Leadership Style Essay, Research Paper
Leadership style
Leadership style has been shown to be a major factor in the effectiveness of the organization, and different leadership styles are sometimes more effective in different situations. DuBrin, Ireland, and Williams (1989) note that effective organizational leaders are generally consistent in the way they try to influence the behavior of group members, with this consistent pattern of behavior being the leadership style of a given manager. The behavior of most managers is too complex to be described by a single style, and a manager may modify his or her style to match a given situation. Different approaches have been used to try to categorize leadership style, using different terms and different criteria for analyzing the issue.
The classical method of classifying leadership styles is based on a continuum of authority exerted by the leader. The styles of leadership identified under this approach are autocratic, participative, and free-rein, as indicated by DuBrin, Ireland, and Williams. The autocratic leader maintains the most authority by issuing orders without consulting group members. The basis for leadership is formal authority. Such a leader may have a few favored subordinates, but in general the autocratic leader regards close interpersonal relationships with group members as superfluous. In some situations, the autocratic style is appropriate, but one argument against this style is that executives using it are not completely effective because they create so much turmoil for their subordinates.
Three levels of participative leadership are identified. A participative leader is one who shares decision-making authority with the group. The consultative leader is one who solicits opinions from the group before making a decision, though he or she does not feel constrained to accept the thinking of the group. A consensual leader encourages group discussion on an issue and then makes a decision reflecting the general consensus, so such a leader gives more authority to the group than does the consultative leader. A democratic leader places final authority in the group, functioning as one who collects opinions and takes a vote before making a decision. Such a leader may give away so much authority as to be classified as a free-rein leader.
The free-rein leader turns over almost all authority to group members and provides as little leadership as possible. Such a leader maintains a hands-off policy as long as the situation is one in which the work to be done by each subordinate is clearly defined. The free-rein style may be held by an abdicator who cares very little for achieving productivity or efficiency, while in other cases this may be an appropriate style leading to high productivity.
One dimension of this type of categorization is the level of decision-making authority. Hersey and Blanchard (1988) note that managers spend much of their time reviewing and acting on the proposals of associates, upper management, and nonmanagement personnel. It is common to hear some managers talked of as being “decisive” and others as “lacking prudent judgment.” The authors find that decision making may seem like a very straightforward process and that there may seem to be simple steps for collecting and analyzing data, weighing alternatives, testing possible solutions, and arriving at a course of action. In actual practice, however, real-life decision are made in a pressure-packed environment in the face of inadequate input, conflicting information, budget restraints, time squeezes, scarce resources, and other elements that cloud the issues and threaten the quality of the decisions made. What the manager needs is a simple and logical framework for making decisions that will be successful.
The authors find that there are four basic decision-making styles–authoritative, consultative, facilitative, and delegative. Each style has a high probability of getting results depending on the readiness of the followers of the given situation, and the leadership style determines the relationship between the leader and his or her followers. Authoritative decision making is applicable in situations where the manager possesses the necessary experience and information to reach a conclusion and where followers do not possess the ability, willingness, or confidence to help. The manager makes the decision without seeking assistance. This style requires direct leader behavior. Followers are not usually active in determining a course of action, and the followers do not usually know what the decision is until the manager announces it. Authoritative decisions are required in cases where the manager has knowledge not possessed by others or where the manager is the only source of information or expertise.
Consultative decision making becomes a valuable strategy in cases where the manager recognizes that the followers also possess some experience or knowledge and are willing but not yet able to help. The best strategy in this case is to seek input before making the decision. The manager using this approach selects those followers who can help reach a decision and asks their assistance. The manager may or may not share with them all the details of the problem, and in any case it is the manager who makes the final decision.
Facilitative decision-making is a cooperative effort in which the manager and the followers work together and reach a shared decision. Delegate decision making occurs when the manager delegates the authority to make the decision, an approach that presumes that followers have the necessary knowledge and motivation to handle their tasks (Hersey & Blanchard: 412-415).
Another approach noted by DuBrin, Ireland, and Williams is the Managerial Grid, a framework for classifying leadership styles based on an examination of a leader’s concern for task accomplishments and people at the same time. The Grid has also been used as a comprehensive system of leadership training and organization development. Two dimensions of leadership are considered particularly important on the Grid–consideration, or the degree to which the leader creates an environment of emotional support and trust; and initiating structure, of the degree to which the leader initiates structure for employees with activities such as assigning specific tasks or scheduling work.
DuBrin et al. also explain Theory X and Theory Y, a classification method based on differences in assumptions made about people. The Theory X leader bases his or her actions on certain assumptions about people:
1) People dislike work and try to avoid it.
2) People dislike work, so managers must control, direct, coerce, and threaten subordinates to push them toward organizational goals.
3) People prefer to be directed, to avoid responsibility, and to seek security, since they lack ambition.
The Theory Y leader has a different set of assumptions about people:
1) Physical and mental work are natural parts of life and are not disliked by people.
2) People are self-motivated when they feel committed.
3) People are committed to goals if they attain rewards once the goals are reached.
4) People will seek and accept responsibility under favorable conditions.
5) People can be innovative in solving problems.
6) People are basically bright, but their abilities are generally underutilized in most job settings.
De Vries (1989) notes that Max Weber popularized the concept of charismatic leadership. This is a leadership style that Weber saw as possible for the gifted but not for every leader: “For Weber, charismatic individuals differ from others in that they have the capacity to personally inspire loyalty, which is quite distinct from authority derived from office or status” (13). The charismatic leader is usually seen as one who is born with this ability rather than as one who has developed it.
The different approaches to categorizing leadership styles all involve an analysis of leadership behavior in the organizational setting, with particular reference to how the leader relates to subordinates. The various investigations of decision-making style also involve the issue of how the leader relates to subordinates, here in terms of how much involvement the leader and the subordinates have in the decision-making process. Giving authority to employees is seen as an act of empowerment that is beneficial to subordinates and the organization: “Participation in organizational decision making allows workers to feel control over the direction of the organization and feel that management respects their opinions. For the organization, worker participation in decisions opens up a communication channel so that management can access an important source of knowledge and innovation–the workers” (Northcraft and Neale, 1990: p. 498).
The leader has a position in the hierarchy of the organization that makes him or her a leader, but how that leadership is manfested can vary widely. Kouzes and Posner (1987) examine successful leaders and state that there are five leadership practices common to these leaders: 1) challenging the process; 2) inspiring a shared vision; 3) enabling others to act; 4) modeling the way; and 5) encouraging the heart. These traits seem to describe the supportive, delegative, and participative leadership styles best, but as noted, other leadership styles can be effective in given situations.
References
De Vries, M.F.R. (1989). Prisoners of Leadership. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
DuBrin, A.J., R.D. Ireland, & J.C. Williams (1989). Managemetn & Organization. Cincinnati: South-Western.
Hersey, P. & K.H. Blanchard (1990). Management of Organizational Behavior. Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey: Prentice-Hall.
Kouzes, J.M. & B.Z. Posner (1987). The Leadership Challenge. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Northcraft, G.B. & M.A. Neale (1990). Organizational Behavior. Chicago: The Dryden Press.
Другие работы по теме:
Leadership Essay Research Paper Leadership
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership There is a lot of important things to preform in taking the position of being a leader. You are looking after others and also setting the role for younger kids.
Our Community Hungers Essay Research Paper In
Our Community Hungers Essay, Research Paper In today’s society, our community hungers for leadership. We as individuals are looking for some one who will step up to the challenge and guide us through the rocky points in life. We have called on such people as presidents to lead us in this great nation, the pope to head our spiritual growth, and our teachers to nurture our minds.
Leadership Skills Essay Research Paper Leadership Skills
Leadership Skills Essay, Research Paper Leadership Skills There are many qualities that a leader needs. If a leader has all the qualities, often they will be a better leader. In the novel, The Once and Future King by T.H. White, Merlyn, a highly educated wizard and Arthur s tutor, teaches the soon to be known King Arthur many of these qualities.
Cleft Palate Essay Research Paper Leadership is
Cleft Palate Essay, Research Paper Leadership is a process that requires many types of skills to help a leader become an affective leader. However, a good leader is a servant before becoming a leader. Robert Greenleaf defines this type of person as a servant-leader. Servant leadership is more effective because the servant-leader considers the needs of the followers, and the followers are able to benefit from this.
An Insightful Look Into The Propaganda Video
Essay, Research Paper The audience is filled with many boys that are interested in seeing Adolf Hitler. They wield drums and other musical instruments to celebrate his arrival. There is a mass amount of excitement shown as the leader Hitler comes out to greet the people. He gives the boys a speech and then leaves waving at the people.
The HerseyBlanchard Situation Essay Research Paper The
The Hersey-Blanchard Situation Essay, Research Paper The Hersey-Blanchard Situational Theory One of the most widely followed leadership models is the situational leadership theory of Paul Heresy and Kenneth Blanchard. Situational Leadership Theory is a contingency theory that focuses on the followers.
Leadership Essay Research Paper LeadershipThere are many
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership There are many ways that one can lead others. The theory of Situational Leadership explains the many different approaches that can be taken to be an effective leader. The different styles depends on the situation, which gives it its name, however, some leaders us a high-risk method and low relationship method, some leaders use low risk method and high relationship method while others may us equal risk and relationship method.
How Would You Describe A Leader And
Leadership Essay, Research Paper A significant part of effective leadership is the close connection between the leader and the follower, which often determines the success of the leader?s mission. Unfortunately, this leader-follower relationship cannot be created according to some simple formula.
Leadership Essay Research Paper LeadershipLeadership is used
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership Leadership is used everyday by many different people, but mainly by the same people day after day. These people are know as Leaders, and in the stories of Beowulf and Iliad there are some great examples of good leaders and bad leaders.
Imperialism Essay Research Paper Jan 17 2001Five
Imperialism Essay, Research Paper Jan 17, 2001 Five Points Imperialism is a country based on the idea of having one supreme form of leadership. The supreme leadership influences a supreme nation. This could prove to be dangerous to the history of every nation in the world.
Tomorrow
’s Business Leaders Essay, Research Paper In the past, people that were above average in one area of leadership skills could survive as a leader. Technology has forced an adaptation in practically all aspects of the business environment over the past decade. The level of skills for leaders in the 21st century will need to adapt as well.
Socrates Essay Research Paper He was heir
Socrates Essay, Research Paper He was heir to the greatest empire on earth?but did not know it. Under his brilliant leadership, Rome was restored to unity and order after years of civil war. Augustus was Julius Caesar`s grand nephew and adopted son, and unbeknownst to him, Caesar had decreed that on his death, Augustus should succeed him as Consul of Rome.
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay Research Paper entrance
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay, Research Paper entrance essay For almost as long as I cn remember, I have been interested in th military. Influenced by such movies as “Patton”, and by my dad’s interest in military history, my
Themes Of The Book
” Eaters Of The Dead” Essay, Research Paper My book is titled ?Eaters of the Dead? by Michael Crichton. There are two major themes to this book. First is man versus man and the second is man versus nature. The nature that man is going up against in this book were the supernatural monsters that terrorized the town.
Leadership Essay Research Paper The most meaningful
Leadership Essay, Research Paper The most meaningful and challenging experiences in my life have been through sports and the 4-H club. They have instilled the values of perseverance, confidence, and teamwork within me. I feel that my peers and others could learn valuable life lessons through participating in these organizations.
Tibet Essay Research Paper TibetTibet needs better
Tibet Essay, Research Paper Tibet Tibet needs better leadership. The Dalai Lama does not qualify as a good leader. If this man was a good leader, then he would have had this cleared up a long time ago. The life of the Tibetans is horrible. Their homes and living style has been changed ever since the invasion.
Leadership Defined Essay Research Paper As defined
Leadership Defined Essay, Research Paper As defined by Webster, a leader is someone who has commanding authority or influence or a first or principal performer of a group. It is my position that Leadership, in essence, is the sum of these definitions. In order to have and maintain commanding authority, a leader must be the principal performer of his/her group.
Leadership Scholarship Essay Research Paper There are
Leadership Scholarship Essay, Research Paper There are two kinds of people in this world, followers and leaders. Followers are the people that never take a leadership role in any activity. However leaders are the ones that use their leadership skills to make a difference in this world, such as presidents, teachers, or even college graduates.
Memorandum Essay Research Paper Throughout this memorandum
Memorandum Essay, Research Paper Throughout this memorandum I will demonstrate why I am the best candidate for the position of Executive Assistant to the President and CEO. You will be informed of my qualities through these three main ideas: Problem solving, Team skills and Initiative. With these three qualities I can insure you that I will meet and exceed all you expectations for someone in this kind of position.
Leadership Essay Research Paper This is the
Leadership Essay, Research Paper This is the essay that got me into the National Honors Society and it was based on leadership skills. I took out some detials and others can fill in the appropriate details
Sundiata Essay Research Paper Sundiatas character shows
Sundiata Essay, Research Paper Sundiata?s character shows great strength with a sense of determination, courage, leadership and justice. He lives as an upright man would caring for his family, those around him, his country, and the way he carries his actions.
Team Work Essay Research Paper Working Successfully
Team Work Essay, Research Paper Working Successfully Through Teamwork Every human process is a key success factor. Every one has been important since people first formed organizations to accomplish tasks too big to be performed by individuals working alone and every one will continue to be a challenge as long as people work together.
Britain And France Essay Research Paper Britain
Britain And France Essay, Research Paper Britain and France remained leading powers in Western Europe as Spain and the United Netherlands declined because these two countries gained so much power and economic strength. France possessed the largest European population during this time. It also had wiser political leadership, economic recovery and consolidation, and a less ambitious foreign policy.
Leadership Essay Research Paper Leadership what is
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership- what is it? There are several different definitions. The dictionary defines Leadership as “…The capacity or ability to lead” or ”Guidance; Direction”. Many people think it is simply about being successful, but it comes down to more than that. Leaders are those people that use their skills in leadership to make a difference: presidents, teachers, etc… It is not a skill that can simply be picked up from reading a book; leadership skills are gained through experience, things such as public speaking or organizing an event.
Leadership Essay Research Paper Leadership connotes a
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership connotes a willingness to stand as an example, as well as to guide and influence others in attaining a goal. Effective leadership begins with the same strengths that can be found in a healthy personality structure. Developing leadership skills is, from this perspective, the same process as attaining a strong sense of personal identity and worth.
Concept Of Leadership Essay Research Paper LeadershipWhat
Concept Of Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership What is leadership? Leadership is having the ability to give guidance to those that will follow. Those that follow will help to complete the mission. Leadership is an immature science and the body of knowledge in the field has developed through a series of fits and starts.
Human Resource Accounting Essay Research Paper Although
Human Resource Accounting Essay, Research Paper Although human resource accounting is a relatively new field, its development has passed through certain stages. The first stage of development from 1960 to 1966 was marked by interest in the HRA and HRA concepts. The initial motivating factors for the HRA came from economic theory on human capital, leadership determining skills and a concern to develop humans as good sources of capital for companies.
Louie Freeh (Director Of Fbi) And Correlation
To C Essay, Research Paper Louie Freeh Louie Freeh grew up a normal boy in a normal family. He had the respect of his parents and those in the community. His actions and attitude fit his job as director of the FBI. His leadership tactics can be compared to that of community oriented policing. Community oriented policing involves satisfying the needs and requests of citizens as well as the department.
Leadership Essay Research Paper Leadership has always
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Leadership has always been a key to my success in life. In today’s business world, effective leadership at all levels is required. I use the same concepts in leading my family, as I do in my business and church. Leadership does make a difference. For example, my daughter is required to take a leadership class at the freshman level of high school.
Leadership Essay Research Paper Getting To Know
Leadership Essay, Research Paper Getting To Know Yourself What is encouraged in being a good leader? After doing the exercise in the context that dealt with the study of leadership traits and characteristics that was done by Kirkpatrick and Locke, I found some of the importance of leadership traits. Knowing the importance is only one step in getting to know yourself.
Short Essay On Life In Virginia
Colony Essay, Research Paper Life in Virginia Colony Being a stranger to the New World, one would expect a rich land with much to offer, abundant in natural resources, and profitable. However, this was not the case in the Virginia colony. The dream was deceiving: life in New England was challenging and was held together by inadequate leadership and a poor economy.