In his Meditations, Rene Descartes attempts to prove the existence and reality of himself and things external to himself. In order to fulfill such a feat, Descartes decides to doubt all that he knows, for he knows not whether that can be relied upon. He doubts his knowledge for three main reasons.
For one, he accounts that in dreams, many times he had thought that things external to himself were real. Also, he had heard people declare pain in limbs that they had lost long ago. After pondering these two experiences he declared, “the chief and most common mistake which is to be found here consists in my judging that the ideas which are in me resemble, or conform to, things outside me” (Descartes 16). These two accounts proved to him that he should doubt the existence of his own body.
Next, he realizes that even when he is “awake,” he cannot trust his senses. Descartes says that “the senses do sometimes deceive us when it is a question of very small and distant things” (14) A perfect example of such would be how a stick that is straight might appear bent when immersed in water, or might mistake the height and shape of distant towers. This makes him further realize that he cannot trust experience.
Finally, he is then forced to question his mind, when he realizes that there might be an Evil Genius that controls his every thought. If there were an Evil Genius doing such, his thoughts would mean nothing and his questioning would mean nothing, because he is constantly being deceived. With this in mind, he is able to stumble upon an epiphany, that the very fact that he is questioning, means that he exists. His reasoning is one that is quite logical. By questioning something, he knows that there has to be someone that does the actual action of the questioning, and if there is someone that questions, that someone must exist. It is a subject-object relationship. In order to question something, there must be something to question, therefore a questionable object exists. And in order for there to be questioning, some thinking thing, i.e. Descartes, must be doing the questioning, therefore, he exists. Even if the Evil Genius is constantly deceiving him, that fact that he is being deceived means that he exists. For this reason, Descartes could not doubt that he was doubting, and thus was able to ” conclude that this proposition, I am, I exist, is necessarily true whenever it is put forward by me or conceived in my mind.” (17).
To completely prove his point to the skeptics he had to go further, for how could one realize that he/she is doubting? Descartes answers that this is possible through natural light- intuition. By establishing that he is a thing that, doubts, questions, thinks, affirms, denies, imagines, and perceives, through examples, he is able to prove how one could realize his/her doubting. Descartes gives us the example of the wax that is melted, and the people on the street with coats. If the wax melts, one still perceives such as wax because the wax is “merely something extended, flexible, and changeable” (21). On the street, one could see coats and hats, but one determines that one is seeing people. This, like the wax, is done through judgement alone, by the intellect alone. With this, Descartes posits that an object can be grasped even when stripped of its outer form and “perceived by the mind alone” (21). He follows that by arguing that the awareness of one’s self is more certain than that of wax and coats, for one understands one’s self more clearly and distinctly than anything else. If one is able to do such, than, through nature of light, one is able to realize that one is doubting.
The main qualm that I have with Descartes’ argument, is with his nature of light argument, that he is only sure that he is doubting from judgements solely based on perception. In order to grasp a concept, one must do such only through perception because the body has to be doubted, so the mind must act alone. Like the wax, one can tell that it is still wax through intellect alone. This proposes that perception is the only measure of reality, and the conception of an object is independent from perception. Therefore, if this is the case, it is impossible to have a change in perception that causes a change in conception. This argument leads Descartes’ into some trouble. For, if one sees coats and hats walking around in the street, one’s nature of light- intuition, would tell one that those things inside of them are people, because that is what we are used to seeing. So, through intellect alone, one is able to determine that those are people out on the street, yet what if that conception changes. According to Descartes, it cannot, but the thing inside the coats and hats might be trained chimpanzees walking around. So suddenly, one realizes that the perception of the coats and hats was wrong, and that the conception changed. Therefore, just as Descartes has the perception that he is doing the doubting, because of the lack of empirical evidence and the unreliable quality of perception, through his method Descartes cannot be clearly and distinctly sure of anything.
3d0
Descartes, Ren?. MEDITATIONS ON FIRST PHILOSOPHY. 3rd ed.
Trans. Donald A. Cress. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing
Company, 1993.
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
DickinsonS Poems Essay Research Paper Dickinson Explication
Dickinson`S Poems Essay, Research Paper Dickinson Explication #130 This poem speaks of the final summer days of the year, possibly coming after the initial fall cool down. The speaker begins by saying “These are the days when Birds come back—A very few—a Bird or two—To take a backward look,” referring to the few remaining birds in the last of the warm days of the year.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Can We Ever Reach Certainty Essay Research
Paper First, I would like to quote Descartes: “Cogito, ergo sum” – I think, therefor I am. He said this, because he didn’t know weather he knew if he existed or not. Descartes thought like this: I know that I’m dreaming, but I don’t know if it’s reality or dream, I doubt. But because I doubt, I think, and if I am thinking, I am a human, thinking, being, and therefor – I exist – “Cogito, ergo sum”.
How If At All Does The Cogito
Help To Ground Our Knowledge Securely? Essay, Research Paper The Cogito is the name given to the famous statement Descartes considers of which he is sure of its certainty: cogito, ergo sum, or ?I
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Sonnet 29 Essay Research Paper Rob BenkovicMrs
Sonnet 29 Essay, Research Paper Rob Benkovic Mrs. Stahl Period 8 5/8/00 Explication of “Sonnet 29” The reader can find Shakespeare’s dilemma in the first two stanzas. His problem is quite clear: he is lonely and depressed. As an outcast of society, he feels unlucky and thinks that there is no hope for him. Not even God can help him.
Descartes Essay Research Paper Everyday we are
Descartes Essay, Research Paper Everyday we are bombarded with various forms of stimuli. We see many people, we hear cars drive by, we feel the cool breeze, etc, but how can we prove that we are really experiencing these stimuli? That is the question that Rene Descartes asked some three hundred fifty years ago, is there anything real in this world? Descartes concluded that at least his mind existed because he was thinking, which led to him saying ?Cogito ergo sum? which means I think therefore I am.
Explication Of Dulce Et Decorum Est Essay
, Research Paper Explication of “Dulce et Decorum Est” In Dulce et Decorum Est Wilfred Owen explores the harsh conditions and realities of war. The burdens of war and the overwhelming weariness faced by soldiers are described in the first ten lines of the poem. Many soldiers in World War I did not have the proper training and equipment to fight a war.
Explication From Hamlet Essay Research Paper Assignment
Explication From Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Assignment 1: Explication from Hamlet (1.3.111-137) (?My lord, he hath importuned me with love? ? [end of scene].Ophelia and Polonius have a father-daughter discussion toward the end of Act 1 where Polonius, concerned father that he is, warns his daughter Ophelia of becoming too involved with Hamlet.
Hamlet Explication Essay Research Paper Hamlet Explication
Hamlet Explication Essay, Research Paper Hamlet Explication In Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, Rosencrantz speaks Act 3 Scene 3 lines 11-23. The lines that he speaks are in response to the Kings request that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern take Hamlet to England immediately. The king feels that Hamlet’s madness is a threat to him and tries to convince the men that it is a threat to the kingdom and that it would be in Hamlet’s best interest to go to England.
Explication Of Ezra Pound
’s In A Station Of The Metro Essay, Research Paper The Explication of Ezra Pound s In a Station of the Metro Ezra Pound s words portray a moment frozen in time. The poem, In a Station of the Metro, is a poem of imagery. Through imagery, Pound imbues his vision and thoughts of his surroundings while on a subway train.
Love Song Explication Essay Research Paper The
Love Song Explication Essay, Research Paper The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock Lines 37-52 In this stanza the man regrets some of the decisions that he has made in his life. The man feels that if he allows himself to reflect upon his past he will have to deal with the emotions and consequences of a life of poor decisions.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Explication Of Blake Essay Research Paper The
Explication Of Blake Essay, Research Paper The poetry of William Blake is renowned for its critique of society and injustice as well as expressing strong religious influences. Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience were written concerning the destiny of the human spirit and the differences between how children and adults view and understand the world.
Come In Explication Essay Research Paper Come
Come In Explication Essay, Research Paper Come In by Robert Frost Robert Frost is a well known American poet often associated with beautiful scenes from the New England area. However, the deeper meanings of his poems is often
Descartes Knowledge Essay Research Paper Descartes Essay
Descartes Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Descartes (Essay #1) Rob Hewitt 9711732 Wednesday October 21, 1998 Justin E. A. Busch The question of our existence in reality is a question which philosophers have tackled throughout time. This essay will look at the phrase, cogito ergo sum or I think therefore I am, a phrase brought about by Rene Descartes.
Frost 2 Essay Research Paper Explication of
Frost 2 Essay, Research Paper Explication of The Road Not Taken Robert Frost, a poet from the early Twentieth Century, is well known not only for his elegant style, but for his use of great symbolism throughout his works. In The Road Not Taken , he depicted his theme and meaning through a four stanza poem which consisted of a set rhyme scheme (A, B, A, A, B).
Explication The Road Not Taken Essay Research
Paper Explication: The Road Not Taken “The Road Not Taken” is a poem written by Robert Frost. In his poem Frost describes a traveler’s choice between two roads and how this choice effects his life later.
Explication Of
“A Study Of Reading Habits” Essay, Research Paper Explication of “A Study of Reading Habits” “A Study of Reading Habits,” is Philip Larkin?s poetic warning that escapism and ignoring reality only makes real life less fulfilling. Larkin develops this idea via a narrator who prefers to escape from life rather than deal with it, as well as through changing use of language and subtle irony.
My Last Duchess Essay Research Paper Explication
My Last Duchess Essay, Research Paper Explication of:”My Last Duchess” by: Robert BrowningThis piece of poetry is about an Italian duke who ordered the murder of his wife and is currently showing her portrait to a servant or envoy of his future father-in-law. The duke shows this painting only to select strangers in order to flaunt his prize, and he enjoys telling them the story of why he ordered her death.
A Poetry Explication Of Option By Robert
Morgan Essay, Research Paper Poetry Explication Option by Robert Morgan Written in free verse, this poem dramatizes the chance confrontation of a groundhog and terrier.
The Explication Of No One Essay Research
Paper The poem “The Monument,” by Elizabeth Bishop can be thematically deconstructed in many ways. At first glance, the poem is about a tangible and solid object. The speaker describes this object, a monument, very thoroughly. After further examination and explication it is evident that the poem is not about one object, but about many intangible things such as creativity, art, and intuition.
Explication Of Roll Call (A Poem By
Yusef Komunyaka Essay, Research Paper Explication This poem is written in free verse containing twenty-two lines. In line two there is a simile (“we must’ve looked like crows”), and also another simile in lines eight and nine (“a helmet on it’s barrel as if it were a man.”) In lines 5-9 it shows how the boots, helmet, and rifle look like a person, representing the dead people.
Poetry Explication Essay Research Paper Poetry ExplicationThe
Poetry Explication Essay, Research Paper Poetry Explication The second sonnet in Mark Jarman’s group of sonnets entitled The Word “Answer” can be interpreted two different ways. Is there a “right” way from which to view this poem, or is the poet simply exercising his God given right to ambiguity? Sonnet 2, as I will refer to it, revolves around someone sitting in a bathtub when suddenly there is a knock at the door, which soon turns into ringing and pounding, and finally the sound of breaking glass.
Explication 2
Explication: “It Sifts From Leaden Sieves” Essay, Research Paper Tess Purnell T. Arnold ENG-157W Explication #3 8-11-00 “It Sifts from Leaden Sieves”: Explication
An Explication Of To The Virgins To
Make Much Of Time Essay, Research Paper The tiltle To the Virgins, to Make much of time, gives a hint as to the meaning of the work. We gleam from the title that Time is going to be significant. However, we cannot know what the context of time is without the benefit of reading further. We also learn that Virgins plays an integral part of this work.