The Marshall Decision Essay, Research Paper
Who: Donald Marshall (a Mikmaq fisherman), Native and non-native fisherman,
Supreme Court of Canada and Herb Dhaliwal (minister of Fisheries and ocean).
Where: Burnt Church, Miramichi Bay
Issue: Donald Marshall, a mikmaq fisherman took a case to the Supreme Court of
Canada arguing that a treaty from 1760 gave him aboriginal fishing rights and he won the
trail justifying three conviction he had on fishing with out a license, fishing off season
and fishing with illegal nets. After the Court ruled in Marshalls favor, many native
fisherman started fishing off season as well. The Minister of Fisheries and Ocean, Herb
Dhaliwal, than banned fishing from the Miramichi Bay to conserve the sea life, which is
being endangered by the off season fishing. The Minister of Fisheries and Ocean
explained that the lobster are being caught before they have time to reproduce themselves,
but aboriginal fisherman fought that the federal fishing regulations did not apply to them
and that they would continue fishing. Also that they had their own way of conserving and
keeping track of the lobster in the Miramichi bay. Non- native fisherman, angry with the
choices currently made destroyed and vandalized native fishing traps to prevent them
from fishing. The Indigenous people concerned with the safety of their people put native
warriors at the bay to protect any native traps or native fisherman from being harmed.
There still continues to be violent confrontation and threats between native and
non-native fisherman over the Marshall decision till this day. The question asked by
many is which is more important, the right of aboriginal people or the conservation of
Canadas natural resources. The Supreme Court of Canada and the Minister of Fisheries
and Ocean continue to look for a solution that will satisfy all parties involved in this
matter.
1. www.newsworld.cbc.ca
This site had reliable news coverage and facts. The information was non based and there many in-depth
stories involving the Marshall decision. The site was very high quality and professionally organized.
From this site I managed to get the basics on the Marshall Decision and with a little searching I found some
information on Donald marshalls past. I. would give this site a very good rating probably nine out of ten.
2. www.arcbc.tripod
This site had lots of information and some history on aboriginal rights. the problem was that it was
extremely biased. I wouldn?t say that all the information was reliable though because of the biased in it. The
information made it appear as if the aboriginal fisherman were victimized and that the law was unfair to
them. It seemed more like an opinion than facts. I would give this site probably a five out of ten.
3. www.picpress
This site was not biased, but it was very criticizing. I liked what the writer thought of the situation, but It
probably isn?t very accurate. I seemed more like an opinion as well, but with an interesting way of looking
at things. I would give this site a 7 out of ten.
4. www.southam
This site was also biased, against Donald Marshall. It had a story on one of Marshalls other victories
in with Marshall won the metis people the right to hunt moose in the off season in New Brunswick. He
described how metis people started over killing the moose in that location and that soon moose with be a
rare in New Brunswick. I thought this story was similar to the fishing issue. The story probably would not
be that reliable since it an opinion. I would give this site an 6 out of ten.
5. www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca
This site had lots of information on the issue. It also had some informative diagrams on the area closure
and lobster life cycle explaining why the bay should be banned from fishing. The information wasn?t biased
and the facts were reliable. I would rate this site a nine out of ten.
Другие работы по теме:
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper The
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper The Supreme Court case of McCulloch v. Maryland set forth important principles in American government. The case itself dealt with whether or not the Congress had power from the Constitution to establish a national bank; also, it dealt with whether or not a state could tax or interfere with the national bank.
Mcculloch V Maryland Essay Research Paper McCulloch
Mcculloch V. Maryland Essay, Research Paper McCulloch v. Maryland The case of McCulloch v. Maryland was brought to the United States Supreme Court in 1819. The decisions of Chief Justice John Marshall in this case would set precedence for all future cases involving the expansion of federal power and any impediment on federal powers by state governments.
Walkabout Essay Research Paper WalkaboutWalkabout is about
Walkabout Essay, Research Paper Walkabout Walkabout is about a young girl, her younger brother, and a bush boy who fight for survival in the Australian desert. James Vance Marshall, the author, shows many problems of survival that the children are faced with, throughout their journey in the Australian desert.
George C Marshall Essay Research Paper George
George C. Marshall Essay, Research Paper George C. Marshall was born on December 31, 1880, in Uniontown, Pennsylvania. He graduated from the Virginia Military Institute (VMI) in 1901 and was commissioned a Second Lieutenant. During World War I he was stationed in France and won acclaim for his direction of the Meuse-Argonne offensive.
Economics 3 Essay Research Paper A Price
Economics 3 Essay, Research Paper A Price to Pay “The Fatal Equilibrium” by Marshall Jevons describes a story of murder and betrayal within the Harvard University faculty. The novel also explains the economic ways of thinking that people apply for decision making in their lives. Economics is in ways like the air.
Commercials Essay Research Paper In every young
Commercials Essay, Research Paper In every young person life there are certain critical decisions that must be made. One of the more important of the many is the choice to resume education after high school. After that decision is made the choice of which college to go to comes into play. In making this decision you must first do research on schools that interest you, you must visit these campuses, and last you must apply to the schools of your choice.
Marbury V Madison Trial Essay Research Paper
Marbury v. Madison The issue before the Supreme Court was the question of the court?s own constitutional authority, and to decide whether or not to issue the writ and if this would
Justice Harlan Essay Research Paper John Marshall
Justice Harlan Essay, Research Paper John Marshall Harlan II was born on May 20, 1899 in Chicago, Illinois. He was born to John Maynard Harlan, an attorney, and Elizabeth Flagg Harlan. John Marshall Harlan II came from a long line of political servants, of whom his grandfather is probably most notable. John Marshall Harlan I, whom John Marshall Harlan II was named after, sat on the Supreme Court as an Associate Justice from 1877 to 1911.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper George Washington
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper George Washington may have been the Father of Our Country, but his friend John Marshall defined for the new nation what it meant to be united and to live under the rule of law.
Madison Vs Marbury Essay Research Paper Between
Madison Vs. Marbury Essay, Research Paper Between 1800 and 1835, the Supreme Court dealt with many cases of great importance to the United States of America. John Marshall served as the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court during this time. The case of Marbury v. Madison, in 1803, was one of the most crucial court cases and decisions made in this time period.
John Marshall
’s Court Rulings Essay, Research Paper Hamilton was a federalist and served as the secretary of the treasury in the 1890s. He was a strong supporter of a centralized federal government. He also advocated loose interpretation of the u.s. constitution and the use of the elastic clause. Which was an ambiguous power of the federal government stating that ?congress can do what it is proper and necessary? john Marshall?s epitomizing of these Hamiltonian principals and philosophies can be seen in several of his court rulings.
Making Of A Writer Essay Research Paper
By: Paule Marshall One woman tries to convey the “variety of voices” from West Indians and black American Engilsh which are her heritage. She gained her knowledge through her
Street Soldier Essay Research Paper Street SoldierStreet
Street Soldier Essay, Research Paper Street Soldier Street Soldier, by Joseph Marshall, is a inspiring well written book. The book is about his life and how he started the Omega Boys Club. The Omega Boys Club is a club that helps keep inter city kids off the streets. There is a connection between the author’s life and certain events in the novel.
Atomic Bomb Essay Research Paper The Right
Atomic Bomb Essay, Research Paper The Right Choice On August 6, 1945, at 8:15 the American plane The Enola Gay changed history forever. The plane dropped the first atomic bomb over the city of Hiroshima, Japan in a successful effort to ended World War II. The question on whether or not such a powerful attack was necessary to end the war has often been asked.
John Marshall The Great Chief Justice Essay
, Research Paper John Marshall: The Great Chief Justice John Marshall was born in Fauquier County, Virginia on September 4, 1755. He was the first son of Thomas Marshall and Mary Randolph Keith. His role in American history is undoubtedly a very important one. As a boy, Marshall was educated by his father. He learned to read and write, along with some lessons in history and poetry.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John Marshall
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall was born on September 24, 1755 in Prince William County, Virginia. When John was ten, his father decided that they were going to move into a valley in the Blue Ridge Mountains, almost thirty miles from the house they lived.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallThe
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall The United States of America, 224 years young, has gone through enumerable changes and stages. Many changes have gone through the constitution and its definitions of a perfect government. The intricate pathways of the branch system and checks and balances have proved to be extremely successful in the course of its existence.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John MarshallIn
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall In early American history, the powers of the executive and legislative branches of the government were already well defined. However, the judicial branch needed to establish its position as an equal of the other two branches. John Marshall was crucial in making this happen.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper My name
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper My name is John Marshall. I am the son of Thomas and Mary Marshall. I was Born on the 24th of September, 1755. I was the oldest of fifteen children in my family. As a child I lived in the near frontier region of Virginia. I was mostly educated by my parents at home. I had more teaching at an academy in Westmore land County.
Thurgood Marshall Essay Research Paper Thurgood MarshallThurgood
Thurgood Marshall Essay, Research Paper Thurgood Marshall Thurgood Marshall was born on July 2, 1908, in Baltimore, Maryland. Thurgood was the grandson of a slave. His father, William Marshall, instilled in him from youth an appreciation for the United States Constitution, and the rule of law. His father became Chief Steward of the prestigious Island Club, while mother Norma Marshall, a graduate of an all black college in Maryland, taught in a segregated Baltimore Elementary School.
Thomas Riley Marshall Essay Research Paper Thomas
Thomas Riley Marshall Essay, Research Paper Thomas Riley Marshall was born in North Ranchester, Indiana on March 14, 1854. He graduated from Wabash College in 1873 where he studied law. Afterwards he was admitted to the Indiana bar in 1875, practicing his profession in Columbia City. His father was a physician.
Gold Rush Essay Research Paper The California
Gold Rush Essay, Research Paper The California Gold Rush had many effects on the American people, westward expansion, the environment, economy and Indian relations ultimately affecting the world as a whole. When John Marshall first found gold in January 1848 at Sutter’s Mill in California many people on the east coast did not believe the news.
A Difficult Decision Essay Research Paper Steve
A Difficult Decision Essay, Research Paper Steve Bayne 1/31/00 English IV Mr. Larson Persuasive Essay A Difficult Decision Throughout each of our lives, we go through many trials. Life seems like a big smack in the face at times. Anyone can relate to this, because no one has had a perfect life, a life without blemish.
Constitutional Law
– Marbury V. Madison Essay, Research Paper Constitutional Law Marbury v. Madison Marbury v. Madison, one of the first Supreme Court cases asserting the
Cohen Vs Virginia Essay Research Paper is
Cohen Vs Virginia Essay, Research Paper is Cohens vs. Virginia, in which the question arose as to the right of the Supreme Court to exercise its appellate jurisdiction over the judgment of a state court involving the validity of state legislation. The contention of the counsel for the state struck at the very root of the judicial system of the Union, with its authority to review state decisions which involved the binding effect of the Federal Constitution and laws: and so to the discussion of this fundamental question Marshall brought his heaviest artillery.
Sir Thomas More Essay Research Paper Man
Sir Thomas More Essay, Research Paper Man For All Seasons Essay In the play, A Man For All Seasons, Sir Thomas More is faced with a number of difficult choices, namely whether to support the King’s decision to divorce Catherine of Aragon and marry Anne Boleyn and the consequences of that decision. More makes his decision to oppose the marriage early on, but even though it is something he does not waver from, he still has trouble with it, especially when he see the pain it causes to his wife and family.
Personal Writing College Essay Research Paper Personal
Personal Writing: College Essay, Research Paper Personal Writing: College In life people have to make choices, in my life I have had to make many, many choices. I think that my biggest decision or choice would be my
Dred Scott Decision Essay Research Paper The
Dred Scott Decision Essay, Research Paper The Dred Scott decision of 1865 had many implications on the status of free blacks in the United States, along with the concept of popular sovereignty, and the future of slavery in America.
Lincoln Application Essay Essay Research Paper Now
Lincoln Application Essay Essay, Research Paper Now is a time to make decision in life that will help me succeed in the future. The decision is to choose the right high school that will help me meet my goals and prepare me for college. A school that can train and give me all the tools I need to be an international business.
AntiEminem Essay Research Paper We the undersigned
Anti-Eminem Essay, Research Paper We, the undersigned, have committed ourselves to living in this crumbling society. We all know that it is losers such as Marshall Mathers (Eminem) that are at fault for the constant downgrading of our society and social values.
Eminem The Real Marshall Essay Research Paper
You would be surprised how many people judge and descrimenate Marshall Mathers *Eminem*. He has been protested against and hated on throughout the most important years of his life- the years that he will remember for the rest of his life. Marshall was born in Detroit Michigan, 1974 and lived there for most of his childhood.
Decision Making Essay Research Paper Any decisionaffecting
Decision Making Essay, Research Paper Any decision-affecting people has ethical ramifications and virtually all-important decisions reflect the decision-maker s mindfulness and resolution to ethical behavior. This is why it is important to know for yourself how you go about making ethical decisions, or making decisions of any kind.
Organ Donation Essay Research Paper Transplantations save
Organ Donation Essay, Research Paper Transplantations save lives, but only if you help. All you need to do is say yes to organ and tissue donation on your donor card and/or driver’s license and discuss your decision with your family.
Eminem Essay Research Paper Marshall Mathers better
Eminem Essay, Research Paper Marshall Mathers, better known as Eminem, has had many achievements in his life, but life wasn’t always good. Growing up in a poor trailer park in Warren Mich. He failed out of ninth grade, which led to him dropping out of high school. He tried to go back but couldn’t do it, he just wanted to rap and to be a star one day.