Untitled Essay, Research Paper
We ought then regard the present state of the universe as the effect of its previous
state and the
cause of the one which is to follow. An intelligence knowing at a given instant of time
all the
forces operating in nature, as well as the position at that instant of all things of which
the
universe consists, would be able to comprehend the motions of the largest bodies in the
universe
and those of the smallest atoms in a single formula – provided that it was sufficiently
powerful to
submit all these data analysis. To it nothing would be uncertain and the future would be
present
to its eyes as much as the past.This passage comes from P.S. de Laplace’s “Philosophical Essay on
Probabilities.” If such
determinism is true, then everyone’s every thought and action must be inevitable;
that no
one really has any choice about anything, because we are all helpless products of blind
forces which have made us what we are. In this paper concerning the free will and
determinism debate I will argue that determinism is not plausible, I shall do this by
giving
reasons for determining how determinism is false, give arguments for determinism, and
then refute those arguments.
There are those who think that our behavior is a result of free choice,
but there are
others who presume “we are servants of cosmic destiny or that behavior is nothing but
a
reflex of heredity and environment.” The position of determinism is that every event
is
the necessary outcome of a cause or set of causes. That everything is a consequence of
external forces, and such forces produce all that happens. Man is not free. If we accept
the determinist argument and assume human behavior as a consequence of external factors
rather than of free choice, then we must realize that our explanation of human behavior
leaves no room for morality. If people do not choose their actions, then they are not
really
responsible for them, and there is no need for praising or blaming them. If determinism
were true, then there would be no basis for human effort, for why should a person make
an effort if what he or she does doesn’t make a difference? If what will be will be,
then
one has an excuse for doing nothing. Life would not be so meaningful for people on
deterministic grounds. “The nature of human life may be such that man must understand
himself as being free, for human life as we know it would not make much sense without
the concept of freedom.” The challenge and struggle usually emerge from situations,
such as helping to recycle or reaching out to youths in inner city projects, in which
individuals feel that their effort can make a difference.
In our everyday lives, there are many times when we have to make
decisions; what
we are going to eat for breakfast, or where we are going to walk. When we talk or write,
we are deciding on the arrangement of our thoughts, and we have to search for the right
expressions. Our life, while we are awake and active, is a mixture of important and
unimportant choices. Having free will means that we are able to act voluntarily, that we
could have decided to act differently than we did. When someone is criticized for looking
sloppy, or making an offensive remark, he may try to excuse himself with a “I could
not
help it” remark. But if he is a normal person mentally, then he could have helped it;
he
could have acted differently. “The great American pragmatist William James in his
famous
essay ‘The Dilemma of Determinism,’ James rejects determinism on the grounds
that there
is no free choice. James appealed to direct experience to provide evidence of the
existence of free choice.” Feelings which we all have such as regret or remorse makes
no
sense unless there is free will. People experience regret or sorrow only because they
believe they could have done otherwise. If determinism were true, then people could
never have done otherwise and there should be no reason to feel any regret.
A determinist may argue that human behavior is caused by environment
conditions,
general trends, circumstances, and social economic forces beyond human effort and will.“Freudians have shown that men do things not because of free choice but because of
deep
unconscious forces and libidinal energy or sexual drives. Darwin described man as a
product of
evolution, as any animal is; Marx showed how man is shaped by economic forces over which
he
has no control; and behaviorist psychologist explained human behavior of evidence in favor
of
deterministic thesis.”Determinist believes that people believe they are free only because they’re ignorant
of the
causes of their actions. Spinoza makes that point when he says, “Men are deceived in
thinking themselves free, a belief that consists of the causes by which they are
determined.” He continues: “In the mind there is no absolute, or free will. The
mind is
determined to this or that volition by a cause, which is likewise determined by another
cause, ad infinitum.” All of his philosophy reflected the deterministic view that we
are
not free to change the world because we are all part of a grand causal chain, but his
philosophy also claims the idea that if we accept determinism we free ourselves from
ignorance and emotional servitude. If a person has the capacity to free himself from the
bondage of ignorance and emotional impulses and come to agree with Spinoza, then this
would seem to be a very significant type of freedom. So it can be concluded that Spinoza
was saying something absurd or that he understood the reality and value of freedom.
Human experience over the course of history does rely itself on freedom.
If determinism is true, why should people bother deliberating about
what to do or
deciding and choose seriously? If determinism is true, then whatever is determined to
happen by the past history of the universe is going to happen. A person’s biography
was
written before he or she was born, so there’s no sense in making an effort. Whatever
will
be will be, whatever the person do or don’t do. So then why even bother getting out
of
bed?
Anthony Flew, Western Philosophy (New York: Bobb_Merrill Company, 1971), p. 223.Thomas Ellis Katen, Doing Philosophy (New Jersey: Prentice-Hall Inc, 1973), p. 321.Ibid., p. 386.Ibid., p. 315.Spinoza. The Ethics. Part 2, proposition 35, sholium.Ibid., proposition 48.
Другие работы по теме:
Untitled Essay Research Paper On vacation this
Untitled Essay, Research Paper On vacation this summer I glanced out the window and sawa beautiful handglider hovering in these pretty mountains.A great looking background surrounded the mountains. About four-hundred feet above the mountain soaredthe handglider. The pilot who appears about five footeleven inches wears a yellow jacket and black snow pants.The handglider hangs with a span of about twenty-ninefeet.
Untitled Essay Research Paper I messed up
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I messed up; I made a mistake, But please, haste do not take. I love you more than any action or words could ever express, Still I find my heart drowning in loneliness.
Untitled Essay Research Paper MATERIAL SAFETY DATA
Untitled Essay, Research Paper MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET WOMEN: A Chemical Analysis ELEMENT: Woman SYMBOL: WO DISCOVERER Adam ATOMIC MASS: Accepted as 118 lbs, known to vary from 110 to 550 lbs. OCCURRENCE: Copious quantities throughout the world. PHYSICAL PROPERTIES: 1. Surface usually covered with a painted film. 2.
Untitled Essay Research Paper I am afraidI
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I am afraid. I am lonely. I want to be at home now. I hate the silence. I hate the circumstances. I want to feel love now. I want to feel passion not emptiness.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In the Heart
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In the Heart of Darkness, it is very easy to forget what is real and what is civilized. The rivets that Marlow talks about, to fix his boat, are very symbolic of his need to become riveted to reality. Marlow feels that he is slipping into savagery from what he sees around him. In the story, The Heart of Darkness, by Joseph Conrad, there is a fine line between civilization and savagery and Marlow needs the rivets to help him find himself in his own soul or where his own reality is.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Animal FarmMr Jones
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Animal FarmMr. Jones owned and managed Manor Farm. He was a bad man who liked to drink. Things on the farm got so bad one night that he fell asleep so drunk that he forgot to lock in the animals. The beasts took advantage of the situation and held a secret meeting. Led by the pigs, they ran the Joneses from their home.The animals of the renamed “Animal Farm” formed a system they called “Animalism.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Being a dental
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Being a dental assistant would be a great job because it has a variety of interesting duties. It has goo hours, pay and benefits. There are always advancement opportunities. Jobs will be available because the dental assistant is needed to help the dentist. Being a dental assistant has many good qualities.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Dear Mr Peace
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Dear Mr. Peace, The Connecticut River also known as by it s Algonquin name Long River is very rich and still useable for transportation. The chemical plant that you are proposing to put on the
Untitled Essay Research Paper Pride and Prejudice
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Pride and Prejudice has two main characters, Elizabeth and Darcy, who at the beginning seem to be disgusted at each other. During the book, their views toward each other seem to change and slowly make progress. At the end of the book, their opinions have completely turned around about each other and they even get engaged and later married.
Untitled Essay Research Paper 7 I have
Untitled Essay, Research Paper 7. I have chosen the character Abigail and will show the impact she had on the witch hunt in Salem because of her strong leadership and the accusations she made towards others in Salem.Abby was a very fluensul girl in the play and the other girls looked up to her and would follow along for what ever she told them.
Untitled Essay Research Paper NonHodgkins Lymphoma
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Non-Hodgkin?s Lymphoma Non-Hodgkin?s lymphoma is a disease in which cancer calls are found in the lymphsystem. The lymph system fights infections found in the body. People with AIDStend to pick up this disease. There are no specific early detections for this disease.Every body is different, and this disease is already difficult to diagnose.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In both the
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In both the traditional and not so traditional tales of ?Snow White? and ?Snow White Tale of Terror?despite there many differences, the plots are both based on jealousy. As viewers watch the movies they are dazzled by the mysterious mirror, entranced by the different takes of the story line, and know that there will be a happy ending.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Jonathan Edwards and
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Jonathan Edwards and Patrick Henry?s biographies and speeches showed a lot of similarcharacteristics, but also many differences, Their speeches both contained incredible powerand impact. Yet the effects and results were hardly on the same subject. Jonathan Edwards was a powerful speaker.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Bottlenose DolphinsThe Bottlenose
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Bottlenose Dolphins The Bottlenose Dolphins Live in Fiordland New Zealand. It is a spectacular environment where it snows all winter and sometimes part of the fiord freezes over. The sides of the fiord are like big pillars of rock reaching way out into the sky. The fiord also consists of great number of wild life including Flora, Fauna, Seals, Penguins, Crayfish, and some types of Sharks.
Untitled Essay Research Paper November 6 1996
Untitled Essay, Research Paper November 6, 1996 Dear Joe, It was nice to hear from you again, I enjoyed hearing about your new business venture and I hope it works out. School is going great and I can’t wait to graduate in two months. The other day I finished reading a book by Michael Crichton called “JURASSIC PARK” you may have heard of the movie.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Analysis of Crito
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Analysis of Crito The question is raised within the dialogue between Socrates and Crito concerning civil disobedience. Crito has the desire, the means, and many compelling
Untitled Essay Research Paper Business has always
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Business has always been the major of my choice because of the endless possibilities. You are on your own in a business – but you are also your own boss. And with this comes the privileges. Structure your business to the limits of your imagination. Anything can be sold for the right price.
Untitled Essay Research Paper One day a
Untitled Essay, Research Paper One day, a woman called herself ?Want the Truth in Westport? wrote to a columnist with a question that she had to have the answered. ?Please find out for sure,? she begged the columnist, ?whether or not Oprah Winfrey has had a facelift.? The columnist refused to answer the question for Ms.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Words 361
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Words = 361 At the conclusion of Barn Burning Sarty faces a major dilemma: go back to his family or just walk away. The consequences of this decision are great. For such a young boy, choosing to leave his family must be overwhelming and frightening. However, Sarty knows that in order for him to actually live, he must do this.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In the novel
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In the novel, To Kill A Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, the author comments onlife. Specifically, Harper Lee comments on racism and true courage. Racism is the first subject that the author comments on. It is obviousfrom her writing that she feels racism is that it is wrong. This is displayed inseveral ways.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A hacker is
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A hacker is a person obsessed with computers. At the heart of the obsession is a drive master the computer. The classic hacker was simply a
Untitled Essay Research Paper A Biographical Report
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A Biographical Report on Thomas Fitzsimons Thomas Fitzsimons, or Fitzsimmons as his last name was sometimes spelled, was born during 1741 and died on August 26, 1811. Originally from Ireland,
Untitled Essay Research Paper Hmmmm I havent
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Hmmmm? I haven?t seen that many plays, but I did see this one, so here comes the review. Produced by Andrew Lloyd Webber, Cats is not his most famous production. Webber also did the Phantom of the Opera. I?ve never seen ?Phantom?, but I would imagine it is better than Cats. That?s not to say Cats was particularly bad, just cheesy.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Physics Geosynchronous Orbits
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Physics Geosynchronous Orbits Geosynchronous Orbits + Geostationary Orbits Webster’s dictionary defines a Geostationary orbit as of, relating to, or being a satellite that travels above Earth’s equator from west to east at an altitude of approximately 35,900 kilometers (22,300 miles) and at a speed matching that of Earth’s rotation, thus remaining stationary in relation to Earth. 2.
Untitled Essay Research Paper A Farewell to
Untitled Essay, Research Paper A Farewell to Arms The overall tone of the book is much different than that of The Sun Also Rises. The characters in the book are propelled by outside forces, in this case WWI, where the characters in SAR seemed to have no direction. Frederick’s actions are determined by his position until he deserts the army.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Sand Pebbles essay The movie Sand Pebbles focus was on the flag. The flag was not only a symbol of a nation, but of nationalism, militarism and imperialism. During the 1800’s and early 1900’s there was a severe foreign influence in China. During this time period the European nations wanted to trade with the Chinese, but the Chinese had no interest in the European products for at the time China was self sufficient.
Untitled Essay Research Paper As John Stuart
Untitled Essay, Research Paper As John Stuart Mills, I believe that my philosophy on government will satisfy the needs of the society. Throughout the 1880?s people have revolted under the circumstances that the government is focused on the society and the individual. My system focuses on liberty, meaning the rights and principles of the individual of a society.
Untitled Essay Research Paper H G WellsHerbert
Untitled Essay, Research Paper H G WellsHerbert George Wells English author and political philosopher, mostfamous for his science-fantasy novels with their prophetic depictions ofthe triumphs of technology as well as the horrors of 20th-century warfare.Wells was born September 21, 1866, in Bromley, Kent, and educated at theNormal School of Science in London, to which he won a scholarship.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In the Crucible
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In the Crucible there were many things that we could have learned. We could have learned about religion, education, family lives, and justice or politics. Because the people in the Crucible did not do things as we do now, we can also what was different about our lifestyles. Our religion today is much different from the religion back in 1692.