The Grammatical Fiction In Darkness At Noon Essay, Research Paper
The Conflict Between the Individual and
the State and the Grammatical Fiction in Darkness At Noon
“The Party denied the free will of an individual-and
at the same time exacted his willing self-sacrifice.” The obvious contradiction
of the above definition of the Communist party is depicts the conflict
between the individual and the State in Arthur Koestler?s novel Darkness
at Noon. Koestler?s protagonist Nicolas Salamanovich Rubashov, devout communist
and former leader of the Communist party, falls victim to his own system
during the time of the Moscow trials. Accused and imprisoned for crimes
he did not commit, Rubashov is forced to choose between the ideology he
has faithfully followed for the past forty years of his life, or a new
found sense of self, which he calls the “grammatical fiction”.
During the beginning of Rubashov?s solitary
incarceration, he begins to doubt the infallibility of the Communist regime,
and for a time, views himself independent from the Party. Rubashov?s pulling
away from Communism is evident in his conversation with the examining magistrate,
Ivanov, during his first hearing. Rubashov addresses Ivanov?s collective
viewpoint with the developing views of his own:
“Your argument is somewhat anachronistic,”
said Rubashov. “As you quite rightly remarked, we were accustomed always
to use the plural ?we? and to avoid as far as possible the first person
singular. I have rather lost the habit of this form of speech; you stick
to it. But who is this ?we? in whose name you speak to-day? It needs re-defining.
That is the point.”
Apart from the Party, Rubashov no longer
functions as part of the Communist unit, but rather as an individual. Within
communist doctrine the individual is only a piece of a larger system, and
for the true communist the pronoun ?I? is not even part of his or her vocabulary.
Rather, the personal ?I? is replaced by ?we?, which represents the Party.
The significance of Rubashov?s statement is that even his speech patterns,
a physical manifestation of one?s subconscious, display his self-detachment
from the Communist Party in that he has lost his ability to associate with
the communist We.
Over and over Rubashov is tormented by
the idea “I shall pay”, an unrest due to his uncertainty about the foundation
of Communism he has placed himself on. Shortly after his first hearing
he writes in his diary “The fact is: I no longer believe in my infallibility.
That is why I am lost.” It is evident that he is beginning to take personal
responsibility for the actions he has committed on behalf of the Party,
the people that he has betrayed and the seemingly absurd doctrines he has
readily submitted to. Both Rubashov?s mental disquiet, and his observable,
critical actions are owed to his new found recognition of himself as an
individual, a loophole in Communist doctrine.
All his life Rubashov had “burnt the remains
of the old illogical morality from his consciousness”, and was unaware
that ideas outside of those expressed by the Party had any logical basis.
He once thought that any other view was irrational and false. In his cell
waiting to be taken to his execution, Rubashov reflects on his former devotion
to the Party:
For in a struggle one must have both legs
firmly planted on the earth. The Party had taught one how to do it. The
infinite was a politically suspect quantity, and the “I” a suspect quality.
The Party did not recognize its existence. The definition of an individual
was a multitude of one million divided by one million.
As a Communist he had sacrificed his individuality
for the benefit of the Party, and forty years later he had lost the capability
to even think outside the lines of the Party?s dogmas. He had denied the
individual within himself, which is why he is confused at the emergence
of his “silent partner”, the free-thinking individual within himself. His
conscious self had been founded in the ?we?, until he was imprisoned. Facing
death, Rubashov realizes the destructiveness of a political system that
doesn?t account for the individual.
No longer confused by his apathy for the
Party, Rubashov?s final hours are marked by a fatalistic mindset and an
internal sense of peace. In Rubashov?s conversation with Ivanov during
Rubashov?s second hearing, Ivanov states: “The greatest temptaion for the
like of us is: to renounce violence, to repent, to make peace with oneself”.
Ivanov represents rubashov?s former viewpoint. However, no longer subject
to the repressive Communist order, Rubashov does find reconciliation with
himself:
He was a man who had lost his shadow, released
from every bond. He followed every thought to its last conclusion and acted
in accordance with it to the very end. The hours which remained to him
belonged to the silent partner, whose realm started just where logical
thought ended. He had christened it the ?grammatical fiction? with that
shamefacedness about the first person singular which the Party had inculcated
in its disciples.
At this point Rubashov rests. The inner
turmoil he had from being torn between two avenues of thought had ceased.
He has realized the futility of the Party?s actions, and in his own way
repented of those actions by dissociating himself from the Party. Although
the Party had essentially banished Rubashov first, Rubashov?s conflict
had resulted from his mental loyalty for the System to which he fell victim.
Having lost his faith in Communism, Rubashov devotes the remaining part
of his life to the “grammatical fiction”, and finds contentment. Rubashov
is no longer afraid of death because death is imminent, and not even the
most logical thought or powerful dictator can alter the natural law of
death. After enduring emotional and mental torment, he realizes he has
“earned the right to sleep” and die peacefully.
Rubashov?s experiences in prison altered
his view of the communist system and upturned the faith he had for it.
The idea that a doctrine in which the individual is not accounted for becomes
an absurdity. The appearance of the grammatical fiction in Rubashov?s case,
is representative of the larger conflict between the individual and the
State. Rubashov?s experience is a microcosm of the people who suppressed
their own individual thought and reason for that of the Party and Stalinist
dictatorship. The idea expressed by Koestler in Darkness at Noon is that
the Communist system?s ultimate failure lies within its idea that the individual
is a “sacrificial lamb” for the Party. Instead, it is the individual that
is the essential factor in making a society. An individual can survive
without a government, but a government can not survive without the support
of the individual, and it is for this reason that no form of Communism
has ever reached the utopian peak in which Marx and Engles expressed in
The Manifesto of the Communist Party.
3ba
Другие работы по теме:
Aristotle On Excellence In Leadership Essay Research
Paper “But when a whole family, or some individual, happens to be so preeminent in excellence as to surpass all others, then it is just that they should be the royal family and supreme over all, or that this one citizen should be king.”(1288a15-20)
The Glass Menagerie And The Conflict Between
Happines And Responsibility Essay, Research Paper An individual’s right to be happy and its conflict with an individual’s responsibilities is a common personal problem. Many people must make the choice between the two daily. Most people have a set opinion of whether responsibility or happiness should prevail.
Constitution Essay Research Paper Brandi Petelle33970266592199Our constitutional
Constitution Essay, Research Paper Brandi Petelle 339-70-2665 9/21/99 Our constitutional rights and civil liberties come into conflict with each other periodically because of certain disagreements and new issues that arise. This week a new conflict has come into play between the U.S. Constitution and ?voluntary school prayer.?
Plato Essay Research Paper The Use of
Plato Essay, Research Paper The Use of Dialectic to Define Justice Through the use of Socratic dialogue, Plato has an advantage at obtaining answers by refuting other philosophers. Plato is able to achieve an answer to the question, what is justice. He derives this answer through an analogy of the ideal city.
The Concept Of Total War Essay Research
Paper Total War The Concept of total Warfare developed in the early nineteenth century due to the economic development and political ideology. Factors that constitute total war 1) The percentage of the population that identifies itself with the war of its nation. i.e the citizens feeling about the conflict, a just war. 2) The percentage of the population and resources that participate in the conflict, in terms of industrial, agricultural and military terms. 3) The percentage of people affected by the conflict, in economic, social and military terms. 4) Common objective pursued by the conflict.
What Is The Influence Of Interpersonal Conflict
In Our Daily Lives And How To Solve It Harmoniously? Essay, Research Paper Interpersonal conflict is one of the most common situations we will face in our daily lives with our family members, relatives, friends or lover. Interpersonal conflict is often the result of negative cognitions, or thoughts. There is one way of defining interpersonal communication that is to compare it to other forms of communication.
Group Work Outline Essay Research Paper Group
Group Work Outline Essay, Research Paper Group Conflict Resolution Annotated Outline I. Introduction In this section, we will state our topic, which is group conflict resolution. We will present the subtopics we will focus on in the paper. We will briefly tie the four subtopics into each other under the umbrella topic of group conflict resolution.
Locke VsHobbes Essay Research Paper Locke versus
Locke Vs.Hobbes Essay, Research Paper Locke versus Hobbes Locke and Hobbes were both social contract theorists, and both natural law theorists, but there the resemblance ends. All other natural law theorists assumed that man was by nature a social animal. Hobbes assumed otherwise, thus his conclusions are strikingly different from those of other natural law theorists.
Bartleby Essay Essay Research Paper Bartleby EssayDiscuss
Bartleby Essay Essay, Research Paper Bartleby Essay Discuss the conflict of the individuals’ need to communicate his individual thoughts and feelings versus the desire of society’s institutions, for conformity in Melville’s “Bartleby, the Scrivener” and Updike’s “A & P.”
Locke In Rousseau
’s Eye Essay, Research Paper The state of nature, as described by Locke, is a state of perfect freedom, a state in which man is completely free, but would Rousseau agree with this? The answer to this question is more complex than it seems. Locke and Rousseau, both great philosophers of their time, have similar ideas, but the similarities between them end at that.
Social Conflict Theory Essay Research Paper History
Social Conflict Theory Essay, Research Paper History has always been fueled by conflict. History books are filled with conflicts of the have and have-nots. For example look at the early history of America, it was a fight between the oppressed colonists and the aristocratic British. Our independence was gained over a conflict.
The Cause Of Conflict Essay Research Paper
The Cause of Conflict Spinoza explained (p.3) ?violence by reference to human imperfection…and logically, the end of conflict must depend on the reform of man?. Spinoza believes that because man does not cooperate to achieve harmony without self-interest and self-gain, the ultimate result is incessant quarrels and physical violence.
Conflict In The Miracle Worker Essay Research
Paper In my opinion, all the types of conflict occur in ?the Miracle Worker?. There is internal conflict such as man versus self. There is also external conflict such as man versus man, man
Differential Association Theory Vs Conflict Theory Essay
, Research Paper Edwin Sutherland s Differential Association Theory is an approach to crime that states that it is a learned behavior. Differential Association Theory in its most basic form claims that if an individual is in close contact with crime than he/she will eventually learn and participate in criminal activity.
Deviance Essay Research Paper Theories of Deviant
Deviance Essay, Research Paper Theories of Deviant Behavior examines various theories and perspectives on conforming and deviant behavior which are products of Western scholarly thought: anomie, functionalism, social disorganization, social conflict, social control, psychoanalysis, status politics, differential association, labeling theory, etc.
Greek Philosophers Socrates Plato And Aristotle Essay
, Research Paper Greek Philosophers Greek Philosophers Socrates, Plato and Aristotle had virtually the same beliefs about man’s relation to the State, although Plato’s political theory of the State was more rational
Rousseau Origin Of Inequality Essay Research Paper
The Origin of Inequality In Rousseau s Discourse on the Origin of Inequalities , Rousseau tries to explain the birth and evolution of inequality between humans dating back to savage man in the pure state of nature. Rousseau proposes that it was not man that progressed toward inequality as much as it was the state of nature itself.
Conflict Management Essay Research Paper In the
Conflict Management Essay, Research Paper In the dictionary conflict is defined as a struggle, a battle, even mutual antagonism. Some people seem to thrive on creating conflict while others do their best to avoid conflict.
The Conflict Essay Research Paper In the
The Conflict Essay, Research Paper In the poem “The Conflict” C. Day Lewis describes being in the midst of human conflict. Since the beginning of mankind, conflicts have been a part of society no matter how big or small. An example of a big conflict is the way some Quebec citizens felt when they were voting in the referendum.
Miniver Essay Research Paper The worn path
Miniver Essay, Research Paper The worn path is about conflict. Praytell, you ask what conflict. The obvious conflict is that an elderly lady needs to get medicine for her sick grandchild, and she has to make perilous journey to reach her destination. Now, why in the hell is an old woman gallivanting through the woods.
Thomas Hobbes And Jonh Locke Essay Research
Paper Thomas Hobbes and John Locke are two philosophers who have thought extensively on the subject human nature and conflict in human society. The question that arises from a discussion of these two men is who is more logical? The best way to answer this question is to compare their arguments and to juxtapose their views.
Laws
– Hobbes, Locke, Rousseau Essay, Research Paper Laws. We all must obey them, but why? For fear of going to jail, or being fined? Those are the individual effects of civil disobedience, but what happens what is the purpose of law in society? Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, and Jean-Jacques Rousseau all attempted to interpret the need for laws in society, in order to maintain the good of the whole and the individual.
The Bill Of Rights Essay Research Paper
The Bill of Rights Bill of Rights The first ten amendments to the US constitution are called the Bill of Rights because they provide basic legal protection for individual rights. The
Masque Of The Red Death Essay
, Research Paper The Masque of the red death By: MC E-mail: MCC1000@AOL In “The Masque of the Red Death”, Poe leads one event into another often. He uses much symbolism, and in the paragraphs below, I will show you it. In the first couple of paragraphs however, I will summarize the plot and state the theme.
Government Essay Research Paper 2 We know
Government Essay, Research Paper 2. We know that the fundamental difference between ancient political science and modern political science has to do with the relationship of the individual to the state. For Aristotle, a person was an inherently political animal. For modern political philosophers (social contract theorists), individual rights existed prior to the formation of government.
India And Pakistan Conflict Essay Research Paper
India’s nuclear tests are a wake-up call to the world, and particularly to the nuclear weapons states. India’s tests got the world’s attention. The country that was really woken up by these tests was Pakistan. These tests have refueled the conflict between Pakistan and India. The two countries have fought three wars, two of them over the disputed region of Kashmir.
The Bargain Ox Essay Research Paper CONFLICTTHE
The Bargain Ox Essay, Research Paper CONFLICT-THE BARGAIN OX The type of conflict in this story is Man vs. Man. The father is fighting against Cramer to grow the biggest pumpkin. The author sets this conflict up
Eudora WeltyS A Worn Path Essay Research
Paper Conflict in ?A Worn Path? Conflict in Eudora Welty?s ?A Worn Path? was not apparent at the beginning. Why was an old sick woman in the forest during winter? The reason became clear towards the end of the story revealing the obstacle was obtaining medicine for her grandson. What kind of society did this woman live in that she had to go all the way from her home in the countryside to the city by herself to get the medicine? The conflict is that of individual versus society and the four problems that Phoenix faces as a result of this were her old age, health, grandson?s health, and state of poverty. ?Her eyes were blue with age.
Psychological Conflicts In Literature1 Essay Research Paper
We all experience psychological conflicts, knowingly or unknowingly. They involve psychological conflicts among our thoughts, emotions, and rational thinking. It may be the most dangerous conflict of all due to the battleground in which it take place in — our mind.
Narcissus And Goldmund
– Herman Hesse Essay, Research Paper Throughout this book Hesse continuously explores the idea of the conflict individuals experience when searching for their true identity. Narcissus and Goldmund, two medieval men whose characters are metaphors for the underlying theme of mans individual search for self and the human experience.
Divine Law Vs Human Law Essay Research
Paper Divine Law vs. Human Law Sophocles’ famous play, Antigone, can be perceived as a conflict between individual conscience and state policy. Yet the issue of the play goes beyond that conflict and touches the universal conditions of suffering, religion, and loyalty. Through Antigone’s character–which represents the spheres of family loyalty, divine law, and human suffering, Sophocles conveys the idea that a law of man that violates religious law is not a law at all.
Conflict In Eudora Welty
’s “A Worn Path” Essay, Research Paper English Conflict in Eudora Welty’s “A Worn Path” In Eudora Welty?s “A Worn Path” the conflict was not apparent at the