Divine Foreknowledge Essay, Research Paper
Nelson Pike wrote the article Divine Omniscience and Voluntary Action as an
elaboration of Boethius’ Divine Foreknowledge and Freedom of the Will. Pike thought that
Boethius had a valid, logical argument that was just not thought out fully. Boethius stated that
perhaps there is a lack of free will if God already knows what is and will happen. However, in
order for this argument to be valid, some assumptions need to be made.
The first assumption is that God exists. Second is the view of God as omniscient. God
knows everything that has ever occurred, is occurring, or will occur. God is never wrong.
Finally, is the view of God as perpetual, not eternal. This means that at any point in time, God
exists. God has a temporal relationship with the universe, as opposed to having a timeless
relationship. Pike uses these assumptions as the basis for his arguement.
To begin with, what God believes is the same as what God knows, whereas believing and
knowing are two completely different things when in reference to anyone else. One can believe
something yet have that belief be factually wrong. The same cannot be said for God.
Next, if someone believed something three days ago, it is not possible to do something
now that would change the belief of that person three days ago. It follows that if said person was
God his belief three days ago could not be changed now.
The same can be said about existance. If someone existed three days ago, it is not
possible to do something now that would make it such that that person did not exist three days
ago. In other words, if God existed three days ago, nothing can happen now that would make
God not have existed three days ago.
One cannot do something that logically contradicts itself. For example, one is not able to
inhale yet exhale at the same time. It is not possible to do something, yet not do that thing at the
same time.
Now, if God exists, and God believes (knows) something three days ago, and it were
possible to do something that was different than what God thought three days ago, there would
be several contridictions.
First, that would mean that God was wrong. Since the assumption is that God is
omniscient, it is not possible for God to be wrong.
Second, if God is never wrong, there is no way to take action now that would change
God’s belief three days ago so that it coresponds to today’s action, thereby making God correct in
God’s belief three days ago.
Third, the belief held three days ago was wrong. That entails that the person who held
that belief could not have been God. But it was stated that God held that belief, therefore it is
not possible to make it such that God did not exist three days ago when, in fact, God did.
These contradictions lead towards the conclusion that it is not possible to do anything
that God did not know about three days ago. If God already knew/knows what will happen, and
if God is never wrong, then there cannot be any choices to be made concerning anything that can
be done. This absence of choice equals the absence of free will.
It is not as if one can out manuver God either. One may decide to change his or her mind
at the last possible moment about something, yet God already knows of those changes, and the
outcomes derived from them, because God knows everything.
This arguement does not claim that there is no free will, nor does it claim that there is
free will but no God. The only purpose is to make clear the problems arising form thinking that
God is omniscient and also thinking that free will exists. It seems to be logically incorrect to
believe in both.
Другие работы по теме:
God The Father Essay Research Paper The
God The Father Essay, Research Paper The Chain of Being Definition Basically The Chain of Being (also called The Divine Order) is an order in which people are ranked from the closest to God, all the way down to the minerals in the earth.
Artificial Nigger Essay Research Paper In OConners
Artificial Nigger Essay, Research Paper In O?Conner?s "The Artificial Nigger" the essences of prejudice and degradation are captured to a great extent. Reality shows us with needless consistency people who need to feel better about themselves and only achieve it by being better than someone else.
Hanging Woman Creek Essay Research Paper Hanging
Hanging Woman Creek Essay, Research Paper Hanging Woman Creek is set in an era of American expansion when the major conflict of the Indian population was not much of a worry. The bigger worry for most men on the frontier was other whites. Bandits were plentiful, and the law was dealt out by the people. The book starts out in Chicago, concerning a man who had just been released from an overnight stay in prison.
Slavery Essay Research Paper 1 Africans were
Slavery Essay, Research Paper 1. Africans were kidnapped and taken aboard ships to be transported to various places. From reading Equianos memoir I gathered that the slaves were terrified. They had never seen whites before, nor did they speak the language of their captors, so they had no idea of their destiny.
Paradise Lost 2 Essay Research Paper Paradise
Paradise Lost 2 Essay, Research Paper Paradise Lost Milton is widely considered to be one of the five greatest poets in the English language and Paradise Lost, a religious epic, is his greatest masterpiece. As stated in the beginning of the first book of Paradise Lost, Milton’s intention for writing his religious epic is, among some other things, to justify the ways of God to men.
A Raisin In The Sun Emerald City
: Third And Pike: Dreams Essay, Research Paper By Gregory Peker and Michael StollerDreams can be seen in many ways. A dream could be something you had in the night that seems so real, or a dream could be your fantasy, where everything is going your way. The last type of dream is something that has more of a deep sense and plays an important role in your life.
Oedipus Rex 2 Essay Research Paper Oedipus
Oedipus Rex 2 Essay, Research Paper Oedipus Rex a Greek tragedy written by Sophocles in the early days of antiquity is based upon an even more ancient story in Greek mythology. Sophocles, however, knowing that his audience is aware of the outcome of the play utilizes that foreknowledge to create various situations in which dramatic and verbal irony play key roles.
Monsters Essay Research Paper 1 Pike Christopher
Monsters Essay, Research Paper 1. Pike, Christopher. Monster. New York, Archway Paperbacks, 1992. 229 p. 2. This book is both a mystery novel and a suspense novel. It is a mystery novel because Angela tries to find out the big mystery about the monsters while, at the same time, it is a suspense novel because of all the adventures that happen throughout the book.
Lucy Stone Essay Research Paper Equality for
Lucy Stone Essay, Research Paper Equality for Woman Lucy Stone was one of the most important workers for suffrage and other women’s rights. Born in 1818 on a farm in Massachusetts, Lucy grew up with an overbearing father that ruled the house and her mother “by divine right.” She was disquieted by her mother’s lowly role in the family.
Settlers And Pioneer Essay Research Paper Settlers
Settlers And Pioneer Essay, Research Paper Settlers and pioneers led very different lives. The code of conduct practiced by both groups was the same. While both groups were dependant on consumer goods, the particular goods demanded by each group were different. Rebecca Burland was born in England and immigrated to Pike County Illinois in 1831 with her family.
Divine Command Theory Essay Research Paper The
Divine Command Theory Essay, Research Paper The Divine Command Theory Religion and ethics are seen to be somehow inseparable in our culture. Religious leaders are usually appealed to in some capacity when
Divine Command Essay Research Paper Divine CommandIn
Divine Command Essay, Research Paper Divine Command In my opinion, trying to differentiate between the Divine Command and the acts of God that impinge on one’s consciousness is one in the same. Divine command to me would basically be the entire Holy Bible. An act of God to me is just waking up in the morning and being able to breathe new air and live another day.
OdysseusThe Hero Homer Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus,The Hero, Homer Essay, Research Paper Odysseus, The Hero In today*s eclectic society, everybody*s heroes are different. However, during the era Homer*s The Odyssey was created all heroes had same characteristics. Heroes were the people who saved people, they were courageous wise and had fighting spirit.
Allegory In The Divine Comedy Essay Research
Paper Dante wrote The Divine Comedy between 1308 and 1321. The Divine Comedy was written as an allegory, Which is a narrative that takes place on both a literal and a figurative or symbolic level. Dante uses himself as the main character and uses allegory to describe himself in the epic.
Remember Me Essay Research Paper Remember Me
Remember Me Essay, Research Paper Remember Me by Christopher Pike I have been interested in novels by Christopher Pike since I first discovered one of his works. I find his stories very concentrated of deep concepts and meaning. I recently
The Jaguar And The Pike Essay Research
Paper Topic: ?The Jaguar?, ?The Pike? and ?Hawk Roosting? by Ted Hughes Compare the three poems, their similarities and differences, their aim and intention. Describe
Divine Command Theory Essay Research Paper Divine
Divine Command Theory Essay, Research Paper Divine Command Theory The divine command theory is the view that moral actions are those which conform to God’s will. Charity, for example, is morally proper because God endorses it, and murder is wrong because God condemns it. One way to test to see whether any action is right or wrong is first to determine if it conforms to God’s will, it is morally permissible, if it does not, then it is impermissible.
Sacred Divine Essay Research Paper The Sacred
Sacred Divine Essay, Research Paper The Sacred Divine I believe the Divine sacred is something more powerful than anything on earth. Not necessarily in a physical sense but more in a spiritual. I feel that the
Dante Reaction Paper Essay Research Paper Dante
Dante Reaction Paper Essay, Research Paper Dante Reaction Paper In his lecture, Professor Mark Dantmore says that Purgatorio is “almost science fiction” to people of the time it was written. I find it very interesting that a book in the Divine Comedy, something the Catholics take as truth, might be described this way.
Divine Discontene Essay Research Paper Each and
Divine Discontene Essay, Research Paper Each and every human strives to be better.A desire, a subconscious power, known as divine discontent leads them to dedicate themselves twoard becoming better or achieving greater goals. Divine discontent leads some to happiness, and others who do not succeed to failure.
Nelson Mandela Essay Research Paper Influential Figures
Nelson Mandela Essay, Research Paper Influential Figures During Apartheid Nelson Mandela: Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was born on July 19, 1918, near Umtata, Transkei. To pursue a political career, he renounced his right to succeed his father as chief of the Tembu tribe. He studied law by correspondence.
Mandella Essay Research Paper Nelson Mandela has
Mandella Essay, Research Paper Nelson Mandela has played an important and controversial role in the history of South Africa and establishing South Africa as a Democratic country. Nelson Rolihlahla Mandela was
Country Music Essay Research Paper Country MusicToday
Country Music Essay, Research Paper Country Music Today, many people in the United States listen to country music. People have almost always listen to this type of music, from early rebels, to the families of today. The topic of true country music usually remains the same in all songs. The country atmosphere is more family oriented and provides children and all people with good role models.
Pike Place Market Essay Research Paper Visiting
Pike Place Market Essay, Research Paper Visiting Seattle?s Pike Place Market Exiting off the freeway directly down any one of the steep hills, one can?t avoid running into the famous sign that serves as a Seattle landmark, ?Pike Place Market?. The market, itself, sits on the edge of a cliff. Looking out one sees all the ferries moving across Puget Sound bringing people to and from the many islands.
Jesus Essay Research Paper JesusJesus is the
Jesus Essay, Research Paper Jesus Jesus is the center of Christianity, born in Bethlehem in Judea. To believers Jesus is the son of Mary. He is the son of God. Jesus was divine but led an
Inspiration Essay Research Paper Inspiration Producers of
Inspiration Essay, Research Paper Inspiration Producers of movies have different ways of getting their message across to their viewers. Some use metaphors and others just lay it all out so we can learn from their experiences whether it being fiction or reality. Movies that we thought had no meaning could suddenly open up a whole new world for us when we are asked to write on or answer a question such as this one; What movie has inspired you the most?.
Petrified Man Essay Research Paper Petrified Man
Petrified Man Essay, Research Paper Petrified Man by Eudora Welty One of Eudora Welty’s criticisms is that she occasionally possibly misrepresents the culture and influence of the south. Do you think that is the case in The Petrified Man?
Compare And Contrast The Tudor And Stuart
Dynasties Essay, Research Paper Throughout history, dynasties, or a series of rulers who belong to the same family, have come and gone. No two are exactly alike. They all have similarities and differences when compared to each other. The Stuart and Tudor dynasties are no exception to the rule. Each had different views on how to rule.
Nelson Mandella Essay Research Paper Nelson Mandela
Nelson Mandella Essay, Research Paper Nelson Mandela was a son of a tribal chief. Nelson was a lawyer and worked tire-lessly to free his people. Nelson has been in jail for twenty-six years. Nelson Rolihlahla Mandla was born on July 18, 1918 at Transku area of South Africa. Nelson Mandela gave a speech Sestember 21, 1953.
Natural Law Theory Essay Research Paper Natural
Natural Law Theory Essay, Research Paper Natural Law Theory The natural law theory is a theory that dates back to the time of the Greeks and great thinkers like Plato and Aristotle. Defined as the law which states
Civil Vs Moral Essay Research Paper Civil
Civil Vs Moral Essay, Research Paper ?Civil Law vs. Moral law? In Sophocles? play ?Antigone?, Antigone?s life is taken from her because of her choice to follow the moral law by burying her brother and disobeying the civil law, which forbid this.
Marketing Essay Research Paper r 110499 TR
Marketing Essay, Research Paper r. 11/04/99 TR 2:30-3:45 Marketing Strategies Penetration Thomas Nelson uses different marketing strategies to penetrate the market to increase