahmoud Abdelkader uses The Modernization of China by Gilbert Rozman (Editor) excerpts to support his views)
Tribal Wisdom Essay Research Paper Tribal Wisdom
Tribal Wisdom Essay, Research Paper Tribal Wisdom Modernization has changed our thinking about every facet of our lives. Tribal Wisdom by David Maybury-Lewis is about the differences between tribal people and modern people. The article describes how modern aged people has moved away from the traditional ways of thinking and has become dependant on technology.
Miss Emily
’s Male Interaction In A Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Miss Emily’s male interaction in A Rose for Emily The way that a person is raised has a lot to do with their