The Media Effects Debate Moral Panics
A moral panic is a term used to describe a sudden flurry of conservative attitudes towards the media (usually film or music) when something which is perceived as too shocking or graphic is released to the public. For example when the film Reservoir Dogs was released in the UK there was a “Moral Panic” because many thought that the wanton violence, and in particular the way the violence was treated by director Quentin Tarantino was offensive and repulsive. This moral panic spread like a forest fire and within a couple of weeks of its release the film was successfully banned. It stayed banned for several years until a slightly edited version came out on video, such was the strength of the furore surrounding its original release. This is a textbook example of a moral panic.
In more recent days there has been an ongoing moral panic against violence in the media as a whole instead of against any particular film. The main champions of this recent panic, notably watchdogs and voluntary parents associations, say that there is good reason for this sudden morality crusade. Robert Peters, president of Morality in Media, inc. says that violence in movies today is wrong for four main reasons
“The first problem is that there is too much of it (violence) the glut of media violence desensitises viewers and contributes to ‘Mean World Syndrome’ (a wholly negative view of the world) secondly much of it (media violence) can be easily imitated, especially by young children a third problem is the manner in which violence is depicted. It is one thing to show a shooting or a stabbing; it is another to show it in sadistic slow motion with the bullets actually penetrating the body The fourth problem is Hollywood’s infatuation with guns, instead of portraying guns as, at best, a necessary evil, handguns especially are portrayed as a means of empowerment”
Moral panics are usually inspired by real life events and tragedies for which the media, and usually the director of the most violent film of the moment, receive blame and condemnation. Recently, the Columbine High School massacre sparked a moral panic into two areas of the media, violent films and violent music. This particular moral panic is still ongoing, as America decides which to ban, guns or screen violence. This problem was at least partially solved earlier this year when the United States senate unanimously agreed with a bill to prohibit violent videos. The bill has not been passed yet, indeed it has only gone through the first part of a long legislation process, but the ball has started rolling and I can’t foresee it coming to a halt when you consider the amount of violence which is actually available for public consumption.
Yes, the media of today IS extremely violent and the music of today (in particular Marilyn Manson, Cradle of Filth etc ) does send out unorthodox messages to the people who listen to it. However, the question we are faced with, the question we keep coming back to, again and again is DOES IT HAVE A NEGATIVE EFFECT ON PEOPLE? The people who instigate and support moral panics might say yes, there is evidence all around us, from the unconventional dress sense of young people who listen to music like Marilyn Manson, Cradle of Filth etc to tragedies such as the Columbine High School Massacre. However, in spite of all of the studies which have been carried out and suggest otherwise, there is no real tangible link between cinematic “fake” violence and real life actual violence.
Therefore, are moral panics unjustified? There are good arguments to be made for both cases but I would say that there are certain times when moral panics ARE justified. Take the case of A Clockwork Orange for example. Whilst I don’t think that the film caused people to act any more violently than they usually did, I DO however think that the general public was not ready for a film of that kind to be released. It was too controversial, too close to the edge and was not suitable for cinema audiences because they had never seen anything like it before. Whether you think the film is a philosophical masterpiece or ultra-violent trash depends on your point of view but whatever your opinion of the film, it WAS much too violent for the time when compared to other violent films of that era. The violence was not only extremely abundant and graphic but it was taken lightly and brutal rape scenes were filmed with the main instigator of the rape performing a rendition of ‘Singin’ in the Rain’ and violently beating his victims in time with the music. This was an unacceptable way to show violence and was the main reason for the huge moral panic surrounding the film.
In conclusion I will say that although moral panics are becoming more and more frequent with each passing year as films, and crimes, get more violent. I personally don’t feel that the majority of them are justified. There are cases, however, when appropriate action should be taken if a film is too ahead of the curve, as A Clockwork Orange was but in retrospect films of that nature can be judged more impartially and be released when in it generally felt the viewing public at large can cope with it.
Другие работы по теме:
Inventing Reality Essay Research Paper Inventing RealityHow
Inventing Reality Essay, Research Paper Inventing Reality How much of what the news media tells us is true, and how does it control our view of the world? In his book Inventing Reality, Michael Parenti examines the subtle but profound ways in which the media influence and manipulate the public’s perception of reality.
Censorship Essay Research Paper The negative messages
Censorship Essay, Research Paper The negative messages kids receive via the media have a damaging affect on their psyche and can create serious societal problems. In truth “[t]he violence to which American children are exposed in the name of
Mad City Essay Research Paper The movie
Mad City Essay, Research Paper The movie Mad City demonstrates to us how the media can control our lives. The media is willing to go to any length for the money a story can bring. Max portrays the role of humanity in this film. Max represents the humanity of the media. He seems to be the only trace of humanity in all of the media.
Propaganda Model Essay Research Paper In the
Propaganda Model Essay, Research Paper In the “Propaganda Model”, Edward Herman and Noam Chomsky focus on the inequalities of wealth and power and its effects on the media at different levels. It allows the government and dominant private corporations and holdings to influence the public through a set of five filters, which make up the propaganda model.
Technology And Media Essay Research Paper Look
Technology And Media Essay, Research Paper Look around us today, what do you see? Technology being thrown at you from all kinds of places. For one the media has brought technology to another level. But if you really look at the whole picture technology is media. The both of them interact with each other. We are swamped by media and technology, having no control over it, and don’t know what to believe about technology anymore.
Attention Deficit Disorder Essay Research Paper The
Attention Deficit Disorder Essay, Research Paper The First Lady Hilary Rodham Clinton and the Clinton Administration has proposed to increase focus and funding for research on the use of psychotropic medications in very young children. The recent reporting of stories in the news media documenting the increased use of psychotropic medications in children under five years old, for conditions such as ADD and depression, has appropriately raised concerns among parents, health care professionals, and legislators.
Media In Society Essay Research Paper The
Media In Society Essay, Research Paper The media in today?s society plays a very important role. There are two different kinds of media, written and non-written. Written media consists of newspapers and magazines. Non-written media consists of television and radio. These media?s differ in many ways. I am going to compare and contrast the two different types of media in today?s society.
Winter Gold 2002 Essay Research Paper The
Winter Gold 2002 Essay, Research Paper The life of an international athlete is hectic and can be very stressful. Just the training itself can be taxing on anyone. For instance; and athlete that is going to the Olympics, trains at least a couple years before, and returning Olympians train from the time they finish the last Olympics to the beginning of the next ones.
Elian Gonzalez Essay Research Paper The swarms
Elian Gonzalez Essay, Research Paper The swarms of rumors and tons of media coverage form a shaded cloud around one boy, his name Elian Gonzalez. Elian has been crowded by cameras , flashes
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper Negative effects
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper Negative effects of Marijuana Marijuana is the least harmful drug, but it does have negative health effects. Though moderate users of marijuana are taking less risks than a moderate
How Rap Effects Socity Essay Research Paper
Many individuals in our society today believe that the positive portrayal of violence and sex in rap music has negative effects on its listeners. Due to this widespread perception, many studies have systematically examined rap music for evidence of its negative effects.
Adoption Essay Research Paper Biracial adoptions have
Adoption Essay, Research Paper Biracial adoptions have been the topic of debate for many years but not only for it s effects on the children and their parents but also for it s effect on society and the effect it has on the child s ability to function in society. With this in mind the Federal Government has decided to step in.
Critical Thinking Essay Research Paper Critical thinking
Critical Thinking Essay, Research Paper Critical thinking would be important to the well being of our society for many reasons except for the fact that hardly anyone ever uses it. If people used critical thinking all the time society would be a very different place. People would actually think about what they were going to say and what it means before they said it.
Abortion Essay Research Paper wwwpottersschoolcomabortionIs it right
Abortion Essay, Research Paper www.pottersschool/abortion/ Is it right or is it wrong? Is it murder or is it a woman’s choice. There are so many conflicting views, but who is right? The debate over abortion will probably never be settled in my life time. As with many computer literate people, the author of this site gives us an objective view on abortion.
Another Computer Essay Essay Research Paper The
Another Computer Essay Essay, Research Paper The Computer Underground. The beginning of the electronic communication revolution that started with the public use of telephones to the emergence
The Truman Show Essay Research Paper The
The Truman Show Essay, Research Paper The Truman Show is a movie about a man who is held captive inside a world that revolves around him. Truman Burbank, the main character has been
The Truman Show Essay Research Paper TRUMAN
The Truman Show Essay, Research Paper TRUMAN SHOW 1/ IN THE TRUMAN SHOW, TRUMAN WAS ADOPTED BY A CORPORATION, RAISED IN A FAMILY AND PROVIDED WHAT MOST WOULD CONSIDER A NORMAL LIFE . WHAT IT MORALLY RIGHT FOR THIS TO TAKE PLACE? EXPLAIN.
Global Warming Effects Essay Research Paper How
Global Warming Effects Essay, Research Paper How the World is changing due to the effects caused by Global Warming The reason for this topic is our increasingly changing climate. Every year our climate
How The Media Affects My Life Essay
, Research Paper Donna Jirkovsky Professor Miller Media and Society Monday, September 25th 2000 How the Media Effects my Life One thousand six hundred and eighteen minutes. One thousand six hundred and eighteen was spent by me, on my computer, in three days. That seems to be a lot of time when you think about it, probably just about twenty seven hours.
Television 2
Television’s Effects On Children Essay, Research Paper Television’s Effects on Children The American Psychological Association released a warning today about television’s generally negative effects on children.
Censorship Of Television Essay Research Paper On
Censorship Of Television Essay, Research Paper On one hand parents argue that violence on television causes agression in their children, on the other hand, media figures, professionals, and figures of authority say that there is no proof that television influences children. There have been more than a thousand papers published on the effects of media on behavior.
Creation Of Reality In 1984 Essay Research
Paper 1984 Essay Creation of reality takes place everywhere in society, both today, and in 1984. Reality can easily be created. Reality is usually created to sway or alter the public opinion. The creation or alteration of reality can have both positive and negative effects.
Difference Between Today
’s Media Coverage On The War And Past Media Essay, Research Paper Over different wars, media has progressed in its technology to show viewers more coverage. It has
The Media And Violence Essay Research Paper
The debate regarding the media’s relationship to violence in society has been a hot issue for most of the past century. From the beginning of the wide use of mass media, from films to radio to television, researchers have tried to explain any association or correlation between media effects and violence. Of particular interest and concern has been the issue of violence in the media and the impact that this has on children.
Diversity Essay Research Paper Diversity and the
Diversity Essay, Research Paper Diversity and the Mass Media The question of weather the media?s role in establishing racial and ethnic equality is not only very easy to answer but needs to be answered. People need to think of how important it is. People tend to under estimate this power and hate to admit that the media shapes our opinions about people.
Media Influences Essay Research Paper Before the
Media Influences Essay, Research Paper Before the late 19th century, there was only the printed word to convey information to the masses. Since then, the, the world has seen and embraced new technology, which not only enhanced society communication but mass media itself as well. We use mass media mainly to entertain, communicate and persuade these three factors are the motives that help influence society.
Effects Of Smoking Essay Research Paper Smoking
Effects Of Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking has many effects on the body and tobacco companies have many ways to advertise but one major target group. In this paper I will tell how they do both. Smoking has effects on all parts of the body. We?ll start with the brain. Smoking impairs your ability to concentrate and to think straight.
Effects Of Media Essay Research Paper It
Effects Of Media Essay, Research Paper It is not so easy to understand what exactly Gitlin is trying to state or prove about television. Although it is not clear, Gitlin does state some important points and facts about his view on television and popular culture. Gitlin raises the question of “More to the point, is television now a dominant force in shaping the character of Americans?” I would have to answer yes to this question.
Does A Violent Media Create A Violent
Society? Essay, Research Paper This issue is one of constant debate, with no real solution. There are many things society as a whole and individuals can do to appease or inflame the issue, however each argument has a counter argument and a counter argument will exist for that and so on.
Influence Of Media Essay Research Paper The
Influence Of Media Essay, Research Paper The media has affected me in a variety of ways. I am manipulated by the media through images and symbols which are portrayed through it. It has influenced my lifestyle, personality and opinions.
Brave New Girls Essay Research Paper Brave
Brave New Girls Essay, Research Paper Brave New Girls This story sets a great example for teenage girls. All the TV shows and media that Debbie Stoller refers to are good types of media that give the girls girl power. Today girls can be influenced by a lot that is shown on television and it effects their lives. All the role models play a very important part in teenager’s lives.
Abortion Essay Research Paper My view on
Abortion Essay, Research Paper My view on the abortion is pro-choice so I will debate the issue from the pro-life point of view. Abortion is in a word: murder. There is no way around it , people that have abortions are committing a crime. If one was killing a person who could defend themselves they would go to jail but the people who have abortions just get continue on with their sinful lives.
Legalize Marijuana Essay Research Paper I for
Legalize Marijuana Essay, Research Paper I, for one, believe that Marijuana should be legalized. I have several reasons for this, the main one is that it would almost completely eliminate the crime and other