Cherokee Removal Essay, Research Paper
Cherokee Removal
These articles, A Permanent Habitat for the American Indians and Memorial of the Cherokee Nation, enlighten the reader to both sides of a very controversial issue in the early 1830 s. The views of Andrew Jackson on removing the Cherokee Indians are very biased and very inconsiderate. As a unified nation, the Cherokees very clearly state their position and authenticate their claim to their native lands. Both articles, when combined, provide a very broad base of information, be it opinion or fact, and allow one to obtain significant knowledge about the issue.
When one article is weighed up to the next one, a very obvious contrast in style becomes clear. While Andrew Jackson tries to make his desires of moving the Indians seem very necessary and fair, the Cherokee bluntly state that they are opposed to the idea completely. Jackson goes through all of his provisions for the Indians, should they cooperate, as if to coax the addressed person to defend his position. On the other side of the issue, the natives show up everything for what it really is. Jackson s statements could make anyone think twice about his actions while the Cherokees side makes it easy to sympathize for them.
While laying out the reasons the Indians should be removed, Jackson presents three basic points as to why his actions are justified. First, he explains that every attempt to try and coexist with the Indians has failed. He says that everything that was attempted only went to prove that Americans could not possibly live with the natives on their soil. Next, he explains that the Indians would live best in a country where they were united and protected. By placing them all together in a common area and establishing their land as independent, the native people could more easily lead normal lives. Jackson s final point is that with the quality of the land that is to be provided and the ample amount of provisions, the Indians will be in a much better situation that their present state. The government would rather take care of what they need than continue to fight them off of their homeland.
Fighting to remain on their native land, the Cherokee insist upon being allowed to stay put. Rules of Congress and treaties with the US give these people the right to remain where they are. All they want is for these treaties to be upheld. Also, the land to which they are to be moved is foreign to all of the Cherokee. Through everything they know, the land is no better use to them than what they have in Georgia. Lastly, the sentimental value of the land must be protected. These people have inhabited the area since the age of their ancestors, and now the white men think they can just take that all away?
After taking both articles into strong consideration, I believe that the American government was wrong in even considering removing the Cherokees and other tribes from their home land. First off, the land isn t American property to begin with. The natives had lived on the land long before America was even dreamed of. The government does not posses the power to order an independent and sovereign society of people off of their native land. A large majority the Jackson statement is simply all the wonderful benefits the government will provide for the Indians just so the people will think that he is right. The Cherokee memorial has a more realistic argument without all of the garbage. Last, Jackson has the audacity to add insult to injury and degrade the Indians. A civilization with strong, ingrained roots and an established culture, and Jackson not only steals their land, but kicks them while they are down?
Другие работы по теме:
Sam Houston Essay Research Paper Samuel Houston
Sam Houston Essay, Research Paper Samuel Houston Samuel Houston is considered by most Texans to have been the greatest man to ever live. While this is their opinion, it is a fact that he was one of the most important men in Texas path to becoming a state.
Trail Of Tears And The Five Civilized
Tribes Essay, Research Paper Trial of Tears and the Five Civilized Tribes During the early years of 1800s, valuable gold deposits were discovered in tribal lands, which by previous cessions had been reduced to about seven million acres in northwest Georgia, eastern Tennessee, and southwest North Carolina.
Persuasion Essay Research Paper Why Jerry Rockwoods
Persuasion Essay, Research Paper Why Jerry Rockwood?s Essay ?Life Intrudes? is Effective Jerry Rockwood?s reflective essay ?Life Intrudes? is effective because of the way in which he has constructed the piece. He uses the four Reflective Strategies that are derived from Reading Critically, Writing Well by Axelrod and Cooper.
Crucible Essay Research Paper When we think
Crucible Essay, Research Paper When we think of the United States we think of equality and justice for all people no matter how far back you go back in our history. Sadly, this hasn’t always been the case, in this land of hope
The Constitution
’s Effect On Native Americans Essay, Research Paper The Constitution’s effect on Native Americans The Constitution had a great effect on Native Americans in general. They were effected in three major ways. They are; the change in where they lived and what land was considered theirs, what Religious rights they had and/or have, and lastly, how they have gone from living freely to living on reservations.
Pigs In Heaven Essay Research Paper As
Pigs In Heaven Essay, Research Paper As a sequel to The Bean Trees Barbara Kingsolver?s Pigs in Heaven continues the story of Taylor and Turtle. The main events of the story start at the Hoover Dam where an illegally adopted six-year-old Cherokee kid, Turtle, saved the life of a man who fell off from the dam. This incident brings Turtle and her mother Taylor not only great recognition, but also to the attention of Annawake Fourkiller, a young Cherokee lawyer in Heaven, Oklahoma.
Native American
& Slavery 1800 Essay, Research Paper The constitution of the United States reads; ?We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain inalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.?
Removal Of Indians Essay Research Paper The
Removal Of Indians Essay, Research Paper The decision of the Jackson administration to remove the Cherokee Indians to land west of the Mississippi River in the 1830 s was more a reformulation of the national policy that
Slavery And Evolution Of The Cherokee Essay
, Research Paper ENC3240 A Review of Slavery and Evolution of the Cherokee Society 1540-1866 by Theda Perdue In this well-written book by Theda Perdue, he discloses much of the history of slavery among the Cherokee people and their evolution during this 326 year period. He begins with their abduction by the Spanish.
Cherokee Women 2 Essay Research Paper Cherokee
Cherokee Women 2 Essay, Research Paper Cherokee Women Although its title says otherwise, this is novel is not a novel that focuses solely on female life. Instead, Cherokee Women rewrites the history of the Cherokee people by placing women in the forefront and by showing how gender affected the Cherokee culture and their relations with Americans.
Cherokee Essay Research Paper The CherokeesThe Removal
Cherokee Essay, Research Paper The Cherokees The Removal of the Cherokee from their land in the 1830’s remains a national disgrace today. How could our great conscientious country have done such a thing? The Cherokee were brutally
Trail Of Tears Essay Research Paper There
Trail Of Tears Essay, Research Paper There have been many movies and television shows about the relationships and conflicts between whites and natives and the idea that the natives caused all the problems and the whites were innocent victims in history. Is this how it really or was it the other way around? Unfortunately it was the white man that settled in America, where the natives where already living, and stole their land as they kept moving westward in the centuries following settlement in this country.
Cultural Tradition Essay Research Paper In Western
Cultural Tradition Essay, Research Paper In Western Cultures, the church teachings influenced the way people died and offered them hope for their afterlife. People believed that we will all die. Towards the end of the twentieth century however, death became a ver private event. People denied death.
Cherokee Indians Essay Research Paper The Cherokee
Cherokee Indians Essay, Research Paper The Cherokee Tribe The Cherokees are a North American tribe. This Indian tribe has a lot to do with our history. It is the biggest Indian tribe that we have today.
Contrasting The Cherokees And The Aztecs Essay
, Research Paper The Cherokees and the Aztecs were very different people in many ways not only in location but also in ways of living. The Cherokees were southwestern woodland farmers. The
Summer Of The Monkey
’s Essay, Research Paper Summer of the Monkeys By:Wilson Rawls The book Summer of the Monkeys is about a family of four that had just moved to the Ozark Mountains, smack dab in the middle of the Cherokee Nation.The ladt thing a fourteen year old boy expects to find along an old Ozark river bottom is a tree full of monkeys.
Cherokee Indains Essay Research Paper The Indians
Cherokee Indains Essay, Research Paper The Indians had many little confrontations with the white settlers and the white government. The Indians didn?t always get along with the white people. Even though the Cherokee Indians were a very peaceful tribe they had wars with the whites. All the wars that the Indians went through they lost land or something valuable to them like faith, homes, life styles and sometimes their life.
The Appalachian Trail Essay Research Paper When
The Appalachian Trail Essay, Research Paper When I was in the seventh grade, our class went on a field trip to Cherokee, North Carolina. The trip lasted four days and three nights, but the adventure would last a lifetime. The experience allowed me to learn many things about myself and to reflect on the beauty that was all around me.
The Constitutionality Involved In The Removal Of
T Essay, Research Paper U.S. Constitution The Constitutionality involved in the Removal of the Cherokee Indians The debate over the legality of sovereignty and acquired lands from the native Americans (specifically the Cherokee) has long been debated. The issues involved have included treaties, land sold or ceded, and the right of the Government to physically enforce their rules on Indian land (i.e. sovereignty).
John Marshall Essay Research Paper John Marshall
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper John Marshall was born on September 24, 1755 in Prince William County, Virginia. When John was ten, his father decided that they were going to move into a valley in the Blue Ridge Mountains, almost thirty miles from the house they lived.
Jeffersonian
& Jacksonian Democracy Essay, Research Paper Jeffersonian and Jacksonian Democracy are the same in just about every regard. Their views and goals as presidents are the same. Both are in favor of the common man and feel that it is the common people who should have the biggest influence on government, not the wealthy aristocrats.
The Creek Essay Research Paper The name
The Creek Essay, Research Paper The name “Creek” came from the shortening of Ocheese Creek Indians a name given by the English to the native people living along the Ocheese
Trail Of Tears Essay Research Paper Trail
Trail Of Tears Essay, Research Paper Trail of Tears At the conclusion of the colonials’ War of Independence with Britain, during which the Cherokee had fought alongside the British, a treaty was signed in 1786, establishing the boundaries of Cherokee territory. As always, encroachments by European-American settlers continued in violation of this written agreement.
The Trail Of Tears Essay Research Paper
The Trail of Tears, was it unjust and inhumane? What happened to the Cherokee during that long and treacherous journey? They were brave and listened to the government,
The Trail From American Indians To American
Citizens Essay, Research Paper The Bill of Rights contains all of the basic rights endowed to all American citizens. For the purpose of our argument we will consider the Indians of the 19th century as American citizens. After reviewing the Bill of Rights it became extremely apparent that as American citizens many Indians civil rights were not only withheld, but also flat out denied and violated.
Native American Persecution Essay Research Paper The
Native American Persecution Essay, Research Paper The pressures of white expansionism led the United States Government to find ways to remove the Native Americans from their fertile lands. Spurred by this pressure, and the
Will Rogers Essay Research Paper Will Rogers18791935Will
Will Rogers Essay, Research Paper Will Rogers(1879-1935) Will Rogers is one of America?s great folk heroes. He was born on November 4, 1879, in Oologah, Indian Territory (now Claremore Oklahoma). His full name is William Penn Adair Rogers. He was # 2340 on the official Cherokee roll. He was named for one of the most revered Cherokees Col.
Andrew Jackson And The Trail Of Tears
Essay, Research Paper Andrew Jackson and the Trail of Tears The Long, Bitter Trail: Andrew Jackson and the Indians was written by Anthony F.C. Wallace. In his book, the main argument was how Andrew Jackson had a direct affect on the mistreatment and removal of the native Americans from their homelands to Indian Territory.
Indian Removal Zinn Chapter 7 Essay Research
Paper Once the white men decided that they wanted lands belonging to the Native Americans (Indians), the United States Government did everything in its power to help the white men acquire Indian land. The US Government did everything from turning a blind eye to passing legislature requiring the Indians to give up their land (see Indian Removal Bill of 1828).
The Education Of Little Tree Essay Research
Paper The Education of Little Tree In the movie, The Education of Little Tree, the young boy learns many of life s most important lessons. Three of the lessons that I feel are most important are; The Way , how to learn from ones mistakes, and finding your secret place. In the personal evaluation that follows, I will discuss why I feel that these are such important lessons.
Reader Report Essay Research Paper READER REPORT
Reader Report Essay, Research Paper READER REPORT “The Trail of Tears” is an essay recounting the great migration of the Cherokee people from their Georgian homeland west across the Mississippi. Jackson was primarily responsible for the Trail of Tears. Though the Indians had been forced to cede their homelands to the United States government for some time, Jackson needed the 35,000 square miles of Cherokee land in order to sweep the frontier and win the election.