Censorship Necessary Or Not? Essay, Research Paper
In Plato’s Republic, he tries to develop a utopia for mankind. He utilizes conversation amongst people within in his book as a vehicle for larger and more serious topics to be discussed. One of the most important propositions made in these discussions is when Socrates and Glaucon are deliberating on the issue of censorship and its necessity in the beginning of “Book III.” Plato leads me to believe that censorship is a necessary evil that must exist to protect the city as a whole. The question arises when addressing this subject matter; does society need censorship to rise to its full potential? Plato seems to think yes, but for me the jury is still out.
“Book III” of the Republic begins by talking about how to create warriors and what the necessary precautions needed to convince people that death is not a bad thing are. Plato wants to invent citizens that are “unafraid of death, preferring it to defeat in battle or slavery (386b4).” Plato believes that the only way to do this is through the censorship of materials that people are exposed to. Plato wants to create a society where everyone worthy of enough desires to be a warrior and where citizens are volunteering to fight for their city-state. The only way he believes it is possible to eliminate people’s fear about death is by eliminating the stories they have been raised on. Plato further reflects on this idea of censorship by saying:
Then we must supervise such stories and those who tell them, and ask them not to disparage the life in Hades in this unconditional way, but rather to praise it, since what they now say is neither true nor beneficial warriors (386b7-386c1).
Many modern day people have taken what Plato said and have implemented into the society with which they live in an attempt to create a utopia of warriors for their benefit. Hitler comes to mind and his development of youth camps. Hitler burned books and brainwashed people for the sake of the state rather then their intellectual well being. Censorship also exists in the United States today, even though we are a society based on freedom of speech. There are people in this nation who try to get books banned from high school curriculums everyday because they feel it is the wrong opinion or information for today’s youth to have. Do I believe they are in the right? To be perfectly honest I think that the deterioration of society can be attributed to those who attempt to restrict free thought. Plato may be right in saying that the easiest method of altering people’s beliefs is to restrict them but it decreases the intelligence of the society it trying to create.
Plato also states that warriors “mustn’t be lovers laughter (388e5).” What kind of society is that? Laughter and merriment is what makes life worth living. You can sensor peoples thoughts if you feel you must, but when you take away the things in life that you enjoy life loses its meaning. Warriors are needed in every society, but that doesn’t mean that a society won’t have warriors if it allows people to think on their own and permits laughter.
I personally believe that while in theory Plato’s ideas on censorship will work, but they will also ruin what is sacred about life. People should be treated as intelligent beings and they deserve to read and hear everything they want. Just because Plato wants the horrible names for Hades to disappear and to glorify death doesn’t mean its true. He doesn’t have the right to ask Homer and other poets to stop referring to the underworld because people have become afraid of dying. Plato’s Republic states:
We’ll ask Homer and the other poets not to be angry if we delete these passages and all similar ones. It isn’t that they aren’t poetic or pleasing to the majority of hearers but that, the more poetic they are, the less they should be heard by children or by men…(387b1-4)
If Plato truly tried to install this act of censorship all of his works would also have to be deleted. Plato himself wrote very liberal ideas before his time and some of this information may have been harmful to the society in his terms.
The question of censorship has plagued mankind for centuries. The real question though should be if censorship is used what kind of effect does it have on the people subjected to it. Part of ancient Greek culture is the stories that were told about the underworld and their theater portrayals of death. I’m not saying that more stories can’t be told to glorify the life and death of a warrior, but the elimination of all those that don’t praise it ridiculous. Citizens deserve a chance to come to their own conclusions about whether they want to join the military or not. Another consideration is that even though Plato believes that people are self-interested, which they are for the most part, that doesn’t mean that when push comes to shove and their civilization is being attack they won’t stand and defend it. Plato was wrong in my opinion on the topic of censorship. It sounds more like brainwashing to me.
Другие работы по теме:
Censorship Essay Research Paper CENSORSHIPCensorship and the
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Censorship Essay Research Paper The negative messages
Censorship Essay, Research Paper The negative messages kids receive via the media have a damaging affect on their psyche and can create serious societal problems. In truth “[t]he violence to which American children are exposed in the name of
Press Censorship Essay Research Paper There are
Press Censorship Essay, Research Paper There are many kinds of censorship within our school system. Such as press Censorship, we aren’t aloud to express freely among our school?s newspaper nor
Censorship 6 Essay Research Paper CensorshipWhat is
Censorship 6 Essay, Research Paper Censorship What is Obscenity? Clearly something hard to talk about. “Obscenity” is difficult to discuss. After all, what makes a thing obscene? It’s an elusive term we use, but can’t explain. Different people often see things differently. Some see obscenity in nude pictures, statues, etc.
Censorship Essay Research Paper I did my
Censorship Essay, Research Paper I did my report on the First Amendment. The First Amendment of the United States states that, “Congress shall make no law against the freedom of speech, nor of the press.” However, the list of banned books in public schools and libraries is astonishing. Most people against literary censorship act with what they beleive to be highest cause: protecting their families as well as their communities from evil.
Journalism Essay Research Paper While Burl Osborne
Journalism Essay, Research Paper While Burl Osborne is a strong believer in the right to free speech, he said that ” the urge to censor is the reaction of well-intended people to the expression of views that they find repugnant.”
Internet Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship of
Internet Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship of inappropriate material has been an issue with every form of mass media. Now the new and upcoming Internet is becoming the focus. Software makers and service providers are choosing what the public should see. Does this seem right? How can a stranger choose what another person or their family sees on the Internet? Parents and adults should choose what they and their children are exposed to on the Internet.
Media Censorship Essay Research Paper Today there
Media Censorship Essay, Research Paper Today there is much controversy over whether there should or shouldn’t be censorship of the media. Censorship should not be imposed on citizens by the government or other agencies; adults have a right to view or listen to what they choose. Additionally, if children’s media is censored, parents are the ones to monitor and regulate it.
Fahrenheit 451 Essay Research Paper In the
Fahrenheit 451 Essay, Research Paper In the book Fahrenheit 451 the theme is a society/world that revolves around being basically brain washed or programmed because of the lack of people not thinking for themselves concerning the loss of knowledge, and imagination from books that don’t exist to them. In such stories as the Kurt Vonnegut’s "You have insulted me letter" also involving censorship to better society from vulgarity and from certain aspects of life that could be seen as disruptive to day to day society which leads to censorship of language and books.
Race Essay Research Paper CensorshipIn many cities
Race Essay, Research Paper Censorship In many cities in the United States there are few efforts being made to stop the over-use of searing in public and to stop the indecent exposure. Ordinances are being set up to stop swearing in public, but it is not being enforced.
Censorship 10 Essay Research Paper CensorshipTom Cruise
Censorship 10 Essay, Research Paper Censorship Tom Cruise and Nicole Kidmen star in the film, Eyes Wide Shut, which is a artistic movie about two people having sex. What has society come to? Shouldn t this have been censored? Or is it showing their art to the world? The never ending debate over censorship boast s so many arguments.
Is Censorship Wrong And Cynical Essay Research
Paper Music, movies, and books should not be censored. Authors deliberately create to express themselves through these things. In consequence of censorship, the public would not be able to receive the main idea of the product for which it was intended. However there are opinions and facts that support both sides to this controversy.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship making the
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship, making the world a better place. Censorship affects our society in many different ways, it affects the music we listen to, the movies we watch, the books we read, and many other aspects of our everyday lives. Even though many might argue that censorship doesn t really have a place in a society that emphases freedom of speech and the freedom to express oneself, but censorship is an essential and needed part of our growing society, it s needed in the television industry, the Internet, and the music industry.
Censorship Essay Research Paper What Happened To
Censorship Essay, Research Paper What Happened To Our Rights? Censorship in America today has gotten way out of hand. There always seems to be some holier than thou group speaking out as if they were representing the majority of Americans. These groups want to censor just about anything and everything we do.
Censorship Essay Research Paper CensorshipSince the beginning
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship Since the beginning of art and entertainment society has tried to censor the public from the so called ?influences? of art, television, movies, and music. Censorship is suppose to protect the children from seeing form of sex, violence, profanity and drugs. If its suppose to protect the children from seeing these thing why do I see so many children doing those things.
Censorship 2 Essay Research Paper CensorshipThere are
Censorship 2 Essay, Research Paper CensorshipThere are many aspects to censorship. But before I explain the many different aspects of censorship, I would like to discuss what censorship includes. Censorship is the supervision and control of the information and ideas that are circulated among the people within a society.
Pornography Censorship Essay Research Paper The censorship
Pornography Censorship Essay, Research Paper The censorship of pornography has a positive affect on the United States of America and is agood thing because pornography leads to crime, pornography has no positiveaffects on society, and censoring pornography is not against theconstitution.
Music Censorship Essay Research Paper Music Censorship
Music Censorship Essay, Research Paper Music Censorship We ve all heard music. We ve all heard curse words. Yet, when the two are put together they cause controversy. Both music and curse words are forms of human expression. Music written with words that convey feelings and situations, and explicit words are words that essentially reinforce a statement or idea.
Music Censorship Essay Research Paper What are
Music Censorship Essay, Research Paper What are some advantages and disadvantages of music censorship? Many bills have been passed to stop explicit messages in music from getting out. Censorship limits the amount of lyrics that get out to the community about violence. (History of Music Censorship) It may also limit anything in music that a community might find offensive to its values or beliefs.
Tv Censorship Essay Research Paper Families all
Tv Censorship Essay, Research Paper Families all over America spend evening?s together watching t.v. This seems to be one of America?s favorite pastimes. But with all the violence that is involved with television programs the question arises on weither or not network television should be censored. It seems unlogical for theses censoring to take place.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Probably the most
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Probably the most obvious example of intolerance in our society today is the existence of censorship. I have yet to encounter a valid argument for any form of censorship. Such arguments as are presented invariably take the form of concern for the well being of others , children frequently being the alleged victims quoted .
Music Censorship Essay Research Paper Music CensorshipMusic
Music Censorship Essay, Research Paper Music Censorship Music censorship has been an ongoing issue in the US for the last fifty years or so. In 1951 radio stations banned Dottie O’Brians “Four or Five Times” and Dean Martins “Wham Bam Thank You Ma’am” because they thought that they were suggestive. Also during the fifties and sixties attempts were mad to censor R&B music.
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship on Television
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship on Television Television, radio, and now even computers are growing as quickly as anyone can imagine. As these media sources expand there is a continued need for censorship. In this day and age television, being the least censored of the masses, should have certain simple and specific regulations set upon it.
Censorship On Freedom Of Speech Essay Research
Paper In my research, I found out that censorship goes against our freedom of speech. According to the American Civil Liberties Union, censorship would shut out parents from deciding what television programming is acceptable for their children, and giving that right to bureaucrats and to executives.
Letter On Censorship Essay Research Paper Dear
Letter On Censorship Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr Smith,I am writing to you on the subject of censorship. It is my belief that the laws governing film censorship should be more versatile.Children of today are becoming mature and adult-like at an
Censoship Essay Research Paper Music is a
Censoship Essay, Research Paper Music is a form of expression and, like all forms of expression, is protected by first amendment rights. So, it would be unconstitutional for the government to censor it. Music censorship has tormented our generations
Censorship Essay Research Paper Why There Should
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Why There Should be Censorship Censorship is the examination of material for objectionable matter. It is used to keep material from influencing people the wrong
Censorship Essay Research Paper Censorship Censorship
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship Censorship is the supervision and control of the information andideas that are circulated among the people within a society( Censorship ). I believe that music, books, and the media should not becensored. In the first amendment, it states that it is a right to have freespeech.