Kentucky Virginia Resolution Essay, Research Paper
The Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions
The Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions were authored in secret by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison in response to the repressive Alien and Sedition Acts passed in 1798. In the opinion of Jefferson and Madison, the Acts were unjust. They also represented a major victory for the Federalists. By writing the Resolutions, Jefferson and Madison spearheaded the protests of those against the Alien and Sedition Acts and those in support of stronger states rights. Although the Resolutions were successful in the two originating states, they did not have much success in the other states. Still, the new ideas presented in the Resolutions were almost revolutionary. Although the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions of 1798 and 1799 were not very successful, they were important because they provided necessary arguments for the supporters of greater states rights against the proponents of a stronger central government.
The Alien and Sedition Acts played major roles in the coming about of the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions. Passed in early 1798, the Acts laid down a number of harsh restrictions on foreigners. The Alien Act stretched the minimum years for eligibility for naturalization from five years to fourteen years. It also gave the President the power to expel any alien from the country. The Sedition Act was even harsher; it gave the government the right to arrest anyone accused of seditious activities. The Sedition Act thus cracked down on many Jeffersonian newspapers which criticized the government. Of course, Jefferson criticized these Acts; he even called them worthy of the 8th and 9th century (2 / p.174). With these laws the Federalists were thought to be stifling the power of the Jeffersonians.
Through the Alien and Sedition Acts, those in support of a stronger federal government achieved a major victory. The Acts gave new powers which were not dictated in the Constitution to both the executive and legislative branches. The Federalists were able to pass these acts with their logic based upon loose translations of the Constitution, especially the elastic clause. In peacetime, these Acts would not have had a chance in being passed, but the undeclared war with France had riled up Congress enough to accept these loose translations.
The opponents of the Alien and Sedition Acts were led by Jefferson and Madison; in response to the Acts the Republicans launched an attack on what they believed were breaches of the Constitution. The attack on the Alien and Sedition Acts was based upon the strict construction theory of the Republicans. To them, the government could not be given powers by implication; the jurisdiction of the federal government was plainly stated in the Constitution, and it had to be followed (4 / p. 162). Using this theory, Jefferson and Madison declared the Alien Act to be unconstitutional on two counts. The first count was the expansion of the powers of the executive branch, and the second was the extension of the authority of the federal government over aliens (4 / p. 163). Jefferson and Madison believed that these breaches of the Constitution attacked the powers of the individual states. The enlarging of the executive branch and the legislative branch shrank the states powers by stripping from each state the ability to offer protection to its people. The Republicans thus decried the Alien Act based on these two counts. The next target was the Sedition Act. Jefferson was especially angry at the Sedition Act; it denied the one principle which Jefferson held most sacred: knowledge and freedom of inquiry (2 / p.180). Without these two freedoms, the federal government could easily become tyrannical. The Sedition Act repressed freedom of speech and press; these two freedoms were obviously essential to the survival of inquiry and criticism. Jefferson with Madison thus set out soon after the passing of the Alien and Sedition Acts to pen the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions.
As said before, Jefferson and Madison wrote the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions as rebuffs to the Alien and Sedition Acts. The Resolutions stated several new theories in the relationship between the federal government and the states. The first and most important was the compact theory. In Jefferson and Madison s interpretation, the Constitution was nothing more than a compact between sovereign states which gave explicitly defined powers to the central government and retained all other powers (1 / p. 3). Here, Jefferson and Madison took the strict construction theory of the Republicans and defined it even further. Thus the Resolutions stated that the states had all residual powers and not the federal government. The second theory in the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions was that the states were the true judges of a law s constitutionality and not the legislative or judicial branches of the federal government (4 / p. 170). If the legislative branch was the final judge of whether a law was constitutional or not, then the checks and balances of the branch would not be in place. Thus, since the compact theory declared that the states had created the government, they would also be in charge of judging a federal law s constitutionality. The third and final theory was put forth only in Jefferson s Kentucky Resolution; it was the theory of nullification. This theory stated that the states were not only the legitimate judges and interpreters of the Constitution but also the executors of their judgements with regard to the constitutionality of federal laws (4 / p. 170). In other words, any federal law could be the target of nullification by a state. Together, these three theories which made up the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions provided for very strong arguments against the Alien and Sedition Acts. The Resolutions were to be the ammunition that was needed in the siege on the Adams administration.
The Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions were quickly adopted in the two originating states. The quick legislation was a victory to the Republicans, for now they had two states on their side clamoring for the abolition of the Alien and Sedition Acts. The Kentucky Resolution was adopted by the Kentucky House of Representatives on November 10, 1798 and passed by the State Senate on the 13th of the same month; the Virginia Resolution was passed in the State Senate on December 24, 1798 (1 / p. 5). The quickness in which the Resolutions were passed of course facilitated the spreading the word about them.
Although the Resolutions did enjoy successes in Kentucky and Virginia, they did not fare so well in the other states. Ten of the fourteen states voiced opposition to the Resolutions (5 / p. 115). This somewhat unexpected opposition was bad news for Jefferson and Madison; their efforts in attacking the repressive actions of the Adams administration had received a strong counterattack. Some of the states even went as far as praising the Alien and Sedition Acts as just and necessary (4 / p. 173-174). Such staunch defenses of the constitutionality of acts of Congress came mainly from the New England states. The series of rejections definitely hampered the Republicans campaign for the repeal of the Alien and Sedition Acts.
Even though the Resolutions were not accepted and even denounced by the other states, the fact that two states accepted them was enough ammunition in the fight against the Federalists. With the Resolutions accusations that the Alien and Sedition Acts denied civil liberties, President Adams s political future was darkened. With these accusations, public opinion on the Alien and Sedition Acts as well as the Adams administration changed (3 / p. 77). The Resolutions proved their usefulness later on as they indirectly helped Jefferson win the Presidency in the campaign of 1800. Thus the Resolutions and the ensuing shift in public opinion proved later on to be the death of Adams s political career.
In conclusion, the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions were important documents in their time. These works of Jefferson and Madison communicated the opposition against Alien and Sedition Act to the Federalists and the public. Although they did not garner much support with the other states, the Resolutions theories were the first to pit state rights and powers against those of the federal government. The Resolutions also had the effect of counterbalancing the restrictive policies of the Adams administration. The Resolutions began the transition from the Federalist government to the Republic government. In other words, the Resolutions were a sort of foreshadowing of the policies of the Jefferson administration which were in many aspects the opposite to those of the Adams administration. In the end, the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions ended up having started the long battle of state rights against the central government s rights.
Другие работы по теме:
Creative Writing Essay Research Paper There was
Creative Writing Essay, Research Paper There was 3 men who had heard about going on a mountain and getting healed from their problems. So they all went to the mountain. The first guy from Virginia who was deaf and God asked him ‘Can I help you son?’ The guy started signing in sign language that he would be so happy if he could only hear, so God touched him and he got his hearing .
The History Of White-Tailed Deer In Kentucky
Essay, Research Paper The History of White-Tailed Deer in Kentucky When our ancestors first reached Kentucky they found a great abundance of game, including deer. Early settlers utilized deer for food and clothing.
Garrett Morgan Essay Research Paper He lived
Garrett Morgan Essay, Research Paper He lived from (1875-1963). I chose this person because I liked his name and he sounded very interesting. He was born in Paris, Kentucky on March 4, 1875. He was the seventh of eleven children in his family. He has a degree in Traffic Engineering. In 1913, Morgan developed a process that could straighten hair.
Abe Essay Research Paper History Abraham
Abe Essay, Research Paper History Abraham Lincoln I was born Feb. 12, 1809, in Hardin County, Kentucky. My parents were both born in Virginia, of undistinguished families–second families, perhaps I should say. My mother, who died in my tenth year, was of a family of the name of Hanks…. My father … removed from Kentucky to … Indiana, in my eighth year….
Shakespeare Sister Essay Research Paper Shakespeare s
Shakespeare Sister Essay, Research Paper Shakespeare s Sister This is a short story written by Virginia Woolf in 1929. She was born in London, where she grew up in an environment of wealth and culture, meeting many of the most distinguished intellectuals of all time. Virginia was home-schooled for all of her education growing up, and later became the center of the intellectual and artistic Bloomsbury Group.
Driving Age Essay Research Paper Driving Age
Driving Age Essay, Research Paper Driving Age How long did you have to wait to get your license, was it three weeks, six weeks maybe? Well, we have to wait 6 months after we get our permit. Now, you didn’t have to wait that long, did you. For the new bill that has passed in Kentucky says that students must wait six months to get their license after you turn sixteen.
Group Work Outline Essay Research Paper Group
Group Work Outline Essay, Research Paper Group Conflict Resolution Annotated Outline I. Introduction In this section, we will state our topic, which is group conflict resolution. We will present the subtopics we will focus on in the paper. We will briefly tie the four subtopics into each other under the umbrella topic of group conflict resolution.
Resolutions Essay Essay Research Paper English 3
Resolutions Essay Essay, Research Paper English 3 Alan King Resolutions essay 1/6/00 We have just recently entered a new millennium. The start of a new millenium means to me a new start. I hope to turn my life around and try not to be so defiant, and just get along with everyone. So here are my resoultions for this year, the year 2005, and the end of the decade.
10 Commandments In Schools Essay Research Paper
P.S. 233-03 Ed Mashek Dr. Hicks 02/08/01 Assignment #1 The 1st Amendment in Schools Right now in Kentucky, there is a somewhat heated debate going on about whether or not the 10 Commandments should be posted in public schools. The people, schools, and our state and federal governments all seem to have their own opinion, but which one is the right one? That is, which one follows the guidelines set in the Bill of Rights? Legally speaking, schools in Kentucky were required to display the Ten Commandments, until the Supreme Court declared that law unconstitutional.
Daniel Boone Essay Research Paper More than
Daniel Boone Essay, Research Paper More than any other man, Daniel Boone was responsible for the exploration and settlement of Kentucky. His grandfather came from England to America in 1717. His father was a weaver and blacksmith, and he raised livestock in the country near Reading, Pennsylvania. Daniel was born there on November 2, 1734.
George Rogers Clark Essay Research Paper George
George Rogers Clark Essay, Research Paper George Rogers ClarkGeorge Rogers Clark was a famous war hero who commanded important victories over the British troops in the Northwest territories during the American Revolution. In the year of 1752, a boy named George Rogers Clark was born in Charlottesville, Virginia.
Virginia Woolf And Her Friendships With Women
Essay, Research Paper Virginia Woolf – Friendships With Women Virginia Woolf was sexually abused as a child. While the extent and duration of this abuse is difficult to establish, it is known that two of her older stepbrothers sexually harassed and abused her between the ages of twelve and twenty-one and perhaps as early as six.
Virginia Woolf Essay Research Paper My Thought
Virginia Woolf Essay, Research Paper My Thought on Virginia Woolf There are many authors who have the ability to be one of the greatest writers of all time, but to my knowledge of books I believe the majority I read are excellent. Virginia Woolf to many, is a prominent writer. I wish I could say the same as well.
Virginia Essay Research Paper In the world
Virginia Essay, Research Paper In the world today there are many things that are alike and that are different. These things have comparisons and contrasts. There are also comparisons and contrasts in old literature. There are many things alike and many things that are different about General History of Virginia and of Plymouth Plantation.
What Does The American Flag Mean To
Me? Essay, Research Paper What Does the American Flag Mean to Me? Freedom. Justice. History. The flag of the United States has a different meaning to it for every person. Whether it?s just standing up in class everyday
Abraham Lincoln 6 Essay Research Paper Abraham
Abraham Lincoln 6 Essay, Research Paper Abraham Lincoln Abraham Lincoln’s ancestors came from Hingham, England and settled in Hingham, Massachusetts in 1637. His father, Thomas Lincoln, was born in Rockingham County, Virginia in 1778. His grandfather was also named Abraham and he was killed by a Native American while clearing land for a farm in 1786.
My College Plans Essay Research Paper My
My College Plans Essay, Research Paper My College Plans Business Computer Applications 7th Period Sunday, March 30, 1997 Created By: At first I never had wanted to go to college because I didn’t like
Daniel Boone Essay Research Paper Daniel Boone
Daniel Boone Essay, Research Paper Daniel Boone was responsible for the exploration and settlement of Kentucky. Daniel?s father was a weaver and blacksmith, and raised livestock in the country near
Constitutional Convention Essay Research Paper The Constitutional
Constitutional Convention Essay, Research Paper The Constitutional Convention Our country was based upon the idea that every citizen has certain rights that can not be taken away from him/her; these inalienable rights form the backbone for our democracy. Our constitution, which secures our rights and how we are governed, was not an easy task to write.
Cohen Vs Virginia Essay Research Paper is
Cohen Vs Virginia Essay, Research Paper is Cohens vs. Virginia, in which the question arose as to the right of the Supreme Court to exercise its appellate jurisdiction over the judgment of a state court involving the validity of state legislation. The contention of the counsel for the state struck at the very root of the judicial system of the Union, with its authority to review state decisions which involved the binding effect of the Federal Constitution and laws: and so to the discussion of this fundamental question Marshall brought his heaviest artillery.
Mxpx
–Andrea Essay, Research Paper Andrea Meeting you was just so unexpected I guess I was scared of being rejected Since you were so nice I wouldn’t think twice
Short Essay On Life In Virginia
Colony Essay, Research Paper Life in Virginia Colony Being a stranger to the New World, one would expect a rich land with much to offer, abundant in natural resources, and profitable. However, this was not the case in the Virginia colony. The dream was deceiving: life in New England was challenging and was held together by inadequate leadership and a poor economy.
Thomas Jefferson 4 Essay Research Paper Jefferson
Thomas Jefferson 4 Essay, Research Paper Jefferson, Thomas 1743-1826, 3d president of the U.S. (1801-9); b. Goochland (now in Albemarle) co., Va. A member (1769-75) of the Virginia house of burgesses, he was a leader of the patriot faction. At the Second CONTINENTAL CONGRESS he drafted the DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE, a historic document that reflects his debt to John LOCKE and other philosophers.
Squeegee Kids Essay Research Paper Squeegee Kids
Squeegee Kids Essay, Research Paper Squeegee Kids “Squeegee kids” should better themselves for humanity and the safety of the city. They should not be wandering the streets, loitering, and disturbing people. They have no right to approach anonymous vehicles and apply what they call “cleaning” on the windshield without the owner’s permission.These people should stop and think whether or not they are benefiting from their actions.
Jefferson Essay Research Paper Thomas Jefferson was
Jefferson Essay, Research Paper Thomas Jefferson was the third president of the United States of America. Jefferson was born April 13, 1743. Jefferson grew up on a tobacco plantation in Shadweell, Virginia. As a child Jefferson worked on his parents plantation.
Embezzlement Essay Research Paper Mac Taylor
Embezzlement Essay, Research Paper Mac Taylor’s Embezzlement Due Process Rights Mac Taylor is employed by American National Bank located in Bowling Green, Kentucky. He has been arrested