Looking at Pictures (Berger) Final Draft
Upon receiving the assignment to visit the Museum of Fine Arts and pick a painting that ?seems silent and still yet invites conversation? I was originally frustrated and wanted to just get it over with and pick out the first painting I saw. However, once I entered the museum my stress and frustration decreased and I wanted to take the time to appreciate the artwork and find a piece that thoroughly grabbed my attention. The classic quiet building put me at ease and I began my search. I passed many European paintings until one particular painting struck my eye. It was a painting that ?spoke? to me and induced conversation among the other visitors of the museum as well. The painting possessed a beauty and a magnetism that I was drawn to. It was an oil painting by Francois Joseph Navez titled ?Pilgrimage in the Roman Campagna?. The painting wielded mystification. By Webster?s definition mystification means to perplex or bewilder. However, it is not the painting in itself that causes confusion, it is the perception of the observer to the painting in collaboration with the meaning the painter intends to portray. In this case Berger?s definition of mystification as ?the process of explaining away what might otherwise be evident? seems more appropriate (Berger 112).
?Pilgrimage in the Roman Campagna?, also titled ?Visit to the Miraculous Shrine?, instantaneously forces the spectator to see the painting in two different ways, before even looking at the painting. The person could perceive the painting?s significance as being the actual pilgrimage that was taken, or could deem the importance as being the ?miraculous shrine?. Navez forces this elucidating division in several ways. Firstly, the painting has many focuses. One of which is the imagery of the peasants. A melancholy sensation emanates from these peasants. As a spectator myself, I found difficulty in diverting my attention away from this particularly somber setting. My ardent concentration on the peasants? expressions and the underlying meanings they provoked prevented me from seeing that perhaps the meaning Navez was trying to convey was quite different from anything having to do with the actual presence of the peasants. Perhaps the painting had little to do with the peasants? journey at all. Maybe the true significance of the painting lied in the ?miraculous shrine?, hence the reason for the double named painting. Were the two titles, ?Pilgrimage in the Roman Campagna?, and ?Visit to the Miraculous Shrine?, possibly another ploy to stupefy the onlooker of the painting? The aestheticism alone was enough to divert the attention of the observer away from the artist?s true implication. Navez?s painting mystifies the spectator and coerces him/her to decipher the true meaning of the piece of art. When I looked at the painting, I saw many things. There were five female peasants dressed in exotic peasant like attire. The facial expressions of the peasants seemed to express distress and longing for something. Perhaps the expression exuded from these peasants is Navez?s way of illustrating the tormented and arduous lives they led. The colors were vivid, yet the aura was somber. What seemed to be that main character in the painting was kneeling down, facing the shrine wit her hands clenched together as though she were praying. This shrine could have symbolized the solution or miraculous occurrence that was anticipated by the peasants. Another woman looks into the sky with her finger on her chin, as thought she is gravely foreseeing what is about to happen. There is a male peasant kneeling on the ground as well, who appears to be praying or searching for salvation. One of the female peasants is holding a long cane-like object and stares at the ground. The other female peasant is leaning over a wreath holding her hand to her head in sorrow. She is holding the hand of a little bow behind her, (perhaps her son) whom looks very concerned. Everyone in the painting is barefoot. It seems like everyone is ?visiting this miraculous shrine?, to await a response to their prayers. The peasant?s appearance of a search for salvation was perhaps Navez?s way of exhibiting their spirituality. According to Webster?s dictionary, ?spiritual?, is defined as ?of, like, or pertaining to the nature of spirit, relating to religion; sacred?. This sanctified scene, if you will, sets the tone for Navez?s intriguing work of art.
After observing the painting with my own eyes, I listened to comments from other people passing by. I heard several comments regarding the appreciation of the painting aesthetically. However, nobody commented on the significance of the painting. It would have been interesting to hear comments from bystanders so that I could compare my interpretation with theirs and perhaps hone my knowledge of the painting. Since I was not successful in that aspect, I looked to the plaque beside this beautiful painting to see what Francois Joseph Navez was thinking when he created this masterpiece. To my dismay, the plaque gave a brief biography of Navez but no discussion of its true significance.
After reading John Berger?s essay titled ?Ways of Seeing?, he helped me to better visualize and comprehend the meaning behind the painting. Perhaps it is not the meaning Navez implies but the meaning with regard to the perspective of the creator of the artwork. Berger discusses mysticism in his essay and how every painting along with every photograph entitles everyone to his/her own perspective. Berger states, ?An image is a sight which has been recreated or reproduced. It is an appearance, or a set of appearances, which has been detached from the place and time in which it first made its appearance and preserved for a few moments or a few centuries. Every image embodies a way of seeing? (Berger 116). It is after reading Berger?s interpretation of ways of seeing that I have learned to appreciate the distinct divisions of interpretations and messages that Navez intends to elicit in ?Pilgrimage in the Roman Campagna?, or ?Visit to the Miraculous Shrine?. Perhaps Navez himself had a reason for providing the interpreter of the painting with so many paths to mender. Perhaps he only had one reason as to what the meaning of the painting was. Whatever the case may be he is entitled to his perspective, just as myself and the visitors of the Museum of Fine Arts are entitled to theirs.
Whatever the reason may be for the appreciation of Navez?s artwork, whether it is for aesthetic beauty, for what it means to the observer, or what it means to the artist, is irrelevant. I must agree with Berger?s theory in that there are infinite possibilities of how that painting could have been seen as well as how it could have been done differently. The real significance of the painting lies in the eye of the beholder.
Другие работы по теме:
Graffiti Art Essay Research Paper GraffitiArt is
Graffiti Art Essay, Research Paper Graffiti Art is expression through any medium. It carries meaning and expression of thoughts and ideas. It holds feeling and energy. It carries force and diversity that not only the artist can see. It carries individuality, reason and inspiration. It does not have to be understood by anyone else.
Vicky Essay Research Paper Maniac Soft Animated
Vicky Essay, Research Paper Maniac Soft Animated GIF Viewer AGV 1.0 ======================================= Hi there, thank you for using AGV 1.0. My name’s Christian “Maniac” Stauffer from Maniac Soft.
The Pigman Essay Research Paper The PigmanThe
The Pigman Essay, Research Paper The Pigman The topic I chose to write about is lonely. Many characters in The Pigman are lonely. Some of the characters in the story that are lonely are
Persuasive Essay Gotham
’s City Cemetery Essay, Research Paper Constructing a cemetery is very useful for many reasons. People in Gotham City should construct a cemetery instead of a monument because people will use it, people will visit it and people will remember it. People in Gotham City need a cemetery than a monument. A cemetery will bring people happier.
Commercials Essay Research Paper In every young
Commercials Essay, Research Paper In every young person life there are certain critical decisions that must be made. One of the more important of the many is the choice to resume education after high school. After that decision is made the choice of which college to go to comes into play. In making this decision you must first do research on schools that interest you, you must visit these campuses, and last you must apply to the schools of your choice.
Lamborghini
’s History Essay, Research Paper Ferruccio Lamborghini was born in 1916 under the Zodiac sign of Taurus, his parents were farmers but Ferruccio soon decided he wanted to do something with mechanics. He started working on his fathers tractor out of interest and was able to attend a technical school in Bologna.
Marketing Essay Research Paper FOREWORDThe first time
Marketing Essay, Research Paper FOREWORD The first time I visited an IKEA-store was in Elisabeth, New Yersey, The U.S. The year was 1995 and I still rember the joy and excitement when I entered the building. It was huge and it
My Trip Essay Research Paper The role
My Trip Essay, Research Paper The role of the visit to Pemberley by Elizabeth and the Gardiners would most closely resemble a modern visit to a museum or a tourist attraction.
Dali Museum Visit Essay Research Paper Dali
Dali Museum Visit Essay, Research Paper Dali is an outstanding figure in art history, therefore I am greatly affected by numerous critiques of his works. It was hard to throw away read material and to look at his work with a ‘fresh eye’.
Vincent
’s Musuem Essay, Research Paper ARTIFACTS GENUINE!!!BY,JEFF MCCLURE VINCENT?S MUSEUM?S ARTIFACTS PROVED REAL see below Recently at Vincent?s museum alot of talk was about the artifact?s
One Place Essay Research Paper IF I
One Place Essay, Research Paper IF I COULD VISIT ONE PLACE IN THE WORLD I WOULD GO TO THE GREAT PYRAMIDS OF EGYPT. THE PYRAMIDS AMAZE ME THE WAY THEY WERE BUILT. THE WAY THE EGYPTIANS DESIGNED AND CONSTRUCTED
Untitled Essay Research Paper November 6 1996
Untitled Essay, Research Paper November 6, 1996 Dear Joe, It was nice to hear from you again, I enjoyed hearing about your new business venture and I hope it works out. School is going great and I can’t wait to graduate in two months. The other day I finished reading a book by Michael Crichton called “JURASSIC PARK” you may have heard of the movie.
A School Visit Essay Research Paper A
A School Visit Essay, Research Paper A School Visit Are you interested in motorcycles? How about a woman who is not only a policewoman, but knows how to ride and use a motorcycle that goes up to 100 miles per
Lagos Nigeria Essay Research Paper Lagos is
Lagos, Nigeria Essay, Research Paper Lagos is the largest city in Nigeria. In 1989 the population was 1,274,000. It is still growing immensely as we speak. It is the former capital of
The British Art Museum Essay Research Paper
What I noticed straight away from the Mexican display at the museum was the size of its room. It was pretty small compared to the rest of the museum so produced an enclosed atmosphere that put
Vincent Van Gogh Essay Research Paper Perhaps
Vincent Van Gogh Essay, Research Paper Perhaps the only way to disentangle, for yourself, the real Vincent Van Gogh from the creation of so many others, is to study the great mass of work he has left behind. Locally, his art is on display at museums including the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, and New York’s, Metropolitan Museum, and Museum of Modern Art.
A Visit To The Norton Museum Essay
, Research Paper A Visit to the Norton Museum I saw a lot of amazing arts when I went to Norton Museum. The one that I was interested in was Nude on a Sofa. It had a different felling form the other arts. The art had a comfortable feeling when I look at it.
The Freud Museum Essay Research Paper The
The Freud Museum Essay, Research Paper The Freud museum is a small ?house museum? which was formerly the home of Sigmund Freud and his family when they escaped the Nazi annexation of Austria. Thus Nazi persecution of Freud led to the extraordinary environment in which he had developed his epoch-making theories being transported, in its entirety, from Vienna to London.
Sleepless In Seattle Essay Research Paper It
Sleepless In Seattle Essay, Research Paper It is difficult to say at times, what exactly makes a movie great. I have found that the good movies are felt as you are leaving the theater. The audience should be able to feel and belive, to some degree. When exiting a movie, I hope that I feel this way. Today, paying large sums of money for each visit to the theater is tough to keep up.
Visual Art Essay Research Paper VISUAL ARTS
Visual Art Essay, Research Paper VISUAL ARTS “The physical impossibility of death in the mind of someone living” By Damien Hirst (photo courtesy of the saatchi collection)
George Bush Library Essay Research Paper George
George Bush Library Essay, Research Paper George Bush Library George Bush was sworn into office January 20th, 2001. The George Bush Library has a museum connected with it. Looking at pictures of the library it seemed to be rather large and impressive.
Monet Essay Research Paper Several years ago
Monet Essay, Research Paper Several years ago when I was ten I had an opportunity to travel to France. I went to a few museums which I liked including Yhe Louvre and The Pompidou Center. The museum I found
Holden Caulfield Essay Research Paper Holden Caulfield
Holden Caulfield Essay, Research Paper Holden Caulfield, the narrator and the main character of The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, is a young adult, who, at first seems to simply describes his four day adventure in New York City after bring expelled from his forth school. However, at the same time he narrates more; through his many experiences, which he describes in the book, we can see the themes of the work.
Japanese Museum Essay Research Paper The museum
Japanese Museum Essay, Research Paper The museum I visited was the Japanese-American National Museum in Little Tokyo. I kind of excited when I visited the Japanese-American National Museum because it was my first time to go to museum. I felt that Japanese-American Museum was really exquisite in its presentation.
Angel City Essay Research Paper Angel
Angel City Essay, Research Paper ? Angel City? The most unique, magnificent, and extraordinary city that I would love to visit is the ?City of Angles?. Tucked away in the midst of our atmosphere, lies the beauty of having everlasting life, and dreams that come true. Baby- blue skies, and cotton candy clouds fills this entire city.
Asher Lev Essay Research Paper There are
Asher Lev Essay, Research Paper There are many choices that Asher Lev is faced with as he journeys from childhood to manhood. These choices define who Asher is, and what he believes in, as well as shattering the boyhood innocence he once possessed.
Past Essay Research Paper Michelle Brandon My
Past Essay, Research Paper Michelle Brandon My Past: I was born in Calgary, Alberta in 1983 then in 1985 I moved to Germany. I stayed in Germany for 3 years then I moved to calgary for 2 years. Cakgary is a nice place to live it s a big city compared to Germany. Germany is a beautiful place to go, I would like to go back to Germany for a visit.
Pink Palace Museum Essay Research Paper English
Pink Palace Museum Essay, Research Paper English Composition 101 29 November 1999 The Pink Palace Museum When I first moved to Memphis, I decided that I wanted to learn more about my new hometown. I thought that the museums would be the perfect place to help me learn more about Memphis. There is one museum in particular that I will never forget.
Community Service Essay Research Paper Andrea OldhamCommunity
Community Service Essay, Research Paper Andrea Oldham Community Service Up to this date I haven’t participated in much community service, but once I get settled in a new home with my degree in environmental sciences, I plan to volunteer for a non-profit environmental organization, and this will be my job or career.
Florida Aquarium Essay Research Paper Florida AquariumOn
Florida Aquarium Essay, Research Paper Florida Aquarium On February 2, 2001, I had the unique opportunity the to visit the Florida Aquarium in Tampa. I was so impressed with the extensive collection and information that I plan to visit the aquarium again very soon.
Come To Rome Essay Research Paper Come
Come To Rome Essay, Research Paper Come to Rome, Italy I am a local travel agent and guide in the great city of Rome, Italy. I am here today to tell you why someone like yourself should choose Rome for their next vacation. Besides its importance to Christianity, because of the Vatican and religious places, Rome is an open museum where works of art, remains, and monuments of past millenniums can be seen by all in the streets and plazas.
The Hermitage
I can’t say that I often go to museums. We are always in a hurry and it is very difficult to spare 2 or 3 hours to visit a local museum. But when I travel I always try to see all the museums and exhibitions that can be found in the place I am. Some month ago I was in S. Petersburg. I visited many places of interest including the Hermitage Gallery and now I want to tell you about it.