Vietnam In Remission Essay, Research Paper
The legacy of the American involvement in the Vietnam War is a memory that will live on forever. After reading the book titled Vietnam in Remission by James F. Veninga and Harry A. Wilmer, my first statement has been strengthened ten-fold because of the deep persuasiveness and informative nature of this book. I will begin by summarizing and interpreting the overall thoughts and perspectives that this work brings forth concerning the initiation and justification of U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War. Next, I will paraphrase the authors’ views on legacy that this war leaves behind and provide comments dealing with what can be learned from this book and the points it raises. This study of the effects of the Vietnam War is an stirring and an instructive perspective on this sorrowful moment in history.
The authors of Vietnam in Remission begin with their thoughts on why the United States first proceeded to become involved in this overseas war, whether justified or not. This seems to be almost rhetorical because they mainly provide reasons why we shouldn’t have started the war.
Many people in Vietnam did not like the idea of being under French control at all. They resented the fact that a country that knew little to anything about them held control over their actions in an attempt for its own gain. Therefore, it was a very easy task for Ho Chi Minh to rally support for his cause. None of this was instigated by Communist influence, however. It is a known fact that the North Vietnamese regarded the Russians as “Americans without money,” and the Russians did not even assist much until the U.S. had committed itself. This is not even to say that the Russians did intervene much; most of the help received by the Vietminh was from the Chinese, which the U.S. was trying to make friends with at the time.
This leads the author to the question of why the U.S. even wanted to get involved. They were trying to befriend the Chinese, the uprising wasn’t even started by external Communist influence, and this was solely the problem of the French to deal with. What many people in the U.S. thought was the theory of the ‘domino effect’. This is the theory that if one key country in Southeast Asia would fall to the ideology of Communism, then the small surrounding would also. With the Cold War on the other side of the U.S. any country that became communist, whether very influential or not, was still considered a loss. With that in mind, an effort was made to flex muscles to scare the rebels from being more serious. However it was said that if a firm stance is not taken early on in a conflict, the other side sees a weakness. Let this be a false notion or true, but the insight is one that encourages the other side to stay strong, thus starting a war.
The next topic covered is what the roots were that grew a tree of failure for the U.S. in the war. In the beginning of the conflict, full effort was not given to the cause. This was the most vulnerable time for the Vietminh because they were still rallying for their cause and had no outside help yet. The U.S. started with only sending several troops at a time, only slowly escalating that number in an attempt to keep the issue quiet and not give Russia and China the idea to step in. If the full U.S. Army was sent at first sign of a danger, there would have be in rout without question and there would have been nothing left for the larger communist countries to support. Next, a short segment is made to how the French did not even fully commit to this issue. They had the idea that they would be forced to withdraw from controlling Vietnam after the South Vietnamese were back in power to prevent further conflicts. Because of that, they withdrew from control in the middle of the war and up until that point were wary about sending much help at all for the cause. None of this was to say that the U.S. should have made a massive attack at once and asked the French to do the same, but that would have been the correct move to make in order to win in that area.
The authors begin to question again why South Vietnam was really worth saving. The leader appointed to control the Vietnamese was for the most part incompetent, and he acted too independent, not listening to the U.S. who was trying to help him so much. Because of this he was booted and the next leaders were ones that were educated in the U.S and France; completely out of touch with the people of Vietnam. Many of the Vietnamese people not allied with Ho Chi Minh didn’t even want most of the help that the U.S. was bringing to them. The poor rural dwellers had lived on their land for generations and it was considered sacred to them, but instead they were put into U.S. protective forts that ended up being more harmful than good. How could the U.S. have handled it differently though? Didn’t the South Vietnamese want to be saved from this rebellion?
Not only did the authors of this book provide a unique look on the U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War, but they also concentrated a great deal on the legacies that were left behind by this unfortunate event in our history.
First what was examined was how much this war contributed to the destruction of the male ego within the American society. When the word contributed is used, it is because the war was not the complete cause, but it added a great deal to the destruction. This entire concern began with a boy not spending enough time with his father. This could be due to the increased commonplace of divorces or fathers working away from home throughout and after the industrial revolution. Male bonding between a father and son used to occur when the father needed to teach his son his work so that he could provide for his family on his father’s land when the time came. When the father works in a factory it is not possible for this type of interaction to occur and the male ego becomes damaged from lack of a strong male figure in one’s life. More things that brought the ego down were the move to suburbia containing no male community, and the women’s movement towards increased rights thus shunning male values. The Vietnam War completely finalized this shattering of male ego, though, because everyone traditionally respected the military and looked at them with admiration. When soldiers discovered that the generals and commanders were lying to the U.S. people about what was really going on, to make themselves look better, that respect was completely gone and there was no longer any strong males in the society that could be respected. The authors considered this betrayal to bring forth an almost ‘female rage’ like when one is not allowed to vote based on gender. A ‘female rage’ definitely does not enhance the male ego, and I don’t think it is a stretch to assume that this thought by the authors is mere speculation.
The last and biggest legacy that the authors give as being caused by the involvement in the Vietnam War is that titled the ‘Vietnam Syndrome’. This syndrome summed up is the necessity for complete assurance of complete success before commitment is made. Of course it makes a good deal of sense in theory, but many examples have occurred in reality. One of the most notable was the concern of the possible war in Lebanon and the need use U.S. Marines in conjunction with French and Italian forces to escort Palestinians out of Beirut. Due to the Vietnam Syndrome, orders were made that the Marines would be taken out immediately if they were ever shot upon. They were shot upon and were taken out, causing lack of the amount of force needed to perform the escort, which in turn caused the Italian and French forces to also be required to withdraw ending in a failed mission. The War Powers Resolution could have caused this lack of confidence, which is basically a direct statement of the Vietnam Syndrome. Not only does this syndrome cover the government, but the general population also is more wary now. The media no longer trusts the government officials and always tries to reveal disreputable things about previously respected leaders. When this book was written, 500,000 people or ten percent of the young men eligible for signing up for the draft broke the law and did not since it was not guaranteed to be a safe thing to do. I can see the institution of the Vietnam syndrome just looking around myself, and it is not always completely beneficial in my opinion.
Although some may argue that we are now a nation more cautious towards preventing deaths, the horrible nightmares that veterans face continue night after night to the point of an overall want to forget that Vietnam ever happened. This book is biased to the point of offering a 10:1 ratio of pages concerning the negative legacies to positive legacies. One cannot really blame the authors for this, though. They do offer a small solution for amending some of these problems, however. They say that we should do what Lincoln would have done if he were still leading us and have a public mourning displaying the complete sadness of what happened and not merely a mask convincing all that they are doing the right thing. They also say that the older men who run the country and run the military should collectively give a public apology to the younger men in an attempt to regain their respect and provide a place for the male ego to come from again. It will be impossible to forget the Vietnam War, but we can still do whatever possible to ease the painful memories and rebuild what was lost.
Bibliography
Veninga, James F. and Wilmer, Harry A. Vietnam in Remission
32f
Другие работы по теме:
The US Involvement In Vietnam And The
Philippines Essay, Research Paper The US involvement in Vietnam and The Philippines Introduction Ever since the ?New Imperialist? era, the United States of America has become quite a large Neo-Imperialist power, particularly in The Philippines and also Vietnam. In order to understand this report the term Neo-Imperialism must be explained, this is when one country gives aid to another country in which the country that recieves aid becomes independent on the helping country.
Vietman War Essay Research Paper The Viet
Vietman War Essay, Research Paper The Viet Cong were experts at the use of several unconventional battle tactics, namely, Guerilla Warfare. This is how they won many of the battles in the Vietnam War. The Viet Cong, during ground battles used small arms, some of which they had made themselves. Another technique they used was psychological warfare.
Vietnam War Essay Research Paper The discussion
Vietnam War Essay, Research Paper The discussion of the Vietnam War and its affect on Americans. In this regard, the opinions and experiences of those who fought in the war, as well as those who stayed at
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Harold
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Harold “Light Bulb” Bryant’s portrayals of life in the Vietnam War offend the human race. Not so much the actions Bryant displayed, but the demeanor of the U.S. armed forces. Through Bryant’s stories one comes to the conclusion that war made these people completely mad, and lost every bit of morality.
MadeUp Nixon Speech Essay Research Paper My
Made-Up Nixon Speech Essay, Research Paper My fellow Americans, I come to you tonight to ask for a hand to lend in my aide. I know that a great number of the silent majority would like to see the Vietnam war to finally come to a close. And, because of my campaign promise, I am standing here tonight to inform you that I have a plan of action that I shall use to uphold that promise.
U.S.A Was Unable To Win The Vietnam
War Because… Essay, Research Paper The U.S.A was unable to win the Vietnam War because they realised too late that the real war in Vietnam was not a military one but a political one.
In 1969 The Plane Came Back Essay
, Research Paper In Kathryn L. Scott?s paper ?In 1969 The Plane Came Back? she addresses the issue of the affect of the Vietnam war on those who served in it.
Vietnam And Politics Essay Research Paper Vietnam
Vietnam And Politics Essay, Research Paper Vietnam was a war of attrition. It was the hardest war the United States has ever fought. We were fighting for a people who did not want us there and for a
Logical Intervention In Vietna Essay Research Paper
Logical Intervention in Vietnam American military intervention in Vietnam has always been a highly controversial issue. Many Americans were against intervention in Vietnam. Many Americans question rather the United States should have ever sent troops to Southeast Asia, and if intervention was the correct action, based on foreign policy and bipartisan ideas.
My Experience Essay Research Paper To whom
My Experience Essay, Research Paper To whom that cares!!! At this moment when i am sitting down here writting this, I suddenly think of this time last year when I was fresh out of highschool, hearing about Berea for the first time. I sent my application to Berea with lots of confidence and hope, and I knew I was not accepted.
How Important Was The My Lai Massacre
In Generating Support For The Peace Protest Movement? Essay, Research Paper The Peace Protest Movement was a time in the Vietnam war when people disagreed with it. This was because of a number of things. The amount of money it was costing, The amount of people killed, but it originated largely from the massacre at My Lai.
Killing Fields Essay Research Paper ESSAYThis essay
Killing Fields Essay, Research Paper ESSAY This essay will discuss the events that happened in Cambodia and how these events were similar to the war events that occurred in Vietnam, the essay will also discuss the important differences in the wars in both countries.
Black Sabath Essay Research Paper Jenny dont
Black Sabath Essay, Research Paper Jenny don?t know what love is. But really Jenny is the one that doesn?t know what love is. Then Jenny starts to try to get a ride She is running away from Forrest. Then Forrest tells her he is going to Vietnam. Jenny stops and looks at him then tells him not to be brave if you?re in trouble or danger run.
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry Cabot Lodge Essay, Research Paper Henry Cabot Lodge Henry Cabot Lodge was an American diplomat. He was born on July 5th 1902. He was born in Nahant Massachusetts. He did alot for our country so in the next few paragraphs I will tell you about Henry Cabot Lodge and some of his accomplishments.
Short Summary Of Vietnam Essay Research Paper
Vietnam was a struggle which, in all honesty, the United States should never have been involved in. North Vietnam was battling for ownership of South Vietnam, so that they would be a unified communist nation. To prevent the domino effect and the further spread of communism, the U.S. held on to the Truman Doctrine and stood behind the South Vietnamese leader, Diem.
Forestgump Essay Research Paper Forrest Gump In
Forestgump Essay, Research Paper Forrest Gump In this paper about Forrest Gump I am going to give several historic events that occurred in the movie, and also I will give my opinion about the film. I will also tell whether or not I would recommend you seeing it. So just sit back and enjoy the show. The story takes place form the 60 s to the 90 s, in Alabama, which was a very controversial time in American history.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Vietnam should the
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Vietnam: should the U.S. have been involved? The Vietnam War created a great deal of controversy in America. Did America really have to sacrifice thousands of lives and millions of dollars? Was it America s duty to be involved in Vietnams affairs? Questions such as these are what derived such a constant debate during the time of the Vietnam War.
Vietnam Poetry Essay Research Paper Two Stories
Vietnam Poetry Essay, Research Paper Two Stories of Vietnam My essay is a comparison of a song and a poem about the Vietnam war. The song is “Goodnight Saigon” written by Billy Joel and the poem is “No Word Spoken” by Edward J. Domaleski. These two are very different but revolve around one main point; the American soldiers experience in the Vietnam war.
American Dream Of The Soldiers Of The
Vietnam War Essay, Research Paper ?When we first got here–all of us–we were real young and innocent, full of romantic bullshit, but we learned pretty damn quick.? This quote was extracted from the
Fallen Angels Essay Essay Research Paper In
Fallen Angels Essay Essay, Research Paper In the book Fallen Angels by Walter Dean Myers, we read about the hardships and troubles of themain character, Richard Perry, during the Vietnam war. We learn a lot about Perry throughout thebook, and by the end of the book we feel like we know exactly how Perry feels, and we have aunderstanding of some of the hardships that the soldiers faced in Vietnam.
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Afflicting Vietnam Veterans
Essay, Research Paper Post Traumatic Stress Disorder afflicts a number of vietnam veterans who suffered extremely traumatic, and often consistent, experiences in the vietnam war. Many who do not understand the disorder at all view PTSD(post traumatic stress disorder) as an elaborate diagnosis for a vague set of symptoms that would otherwise be associated with other psycological problems.
Norman Schwarzkopf Essay Research Paper Norman SchwarzkopfNorman
Norman Schwarzkopf Essay, Research Paper Norman Schwarzkopf Norman Schwarzkopf and I are alike in many ways. He and I both have family in Germany. His father lives in Germany and my great grandparents live in Germany. He served in Vietnam and so did my grandfather.
Platoon Truth Or Fiction Essay Research Paper
The Vietnam War was a military struggle fought in Vietnam from 1959 to 1975. It began as a determined attempt by Communist society (called Vietcong) in the South, backed by Communist North Vietnam, to overthrow the government of South Vietnam. The struggle widened into a war between South Vietnam and North Vietnam and eventually into an international conflict.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Against the celebrated
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper -Against the celebrated and glorious backdrop of American history, the Vietnam War stands ghastly out of place. The war was an exercise in economic, military, and political futility. The greatest tragedy of the Vietnam War, however, stems from the unnecessary deaths of 58 000 young American boys and the installment of terror, mistrust, and sorrow in those who found a way to survive in an inferno where the laws of man were obsolete.
Antiwar Movment In Vietnam Essay Research Paper
The antiwar movement against Vietnam in the US from 1965-1971 was the most significant movement of its kind in the nation’s history. The United States first became directly involved in Vietnam in 1950 when President Harry Truman started to underwrite the costs of France’s war against the Viet Minh. Later, the presidencies of Dwight Eisenhower and John F.
Desert Storm Compare And Contrast To Vietnam
War Essay, Research Paper Desert Storm and Vietnam were portrayed in the media are similar because in each the American soldiers had confidence when fighting, both were on tv, journalists and reporters were with soldiers on the battlefield. They were different because Desert Storm lasted six weeks and Vietnam was ten years plus.
Lyndon B Johnson Essay Research Paper Lyndon
Lyndon B. Johnson Essay, Research Paper Lyndon B. Johnson and American Liberalism Bruce J. Schulman This brief biography of Lyndon Johnson outlined his life beginning in rural Texas and followed the ups and downs of his political career. It discusses his liberal, “active government” mentality and its implications on both domestic and foreign issues.
My Lai Essay Research Paper THE MY
My Lai Essay, Research Paper THE MY LAI MASSACRE Boys will be boys. A commonly use quote. So what happens when a group of young men, who have just seen their best friend killed, goes on a search and destroy mission to face a village full of strangers from a distant land? You get the My Lai massacre. The whole village was wiped out by the US Eleventh Light Infantry Brigade.
Why Did The Usa Become Involved In
Vietnam In The 1950S And 1960S Essay, Research Paper Why did the USA become involved in Vietnam in the 1950s and 1960s? The USA became involved in Vietnam because of a cry for help from the Vietnamese president of that time, Ngo Dinh Diem, or at least, they used it as an excuse for what they did. The Americans saw it as a prime example to the rest of the world of how capitalism could conquer communism.
Vietnam Memorial Essay Research Paper At the
Vietnam Memorial Essay, Research Paper At the age of twenty one, a female undergraduate at Yale University named Maya Lin submitted her design for the Vietnam Memorial. Her idea
Vietnam Survey Essay Research Paper Survey of
Vietnam Survey Essay, Research Paper Survey of The Sixties and Early Seventies In the 1960 s, the baby boomers became teenagers and were growing up in the Cold War. Because of the threat of nuclear disaster, many of these young people felt they were living on the edge of disaster. Many of them blamed their elders who had grown up in the Depression and World War II , this created the generation gap .