Movement Essay, Research Paper
Compare and contrast political machines and the reform movement in terms of their views of the purposes of politics and government, the role of the average citizen in public affairs, and the appropriate processes of decision making.
Urban machines and the reform movement have radically different perceptions of how a local (city) government is supposed to function and be structured within a democratic society.
Political machines, in the beginning constructed by ambitious and hungry for power Irish, resulted in being a means of incorporation of the new immigrants into broader community. Their existence was the result of the perception of the early Irish immigrants that they can achieve social and financial recognition in the New World through political mobilization. Using financial resources to direct votes, machine bosses consolidated power as they controlled local government. Consequently, they were rendered local patronage by the city government in the form of divisible benefits. Such benefits as cash, jobs and contracts, which appealed to the working class as well as to the business community, were distributed again producing more political power for the machine. Through this mechanism, machines organized the entire range of political influence, engaging both the business community and the lower and upper classes in a strenuous political race. Given that the usual citizen could have his claim heard within the gulfs of the machine, the actual decision makers were not only the men at the head of the it, but decisions were the outcome of a function whose variables represented the whole spectrum of society.
Nevertheless, urban machines collapsed during the 20th century, giving way to the reform movement whose two of its major goals were the moralization of politics and the de facto dominance of public over private interest. Furthermore, reformers believed that corruption could be reduced and governmental procedures could become more efficient only by the substitution of party-affiliated politicians for nonpartisan professional administrators. The latter would handle city politics in a businesslike way in order to secure an honest and methodical distribution of social services (schools, redevelopment projects, parks, etc.) among different city groups. Therefore, in contrast with machine politics, there was usually no room available for patronage into the reform movement. However, there was no room for citizen influence over decision making either. Especially when the adopted election system was at-large, nonpartisan and council-manager, constituency s only power laid on the ballot. Taking into consideration the voters lack of access to the city s mechanisms and often being influenced by business groups, the municipal council and the city s manager sometimes reached conclusions about the city s issues covertly. Although manager and council have always been in the area of power balance and mutual influence between them, the average citizen s only hope was in fact an insurgency.
Thus, we can see quite clearly that machines were effective in policy making. However, issues were raised on whether their methods were acceptable in an organized community. These issues were solved with the emergence of the reformers. But now it was the effectiveness of the system that was challenged.
Другие работы по теме:
How Issues Are Affected By The Essay
, Research Paper How Issues Are Affected By the Political Spectrum On April 30, 1789, the United States of America elected our first president to lead our country. Then every four years thereafter, another president is elected. When election time comes around most Americans do not know anything about the issues involved and/or do not even know who is running.
Monasteries Essay Research Paper
Colossal and rich in C8 (Lorsch and Fulda). ? Nobles provided them with patronage for spiritual provision. Also were a good political club to join ? different families
AP American HistoryEarly American Nationalism And Reform
Essay, Research Paper The rise of immigration in the mid 17th century lead to a spirit of national reform in the United States. Many Europeans, particularly the Irish and the German, immigrated to America during the 1800s. There were many different reasons for their immigration, and when they came they influenced American culture greatly.
Freedom Bound Essay Research Paper In his
Freedom Bound Essay, Research Paper In his book, Freedom Bound, Robert Weisbrot argues that the civil rights movement is interwoven with American political reform of the time, and furthermore, that “the black quest for justice and the national crusade for a ‘Great Society’ are best understood in relation to each other” (Weisbrot xiv).
The Congress Of Vienna Essay Research Paper
the Congress of Vienna This essay is about the effects of the French Revolution on Europe, the Congress of Vienna, and its goals. It will tell about the role of Nationalism,
Health Care Reform Essay Research Paper From
Health Care Reform Essay, Research Paper From FDR s New Deal to Lyndon Johnson s Great Society, the United States government has attempted to centralize extensive social policies. In the early eighties, when recession and inflation were at a high, Ronald Reagan took office and pronounced that the federal government needed to take a lesser role in the lives of the American people.
A Conflict In Interest Essay Research Paper
A Conflict in Interest The year 1910 marked the beginning of reform within the Mexican political order. Proposals such as Francisco Madero’s Plan of San Luis Potosi and The Plan de Ayala by Emiliano Zapata denounced the rigid control of dictator Porfirio Diaz, stating that the existing government offered no concessions to the Mexican people.
Reform Party Essay Research Paper History of
Reform Party Essay, Research Paper History of the Reform Party In 1992, with Americans disappointed in the policy options and candidate choices offered by the two traditional parties, a self-made Texas billionaire named Ross Perot spent over $60,000,000 of his own money to run for President as an independent.
Samuel Adams Essay Research Paper 427Revolutionary America
Samuel Adams Essay, Research Paper (427) Revolutionary America was an extraordinary time. The Revolution changed many unsuspecting men into heroes; our founding fathers. One of these men was Samuel Adams, a man with unsurpassed dedication and the political intellect to make a difference in America s revolution.
Reform Party Essay Research Paper A Reform
Reform Party Essay, Research Paper A Reform is a way of changing society. During the 1880?s and 90?s many people had different opinions on reform and how society was to be changed. This was the ending of the war and people needed a brake through both everyday life and politics. Since there were so many people there were different arguments about how the reforms should be.
The Comparison Between Booker T. Washington And
W.E.B. Dubois Essay, Research Paper Comparison of Tones Through reading the pieces of writings by Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. DuBois in the Three Negro Classic I have learned they have different attitudes/tones
Immigration Reform Essay Research Paper Immigration ReformImmigration
Immigration Reform Essay, Research Paper Immigration Reform Immigration reform is a political idea construed to mislead our society into blaming innocent immigrant minorities for the current problems that plague our nation. It is well known that this country has prospered through centuries of economic and social misfortunes from the labor of immigrants who have made this country what it is today.
Basketball And The History Essay Research Paper
Chapter 12 Vignette: By 1832, many American workers felt threatened by the new industrial order. Worker protests had become increasingly common in the nation’s manufacturing centers. President Jackson had rewarded voters’ expectations but his term in office had also revealed many unreconciled tensions within the democratic political economy.
South Korean Political Parties Essay Research Paper
Lisa Scorzafave Poli Sci 083 Paper #3 November 30, 2000 Why have so many political parties existed in South Korea? We have previously discussed that the Chaebol is a prominent factor as well as is the existence of Korea?s mixed-party electoral system.
The Mirror With A Memory And Usda
? Government Inspected? Essay, Research Paper Jose Fussa March 19,2000 English Sec. The parallel between “The Mirror with a Memory” and “USDA Government
Response To Civil Disobedience By Henry David
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau’s well-publicized essay, “Civil Disobedience,” has been a prized piece of literature in the hearts of many famous Americans and other leaders. Great political figures, such as Mohandas K. Gandhi and John F. Kennedy, have used Thoreau’s essay calling for the reform of government to their advantage when speaking to their fellow countrymen.
Philosophy That People And Animals Are Persons
But Not Machines Essay, Research Paper What Constitutes Being a Person? What constitutes being a ?person?? The question of the week. No clear cut conclusions have been reached. No argument has been presented without significant loop holes. So, what to think? Well, within this chaos we all seem to have an opinion.
Gilded Age By Mark Twain Essay Research
Paper The last quarter of the nineteenth century was dubbed the Gilded Age by Mark Twain for its shallowness and corruption in both American society and politics. The most consuming governmental issues at the national level were the tariff, currency, civil-service reform, and government regulation of railroads, but the prevailing sentiment in Washington was to run a limited, laissez-faire government that would foster economic growth.
Finace Reform Essay Research Paper After what
Finace Reform Essay, Research Paper After what would be considered the closet race in presidential history, the US Supreme Court needs to find a way to get the public more involved. Senator John McCain and Russ Feingold are pushing towards a campaign finance reform. Republic John McCain is saying that we must put a stop on “soft” money, and increase “hard” money.
Critical Review Essay Research Paper In the
Critical Review Essay, Research Paper In the article, “A Cyborg Manifesto” Haraway tries to create “an ironic political myth”(p.65) which combines postmodernism with socialist feminism.
Campaign Reform Financing Essay Research Paper Campaign
Campaign Reform Financing Essay, Research Paper Campaign Reform Financing Campaign reform financing is a very serious issue in our government today. Many debate the fact if the reform is even needed. The campaigns are bringing into much money and are asking too much of the businessmen. The “soft money” contributions are becoming out of hand, and something needs too be done.
Political Spectrum Essay Research Paper The Political
Political Spectrum Essay, Research Paper The Political Spectrum The spectrum of political attitudes is a diagram that divides political thoughts and ideologies into two parts or halves: the left and the right. From the center, moving to the left, the attitudes and ideologies grow more liberal, from liberal to radical and from liberalism to communism.
People And Machines Essay Research Paper People
People And Machines Essay, Research Paper People and Machines The problem is not with the machine: it is with the man who allows himself to become mechanical. People work on machines all day long. Many of
Eastern Europe
– From 1970 To 1990 Essay, Research Paper From 1970 to 1990, Eastern European nations realized they needed a change in their governments as well as economies. Politically, reformers and dissidents wanted to end party-state dictatorships and move towards a pluralist democracy. Economically, centrally planned economies were unsuccessful due to increased bureaucracy, excessive centralization, and debt obligation.
Post Soviet Russia Essay Research Paper In
Post Soviet Russia Essay, Research Paper In December of 1991, the Soviet Union disintegrated into fifteen separate countries. Its collapse was hailed by the west as a victory for freedom, a triumph of democracy over totalitarianism, and evidence of the superiority of capitalism over socialism. It was a relief for many to watch the Soviet Union brake down, finally bringing the cold world to an end.
Renewal In Italian Labor Union Essay Research
Paper What is the cause of the recent revival in the Italian labor unions? In the past five decades, Italian labor unions have been like a Ping Pong ball, bouncing from weak and divided to strong and united. Membership has also been increasing and decreasing as the unity and strength have been fluctuating. Over the past ten years, Italian unions have experienced a remarkable resurgence.
The Side Effects Of Urbanization And Immigration
Essay, Research Paper The Side Effects of Urbanization and Immigration In the times of urbanization, changes and improvements occurred hand-in-hand with the arrival of immigrants. Anti-immigration acts, problems that resulted from overcrowded cities, political machines, and the Civil Service Commission, are just some of the side affects that urbanization and immigration has brought about to the United States in 1850 to 1940.
Campaign Finance Reform Essay Research Paper Campaign
Campaign Finance Reform Essay, Research Paper Campaign Finance Reform: Soft Money One of the key issues facing this year?s Presidential Campaign is campaign finance reform. More specifically, whether or not to ban soft
Political Change Essay Research Paper Political ChangeIn
Political Change Essay, Research Paper Political Change In the French and Russian Revolutions, could political change have occurred without bloodshed and the use of force? In the French and Russian Revolutions, there was a lot of force and bloodshed used. Can political change occur without the use of bloodshed and force?
Progressive Reform Essay Research Paper The Progressive
Progressive Reform Essay, Research Paper The Progressive Era produced widespread consumer, labor, and political changes in our country in the late 1800 s. For a while a basic principle inherited from Great Britain was used by American businesses, which led to consumer protection. Many labor laws were passed to protect workers who were injured on the job.