Revolutionary War Essay, Research Paper
On May 4, 1778, the Continental Congress of the United States of America ratified the two treaties that formed the Franco-American alliance. Why, one may ask, did France finally decide to offer the “rebel” Americans alliance in 1778? To explore the depth of this question fully, it is necessary to analyze the varying interpretations of historical evidence relating to this momentous time in American history.
The American victory at the Battle of Saratoga in 1778, many historical critics believe, does not merit the importance it has been assigned. Certainly a minimal American capacity for war was essential to an alliance, since France needed the pressure of the American army on British military reserves to fight Britain on fair terms. Diplomatically Saratoga served not as a cause for France to abandon her neutrality, but as an excuse. An almost uncontrollable growth of tension with Britain made an alliance with America not an “if” but a “when.” In addition, France was still “licking her wounds” from her defeat to Britain in 1763 in the Seven Years War and was looking for revenge. Eager to reassert her superiority over Britain, France saw the American Revolution as a perfect opportunity.
A romantic yet shaky thesis presented by George Bancroft and Bernard Fa holds that “the movement of intellectual freedom” within French society produced the alliance. Bancroft and Fa , however, do concede that French enthusiasm for the alliance probably stemmed much less from any concern for American liberty than from enmity toward Britain.
Other historians maintain that France sought commercial rather than territorial rewards from the alliance. An independent United States would be grateful for help and would reward France by making her its foremost trading partner. Moreover, France would capture the rich North American market that England would lose.
Still other historians suspect that the French decision for open war against Britain was reinforced less by Saratoga than by General Washington’s defeats, which demonstrated that although the Americans could destroy large detachments, they were still incapable of destroying the main British army without direct assistance from the French.
Another point that warrants consideration deals with which side took the initiative in drawing up the alliance. The conventional view insists that Americans, rather than Frenchmen, made the first move, that they declared independence mainly to attract a French alliance. American arms, according to this view, could not cope with the brute military power of the British. Americans needed foreign aid in any form but desired a firm commitment to their cause, as in a treaty of alliance, and that is what their representatives in France sought.
On the other hand, some historians hold the belief that France desired war with England and was seeking an alliance from the beginning of her secret aid to the Americans. From the start of the Revolutionary War, French ministers indicated that if the American colonies declared independence, France would help them maintain it. Supporters of this thesis further assert that Americans really had no desire for a military or political connection, fearing it would make America a client state of France–much like America was during the English colonial period.
This wariness toward France was illustrated in the attitudes of insurgent leaders in Congress who wanted only a commercial connection. They argued that an alliance would tie United States to French policy “like a tail on a kite” and endanger more long-term American goals concerning foreign policy. Americans, however, accepted the entangling connection because France demanded it as the price for increased support. This interpretation also shows that the Americans, in order to survive, had no choice but to accept the alliance.
A far more incorporating view, presented by British historian J. H. Plumb, suggests that England’s general inability to crush the American rebels quickly convinced the French to make an alliance, in addition to the secret aid being supplied. France was forced by the end of 1777 to either accept war with Britain or retreat, again in humiliation, from her program of aid to the Americans. Retreat, considering the past clashes with the British, was looking less and less appealing to the French as a way of solidifying her position. The idea of an American defeat followed by reconciliation with the English was so disgusting to the French that an alliance must be formed.
This collection of views only represents the major theories of why France allied with the American rebels in 1778. Nevertheless, this discussion of interpretations of historical evidence goes far to answer the question initially presented. While no one today may truly know exactly why the Franco-American alliance of 1788 formed, it is reasonable to conclude that many of the ideas put forth, in concert with one another, create a quite realistic scenario of what actually took place.
Другие работы по теме:
John Steinbeck Of Mice And Men Essay
, Research Paper Death of Dreams Bill Cozad American Literature 12-21-00 Warren French put it best when he said ?maturity means the destruction of dreams.? Children and those with childish minds often use their imagination to put themselves in wonderful places. That does not make them any less intelligent than those who don?t have dreams, there just less experienced in life.
The Quiet American Essay Research Paper Book
The Quiet American Essay, Research Paper Book Report Author: Graham Greene Titles of some other works by the same author: a.o.: A Burnt-Out Case, The Power and the Glory, The Heart of the
The Battle Of Yorktown Essay Research Paper
The Battle of Yorktown The battle of Yorktown was the most important battle of the revolutionary war because Yorktown was a very big and very populated town and thoarfor made it a very important military benifet.
Women In Politics Essay Research Paper During
Women In Politics Essay, Research Paper During the revolutionary era, American leaders decided to use economic boycotts in their struggle against Britain. The goal of these boycotts was to stop the purchase of imported goods
French Revolution 4 Essay Research Paper The
French Revolution 4 Essay, Research Paper The causes of the French Revolution, being provoked by this collision of the powers of the rising bourgeoise and an sinking aristocracy defending its privileges, was the Financial debt of the government and the long-standing political differences in the government.
French Rev Essay Research Paper The year
French Rev Essay, Research Paper The year 1989 marks the 200th anniversary of the French Revolution. To celebrate, the French government is throwing its biggest party in at least
French And German Constitution Essay Research Paper
The executive in the French Vth Republic and the executive in the Federal republic in Germany have a few similarities and many differences. Since the French Vth constitution was tailor made by DeGaulles himself, the executive in this republic is very strong and authoritative. However, the executive in the Federal Republic of Germany, (the Bundesrepublik- Germany after 1945) was made up to prevent another Hitler from raising up, so it is very weak and is more of an executive figurehead.
The American Revolution Led To The French
Revolution Essay, Research Paper The French had many problems during the American Revolution. These problems started when the French agreed to give the Americans supplies. The Americans thanked them but the French did the wrong thing for their country. They gave a lot of their supplies that they needed at home to the Americans.
The Louisiana Purchase Essay Research Paper The
The Louisiana Purchase Essay, Research Paper The Louisiana Purchase was the purchase of the French province of Louisiana by the United States in 1803. The province stretched from the Mississippi River westward to the
Major Battles Of The American Revolution Essay
, Research Paper The American Revolution began on April 19, 1775, when British soldiers and American patriots clashed at Lexington, Massachusetts, and at nearby Concord. The war lasted eight years. It ended on September 3, 1783, when Britain signed the Treaty of Paris, which gave independence to the United States.
How And Why Australia
’s International Relationships Have Changed Through Its Participation In Overseas Conflict. Essay, Research Paper In this essay I will answer the question- how and why have our(Australia’s) international relationships changed by our participation in overseas conflicts ? The answer to this is that we have had changed international relationships, more independence, it ended Australia’s isolation, it gave greater social rights to women, it affirmed Australia’s alliances with the world powers and most importantly it gave Australia an identity.
The Causes Of American Revolution Essay Research
Paper The American Revolution was a dramatic change in the political, social, and economic system of New England. It was not a bloody revolution; on the contrary it is unique because it was not as violence as other revolutions we know (French, Russia and China).
Was The American Revolution A True Revolution
Essay, Research Paper Was the American Revolution a True Revolution? In 1789 the American Revolution came to an end, when the Constitution was ratified. But was this revolution really a revolution? Many renowned experts on revolutions have argued whether or not the American Revolution was in actuality a revolution.
John Doe Essay Research Paper French Revolution
John Doe Essay, Research Paper French Revolution “Revolutions evolve in definite phases. At first they are moderate in scope, then they become radical to excess and finally they are brought to abrupt conclusions by the emerg…
A Voice From The South Essay Research
Paper Anna J. Cooper ? A Voice from the South In her book, A Voice from the South, Anna J. Cooper expressly addresses two issues: the participation of women in American society and America?s race problem. These are two issues very close to Cooper as an African American woman herself and she claims to speak for all African American women on these points.
French Government Essay Research Paper The modern
French Government Essay, Research Paper The modern French government is run very much like the government of the United States. France is a democratic republic that is divided into three branches,
Colonial Society And Economy Essay Research Paper
There were numerous effects of the French and Indian War; the Peace of Paris of 1763 ended the French and Indian War, closing all French power in North America. With the Death of King George II, the new English king, King George the III, wanted to put an end to the French and Indian War, pursuing peace and agreement.
French And Indian War Summary Essay Research
Paper The French and Indian War, a colonial extension of the Seven Years War that ravaged Europe from 1756 to 1763, was the bloodiest American war in the 18th century. It took more lives than the American Revolution, involved people on three continents, including the Caribbean. The war was the product of an imperial struggle, a clash between the French and English over colonial territory and wealth.
American Literature Essay Research Paper Thomas Jefferson
American Literature Essay, Research Paper Thomas Jefferson was a man of many life issues. He struggled with problems in political life as well as well as personal life. While in presidency Jefferson struggled with the burden of keeping America out of war, and also struggled with problems using the embargo act.
French Revolution Essay Research Paper The French
French Revolution Essay, Research Paper The French Revolution began on 1789. It is the most darkest period of France s history, blended with confusion and chaos which many innocent victims were killed or
The French Language Charter Essay Research Paper
Expository Essay – The French Language Charter In 1977, the French Language Charter (Bill 101) was introduced to the residents of Quebec by the Parti Quebecois . It made French the official language in the province. Bill
Causes Of The French Revolution 2 Essay
, Research Paper Causes of the French Revolution On July 14, 1789, several starving working people of Paris and sixty soldiers seized control of the Bastille, forever changing the course of French history. The seizing of the Bastille wasn t caused by one event, but several underlying causes such as the Old
Russian Revolution VS French Revolution Essay Research
Paper The Russian Revolution (1917-1939) and the French Revolution (1789-1815) were very similar and dissimilar in long-term causes, immediate causes, stages of the revolution, and the world?s reaction to the revolution.
France Society Essay Research Paper Luis LereboursFrench
France Society Essay, Research Paper Luis Lerebours French II 5/19/99 French Culture Introduction Not large by North American standards (about the size of Texas), France is nonetheless extremely diverse: it concentrates a wealth of scenery, regional identities each with their own particular flavor defined by cultural and historic differences.
President Roosevelt Essay Research Paper In 1943
President Roosevelt Essay, Research Paper In 1943 President Roosevelt suggested that Indochina come under the control of four powers after the war, proposing that the eventual independence of the Indo-chinese might follow in twenty to thirty years time. No one knew whether the policy would require American troops, but America was firm on the fact that independence could not be taken by the Vietnamese, but would be granted to the Vietnamese by the Great Powers at their convenience.
Changing Roles Of Women Due To The
Revolution Essay, Research Paper changing roles of women due to the revolution. During the revolutionary era, American leaders decided to use economic boycotts in theirstruggle against Britain. The goal of these boycotts was to stop the purchase of imported goods(which could only be purchased from England).
The French And Indian War Essay Research
Paper The French and Indian War The French and Indian War was fought on July 9, 1755. This battle took place at Fort Duquesne, in western Pennsylvania, which was one of the many
French Essay Research Paper From a young
French Essay, Research Paper From a young age, the French are taught to adhere to a certain schedule which helps them learn to be more independent people as they grow older and become adults. Typical work hours for the French are from around nine in the morning until about six in the evening. Interestingly lunch is an important meal for them and they set aside around two hours in the afternoon for this meal.
Political Participation Essay Research Paper Political participation
Political Participation Essay, Research Paper Political participation has many different forms. The different forms are placed into two categories, conventional participation and unconventional participation. Some examples of conventional participation are writing letters, attending meetings, working in campaigns, contributing money, contacting officials, and voting.
History French And British Essay Research Paper
Free-Response Essay There is no American history separate from the history of Europe. The truth in this statement can be widely examined, with one taking a justifiable position that American
How Meritorious Is The French Education System
? Essay, Research Paper How meritorious is the French education system? In my opinion, the French education system is faulty and undeserving. Meisler portrays for us in animated detail, the torture that French pupils go through in their schooldays. It is also relatively easy for me to understand this scenario because in my country, India, the scene is strikingly similar.