“Feminism and the Standpoint of Lesbianism”
In chapter ten of her text Whose Science Whose Knowledge, Sandra Harding introduces the standpoint of a distinct lesbian epistemology. Her objective is to acknowledge a perspective that will recognize the viewpoint of all women and not just heterosexual women that are seen by the androcentric stipulations as essential or typical. Harding’s valuable argument begins with the conceptualization of “what is a lesbian”(Harding, 250): if that is definable in any such terms at all. Harding then adds to her idea of a lesbian epistemology by examining lesbian contributions to feminist thought and scientific advantages.
Interestingly, Harding’s analysis begins with the idea that there is not a clear definable trait that can be agreed on in defining the term lesbian. Lesbianism, according to the dominant ideology, insinuates that a woman must have sex with another woman to be categorized as such. Nonetheless what evidence is there to establish that a sexual relation exists? A male centered viewpoint would insist that this is the case, nevertheless, Harding allows the categorization of lesbian to be defined by those women who chose to use the term themselves ” privileging an autonomy for lesbians to name themselves and their worlds as they wish . . .” (Harding, 252). However, Harding points out that Adrienne Rich thinks instead that ” . . . one should think of a ‘lesbian continuum’ . . . all women who have engaged in resistance against compulsory heterosexuality, whether or not they have actually had sexual relations with another woman.” (Harding, 250).
In constructing her discussion that there should be a lesbian standpoint Harding includes the significant contributions that such a standpoint would have towards feminist thought. In brief, according to Harding, the basic framework of a lesbian contribution to a feminist standpoint includes seeing women in relation to other women. Harding argues that a lesbian perspective accomplishes this in a variety of ways. Bonnie Zimmerman suggests that through female bonding and breaking the myth of the negative/positive stereotypes of ” . . . witch or saint . . .” (Harding, 254) lesbians have enabled women to view themselves as independent persons and individuals rather than ” . . . as appendages or as a class . . .” (Harding, 254). As well, Harding notes that women have seen each other in terms of each other as rivals, and in definitions established by male perspectives (Harding, 254). This perspective can, also, “. . . provide a clear sense of the potential for a kind of female independence that is invisible from the perspective of heterosexual women’s lives.” (Harding, 257).
Next Harding examines lesbian contributions to the notion that women as heterosexual and female sexuality are social constructs and not biological facts. Harding affirms these elements in a lesbian standpoint by pointing out that heterosexuality does differ from culture to culture and throughout history. In addition Gail Rubin, used the ideals of Freud and Levis-Struass to show the social construct of heterosexuality. Harding stressed this point by suggesting that further reading of Rubin’s work in comparison to a lesbian perspective showed ” . . . compulsory heterosexuality restrict women in ways that do not restrict men. Kinship systems are constructed . . . [and] women . . . are property that men give each other . . .” (Harding, 258).
Further to this point, a lesbian standpoint ” . . .centers female sexuality . . .” (Harding, 259) maintaining that women manufacture female sexuality implying that the physical nature of a woman in relation to sexual attitudes or activity must comply with androcentric needs. For example female sexuality has been seen as a biological object in terms of reproduction of the species and an economic object when women ” . . . trade it to men in return for economic support . . .” (Harding, 259). Also, as a ‘political object’ in that aristocratic families used their daughters to construct family relations through marriages and exchanges of daughters (Harding, 260). Daughters were exchanged as a matter of good will between families or in the case of marriages to maintain political alliances as now two families are joined.
Likewise, Harding examines how lesbian epistemology contributes to ideas of women’s sexual oppression and how gyneophobia contributes to racism. Women’s sexual oppression has its roots deeply embedded in history beginning with Aristotle’s views of the inferiority of women because of their lack of semen, to common conceptualizations of the ” . . . perversions. . . [and] . . . animal like” (Harding, 262) nature of deviant or ‘unnatural’ sexual choices that do not conform to white, heterosexual, male dominated ideas.
As well, Harding declares that a “lesbian standpoint shows that gynephobia supports racism . . . by blocking white women’s ability to identify with the concerns of women of color as women of color – with their concerns as mothers . . .” (Harding, 263). By not being able to identify with other women Harding is showing that the loss of shared experiences can create a situation where women hate each other rather than celebrate their commonalties.
The final ideal in Harding’s argument for a lesbian epistemology is formed in the ” . . . analogous arguments about the scientific advantages to be gained . . .” (264) by our society in relation to a different perspective of knowledge and thought. First, Harding suggests there would be a less partial and distorted understanding of social relations as the lesbian perspective has been “. . . devalued and neglected as origin points. . .” (264) and a new source for information. Second, lesbianism asks how and why the control of female sexuality can contribute to a racism, capitalism and male dominance. Third, this perspective can “. . . reveal the caring and valuing of women, the prioritizing of their welfare. . .” (Harding, 265). Finally, the lesbian perspective “permits various cultural ‘irrationalities’ to emerge. . . [such as the] . . . ‘normal’ female dependency and so-called male ‘autonomy’. . .” (265).
In conclusion, Sandra Harding introduces the standpoint of a distinct lesbian epistemology to acknowledge a perspective that will recognize the viewpoint of all women and not just heterosexual women that are seen by the androcentric stipulations as essential or typical. She begins with the conceptualization of what a lesbian is and then turns to examining lesbian contributions to feminist thought and the scientific advantages of such a standpoint. Overall Harding has presented an additional theory of knowledge that not only “. . . show[s] how to move from including others’ lives and thoughts in research and scholarly projects to starting from their lives to ask research questions, develop theoretical concepts, design research, collect data, and interpret findings.” (Harding, 268).
Citations Harding, S. (1991). Whose Science? Whose Knowledge? New York: Cornell University Press. (249-267).
Другие работы по теме:
Graffiti Art Essay Research Paper GraffitiArt is
Graffiti Art Essay, Research Paper Graffiti Art is expression through any medium. It carries meaning and expression of thoughts and ideas. It holds feeling and energy. It carries force and diversity that not only the artist can see. It carries individuality, reason and inspiration. It does not have to be understood by anyone else.
Importance Of Diversity Training Essay Research Paper
Diversity training has become a necessity in businesses today. Diversity training is necessary because of people s differences in our work force. Some of these differences are race, gender, culture, age, and disabilities. Because our organization is so diverse, this program will help educate, sensitize and prepare people to get along in our workplace.
Editha Essay Research Paper Feminism in American
Editha Essay, Research Paper Feminism in American Short Stories Editha, by William Dean Howells and The Revolt of Mother, by Mary E. Wilkins Freeman, present essentially the same type of character in two very distinct manners. Howells depicts Editha as a selfish and spoiled lady, while Freeman describes mother as a strong-willed person who simply does things when they need to be done.
Humans Are More Alike Than Unlike Essay
, Research Paper “I looked up the road I was going and back the way I had came since I was not satisfied I stepped off the road and created a new path”(Maya Angelou) Humans are more alike than unlike. Once we in America grasp this concept only than will we began to create a new path for the world we live.
Island Of The Blue DolphinsFeminism Essay Research
Paper The issue I have chosen to cover is feminism. There are many different opinions and thoughts on this issue. Despite all the grumblings about feminism, 66% of men still feel they hold a more powerful position in society. But, within relationships, they concede, it is women who resolve the day to day issues, while men settle the life changing disputes (“Are you a normal guy?” 19).
Review On The World According To Garp
Essay, Research Paper In the novel The World According to Garp, by John Irving, feminism isboth glorified and ridiculed. This is shown through the life of T.S.Garp and his family. When the author refers to Garp’s mother Jenny,feminism is shown as a great thing that is totally for the benefit ofwomen and all mankind.
Feminism Essay Research Paper FeminismFeminism can be
Feminism Essay, Research Paper Feminism Feminism can be roughly defined as a movement that seeks to enhance the quality of women’s lives by impacting the norms and moves of a society based on male dominance and subsequent female subordination. The means of change in the work place, politically, and domestically.
Racism Essay Research Paper The understanding of
Racism Essay, Research Paper The understanding of prejudice can lead to us removing of racism and discrimination in our country. Stereotyping, or forming a set of characteristics thought to be common to all members of a certain group, leads to prejudice influencing the observer to be part of a group rather than an individual.
Feminists 2 Essay Research Paper Final Composition
Feminists 2 Essay, Research Paper Final Composition-”Feminism” Women have a disease, a disease that will prevent them from ever achieving political, social or economic greatness. This “disease” is the need for independancy and self-respect or the lack there of. This is what we have come to know as feminism.
Brazilian Feminism Essay Research Paper For decades
Brazilian Feminism Essay, Research Paper For decades, women around the world have looked to each other for support and help in empowering the gender overall. In Brazil, for example, women have been making themselves heard and seen in the public arena since the early 1970 s. Brazilian feminism is a political action in which both theory and practice are incorporated.
The World According To Garp By John
Irving Essay, Research Paper The World According to Garp by John IrvingIn the novel The World According to Garp, by John Irving, feminism is both glorified and ridiculed. This is shown through the life of T.S. Garp and his family. When the author refers to Garp s mother Jenny, feminism is shown as a great thing that is totally for the benefit of women and all mankind.
Family Diversity Essay Research Paper In modern
Family Diversity Essay, Research Paper In modern Britain post WW2, the amount of the diverse families has grown due to changes over time. The invention of the pill, allowing both men and women to file for divorce without having to prove adultery and even religion not playing such an important part in peoples lives meant that changes in the family structure became more acceptable.
Brazilian Feminism Essay Research Paper Brazilian Feminism
Brazilian Feminism Essay, Research Paper Brazilian Feminism: The Struggle to Overcome Male Dominance For decades, women around the world have looked to each other for support and help in empowering the gender overall. In Brazil, for example, women have been making themselves heard and seen in the public arena since the early 1970’s.
Feminism Essay Research Paper Feminism PaperThe goal
Feminism Essay, Research Paper Feminism Paper The goal of this paper is to describe and analyze gender inequality, focusing on the history of feminist ideas. I will start with a basic overview of the entire feminist movement, and will then analyze feminism more specifically. In this analysis I will focus on the different types of feminism.
Thoughts On Feminists Essay Research Paper Thoughts
Thoughts On Feminists Essay, Research Paper Thoughts on Feminists. I was not yet ten when I was first made aware of the feminist movement and my mother didn?t have much use for that type of thing. You see, feminism in the eighties was a female version of the neo-nazi skinhead mentality. With men being the enemy instead of other races.
University Transfer Statement Essay Research Paper Transfer
University Transfer Statement Essay, Research Paper Transfer Statement I believe that the University will offer me a variety of new experiences that I am looking to get out of college life. I don?t believe that I am currently getting out of college all that I should be. I am looking to find a school that is different from where I am, but that will also provide a reputable program.
Workforce Diversity Essay Research Paper IndtroductionWorkplace diversity
Workforce Diversity Essay, Research Paper Indtroduction Workplace diversity is a worldwide concept that continues to evolve as more industries move into the global market. Most people try and hold the belief that all people are of equal stature and deserve all of the same opportunities invariant of their race, age, gender, disability, religion or sexual preference.
Canada Essay Research Paper Canada is a
Canada Essay, Research Paper Canada is a land of great diversity and variety. With a population of 28 000 and the second largest country in the world, it has many cultural, physical and climatic differences.
Wife Of Bath Essay Research Paper Wife
Wife Of Bath Essay, Research Paper Wife Of Bath Feminism, or a doctrine advocating social, politcal, and economic rights for women equal to those of men, plays a large role in “The Wife of Bath’s
Diversity Essay Research Paper DiversityDiversity is a
Diversity Essay, Research Paper Diversity Diversity is a big part of today?s society. But to understand diversity we have to know what it is. Diversity is where there are many different backgrounds, religion, and races. Ralph Bunch said ?I have a deep seated bias against hate and intolerance. I have a bias against racial and religious bigotry.
Diversity Essay Research Paper Diversity and the
Diversity Essay, Research Paper Diversity and the Mass Media The question of weather the media?s role in establishing racial and ethnic equality is not only very easy to answer but needs to be answered. People need to think of how important it is. People tend to under estimate this power and hate to admit that the media shapes our opinions about people.
Cultural Diversity Essay Research Paper Cultural Diversity
Cultural Diversity Essay, Research Paper Cultural Diversity: Campus Climates and Classroom Instruction American Society has been and continues to become increasingly mixed, complex, and variegated in its cultural practices and ethnic make up. However, the state schools have fallen short of race goals established thirty-one years ago in a desegregation case now known as Geier v.
The Myth Of New Feminism Essay Research
Paper The myth of new feminism New feminism. Everybody will probably have heard these divine words before. It seems that desperate women with too much time on their hands want to apply the technique of putting something which has gone out of the spotlights into a new package and claiming it has been improved revolutionary.
Feminism Essay Research Paper What is feminism
Feminism Essay, Research Paper What is feminism? By general definition, feminism is a philosophy in which women and their contributions are valued. It is based on social, political and economical equality for women. Feminists can be anyone in the population, men, women, girl or boys. Feminism can also be described as a movement.
An Ideal Society Essay Research Paper An
An Ideal Society Essay, Research Paper An Ideal Society There is no real way to describe an ideal society many authors have tried to write what they believe it might be like, but by the end of every story the perfect society all most always fails . The only real way we could have a perfect society is if the people who made up the society were perfect.
Womens Studies Essay Research Paper What is
Womens Studies Essay, Research Paper What is Women s Studies? Women s Studies explores a wide assortment of issues. Since the scope of topics that Women s Studies covers is so broad, it is difficult to come up with a solid definition that fully explains this subject.
Is Antigone A Feminist Or AntiFeminist Play
? Essay, Research Paper Ahmed B. Karim Antigone Essay (Is Antigone a Feminist/Anti-Feminist Play) Sunday, Oct. 31, 2000 I think Antigone was a feminist play because of three main facts. Antigone was in all the conflicts, even though Creon started them all, even though Creon had all the power, Antigone still won the war between her and Creon, also no woman in her time would even think of doing the things that Antigone did.
Grand Canyon Essay Research Paper Imagine a
Grand Canyon Essay, Research Paper Imagine a cut in the earth 277 miles long, a mile deep, and as wide as 18 miles in certain places. It is hard to picture such a huge place, but it?s exactly what you would see if you went to see the Grand Canyon. Formed in Northern Arizona, the Grand Canyon National Park is one of the most interesting places on the earth as far as diversity goes.